Ear Candling

this charming man

Graduate Poster
Joined
Jul 22, 2007
Messages
1,046
Here (Hear?) is a story on ear candling:

http://doesitwork.msnbc.msn.com/archive/2008/01/17/585352.aspx

I'm just happy with the conclusion. At least they spoke to a real physician.

The aesthetician (funny how they try to make themselves sound clinical) said the residue was fungus. :rolleyes:

My spa experience felt relaxing, but the ear candling didn’t seem to make any kind of difference. Three days later, the popping in my ears is the same as before the procedure. And, after learning more about the dangers of candling, I wouldn’t recommend it for anyone. Next time I’m in the mood for the soothing sounds of Enya, I’ll book a massage.

btw read some of the comments...
 
Ive had ear candling done and the amount of wax removed was frightening. I had enough to make a candle! I had it done because the amount of the substance in my ear made it difficult to hear. I have a friend who majors in sound editing and his proffesor recommended they have it done before their semester started. Also, as a general rule you are supposed to stay indoors for twentyfour hours after the proceedure so that your ear can build up a safe amount of wax in the ear, because it does serve a purpose. However for people where to much wax is a problem, this does seem to work. The vacume created DOES remove a substantial amount of wax from the ear.

Also, if done properly, there is no danger involved. Even if wax does manage to enter the candy and pass the acumilated ear wax inside, it will cool before it enters the ear. That is why you remove the candle before it reaches
a certain length. I am not sure if removing wax is a good thing however this process does remove wax from the ear. That aspect is science.
 
Ive had ear candling done and the amount of wax removed was frightening. I had enough to make a candle! I had it done because the amount of the substance in my ear made it difficult to hear. I have a friend who majors in sound editing and his proffesor recommended they have it done before their semester started. Also, as a general rule you are supposed to stay indoors for twentyfour hours after the proceedure so that your ear can build up a safe amount of wax in the ear, because it does serve a purpose. However for people where to much wax is a problem, this does seem to work. The vacume created DOES remove a substantial amount of wax from the ear.

Ear candling does no such thing. If you burn one of the candlles on a plate and look inside it when it is done, you'll see just as much residue as you would see if you stuck it in your ear to burn. The candle does not produce a vacuum. If it did, you would be deafened as your eardrum burst.
 
Ive had ear candling done and the amount of wax removed was frightening. I had enough to make a candle! I had it done because the amount of the substance in my ear made it difficult to hear. I have a friend who majors in sound editing and his proffesor recommended they have it done before their semester started. Also, as a general rule you are supposed to stay indoors for twentyfour hours after the proceedure so that your ear can build up a safe amount of wax in the ear, because it does serve a purpose. However for people where to much wax is a problem, this does seem to work. The vacume created DOES remove a substantial amount of wax from the ear.

Also, if done properly, there is no danger involved. Even if wax does manage to enter the candy and pass the acumilated ear wax inside, it will cool before it enters the ear. That is why you remove the candle before it reaches
a certain length. I am not sure if removing wax is a good thing however this process does remove wax from the ear. That aspect is science.

No, you are mistaken... Any "result" is due to the placebo effect.

eta...as ID stated a vacuum would be very bad for your ear.
 
Last edited:
I think the author should have stated IT DOES NOT WORK clearly up front, instead of at the very end of the article.

Many of those comments make me feel very sad for humanity.
 
Why is it my ear wax was gone, and the candle was full of a different wax than the candle, which was a pale bees wax, was a dark orange, a different density and weight, and smelt like ear wax? I am willing to have it done again, with unbiased skepticism, recording the process and results, then posting them in the forums to put this mystery to rest. I suppose there are more than one likely exlanations. So I will ignore my personal bias. I think thais fair.
 
Why is it my ear wax was gone, and the candle was full of a different wax than the candle, which was a pale bees wax, was a dark orange, a different density and weight, and smelt like ear wax? I am willing to have it done again, with unbiased skepticism, recording the process and results, then posting them in the forums to put this mystery to rest. I suppose there are more than one likely exlanations. So I will ignore my personal bias. I think thais fair.

Just burn the thing on a plate. The consistency and color of melted wax from a candle with as thick a wick as is used for ear candling should be different from the wax in the unburned candle. Just burn an ear candling candle upright on a plate and you'll see the alleged "earwax."
 
Why is it my ear wax was gone, and the candle was full of a different wax than the candle, which was a pale bees wax, was a dark orange, a different density and weight, and smelt like ear wax? I am willing to have it done again, with unbiased skepticism, recording the process and results, then posting them in the forums to put this mystery to rest. I suppose there are more than one likely exlanations. So I will ignore my personal bias. I think thais fair.
According to the article, plenty of unbiased scientific tests have all ready been done. All show that there is no wax being taken out of the ear.

Besides, how would it work? I'm pretty sure putting a stick in your ear isn't going to create an airtight vacuum and, if it did, you'd seriously injure yourself (the inner ear is pretty delicate). And how would ear wax make it all the way up the stick?
 
That sounds reasonable. To be safe, I will do both in the ear and on a plate. I might have time this weekend, so stay tuned. This is exiting! :D
 
To make things clear, it is not a stick, it is a hollow cadle with a burning top. The heat supposidle warms and draws out the wax.
 
The entry for Ear Candling in my brain reads, "Useless, physically nonsense and dangerous". I've told my brain not to change a word of this based on what I have read here.

If you want to try self medication, try a few drops of hydrogen peroxide. It makes a nice bubbling and crackling noise as it works.

Note -- I am not a Doctor and would never pretend to be, even for money.

At least my government has got it right:
http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/iyh-vsv/med/ear-oreille_e.html
 
Why is it my ear wax was gone, and the candle was full of a different wax than the candle, which was a pale bees wax, was a dark orange, a different density and weight, and smelt like ear wax? I am willing to have it done again, with unbiased skepticism, recording the process and results, then posting them in the forums to put this mystery to rest. I suppose there are more than one likely exlanations. So I will ignore my personal bias. I think thais fair.

The issue has already been put to rest; Science and Medicine have shown that. I am not aware of any double-blind study that shows that ear candling "works"

http://www.randi.org/jr/02-02-2001.html

http://www.bcm.edu/oto/grand/04_27_06.htm

http://altmed.creighton.edu/ear/experiment.htm
 
Being a guinea pig is a fine hobby by my standards, although that article makes it seam dangerous.
 
To make things clear, it is not a stick, it is a hollow cadle with a burning top. The heat supposidle warms and draws out the wax.

First you said it was a vacuum, now the candle draws ear wax out by heat...

Ear candling does neither.
 
Last edited:
That sounds reasonable. To be safe, I will do both in the ear and on a plate. I might have time this weekend, so stay tuned. This is exiting! :D

Yes! Ignoring the snarky replies, this is exactly the kind of experiment you (and those other proponents) should be doing. Make sure both of them are done at the same angle. I'm not sure what other kinds of controls should be in place.
 
Charming man, You misinterpreted what I said. You know how to get an egg into a bottle? Pickle it, stick it onto the entrance, heat the bottom and the egg will get sucked in. In theory this is how ear canceling works. I am not claiming it is the truth, that is why I am going to experiment. It is no problem for me because I can get them for free.
 
Last edited:
ok, alfaniner. Anyone have anymore ideas to make this experiment more acurate, or scientific?
 
Charming man, You misinterpreted what I said. You know how to get an egg into a bottle? Pickle it, stick it onto the entrance, heat the bottom and the egg will get sucked in. In theory this is how ear canceling works. I am not claiming it is the truth, that is why I am going to experiment. It is no problem for me because I can get them for free.
eta:
ok, alfaniner. Anyone have anymore ideas to make this experiment more acurate, or scientific?

Perhaps I have misinterpreted; for that I apologize; however, please read the links I have provided. Please do use care when you do your experiment. If you can find someone who has no idea what ear candling is and what it is "supposed" to do, that person may be a better test subject. You could do the candling and record what he or she experienced. It would be important for this person not to have any knowledge of the supposed effects of the candling.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom