The omission of pertinent structural features from the NIST WTC 7 report, that would invalidate their failure initiation mechanism hypothesis, is not a minor point.
The focus on the initiating detail that started progression to global collapse IS a minor point. Why did you recharacterize what I said in my post? Are you training for politics?
There are now how many, say the words Tony, how many professional engineering studies that come to the conclusion that FIRE damage caused the initiating failure event AND that this progressed to global collapse? Here's a hint, it is greater than one and less than 10.
The simultaneous free fall collapse of all four corners of the roofline of WTC 7, which is not indicative of a progressive east to west interior collapse, is not a minor point.
Why do you choose to divide out a near last moment in time from what IS clearly a progresive collapse taking close to 20 seconds?
The less than one second horizontal propagation, from the southwest to northeast corners, of the collapse initiation across the entire 98th floor of WTC 1, is not a minor point.
Yes, it is. I again note that not one of the professional engineering organizations that studied WTC in detail expressed any incredulity at this point or any other. Neither did such organizations as the ASCE, CTBUH, or AIA.
The lack of deceleration, in the measurements of the fall of the upper section of WTC 1, is not a minor point
Once again that ambiguous word "deceleration". <<sigh>>
But yes it is minor, the lack of your erroneously expected jolt has been listed in these page numerous times. Repeating you argument from incredulity doesnt make them any better with age.
These things have not been explained by NIST, or anyone else who supports the natural collapse by fire scenario, and they are elephants in the room which show that scenario to be impossible as an explanation.
Mice, no make that voles, no on third thought make that dust mites.
Yours is the only, the sole, even remotely professional organization, that characterizes the reports that way. YOU are in the fringe minority and have done very little to try to change that.
You don't even try.]
What does rise to an elephantine level is that AE911T has performed no study whatsoever of the breadth and detail of those done by NIST, Purdue U., ARUP, WAI, or Nordenson & Associates, instead choosing to spend most of their funds on world speaking tours by Gage, specifically designed to avoid the professional engineering community.
I had little issue with tfk beyond his strict Bazantian outlook and ascerbic manner. I would however not characterize him as my "star".
had no answers for solid points like these and that is why he dropped out of our debate. It is clear that none of you here can either, and that is why you will not debate one-on-one and continue to hang in a group where you can throw a barb and run for cover behind your like-minded brethren, while trying to overwhelm the individuals who come on here with superior arguments.
I note that you respond to a post of mine now but not to the several instances of my asking these questions, which directly relate to such a debate:
Originally Posted by jaydeehess
So, Tony, as for the value of debating on the internet:
The entire rason d'etre, it appears, of AE911T, is education about the events of 9/11.
EXACTLY how has the cause been advanced by having tfk withdraw from an internet forum debate?
EXACTLY how has tfk withdrawing from debate increased the technical veracity of the claims?
EXACTLY how would debating a different internet poster further the cause of AE911T, or increase the veracity of the claims that AE911T make?
I will not engage in a full debate here. If you want to debate me it has to be one-on-one, with time for thoughtful responses. Otherwise, things just get lost in the noise, which may be an intentional facet of a forum like the ISF.
I dont care.
I find no value in such an online debate.
ETA from post 138:
Tony could debate each and every one of us on this forum, and it would do exactly what, to the veracity of the claims that AE911T makes? Note that for this question it matters not a whit what the outcome of said series of debates would be. Whether Tony came out on top of every single poster here, or was completely shot down by every poster here, or if it resulted in a tie, makes absolutely no difference to the furthering of the cause. Does anyone think that, for instance, the CTBUH, or the ASCE, or the AIA would be swayed to look more favourably on the claims of AE911T if Tony could say that he had debated, and won, each and every single ISF poster?
Tony? Do you think crushing everyone of us would garner you greater attention from such orgs?