Dowsing for spirits

I tried dowsing. In the spirit of open-mindedness I devoted a whole day to farting around with sticks over jars of random gumph. Didn't work. What now?

see, that's your problem. It only works with brazing rods and water. Just ask Tiger, he knows everything.
 
I do believe there is something to the dowsing for water that's all sceintific..
A little vocabulary tip here, Tiger. The word you really want to use here is 'scientifical'. Just 'flows' better, don'cha know.

Oh, and, years ago, I did try my hand at dowsing. I must be pretty inept, 'cause I couldn't even get the ideomotor effect to work!
 
So tiger--what to you suspect is moving the rods then--some kind of mystical power?
 
My company was on a project that required vapor probes to be driven into the ground around a fuel station on a military base. The Air Force had their line locate guy come out and mark the locations of the buried fuel pipes and electric cables. He pulled out his bent welding rods, walked a path in the most reasonable place for buried fuel lines to be, marked the location with bright orange spray paint, then signed a form stating that the utilities had been located.

Our crew questioned this, and was told that this was standard procedure. To be cautious, the crew moved more than 10 feet away from the orange lines, and drove several steel probes dead center through the buried diesel pipe. When I got there, the pavement was busted out, ground water had run into the diesel line, filled the diesel tank, and floated hundreds of gallons of diesel out into the pit. The cost was well over $50,000 to clean up the mess, and another $50,000 or so to replace the fuel station - and the Air Force paid for it - since we had the signed form and the orange paint on the pavement.

Your dowsing tax dollars at work.
 
Tiger, I know it's difficult and embarrassing to admit to being wrong, but please try not to take offence and clam up.

Well put. I've learned a heck of a lot more from being wrong than being right. And I've learned a lot over the years.

I also once believed in dowsing. The first house I bought was in the country and that means septic tanks. The inspector who did the perk test on the property offered to show me where the leaching tiles ran and I accepted his kind offer. He pulled out two bent wires and told me where they were. He let me try dowsing with his get-up but couldn't get the stupid wires to do squat. He told me to keep practicing and I would get better. Years afterwards, I had to have a new leaching field put in and when the engineer excavated the system, the tiles did not lay as the dowser had told me. That's when I became a little suspicious.

To tiger: try it again with distilled water. Better still, have someone fill up cups with either distilled and tap water and see if you can tell which is which. If not, it's not dissolved minerals and must be something else. That's how science works.
 
I did this and experenced it was in college during a Physical Science class the professor showed it could be done. But he used the brazing rods and so me and others tried it and it worked by setting a cup of water on the floor.

it was just performed by a professor with the rods and a cup of water. Some of us tried it and the rods spread apart when they came over the water in the cup. And It's been along time ago so I don't remember everything he said to explain it and so forth.

I think I see the problem. The Prof explained the ideomotor effect but, he failed to explain it well enough so that you would understand and remember it.
 
but what gets me is the claim that rods move because we expect them to. Is someone saying that people can will
objects to move. And the hand is moving the objects without the participants knowledge is a little hard to swallow boys.

Dude, seriously...

You are making yourself look very, very foolish here. If you've never heard of the ideomotor effect (the "hand moving the objects without the participant's knowledge"), I can see where it might seem hard to swallow. However, your personal incredulity doesn't change the fact it is a thoroughly established physiological phenomenon, well-documented, well-understood, easily testable and reproducible -- in other words, all the things that dowsing is not. We're not asking you to take our word on this. We have given you links to read and ways of demonstrating it yourself, any of which would take less than five minutes to deal with. But instead you keep closing your eyes and sticking your fingers in your ears and making raspberry noises, and demanding that people prove you wrong.

You want someone to prove you wrong? Fine. I can! Now prove that I can't!

(Note: the correct response to that is, "I can! Now prove that I can't!" And that is why we don't deal in proving negatives.)
 
Last edited:
Tiger, if you're still convinced there's something in this, you can easily test this for yourself. Get ten buckets, get someone to put water in some of them and cover them. Get someone else to move them around. Get both people to leave (in case they subconciously lead you toward certain buckets) and try to dowse for water. Rinse and repeat, record your results. Then set up the same thing, but for someone just choosing buckets at random. You'll find that the dowsing guy will do no better than the random guy.
 
Last edited:
Oh wait heres a ten year study done by the University of Munich
that claims 96 % rate with dowsing. I think Mr. Randi just lost 1 million dollars to that University. Wow 10years and 2000 wells and a test rate with water dowsers at 96 % going to be hard to dispute this since this
site is always saying there's a rational explaination thru science.

http://www.twm.co.nz/dowsing_jse_com.html

Here's my summary of that Betz 3rd hand account:
http://groups.google.com/group/sci.skeptic/msg/e97497094efc61e5

In short - he summarises the dowsers account only.

The dowser only discusses some of the wells, and then, only the successes.

The clincher is in the first paragraph of the full report where the DOWSER states that the dowser NEVER had any input on the final positioning of a wells site.

Other thing to note is that the Engineers and Geos put in 5 years of review and study of the area and the previous drilling campaigns before they started well work.

Dowsing had nothing to do with siting the wells, nor the success of these drilling campaigns.

Oh, and before you say, "try it yourself".
Been there, done that:
http://groups.google.com/group/sci.skeptic/msg/e97497094efc61e5

Didn't work.

Occam's razor. If bent wire can find water (or oil) - why does industry spend billions on seismic and interpretation each year, when they could just hire a dowser for a few hundred?
 
I think tiger may be a shill for the brazing rod company. He's just trying to drive up sales.
 
In response to this thread's original question, I have found an explanation by someone named "whistling owl" as to why they believe dowsing rods indicate the presence of spooks and spirits.

Dowsing is intuition technology. Like most things in the world, it is not 100% accurate and like ghost investigating it is not an exact science. We are dealing with intuition and collective unconscious sending messages through a human mind.

Such inexactitude fits right in with the idea that the dowsing rods indicate a spooks presence, but you just can't confirm it, since spooks are invisible.
 
I was hoping this thread was about vodka.

Carry on.

Talking of vodka, i was in the supermarket yesterday and didn't know which brand of my favourite drink to buy. So i bought three different bottles. All different brands.

What this forum needs is more vodka-based threads for us serious drinkers to discuss our favourite tipple.

P.S I ma nto drnuk.
 
Talking of vodka, i was in the supermarket yesterday and didn't know which brand of my favourite drink to buy. So i bought three different bottles. All different brands.

What this forum needs is more vodka-based threads for us serious drinkers to discuss our favourite tipple.

P.S I ma nto drnuk.

Speaking of things that need to be debunked - I read a book on marketing that reminded readers that truely unique and exceptional producte don't need much marketing. They stand out on their own. How much advertising does the best restaurant in your town do?

But products that are otherwise indistinguishable need lots of marketing. They need branding and consumer loyalty. They have to make the package stand out because the product doesn't. The book advised that one product like this is vodka. Why all the different artistic bottles? Sky and Grey Goose and Absolut all have very distinctive bottles. It's because the product inside is identical.

Pour yourself three small tastes of your three vodkas. Mix them up and try to identify which is which. Try to identify which you like the most. Then do it again. Did you match the vodkas? Did you pick the same one as your favorite?

I'm honestly curious. I don't drink and, although the book made sense to me, I'd love confirmation.

[Sorry for the derail. Mods move the post if you'd like.]
 
Pour yourself three small tastes of your three vodkas. Mix them up and try to identify which is which. Try to identify which you like the most. Then do it again. Did you match the vodkas? Did you pick the same one as your favorite?

Not to continue the derail or anything, but there is a very clear difference between expensive and cheap vodka. If you run the cheapest vodka you can find through a water filter 4 or 5 times it will end up almost identical to the most expensive. Not that I'm cheap or anything. Of course, if you drink it mixed in sensible proportions (say, 50-50) with coke or orange juice then you shouldn't be able to taste it anyway. At least not if you drink it fast enough.
 
Continuing the derail, i can tell the difference between good and bad vodka.
If i drink a shot of cheap vodka, it feels like my throat is being attacked by a blowtorch, however, if i have a shot of Smirnoff Black, it doesn't.

I can also ascertain the difference by using dowsing rods, if i hold my top-quality rods over a cheap and nasty bottle of vodka they go haywire because of all the impurities, if i hold them over a top-notch bottle they don't.

So there.

Again, i must reiterate i am not drunk.
 
I can also ascertain the difference by using dowsing rods, if i hold my top-quality rods over a cheap and nasty bottle of vodka they go haywire because of all the impurities, if i hold them over a top-notch bottle they don't.

So there.

Again, i must reiterate i am not drunk.


The problem with n00bs is that you can't tell when they're joking.
 
JOKING?????

How dare you sir?

I take my vodka drinking very, very seriously, and to ensure that i only drink excellent vodka i only use top-of-the-range-guaranteed-to-work-vodka-quality-testing-dowsing-rods to make sure i only drink the best stuff.

Although i must confess i do get some funny looks from people in the supermarket when i use them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom