Dowsing for spirits

I have no doubt the rods worked convincingly when moving over a cup of water.



Randi sort of did the same thing when he had dowsers "dowse" a pipe with water flowing through it. They were told in advance which pipe had water, so the dowsing rods worked flawlessly. But when they didn't know in advance, their dowsing efforts significantly failed.

The video is a little slow moving, so skip ahead, go right to 32:17, or even 34:17, and listen as Randi explains the results of the test, and the ideomotor effect.
I do believe there is something to the dowsing for water that's all sceintific
but how far down does it work I don't really know. It has a history to it which I believe at some point turned sour with people claiming divine
power, psychic ability and so forth. Thats kind of what I saw on the
video, with claims I'm psychic because of this. I don't know his but I think it has more to do with the minerals in the water than anything else.
 
Hey I don't no anything about all your delusional concepts ...well lets just say screw ball thoughts.

This is just too bizarre, tiger. You think metal rods can detect hidden water in your hands although dowsing has been debunked more times than you have years and you have the temerity to call anything "delusional". Will wonders never cease? Have you so little education that you don't know that dowsing has been claimed effective in finding just about anything on this planet?

You've come to the exact wrong place on earth to be taken seriously. You don't know what the ideomotor effect is, you don't know what a double blind test is, and you can't spell "construed" to save your life. Go away and come back after you've grown a brain.
 
This is just too bizarre, tiger. You think metal rods can detect hidden water in your hands although dowsing has been debunked more times than you have years and you have the temerity to call anything "delusional". Will wonders never cease? Have you so little education that you don't know that dowsing has been claimed effective in finding just about anything on this planet?

You've come to the exact wrong place on earth to be taken seriously. You don't know what the ideomotor effect is, you don't know what a double blind test is, and you can't spell "construed" to save your life. Go away and come back after you've grown a brain.
You know I hope I meet you someday face to face!
 
Please don't be rude to Tiger - he is only just starting to realise that he is right at the start of his education on this, not in the middle.

Tiger, you need to go to Google and look up the following two subjects. Should take you only a moment or two, and it will go towards explaining properly a lot of what you may have believed was so.

Ideomotor effect
Double blinded testing
 
This is just too bizarre, tiger. You think metal rods can detect hidden water in your hands although dowsing has been debunked more times than you have years and you have the temerity to call anything "delusional". Will wonders never cease? Have you so little education that you don't know that dowsing has been claimed effective in finding just about anything on this planet?

You've come to the exact wrong place on earth to be taken seriously. You don't know what the ideomotor effect is, you don't know what a double blind test is, and you can't spell "construed" to save your life. Go away and come back after you've grown a brain.
Oh of course you have the chance to try it yourself little man and prove me wrong so why don't you!
 
Please don't be rude to Tiger - he is only just starting to realise that he is right at the start of his education on this, not in the middle.

Tiger, you need to go to Google and look up the following two subjects. Should take you only a moment or two, and it will go towards explaining properly a lot of what you may have believed was so.

Ideomotor effect
Double blinded testing
I appreciate your links! However no need to defend against me Slimeball has I said He can either put up or shut up. He's only here to cause has much trouble has he can and has always with him he can't get beyond proving anyone wrong. Well Slime ball you going to prove me wrong or sit at your computer and get fat, come on lets see it little man.
 
However no need to defend against me Slimeball has I said He can either put up or shut up. He's only here to cause has much trouble has he can and has always with him he can't get beyond proving anyone wrong.

Maybe you can dowse up a grammar book, eh, tiger?

Well Slime ball you going to prove me wrong or sit at your computer and get fat, come on lets see it little man.
OK. Did it. Didn't work. Go away. Grow brain. Buh-bye!!! :p


Keep in mind your membership agreement concerning civility toward other members. I expect the two of you to stop this mudslinging immediately and stick to substantive discussion concerning the topic.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: jmercer
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Maybe you can dowse up a grammar book, eh, tiger?



OK. Did it. Didn't work. Go away. Grow brain. Buh-bye!!! :p
Like I said slimeball put up or shut up! Prove me wrong, go get your camcorder and some brazing rods and prove me wrong. Whats the matter
is personal attacks all you have...little man!:D


Keep in mind your membership agreement concerning civility toward other members. I expect the two of you to stop this mudslinging immediately and stick to substantive discussion concerning the topic.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: jmercer
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Don't make me reach back there!

istockphoto_106384_family_vacation.jpg

http://www1.istockphoto.com/file_thumbview_approve/106384/2/istockphoto_106384_family_vacation.jpg
 
Tiger, have you read up those links I gave you yet? If not, how about it, OK?

Or are you here just for a mud-wrestle with the other brats...
 
Tiger, have you read up those links I gave you yet? If not, how about it, OK?

Or are you here just for a mud-wrestle with the other brats...
I read them...yes! But like I said this mud wrestling is between me and him
and noone else.
 
OK, OK, you've got me. Here's the video
Oh wow slimeball someone else already did that! I think we need you and your own video proving me wrong. You came on here looking for a fight
and you have got your wish. Go get your video camera and some brazing rods and prove me wrong. Do you have the gut's or not! You came on this topic talking smack now back it up! Stop using others peoples hard work!
 
If I may interrput the schoolyard taunting for a brief moment...

Tiger, here's the thing that people have eluded to, but I don't think anyone has explained yet. When you tried the rods in class, I'm sure they worked very well. But the reason they moved isn't because they "detected" water; it's because you expected them to move, and therefore you moved them without realizing you were moving them. Yes, really.

I know, I know you swear you didn't move them. But you did. This is called the "idiometer response." Here's another way to demonstrate it. Take a ring or a key or any other small-ish object with a hole in it. Thread a string about two feet long through it, and hold the ends of the string together so the ring dangles freely. Rest your elbow on the table and hold the ends of the string between your index finger and thumb. With your other hand, stop the ring from swinging so it's perfectly still. Now be as still as you possibly can, but just imagine the ring swinging back and forth, away from you and back toward you. Pretty soon the ring will actually start to move that way, even though you think you're being still. The longer you think about it, the further it will swing. Now change direction and think about it swinging side to side, and soon the ring will follow suit. Ditto with swinging in a circle, both clockwise and counter-clockwise. It works because when you think about the motion, your body produces an involuntary movement that's too small for you to feel, but big enough to start the ring swinging. It's the same thing that makes Ouija boards work... and dowsing rods.

So back to the test you did. If you don't believe me that it was just the ideometer effect, here's how to tell whether it was or not. If it was really the rods finding the water, then they should be able to find it whether you know where it is or not, right? So try this: get ten paper cups and ten paper bags. Put one cup in each bag, but leave the tops of the bags open so you can see into them. Spread them around the room. Put water in five of the cups. Check your dowsing rods to make sure "they" work, which they very probably will as long as you know which cups have water in them. Then try this: leave the room, and have a friend go in and mix the bags up and close up the tops, so that when you walk back in, all you'll see is ten closed bags and you won't know which ones contain water. Have your friend leave the room. Then see how well the dowsing rods work with the bags closed. "Dowse" all ten bags, and make a record of which ones you think have water in them before you look inside any of them. Once you've made your choices, then open them up and see how accurate the rods were. Then see if you still think there's anything to it.

Oh, and yes, people have been using this "technique" to allegedly find water and all sorts of other things for years. The thing is, they've all been mistaken. Yes, all of them, every single time, for all those years. And if you think that many people couldn't possibly be that wrong that consistently for that long, then stick around and prepare to have your eyes opened.
 
Last edited:
If I may interrput the schoolyard taunting for a brief moment...

Tiger, here's the thing that people have eluded to, but I don't think anyone has explained yet. When you tried the rods in class, I'm sure they worked very well. But the reason they moved isn't because they "detected" water; it's because you expected them to move, and therefore you moved them without realizing you were moving them. Yes, really.

I know, I know you swear you didn't move them. But you did. This is called the "idiometer response." Here's another way to demonstrate it. Take a ring or a key or any other small-ish object with a hole in it. Thread a string about two feet long through it, and hold the ends of the string together so the ring dangles freely. Rest your elbow on the table and hold the ends of the string between your index finger and thumb. With your other hand, stop the ring from swinging so it's perfectly still. Now be as still as you possibly can, but just imagine the ring swinging back and forth, away from you and back toward you. Pretty soon the ring will actually start to move that way, even though you think you're being still. The longer you think about it, the further it will swing. Now change direction and think about it swinging side to side, and soon the ring will follow suit. Ditto with swinging in a circle, both clockwise and counter-clockwise. It works because when you think about the motion, your body produces an involuntary movement that's too small for you to feel, but big enough to start the ring swinging. It's the same thing that makes Ouija boards work... and dowsing rods.

So back to the test you did. If you don't believe me that it was just the ideometer effect, here's how to tell whether it was or not. If it was really the rods finding the water, then they should be able to find it whether you know where it is or not, right? So try this: get ten paper cups and ten paper bags. Put one cup in each bag, but leave the tops of the bags open so you can see into them. Spread them around the room. Put water in five of the cups. Check your dowsing rods to make sure "they" work, which they very probably will as long as you know which cups have water in them. Then try this: leave the room, and have a friend go in and mix the bags up and close up the tops, so that when you walk back in, all you'll see is ten closed bags and you won't know which ones contain water. Have your friend leave the room. Then see how well the dowsing rods work with the bags closed. "Dowse" all ten bags, and make a record of which ones you think have water in them before you look inside any of them. Once you've made your choices, then open them up and see how accurate the rods were. Then see if you still think there's anything to it.

Oh, and yes, people have been using this "technique" to allegedly find water and all sorts of other things for years. The thing is, they've all been mistaken. Yes, all of them, every single time, for all those years. And if you think that many people couldn't possibly be that wrong that consistently for that long, then stick around and prepare to have your eyes opened.

Well like I told everyone else the brazing rods are located at your local hardware store and they are inexpensive, try the experiment yourself.

http://www.twm.co.nz/dowsing_jse_com.html

I await everyones results!
 
Well like I told everyone else the brazing rods are located at your local hardware store and they are inexpensive, try the experiment yourself.

You miss the point. The "experiment" you described is a well-known one, with well-documented, predictable results. I have tried it, and as long as I knew where the targets were, it worked beautifully (and it was really cool). But what I'm telling you is, it doesn't demonstrate what you think it demonstrates. The slightly more involved experiment I described will make the difference incredibly, palpably clear to you -- way more than anything any of us could write on this board ever would. So you've got two choices: you can keep challenging people here to prove you wrong, comfortable in the knowledge that you'll be able to dismiss anything that anyone says and thus leave your belief intact and unthreatened; or you can spend the 45 minutes necessary to find out for yourself if your experiment means what you think it does. Your call, but if I were in your shoes, I would definitely want to find out for sure.
 
You miss the point. The "experiment" you described is a well-known one, with well-documented, predictable results. I have tried it, and as long as I knew where the targets were, it worked beautifully (and it was really cool). But what I'm telling you is, it doesn't demonstrate what you think it demonstrates. The slightly more involved experiment I described will make the difference incredibly, palpably clear to you -- way more than anything any of us could write on this board ever would. So you've got two choices: you can keep challenging people here to prove you wrong, comfortable in the knowledge that you'll be able to dismiss anything that anyone says and thus leave your belief intact and unthreatened; or you can spend the 45 minutes necessary to find out for yourself if your experiment means what you think it does. Your call, but if I were in your shoes, I would definitely want to find out for sure.

I haven't missed your point you have missed mine! Your looking at dowsing for water has trickery and fakery and I'm not sure it is. And I have already done it and it was successful. For has much science that has been learned about the earth there's alot we don't know or haven't figured out.
Water dowsing is put in the catagory of paranormal does it belong there
not really because it may turn out to be true to a point. It's a scientific
fact that roots of trees grow towards the best water chance. Is it so hard to believe that water dowsing could be true to a certain point. Your dismissing every part of the concept and giving none of it a chance. I'm not saying all of it is true but if we all just dismiss things that certainly do fall in the realm of science not the paranormal we learn nothing. Your dealing with nature
here not religion,not ghosts,not psychic ability, but water, metals, magnatism, wood or dare I say science.
 
Last edited:
I haven't missed your point you have missed mine!

...snip....

No you have missed the point: dowsing has been tested many, many, many times and in every single test that was a "double blind" test it did not work.

What you are trying to argue is that we all should keep throwing balls up into the air to check again that gravity is still "working".

However if we are wrong and you are the first person ever to be able to prove dowsing works under controlled circumstances you could very quickly be a million dollars richer, never mind revolutionising how we all think about the world.
 
I haven't missed your point you have missed mine! Your looking at dowsing for water has trickery and fakery and I'm not sure it is. And I have already done it and it was successful. For has much science that has been learned about the earth there's alot we don't know or haven't figured out.
Uuhmm...Yes, you have missed the point, tiger. The rods move, but it doesn't mean anything.

I actually did an experiment one time where I had a stage divided up into grids and I hid a bucket of water under the stage. I sent people in one at a time to try to dowse which grid square the bucket was underneath. The locations that people chose were scattered all over the place, with no preference for any particular spot. Obviously, the dowsing didn't work.

That's because it doesn't work. Oh yes, the rods may move, but it has nothing to do with the water.

Imagine this: you're back in your "science" class testing the brazing rods. Only this time, that cup in the middle of the floor has a lid so that you can't see inside it. What we're all trying to tell you is that the brazing rods will move even if there's no water in the cup, just because you expect them to move. The whole point of the brazing rods is that you hold them in a way so that it is fairly difficult to hold them still, so that tiny movements of your hands will make the rod swing.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom