Dowsing for spirits

No you have missed the point: dowsing has been tested many, many, many times and in every single test that was a "double blind" test it did not work.

What you are trying to argue is that we all should keep throwing balls up into the air to check again that gravity is still "working".

However if we are wrong and you are the first person ever to be able to prove dowsing works under controlled circumstances you could very quickly be a million dollars richer, never mind revolutionising how we all think about the world.
You know what dismiss it all even though your dealing with nature and
science just walk away. Oh by the way theres a link up there from a science field test maybe you should read.
 
Uuhmm...Yes, you have missed the point, tiger. The rods move, but it doesn't mean anything.

I actually did an experiment one time where I had a stage divided up into grids and I hid a bucket of water under the stage. I sent people in one at a time to try to dowse which grid square the bucket was underneath. The locations that people chose were scattered all over the place, with no preference for any particular spot. Obviously, the dowsing didn't work.

That's because it doesn't work. Oh yes, the rods may move, but it has nothing to do with the water.

Imagine this: you're back in your "science" class testing the brazing rods. Only this time, that cup in the middle of the floor has a lid so that you can't see inside it. What we're all trying to tell you is that the brazing rods will move even if there's no water in the cup, just because you expect them to move. The whole point of the brazing rods is that you hold them in a way so that it is fairly difficult to hold them still, so that tiny movements of your hands will make the rod swing.

Oh wait heres a ten year study done by the University of Munich
that claims 96 % rate with dowsing. I think Mr. Randi just lost 1 million dollars to that University. Wow 10years and 2000 wells and a test rate with water dowsers at 96 % going to be hard to dispute this since this
site is always saying there's a rational explaination thru science.

http://www.twm.co.nz/dowsing_jse_com.html
 
Tiger,

Prof. Betz is operating outside his field if he was reporting on dowsing. He's a biblical scholar, not a physicist. It's like getting your greengrocer to advise on house-building.

Look him up here.

And he was NOT responsible for the 10-Year Study, nor was the Munich University. A bunch of Sri Lankan dowsers were. In short, he was scammed by "professional" dowsers to give them free advertising.

BIG hint: In your referred page, the ONLY source of information was The American Dowser magazine.
 
Oh wait heres a ten year study done by the University of Munich
that claims 96 % rate with dowsing. I think Mr. Randi just lost 1 million dollars to that University. Wow 10years and 2000 wells and a test rate with water dowsers at 96 % going to be hard to dispute this since this
site is always saying there's a rational explaination thru science.

http://www.twm.co.nz/dowsing_jse_com.html

A study published in "Journal of Scientific Exploration" which is not a peer reviewed journal, this is from their "Instructions for Authors"

REFEREEING: In established disciplines, concordance with accepted disciplinary paradigms is the chief guide in evaluating material for scholarly publication. On the matters of interest to the Society for Scientific Exploration, however, consensus does not prevail. Therefore the Journal of Scientific Exploration necessarily publishes claimed observations and proffered explanations that will seem more speculative or less plausible than in some mainstream disciplinary journals. Nevertheless, those observations and explanations must conform to rigorous standards of observational techniques and logical argument.
 
This may be off-topic but I just noticed this in their "Instructions for Authors"

PAGE CHARGES: As with publications of other scientific societies, the Journal of Scientific Exploration costs more to produce than the subscription price for individuals. Authors are requested wherever possible to help defray these costs by making a contribution in the form of page charges of $30 per journal page.

Is the section I've put in bold standard or not unusual for science periodicals?
 
Was the test double blind?

Well, that's the important question. I have two brothers, one a believer in dowsing and similar stuff, the other a scientist. The dowsing brother was making claims for the efficacy of dowing one day, so the scientist brother constructed a little double blind test. The dowsing not only failed, but failed miserably. So, I haven't tried dowsing for myself, but I've seen someone else try it for himself, and it just didn't work.
 
This may be off-topic but I just noticed this in their "Instructions for Authors"



Is the section I've put in bold standard or not unusual for science periodicals?
Sure! But I still stand by my statement I consider water dowsing a scientific situation, I do not consider it under the dream of psychic abilitys.
We are dealing with nature and I beleive there is some truth to it, but not
all of it. I won't dismiss something has not being science when it is dealing with nature. Someone has labeled this has paranormal and has with everything in nature we haven't learned it all, but theres a difference between nature and paranormal. And like I said it may not be all true
but were looking at this has paranormal abilitys and not from a sceince point of veiw. You claimed I missed the point but I haven't your looking at
it from a paranormal side and I'm looking at it from the side of nature.
And nature is always science, but what gets me is the claim that rods move because we expect them to. Is someone saying that people can will
objects to move. And the hand is moving the objects without the participants knowledge is a little hard to swallow boys. I wonder why the million is still there maybe because it's, oh your hand moving them.
 
Sure! But I still stand by my statement I consider water dowsing a scientific situation, I do not consider it under the dream of psychic abilitys.
We are dealing with nature and I beleive there is some truth to it, but not
all of it. I won't dismiss something has not being science when it is dealing with nature. Someone has labeled this has paranormal and has with everything in nature we haven't learned it all, but theres a difference between nature and paranormal. And like I said it may not be all true
but were looking at this has paranormal abilitys and not from a sceince point of veiw. You claimed I missed the point but I haven't your looking at
it from a paranormal side and I'm looking at it from the side of nature.
And nature is always science, but what gets me is the claim that rods move because we expect them to. Is someone saying that people can will
objects to move. And the hand is moving the objects without the participants knowledge is a little hard to swallow boys. I wonder why the million is still there maybe because it's, oh your hand moving them.
You say believe (well sometimes beleive) a lot. What other people here are suggesting is that you test this belief in a methodical fashion. If you're not willing to do this and instead just want to preach then you're welcome to do that, just don't expect much in the way of success.
 
Sure! But I still stand by my statement I consider water dowsing a scientific situation,

Even though the scientific evidence is that it does not work or rather is not what it is claimed to be i.e. a method of detecting substances.
I do not consider it under the dream of psychic abilitys.
We are dealing with nature and I beleive there is some truth to it, but not
all of it. I won't dismiss something has not being science when it is dealing with nature.

I have no idea what you are going on about. Dowsing has been tested many times and whenever those tests are "scientific" (i.e. controlled, double blind experiments) it has never been shown to be a method that can detect substances.

It does not matter how it is supposed to work since there is no evidence that it does work.

...snip... You claimed I missed the point but I haven't your looking at
it from a paranormal side and I'm looking at it from the side of nature.
...snip..

I am not looking at it from any "side", I just look at the evidence which is overwhelmingly negative and from that I draw the conclusion that it is not possible to detect anything with the technique known as "dowsing".
 
Tiger, I know it's difficult and embarrassing to admit to being wrong, but please try not to take offence and clam up. Do read some of what's been presented to you. Insofar as I have ever confidently believed anything paranormal, it was dowsing, and it was for very similar reasons as you.

Only a little over a year ago, if someone had asked me about dowsing, I'd have said (and did say) "oh yes, that works; archaeologists use it to find buried features". Though I had little experience (even reinforcing positive experience such as actually seeing it "work") I was quite confident in saying this because my (sixth form) college archaeology lecturer had told me how it worked. I had seen New Age types waving sticks and pendulums around, but this didn't faze me; I just assumed that there was "scientific" dowsing and "woo" dowsing. Maybe the crystal thing was bunk, but the metal rods could detect changes in magnetic fields left by buried ditches and banks? I didn't give it a lot of thought, nor research, because:

a) I was 17, and lazy!
b) I was interested, but enough to research it
c) I had yet (1996) to be shown the wonders of the internet
d) Most importantly, I trusted, liked, and looked up to my lecturer - he was young, one of the "good guys", not some stuffy academic, and had real experience and enthusiasm for the subject. But he still carried the authority of an educational institution.

I didn't think too much about this; I simply filed it away in the old brain. Some years later, now in my second career job, an equally respected colleague and frequenter of this forum was discussing "woo" with me; astrology if I recall correctly. Having taken some time to research that topic, I had independently come to the conclusion that it was bunk, and so I was eagerly agreeing as such with my friend. Then he happened to mention dowsing. I responded as above; "oh, but that works, doesn't it?". I got fairly short shrift from him, and realising that I had never truly thought it through critically, I backed down and hit the web right away, including my first visit to Randi.org. Of course I soon found the references to the ideomotor effect, confirmational bias, and the lack of any empirical evidence for water dowsing. I felt pretty silly, but relieved and grateful that I had been gently prodded down the route of universal critical thinking, not just about topics that I personally found implausible, ludicrous, or silly.

Hopefully you can also take a step back, set aside any animosity you've built up over this thread, and start to see the complete lack of real, verifiable evidence for what should be entirely within the capability of science to test. If dowsing finds water, dowsers should be able to perform better than pure chance. They can't. Just like "psychics", astrologers, tarot readers, and all the other self-deluded, well-meaning people (as well as outright charlatans) that choose to believe and perpetuate this stuff in order to feel special and of worth to the community (not that most of them couldn't be in other ways, if they tried).

If you have a "BS meter" at all, a few minutes reading of the links provided should start it beeping. Try not to rely on what you've seen in the past; there are many reasons why, and ways in which, the most intelligent and astute of us can be deceived. After all, thinking uncritically, David Copperfield's antics appear "real". But deep down, you know your eyes are deceiving you. You just don't know how. This only difference here is that dowsers (for the most part) don't know that they are deceiving you, as well as themselves. Any that do, well, it's they that deserve contempt, not the self-deluders, and certainly not the casual observers like you or I. Hopefully, you will find out the "how" of dowsing, and apply the same critical approach to anything you don't understand.

It's what we don't take the trouble to understand that has the power to deceive us.
 
Last edited:
It does not matter how it is supposed to work since there is no evidence that it does work.
Not only that, there is clear evidence that it does not work!

tiger, I don't think too many people will want to argue this with you.
Dowsing has so completely been proven to be bogus, that we just laugh whenever we hear "but it really works because this friend of my cousins...!".

Don't tell us to go test it, since many of us have. We've been good enough to actually try what you are suggesting. Why can't you do the same thing and try what we're suggesting?

Honestly, we're not in denial about the way the world works. We're the ones with open eyes.
 
Sure! But I still stand by my statement I consider water dowsing a scientific situation, I do not consider it under the dream of psychic abilitys.
We are dealing with nature and I beleive there is some truth to it, but not
all of it. I won't dismiss something has not being science when it is dealing with nature. Someone has labeled this has paranormal and has with everything in nature we haven't learned it all, but theres a difference between nature and paranormal. And like I said it may not be all true
but were looking at this has paranormal abilitys and not from a sceince point of veiw. You claimed I missed the point but I haven't your looking at
it from a paranormal side and I'm looking at it from the side of nature.
And nature is always science, but what gets me is the claim that rods move because we expect them to. Is someone saying that people can will
objects to move. And the hand is moving the objects without the participants knowledge is a little hard to swallow boys. I wonder why the million is still there maybe because it's, oh your hand moving them.
If you aren't satisfied with this explanation you are welcome to come up with another explanation and test it scientifically. However, when you test for the ideometer effect vs the dowsing explanation, dowsing doesn't work, so scientifically, there is no reason to believe that dowsing works.
 
But you can prove me wrong by getting 2 brazing rods and trying it yourself.
No, I can't, because even if I find no effect, you can just say that I wasn't doing it right, or I don't have the ability. Proving a negative in this way is not possible.

But you can prove yourself right (if you have the ability you claim) by taking a test yourself, and you can even win a million Dollars by doing it.
 
Sure! But I still stand by my statement I consider water dowsing a scientific situation
Why?

I t has repeatedly been pointed out to you that science has a perfect explanation for your personal experience of dowsing. This is called ideomotor effect, but you choose to ignore it. Science also has a method to overcome the ideomotor effect, and that is called double-blind testing, and you also choose to ignore this.

At least you could explain why double-blind testing is not relevant to your thinking, and why you do not think the ideomotor effect if applicable.
 
Tiger, I know it's difficult and embarrassing to admit to being wrong, but please try not to take offence and clam up. Do read some of what's been presented to you. Insofar as I have ever confidently believed anything paranormal, it was dowsing, and it was for very similar reasons as you.

Tiger, same thing with me. I once also assumed dowsing was a real, nature-based phenomena. Just like you, I'd assumed it "had something to do with the minerals in the water". I've since learned how the ideomotor effect works and why it works. There's never anything wrong with learning something new.
 
I tried dowsing. In the spirit of open-mindedness I devoted a whole day to farting around with sticks over jars of random gumph. Didn't work. What now?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom