Ear Candling

ok, alfaniner. Anyone have anymore ideas to make this experiment more acurate, or scientific?

1. Get a sensitive scale.
2. Procure an otoscope (you can get a usable one for about a hundred bucks).
3. Get a friend to peer into your ear using the otoscope. Preferably get one who won't claim he can see all the way through to the other side of your head. Get one who has a good visual memory so he can judge the scenic contours and stalactites of your earwax.
4. Carefully mark both candles to the point where you will extinguish them. Make sure both are burning to the same length.
5. Burn both candles, one in your ear. I'd recommend placing the other candle so its neck is within the neck of an upright empty bottle, so they'd burn in relatively the same position.
6. Weigh both candle stubs.
7. Cut open both candle stubs. Compare the material inside them.
8. Have your friend gaze into your ear again with the otoscope. Any visible changes?
 
If you want to try self medication, try a few drops of hydrogen peroxide. It makes a nice bubbling and crackling noise as it works.

Make sure you use the 3% solution of hydrogen peroxide from the drug store. Pure hydrogen peroxide would not be pleasant.
 
To make things clear, it is not a stick, it is a hollow cadle with a burning top. The heat supposidle warms and draws out the wax.
So are you saying sticking the candle stick in your ear creates a vacuum or just that the heat somehow circulates and brings the ear wax up? If the latter, I still don't understand.

Look at the picture of ear candling being performed next to the article. Is that an accurate representation of it? The woman is laying on her side with the candle sticking up out of her ear. What I don't understand is that the heat could not warm the wax in your ear. The heat rises, it doesn't go down into the hollow candle. The only way to heat the wax in your ear would be to hold the candle beneath your ear and let the flame burn up the candle
 
The entry for Ear Candling in my brain reads, "Useless, physically nonsense and dangerous". I've told my brain not to change a word of this based on what I have read here.

If you want to try self medication, try a few drops of hydrogen peroxide. It makes a nice bubbling and crackling noise as it works.

Note -- I am not a Doctor and would never pretend to be, even for money.

At least my government has got it right:
http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/iyh-vsv/med/ear-oreille_e.html

Make sure you use the 3% solution of hydrogen peroxide from the drug store. Pure hydrogen peroxide would not be pleasant.

Yes this is what the Dr. or Nurse will use in his or her office. As a matter of fact, if you ask nicely, he or she will do it for you on your next visit or check up.
 
Ok skeptator, I can do all of those besides the otoscope. Starving student. Is there a cheaper way to glance inside the ear? Although, I would probably consider the contents to be a fair indicator of its validity. The problem is replicating the human ear, because a candle burning by itself could burn differeently than one burning in the ear. I suppose that is what the bottle is for? Makes sense, I will try to get one as close to the demensions of an ear canal, perhaps cover it in a mayor of latex tomimic the human skin.
 
Sorry about the double post and bad spelling/grammar. Typing on iPod is a pain!
 
Last edited:
Ok skeptator, I can do all of those besides the otoscope. Starving student. Is there a cheaper way to glance inside the ear? Although, I would probably consider the contents to be a fair indicator of its validity. The problem is replicating the human ear, because a candle burning by itself could burn differeently than one burning in the ear. I suppose that is what the bottle is for? Makes sense, I will try to get one as close to the demensions of an ear canal, perhaps cover it in a mayor of latex tomimic the human skin.

I really dont think that is necessary. Anyone else think so?

re: the otoscope

Perhaps if you are at an institution that has med students, you could use one of them to help.

Also, see if the school nurse will participate. He or she may be receptive to such an experiment.
 
Last edited:
Charming man, You misinterpreted what I said. You know how to get an egg into a bottle? Pickle it, stick it onto the entrance, heat the bottom and the egg will get sucked in. In theory this is how ear canceling works. I am not claiming it is the truth, that is why I am going to experiment. It is no problem for me because I can get them for free.

Okay- if we assume that the candle is heating the air inside your ear, and then vacuuming it out (and taking the earwax with it), consider this as a thought-experiment.

Take a bottle. Smear vaseline on the inside to represent earwax.

Try to remove the vaseline with a vacuum cleaner.
 
Madalch, Suction from a vacume functioned differently than the suction caused by heat. Also, Vaseline is not a good subsitude for ear wax. That experiment will not validate, nor invalidate ear candling. I think the experiment is already fair, unless you have something to add.
 
So are you saying sticking the candle stick in your ear creates a vacuum or just that the heat somehow circulates and brings the ear wax up? If the latter, I still don't understand.

Look at the picture of ear candling being performed next to the article. Is that an accurate representation of it? The woman is laying on her side with the candle sticking up out of her ear. What I don't understand is that the heat could not warm the wax in your ear. The heat rises, it doesn't go down into the hollow candle. The only way to heat the wax in your ear would be to hold the candle beneath your ear and let the flame burn up the candle

Good points. And another thing to think about, avocado -- if you believe that the wax build-up in the bottom of the candle comes from your ear, don't you think there'd also be an appreciable amount of build-up in the outer areas of your ear? The toxins and wax wouldn't be magically jumping from your ear into the candle (at least, I haven't heard that claim.) If this "wax" and "debris" were being drawn from deep inside your ear, you'd expect to see an equal amount of deposits along its entire route.
 
Good point Blackwell, I suppose right now it looks like I may have been wrong. We will see conclusively after experiment. I hope. Fish bate, that was a little innapropriate, I was a small child when I was made to have it done, and now I am attempting a skeptical test to measure the processes validity. If you don't have anything construcive to say, other than pointing out my ignorance and stupidity as a child, don't say anything at all.

Guys I will ask the school nurse if she can help today.
 
After reading those links, I will try to find bee wax candles, because randy suggests in that link that the ear wax is actually heated bees wax.
 
Madalch, Suction from a vacume functioned differently than the suction caused by heat. Also, Vaseline is not a good subsitude for ear wax. That experiment will not validate, nor invalidate ear candling. I think the experiment is already fair, unless you have something to add.
My point is that you cannot suck things out of a bottle by creating a vacuum in it. Your ear, like the bottle, has only one opening for air to enter or leave. If you create a partial vacuum in your ear (either by warming up the air, letting it escape, then cooling down what's left, or by applying a vacuum cleaner), the only thing that will leave the ear is air. The wax which is sitting on the sides of the ear canal will not be affected by the lowering of the pressure- unless you have a hole in your head and get a good draft going.

You can vacuum out a tube, but you cannot vacuum out a bottle (assuming the vacuum nozzle doesn't fit inside the bottle....).
 
well, refering back to the egg in a bottle analogy, in theory, the vacume is in the candle and the wax is the egg. Although,I don't see how that would work, because the heat is on the wrong end, or the top of the candle would have to be sealed. You might be right.
 
perhaps this may be beneficial:

Hold the tip of a candle to a piece of paper and ignite the other end. If, when you lift the candle, it does not keep the piece of paper attached to the unlit end, one could assume there is not enough vacuum to clean the wax out of an ear.
 
Fish bate, that was a little innapropriate, I was a small child when I was made to have it done, and now I am attempting a skeptical test to measure the processes validity. If you don't have anything construcive to say, other than pointing out my ignorance and stupidity as a child, don't say anything at all.
How could I point out your ignorance and stupidity as a child when you never mentioned that you were made to do this as a child?
Advising you to see a qualified physician if you have ear problems is not constuctive?

This is a public forum and I will post anything I please as long as it does not violate the rules. If you have ear issues, go see a doctor and stop being an ass.
 
well, refering back to the egg in a bottle analogy, in theory, the vacume is in the candle and the wax is the egg. Although,I don't see how that would work, because the heat is on the wrong end, or the top of the candle would have to be sealed. You might be right.

The difference being that the egg has air behind it to push it into the bottle. The ear wax is on the surface of your skin, and is not going to be pushed out unless your inner ear completely collapses.
 
The protocol we used to convince my friend was we did eight ear candlings: two in a row in each ear, then a complete cleaning with isopropanol and Q-tips, and then the third candling in each wax-free ear. Two more were burned on a plate out of curiousity.

FWIW: candlewax will often burn incompletely and leave residue that does not resemble the original wax in colour or composition. There can be foreign materials mixed into any wax, and there's no reason to expect the manufacturer would itemize them on the product packaging.

We labelled them under code, then my friend was allowed to open and examine them and guess which were the first, second, third, and plate burnings. They pretty much all looked the same, which convinced her that the residue is just crap from burning an overpriced candle.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom