Dowsing for spirits

Not to continue the derail or anything, but there is a very clear difference between expensive and cheap vodka. If you run the cheapest vodka you can find through a water filter 4 or 5 times it will end up almost identical to the most expensive.
I thought the Mythbusters busted that one? From what I recall, running cheap vodka through a filter made it better, but it was still not nearly as good as the expensive stuff.
 
It did noticably improve it, and a "professional taster" was able to correctly order the unfiltered, once filtered, twice filtered, etc. etc. cheap stuff, and the good stuff. I don't remember if their conclusion was that the filtered stuff was "not nearly as good" as the expensive stuff, or if it was "good enough that anything less than a perfect palate won't be able to tell the difference".

ETA:
http://kwc.org/mythbusters/2006/04/episode_50_bullets_fired_up_vo.html
The myth was:
You can turn low-end vodka into top-shelf vodka with six filtrations of a domestic charcoal water filter (i.e. Brita filters)
Conclusion: Busted.

Still, that doesn't exactly contradict what Cuddles said.
 
Last edited:
Not to derail this derail, but...

For the Record it's been 48 hours since tiger last posted that he/she knows that dowsing for water is real & scientific, yada yada yada.
Well. the exact quote was
Sure! But I still stand by my statement I consider water dowsing a scientific situation, I do not consider it under the dream of psychic abilitys.

Yet, he/she did visit the forum today.
So tiger, have you performed the dowsing experiment double-blinded yet?
 
Tiger has made the jump over to the UK-Skeptics Forum and is trolling like....well...a troll.

Dive over and fly the flag for reason. You do not need to be in the UK to register....:D ;)
 
Tiger has made the jump over to the UK-Skeptics Forum and is trolling like....well...a troll.

Dive over and fly the flag for reason. You do not need to be in the UK to register....:D ;)

Wish I could help, but when he refers to "sources of wood,water,metal,soil and magnatism and how they all work together and conincide and take on each others properties" I haven't a clue what he's talking about.
 
Last edited:
Phew!

I thought my brain had stopped working.....I cant work it out either. ;)
 
edge's brain is going to go stupid reading all that stuff.

...and he needs to concentrate on fixing the protocols before April 1st deadline.



PS: I read all hocking's stuff. Amazing isn't it how a think can be slanted to give an impression opposite of what actually ocurred. I remind myself of that whenever I see a study that has shown that water has cured something or other (I'm talking homoeopathy here, of course)


edit: Sorry, wrong thread!
 
Last edited:
I thought the Mythbusters busted that one? From what I recall, running cheap vodka through a filter made it better, but it was still not nearly as good as the expensive stuff.

It depends what you mean by "As good as the expensive stuff". From CynicalSkeptic's post it seems that they actually tested if it tasted "the same as" and not "as good as". I have no doubt that a professional tester would be able to tell the difference but this does not mean that one is better than the other, only that they taste different and he already knows what the expensive one tastes like. A wine taster can tell the difference between two wines, but that doesn't mean that one is better than other, just that they are recognisably different.

Of course, it also depends what you mean by "expensive". Our tests were done as students and didn't exactly use the most expensive drinks we could find. While you can debate whether cheap vodka can be made as good as anything else, there is no doubt that it can be made a lot better, and for many people this means making it as good as a regular supermarket brand and not some really expensive, high class stuff.

In fact, Mythbusters actually debunk their own debunking here.
Anthony showed off his tasting skills: his ranking corresponded exactly to the number of filtrations,
[snip]
They analyzed the vodka samples and found that there was no difference in chemical composition between the filtered vodka and the unfiltered vodka.
They claim there is no difference between filtered and unfiltered, and yet their taster could tell the difference.

You're better off buying the top-shelf stuff than wasting a bunch of water filters.
In fact, given the price of water filters and the price of top-shelf vodka, you are much better off filtering cheap stuff than buying expensive stuff. Unless of course you are a professional vodka taster.
 
edge's brain is going to go stupid reading all that stuff.

...and he needs to concentrate on fixing the protocols before April 1st deadline.



PS: I read all hocking's stuff. Amazing isn't it how a think can be slanted to give an impression opposite of what actually ocurred. I remind myself of that whenever I see a study that has shown that water has cured something or other (I'm talking homoeopathy here, of course)


edit: Sorry, wrong thread!
Might have been my fault - I quoted a post in the Million Dollar Forum where Edge is banging on about his dowsing proficiency (but inability to take the Challenge).

When I hunted my own articles out, I was surprised that I'd whacked the Betz thing in 1999 and people still quote it as "scientific proof".

One day I'll do a proper write up - dowsing is a bit of a hobby for me. In 22 years in the oil industry, working on every continent except Antarctica, I'm yet to find one person that has seen it used, or heard about it being used, even just for site water sources. Considering the war stories and flat out "urban" legends I *have* heard, the fact I've not had a dowsing story thrown at me is, frankly, a surprise.
 
Tiger has made the jump over to the UK-Skeptics Forum and is trolling like....well...a troll.

Dive over and fly the flag for reason. You do not need to be in the UK to register....:D ;)

Reading his posts there makes my brain hurt.
 
In fact, Mythbusters actually debunk their own debunking here.

They claim there is no difference between filtered and unfiltered, and yet their taster could tell the difference.

Dunno, Cuddles. It depends on what they measured. Many stereospecific flavorants don't show up in the classical tests for ethanol its congeners. We really would have to see what they meant by "chemical testing" to see whether or not the various vodkas were equivalent.

My guess is that they didn't test for all "flavorants" as this test would have been ruinously expensive.
 
Tiger, if you're still convinced there's something in this, you can easily test this for yourself. Get ten buckets, get someone to put water in some of them and cover them. Get someone else to move them around. Get both people to leave (in case they subconciously lead you toward certain buckets) and try to dowse for water. Rinse and repeat, record your results. Then set up the same thing, but for someone just choosing buckets at random. You'll find that the dowsing guy will do no better than the random guy.

One suggestion - I would put the water in something in the bucket. (Assuming the open/control test proves you can detect through the two containers).

If you put water directly into the bucket/s you may end up with condensation on the outside.
 
Can anyone enlighten me about dowsing for spirits! I know for a fact that taking 2 brazing rods and bending them can help find water, I have done and seen this myself it works. But these paranormal groups are doing this with allegedly trying to located alleged ghosts.

Why dowse for spirits when you can drink them?

Just ask the guy behind the bar for some. No searching needed.





















YEAH I KNOW THE JOKE WAS ALREADY MADE! SUE ME!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom