Ear Candling

I remember an old Swift issue that covered ear candling. Ah! Here it is.

There is a lot of info there not only on how ineffective it is, but also how dangerous. Putting burning things in your ears is beyond merely stupid.

But the experiments also showed it didn't work. In a rare burst of honesty, followed by an example of Xtreme Rationalization, one woo had the following comment:
Sandra Yemm now admits that ear candling doesn't remove the wax from one's ears, but not willing to admit that she’s selling quackery, she adds, that's not the point. "It doesn't matter whether [ear wax is] being removed or not because you're going to get some harmony through the changing of the energies and perhaps that's all that's needed" she says.
 
Those of you folks who are being snarky -- please leave avacado alone. He/she is actually trying to experiment, which is a good thing.

Although I probably would not do the ear candling part, because it's dangerous. It's not a truly scientific experiment to NOT do it, but I would simply set up the candle in a similar situation (bottle, as suggested, or maybe try to get a fake model ear) and see if the character of the candle changes without being in an actual human ear.

I'd be very interested in seeing the results of your experiment, avacado. Please do post it here when you're done!
 
Those of you folks who are being snarky -- please leave avacado alone. He/she is actually trying to experiment, which is a good thing.
Doing an experiment is a good thing. Nobody has a problem with that. What we are commenting on is the foolishness of sticking a burning candle in the ear as an experiment.

Although I probably would not do the ear candling part, because it's dangerous.
Would you characetrize this as a foolish act?
 
Those of you folks who are being snarky -- please leave avacado alone. He/she is actually trying to experiment, which is a good thing.

Although I probably would not do the ear candling part, because it's dangerous. It's not a truly scientific experiment to NOT do it, but I would simply set up the candle in a similar situation (bottle, as suggested, or maybe try to get a fake model ear) and see if the character of the candle changes without being in an actual human ear.

I'd be very interested in seeing the results of your experiment, avacado. Please do post it here when you're done!

avacado, please don't try any experiments with ear candles. Other, more competent people have done so and you might burn yourself or your house down.

:mad:
 
Simply adding to the "ear candling doesn't work, period" side of thing, from the Straight Dope.

First we peered into Pat's ears with an otoscope, the familiar flashlight-type examining device. The poor guy had enough wax in there to make his own candles. We put him on the table, lit the candle, and stuck it in his ear in the prescribed manner. Then we watched, struggling to suppress the thought that we should also be chanting and maybe sacrificing small animals.

When the candle had burned down to two inches we snuffed it and examined the treated ear with the otoscope. No change, except that possibly the wax was dented where the candle had been stuck in. Upon slicing open the candle stub, however, we found a considerable quantity of brown wax and whitish powder. The manual had the audacity to intimate that the powder was candida yeast extracted from the ear, conceding that possibly "1% to 10%" was from the used candle. The disappointed MDs were more inclined to say it was 100 percent, but just to be sure we burned another candle in the open air. When we sliced it open we found wax and powder identical to that in the first. Conclusion: it's a hoax. Ain't it always the way? Maybe we're not doing enemas anymore, but we're winding up with the same old stuff.
 
I've got bad news. I've just found out that my grandmother passed away and my grandfather is on the brink. My family is taking it hard and I am going to have to leave the country as soon as I can organize things at work, school, and make passport arrangements. No emoticon can express how sad I am. I won't be able to try the experiment, perhaps all is for the best, you've convinced me it's woo and perhaps it may be too dangerous.

Sorry about the pretentious post Fish Bait.
 
I've got bad news. I've just found out that my grandmother passed away and my grandfather is on the brink. My family is taking it hard and I am going to have to leave the country as soon as I can organize things at work, school, and make passport arrangements.
I'm very sorry to hear of your loss, av.
 
Doing an experiment is a good thing. Nobody has a problem with that. What we are commenting on is the foolishness of sticking a burning candle in the ear as an experiment.

Would you characetrize this as a foolish act?

I would probably not characterize it that way, no. Because when I am trying to persuade someone, I try very hard not to use words that are going to shut off their brains. Calling someone stupid or foolish is likely to do that. In this situation, it is not how I feel or what I know about what's going on; it's about how the other person feels about it, and how I can get them to come to what I know about it (assuming I'm right, of course) on his or her own. Avacado wants to run an experiment. This is good, and it is precisely what we as skeptics should be encouraging him or her to do.

However, I still would advise against sticking a burning candle in the ear, because it's not safe. It lessens the effectiveness of the experiment; still, there would be some value to simply burning a candle and observing that there's debris left over in the candle.

Avacado, do you still have any of the candles that you have previously used in your ears? If so, please consider using those for comparison to the candle(s) you burn independent of your ears. That way, you don't have to stick another burning thing in your ear and risk injury.
 
well, refering back to the egg in a bottle analogy, in theory, the vacume is in the candle and the wax is the egg. Although,I don't see how that would work, because the heat is on the wrong end, or the top of the candle would have to be sealed. You might be right.

The egg in the bottle trick works differently and has a perfectly valid explanation.

Burning a match in a bottle causes the expansion of the air whist the flame heats it which escapes past the egg. Then the air contracts on cooling causing a partial vacuum. Normal air pressure then pushes the egg into the bottle.

I don't see how this applies to a hollow paper and wax tube. Can you explain how it would?
 
I've had time to digest this, and the best comparitive example I can come up with is that if the candle is creating lower pressure, this is identical to the situation we find ourselves in when travelling uphill: the air pressure on the outside of the eardrum is lowered. The difference is that in planes or hiking situations you can equalize it by yawning.

Two things:

1. you feel it to the point of discomfort. Does a person using ear candles feel this unrelieveable pressure?

2. does anything - like skin oil - fly out of your ears when you hike uphill or go up in a plane? Would you expect it to?
 
The egg in the bottle trick works differently and has a perfectly valid explanation.

Burning a match in a bottle causes the expansion of the air whist the flame heats it which escapes past the egg. Then the air contracts on cooling causing a partial vacuum. Normal air pressure then pushes the egg into the bottle.

I don't see how this applies to a hollow paper and wax tube. Can you explain how it would?

I've had time to digest this, and the best comparitive example I can come up with is that if the candle is creating lower pressure, this is identical to the situation we find ourselves in when travelling uphill: the air pressure on the outside of the eardrum is lowered. The difference is that in planes or hiking situations you can equalize it by yawning.

Two things:

1. you feel it to the point of discomfort. Does a person using ear candles feel this unrelieveable pressure?

2. does anything - like skin oil - fly out of your ears when you hike uphill or go up in a plane? Would you expect it to?

Avocado has realized the ear candling is bunk; Avacodo has read and digested the information given, and has reversed his/her stance.
 
Avocado has realized the ear candling is bunk; Avacodo has read and digested the information given, and has reversed his/her stance.

I'm sure that's true. We're still allowed to have a discussion anyway, right? We all benefit from reading a variety of ideas.
 
Apart from the danger of dripping hot wax INTO your ear, I'm sure I read of someone ear-candling themselves alone at home, and catching the curtains alight. House caught fire.......!!
 
Apart from the danger of dripping hot wax INTO your ear, I'm sure I read of someone ear-candling themselves alone at home, and catching the curtains alight. House caught fire.......!!

Yes, I have a case like that listed here:

http://whatstheharm.net/earcandling.html

Not only did she die from smoke inhalation caused by the ensuing fire, but five other people in her apartment complex were left homeless.

If you know of other cases than the ones I have listed, be sure to send them to submit "at" whatstheharm "dot" net.

--Tim Farley
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom