Ear Candling

Ear Candling is discussed and dismissed in 'Trick or Treatment' if I remember rightly. Anyway logic suggests that if the candle did create sufficient suction to be effective it would either damage the ear drum, cause enormous pain or suck itelf into the ear THEN damage the ear drum and cause enormous pain!!

As a friend of mine once advised, the only thing you should ever stick in your ear is your own elbow! Good advice! I suffer from periodic excessive earwax build up that can leave me alwost completely deaf, my recommendation is a weeks course of wax softner (olive oil, Earex or dilute hydrogen peroxide) used according to directions followed by a trip to a qualified medical professional for syringing. Quick, very effective, safe and painless (infact the old fashioned syringing process feels quite nice, the modern water pumps are a bit odd). Walking out afterwards and realising that you can hear birdsong for the first time in days or weeks (it kinda creeps up on me!) is an amazing feeling. And incidentally I've never been told to stay indoors for 48 hours afterward.

Well done to Avocado for listening to the responses and having the courage and intellectual honesty to publicly change his position in response to new information, and my condolences to you and your family.
 
I've got bad news. I've just found out that my grandmother passed away and my grandfather is on the brink. My family is taking it hard and I am going to have to leave the country as soon as I can organize things at work, school, and make passport arrangements. No emoticon can express how sad I am. I won't be able to try the experiment, perhaps all is for the best, you've convinced me it's woo and perhaps it may be too dangerous.

Sorry about the pretentious post Fish Bait.


You have my sincere condolences.

On a positive note, you didn't risk your hearing or waste your time testing something that has been absolutely proven not to work.
 
Ive had ear candling done and the amount of wax removed was frightening. I had enough to make a candle! I had it done because the amount of the substance in my ear made it difficult to hear. I have a friend who majors in sound editing and his proffesor recommended they have it done before their semester started. Also, as a general rule you are supposed to stay indoors for twentyfour hours after the proceedure so that your ear can build up a safe amount of wax in the ear, because it does serve a purpose. However for people where to much wax is a problem, this does seem to work. The vacume created DOES remove a substantial amount of wax from the ear.

Also, if done properly, there is no danger involved. Even if wax does manage to enter the candy and pass the acumilated ear wax inside, it will cool before it enters the ear. That is why you remove the candle before it reaches
a certain length. I am not sure if removing wax is a good thing however this process does remove wax from the ear. That aspect is science.
You can buy an over the counter rubber syringe at any drug store that works better than the candle. A medicine comes with it that includes an eyedropper and it gets rid of the wax in one or two applications. I recomment using the dropper to squirt a water, hydrogen pyroxide soultion into the ear to kill germs after the wax is removed.
 
Ugh, they have these contraptions on the counter of the pharmacy I go to.

I go to an ear specialist when I need my buildup dealt with.
 
...and I went there today.

I quizzed the pharmacist about them, asking him if they actually work. All he could say is "Well people keep coming back to buy them". Okay.

http://www.earcandlesbylouise.co.nz/

I got the same response from my pharmacist with respect to homeopathic teething drops for babies. If I were a baby, I would gather other babies together and launch a class-action suit against the "manufacturer". All the babies I have spoken to have just grimaced in pain and not indicated they wanted to become involved. :mad:
 
... You know how to get an egg into a bottle? Pickle it, stick it onto the entrance, heat the bottom and the egg will get sucked in. In theory this is how ear canceling works ...
I think you might be misremembering that particular physics trick. You don't heat the bottom of the bottle while the egg sits in the spout. The approximate vacuum, that sucks the egg into the bottle, is created by burning off the oxygen within the bottle--not by some sort of chimney effect which is presumably how ear candling "works."

This may be said further down the thread, but I cannot stress it enough -- your experiment should be blinded. When you're comparing your test case with the control, you should not know which is which. Years ago, I actually did this experiment. There's no reason why you should simply benefit from my results. Do it for yourself, and see what you learn.

It might help you to know, that the wax that flows into the spout of the ear candle darkens as it collects from a large thin layer spread about the surface of the candle, into a concentrated mass. I'm unfamiliar with the "smell of ear wax," so I cannot comment on that aspect of your aforementioned anecdotes.
 
I suggest almost any digital camera on a supermacro setting will take adequate before and after pics of the ear.
I also suggest you do this over a sink and have a jug of water within reach in case you burn yourself. There have been many cases of people suffering burns to the ear and face through this nonsense.
Best have a sensible & reliable helper on hand to hold things like cameras and water jugs and witness the whole thing. Not someone who will act the fool.
 
I've got bad news. I've just found out that my grandmother passed away and my grandfather is on the brink. My family is taking it hard and I am going to have to leave the country as soon as I can organize things at work, school, and make passport arrangements. No emoticon can express how sad I am. I won't be able to try the experiment, perhaps all is for the best, you've convinced me it's woo and perhaps it may be too dangerous.

Sorry about the pretentious post Fish Bait.
I'm sorry. Good luck.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom