does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Answer here:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11670334&postcount=1509

It ends with a challenge:



Now, Dave, Mr. president, u can hardly hide behind the same lame "not my area of expertise" excuse this time since u have been boasting here about an article about debunking thermite and other times u boast about your YouTube videos about thermite and your webpage is full of material supposed to debunk it, including a mad raving section about me - and u boldly conclude in a very authoritative tone that



There no disclaimer about your lack of credentials to make these claims!

And lets not forget that you boasted that the the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation had your mug on a story about debunkin thermite


There no disclaimer about your lack of credentials to make these claims!

So, is all that just the Dave Thomas brand of pseudo-skepic flatulence?

Dave Thomas, Mr. NMSR president, are you up to a debate on the 911freeforum about 9/11 and thermite?

Oystein offered to debate you two pages ago. Why resort to childish nonsense trolling someone else when you could just go and debate a willing participant?
 
Answer here:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11670334&postcount=1509

It ends with a challenge:



Now, Dave, Mr. president, u can hardly hide behind the same lame "not my area of expertise" excuse this time since u have been boasting here about an article about debunking thermite and other times u boast about your YouTube videos about thermite and your webpage is full of material supposed to debunk it, including a mad raving section about me - and u boldly conclude in a very authoritative tone that



There no disclaimer about your lack of credentials to make these claims!

And lets not forget that you boasted that the the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation had your mug on a story about debunkin thermite


There no disclaimer about your lack of credentials to make these claims!

So, is all that just the Dave Thomas brand of pseudo-skepic flatulence?

Dave Thomas, Mr. NMSR president, are you up to a debate on the 911freeforum about 9/11 and thermite?

My, my, you certainly are eager for a "debate."

However, I see no upside to giving you another platform for you to make perceptive, well-argued, reasonable and convincing arguments like this one:
U are babbling again...u will try and say anything to try to cover uo your bs, but covering up bs with more bs only serves to cover u in **** and make u smell bad...but you are good for a laugh.


What part of this couldn't you understand?
You guys are just gonna have to find someone else to play the role of Satan in your cheesy Passion Play. Good luck with that! :rolleyes:


Shaw had it just right.
 
Dave Thomas, Mr. NMSR president, are you up to a debate on the 911freeforum about 9/11 and thermite?


You might want to be careful about debating anyone about thermite.

After all, 1/2 tons of thermite was unable to cut a vehicle in two parts, and it took 1500 pounds od thermite just to burn through two steel legs of a steel tower, and of course, thermite had failed on the first attempt to collapse a severely damaged steel-framed roof that was already in danger of collapsing.

Those are very good reasons among others, why demolition companies do use thermite to demolish tall steel-framed buildings. In other words, thermite's ineffectiveness against such structures is a very good reason why you would lose a debate. I might add that investigators found no evidence in their dust samples that thermite was used to bring down the WTC buildings.

.
 
Last edited:
The 12th floor girder between columns 44 and 79 is not hotter than the one on the 13th floor when the failure is alleged to have happened.

This is just flailing around saying whatever you want, because you can't show an analysis that shows what you are saying.

In your analysis, then, presuming that you can show one that shows what you're saying, how hot was the girder on the 13th floor that failed, and how hot was the girder on the 12th that it fell on?

Dave
 
BTW, bent. could not refute that argument either and also avoids talking about it..and his lying.
.

Couldn't refute what argument? LOL. You want to defend Korol's clearly erroneous methodologies by claiming, erroneously, that there was 170 minutes of direct heating in the '93 Cardington studies compartmental fires?

I responded to and refuted you already. Do you even understand what we are talking about? Do you want to tell Tony and Korol their paper needs to be adjusted to not only take into account pre-heating and at least 50 min of direct heating, but instead pre-heating and 170 minutes of direct heating? Is that really your "gotcha" after three days of saying nothing?

Love it. Don't ever stop clowning.

By the way, do you want to weigh in on Tony's clearly erroneous floor collapse propagation "model" too?

Want to tell everyone why you are dodging Oystein's offer to debate you?
 
Last edited:
My, my, you certainly are eager for a "debate."

However, I see no upside to giving you another platform for you to make perceptive, well-argued, reasonable and convincing arguments like this one:
U are babbling again...u will try and say anything to try to cover uo your bs, but covering up bs with more bs only serves to cover u in **** and make u smell bad...but you are good for a laugh.


What part of this couldn't you understand?
You guys are just gonna have to find someone else to play the role of Satan in your cheesy Passion Play. Good luck with that! :rolleyes:


Shaw had it just right.

Dave, don't worry about Ziggi, and you know why, no reason to debate about a sinking ship,
If he were smart, (and I mean If,) he would abandon it before the
Under toe drags him down as well.
However I guess it is to late for him and Tony, and for many Twoofers, they are a lost cause,
2017 is going to be a very good year for everyone but them.
 
Last edited:
Couldn't refute what argument? LOL. You want to defend Korol's clearly erroneous methodologies by claiming, erroneously, that there was 170 minutes of direct heating in the '93 Cardington studies compartmental fires?

I responded to and refuted you already. Do you even understand what we are talking about? Do you want to tell Tony and Korol their paper needs to be adjusted to not only take into account pre-heating and at least 50 min of direct heating, but instead pre-heating and 170 minutes of direct heating? Is that really your "gotcha" after three days of saying nothing?

Love it. Don't ever stop clowning.

By the way, do you want to weigh in on Tony's clearly erroneous floor collapse propagation "model" too?

Want to tell everyone why you are dodging Oystein's offer to debate you?

Unlike the Ringling Bros Circus, Clowns like Ziggi, will always have a place here.:D
 
Dave Thomas, ,, are you up to a debate on the 911freeforum about 9/11 and thermite?

So internet debate is the proposed replacement for Basile's further study?

I was not aware that it could cost one up to $5000 to conduct a one-on-one debate on 911freeforum.

Perhaps you might answer these questions concerning debate on the internet concerning 9/11:
[1] as for the value of debating on the internet:
The entire rason d'etre, it appears, of AE911T, is education about the events of 9/11.

EXACTLY how has the cause been advanced by having tfk withdraw from an internet forum debate?

EXACTLY how has tfk withdrawing from debate increased the technical veracity of the claims?

EXACTLY how would debating a different internet poster further the cause of AE911T, or increase the veracity of the claims that AE911T make? If you debated every single ISF 9/11 debunker poster, and "won" every time, EXACTLY how would this further the cause of AE911T to garner a new investigation?


[2] There exists no testable CD hypothesis for WTC7. <- Tony(ETA): Ziggi, is that correct? If you disagree, then please provide the URL to the site that hold this hypothesis, so we can test it!
 
Last edited:
Answer here:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11670334&postcount=1509

It ends with a challenge:

Now, Dave, Mr. president, u can hardly hide behind the same lame "not my area of expertise" excuse this time since u have been boasting here about an article about debunking thermite and other times u boast about your YouTube videos about thermite and your webpage is full of material supposed to debunk it, including a mad raving section about me - and u boldly conclude in a very authoritative tone that



There no disclaimer about your lack of credentials to make these claims!

And lets not forget that you boasted that the the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation had your mug on a story about debunkin thermite


There no disclaimer about your lack of credentials to make these claims!

So, is all that just the Dave Thomas brand of pseudo-skepic flatulence?

Dave Thomas, Mr. NMSR president, are you up to a debate on the 911freeforum about 9/11 and thermite?
May I ask why you waited ten years (from the date of the publishing of the SI article) to issue this challenge?
 
This is not about black or white. In any case where someone wants a new investigation using public funds, the first step is to show that the original was insufficient, and that has been proven. You have created a strawman claim saying that truthers believe that NIST proven false makes our case for cd correct. We do not say that. We say that a new impartial investigation (ETA: replacing NIST) would conclude cd.

WOW! just noticed that you contradict yourself here.

"It's not B & W but it is CD since NIST is wrong"
 
Last edited:
WOW! just noticed that you contradict yourself here.

"It's not B & W but it is CD since NIST is wrong"

What I find funny is he thinks innuendo, and lying are proof of claim, we know the truth movement is false, simply because they can't tell the truth.
 
What I find funny is he thinks innuendo, and lying are proof of claim, we know the truth movement is false, simply because they can't tell the truth.

What I find the most hilarious is that AE911T pinned their hopes on their "Smoking Gun", WTC 7. We were told that NIST's report taking so long to be published pointed to fraud, we were told that NIST withholding their FEA data inputs for WTC 7 pointed to fraud, we were told that a new investigation, as Ziggi puts it, "would conclude cd".

So what happened?
Well Basile has taken a long time and still not produced his promised paper, but that's ok because he's a truther. (nevermind that NIST had good reason to finish up the reports on WTC 1 & 2 before moving to finalize the report on WTC7 while Basile has no good reason to drag his feet this long)
Several other professional engineering organizations produced reports (ie. new investigations) on the collapse of WTC 7 without having to cajole NIST for their withheld input data,
and those other reports also CONCLUDED that fire was the driving force that initiated the progressive collapse of WTC 7.


Bingo, bango, bongo the "Smoking Gun" is nothing more than vapour.
 
Last edited:
What I find the most hilarious is that AE911T pinned their hopes on their "Smoking Gun", WTC 7. We were told that NIST's report taking so long to be published pointed to fraud, we were told that NIST withholding their FEA data inputs for WTC 7 pointed to fraud, we were told that a new investigation, as Ziggi puts it, "would conclude cd".

So what happened?
Well Basile has taken a long time and still not produced his promised paper, but that's ok because he's a truther. (nevermind that NIST had good reason to finish up the reports on WTC 1 & 2 before moving to finalize the report on WTC7 while Basile has no good reason to drag his feet this long)
Several other professional engineering organizations produced reports (ie. new investigations) on the collapse of WTC 7 without having to cajole NIST for their withheld input data,
and those other reports also CONCLUDED that fire was the driving force that initiated the progressive collapse of WTC 7.


Bingo, bango, bongo the "Smoking Gun" is nothing more than vapour.

Of all the people on the planet, it was the plaintiffs in the Aegis Insurance case who had the largest incentive to discover and document a plot by which WTC7 was destroyed deliberately. They had billions on the line, which is why they retained some of the world's foremost tall building and fire science experts, who in turn retained the world's foremost forensic engineering firm (ARUP). After years of investigation and study, these experts, as documented in detailed reports that are now in the public domain, concluded it was a fire induced collapse.

In contrast, to conduct a study of its own, AE911Truth has only recently retained an expert on bridges who it misrepresents as "one of the top forensic structural engineers in the country," despite the fact that he has never been the principal on a major forensic engineering study or even testified in court as a forensic engineering expert, and who has already jumped to AE911Truth's desired conclusion, even though he openly admits he hasn't completed the study necessary to do so.

Then you have Tony here who knows that ARUP has demonstrated that there are reasonable scenarios in which the girder connections in WTC7 can fail. In fact, Tony uses ARUP's girder failure modeling as the basis for his oft-repeated claims that NIST's walk off hypothesis is "invalid". Of course, we know that Tony is erroneously applying ARUP's conclusions when he makes such claims, but his error doesn't stop us from continuing to think through the implications of that girder failure--including that damage to the girder connections can contribute to collapse propagation, as Tony himself cannot deny. Tony has tried to hand wave this away previously by saying that such failures could only propagate under "ridiculous" temperatures, but he has utterly failed to demonstrate that and, in fact, merely demonstrated that he, and not any of the major investigations to date, erred in how he conceptualized the effects of the fires in the buildings.

Tony--when will you garner enough intellectual honesty to just say what we already know--that it was possible that fire caused the collapse of WTC7? We can keep working on likely or probable, but you know it's at least established that it is possible. Know-nothings like Ziggi may not grasp the significance of the established possibility of two or more consecutive floors collapsing at once, but I know you do.
 
Last edited:
Tony--when will you garner enough intellectual honesty to just say what we already know--that it was possible that fire caused the collapse of WTC7? .

He almost certainly won't. He cannot.
That would simply put focus the null hypothesis, that the only known, and patently obvious, driving mechanisms for the initiation of collapse are the impact damage from WTC 1, and the fires in the structure.
ALL studies conclude that impact damage could not have initiated the collapse as observed. That leaves fire as THE ONLY demonstrated possible mechanism of initial failure in the progressive collapse. If it's the only possibility left then it IS the Null. It can only be supplanted with extraordinary evidence of another mechanism.
So far CD has ..... "well it could'a been"
 
Tony started this thread, hoping to find someone to debate him 1-on-1 at the other forum.
Strange that he ignores my taking the bait despite him saying explicitly he would debate me:

Two days ago, Tony had claimed he would debate me on the 911 free forum. I took him up on that offer - and he ignored that!
...
Do you promise to answer questions in such a debate? If yes, why don't you answer questions when asked? ...

...

I propose one of the following [three] topics for a debate:
...
I will insist on one ground rule:
...
So I gotta repeat:

Three days ago, Tony had claimed he would debate me on the 911 free forum. I took him up on that offer - and he ignored that!
Why? Because I asked preliminary questions, expecting straight and honest answers, to see if he is actually willing and able to debate honestly. I repeat:



Do you promise to answer questions in such a debate? If yes, why don't you answer questions when asked? Such as...

[1] as for the value of debating on the internet:
The entire rason d'etre, it appears, of AE911T, is education about the events of 9/11.

EXACTLY how has the cause been advanced by having tfk withdraw from an internet forum debate?

EXACTLY how has tfk withdrawing from debate increased the technical veracity of the claims?

EXACTLY how would debating a different internet poster further the cause of AE911T, or increase the veracity of the claims that AE911T make?


[2] There exists no testable CD hypothesis for WTC7. <- Tony, is that correct? If you disagree, then please provide the URL to the site that hold this hypothesis, so we can test it!
[In the meantime, Tony has admitted that neither he nor AE911Truth nor anyone else in the entire Truth Movement has a CD hypothesis for WTC7. But since he subsequently tried to deflect attention from his and the TM's failure to provide a viable hypothesis, I keep that question open until he gives a straight answer, which can only be: "Yes, that is correct. There exists no testable CD hypothesis for WTC7."]


[3]Tony, more than 15 years after 9/11, and after you have spent so many years reviewing all of the evidence, what is, in your opinion today, the most likely ultimate cause of the WTC7 collapse?
(Remember, a straight and honest answer could easily be a single word, or a brief sentence )​
It's most puzzling that you are so obviously mortally afraid of such simple questions. As if you had no convictions at all.




I propose one of the following topics for a debate:

  1. The data in Harrit et al (2009) proves the red layer is "Active Thermitic Material" (That would be your proposal to present and justify)
  2. All of the "Whereas" clauses in AE911Truth's 2017 AIA resolution proposal are both relevant to the cause of WTC7's collapse and factually correct. (You, Tony, promise to write an open letter to Richard Gage, informing him of all the CRAP in the proposal that we'll find)
  3. Your explosive CD hypothesis for WTC7 - you will actually spell out that hypothesis, we will scrutinize it to the level of detail that you scrutinize the existing WTC7 reports.

I will insist on one ground rule:
  • Per post, each of us can identifiy up to three (two? one?) questions which the other must respond to straight[*] and honestly in the very next post. The only excuse not to give a straight and honest answer will be an argument that the question is either not relevant or not straight. Failure to give a straight and honest answer to a straight and relevant question will end and lose the discussion.


[*]Where the idea of "straight" is: Brief (a short paragraph at most), to the point, to one point only, no evasions, no moving goal post, no second-guessing. A question must lend itself to being answered straight in order to count as straight itself.
 
The same can be said of the Twin Towers with the ACE elevator upgrade which was occurring in the eight months prior to Sept. 11, 2001.

I don't know if this has been answered but nearly a year before 9/11 there was a problem with an elevator in the WTC

Breaking News

Elevator Accident at World Trade Center

Aired August 11, 2000 - 9:19 a.m. ET
THIS IS A RUSH TRANSCRIPT. THIS COPY MAY NOT BE IN ITS FINAL FORM AND MAY BE UPDATED.

BILL HEMMER, CNN ANCHOR: We want to shift our attention now across town on the island of Manhattan, south end of the island, the World Trade Center. A breaking news story developing there.

Apparently there is a problem with an elevator inside the World Trade Center a short time ago. The information we have, and it's not much just yet, but apparently 22 people were on an elevator that did experience difficulties earlier today. It is said that minor injuries did occur as a result of this accident there. These pictures, you're seeing a live picture now as people mill on the street below, from -- courtesy of WCBS, our affiliate there in New York City.

Again, an elevator accident just a short time ago. Twenty-two people onboard that elevator, said to be minor injuries. As we get more details we'll certainly bring them to you. Emergency crews indeed have responded to the scene as you can tell from that live picture.
http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0008/11/bn.01.html

Elevator repairs would most definately have occured after this incident. If these were the "suspicious" repairs 8 months prior then charges could not have been placed because since these guys would have been working on fixing only one elevator in one shaft and likely would have taken a couple of days not months.
 
Last edited:
If you can't support your positions with reason, then just resort to lame throwaway insults? You are dodging my last post in a rather sad way.

Come on, Tony. You are claiming that you modeled the girder connections sufficiently to prove that two consecutive floors could not have collapsed under any reasonable set of fire conditions. But it's one thing to claim it and another to actually have done it.

As we've already established, your model is an overly-simplistic representation of a single girder connection at a single temperature. It includes no other structural elements and, as far as I can tell, does not at all account for any damage that could have reasonably occurred to that connection because it seems like you didn't even run a simulation at the heightened temperature but instead used back-of-the-envelope guesstimates as to the effect of the increase in temperature on the connection.

Without even looking at such a model in detail we know it is lacking. How do we know? Because, as you know, ARUP, WAI and NIST all found that the girder connections in question could completely fail in reasonable fire scenarios without sustaining any impact from a falling floor above. That's how the first floor falls in any model, after all. You take issue with NIST's failure model so I'm happy to table it, even though I don't agree with your criticism in context, but you have never so much as even raised a critique of ARUP's or WAI's (and WAI not only established its own failure scenarios, but it also replicated ARUP's!).

Given that multiple fulsome, finite element model analyses have demonstrated that, under reasonable fire scenarios, the girder connections could completely fail even without sustaining impact damage from above, your overly-simplistic model that you claim demonstrates they could never fail even after sustaining impact damage is obviously wrong. It could be wrong because of how it omits all of the other structural elements in the floor. It could be wrong because it doesn't actually model girder behavior during heating and thus omits damage that occurs to the girder connections from said heating (the same heating that ARUP demonstrates could completely fail such connections). It could be wrong because you set the parameters incorrectly. It could be wrong because it doesn't even exist and its "conclusion" is just a lie you are telling in an attempt to reach a conclusion that is out of your grasp. It could be wrong for any number of reasons. But we know it is wrong. If one floor can fail from fire alone, then clearly another floor can fail from fires of similar severity plus the impact of the floor above it. And we can know this without even pointing out that WAI also specifically undertook additional modeling to prove it true in reasonable fire scenarios in WTC7.

Do you want to add to your inability to address the fundamental error you and Korol made re heating an inability to address the clear limits of your floor collapse propagation model? Or do you want to correct the record?

It is painful to even try to read your inanities. You don't even know what is necessary and have the nerve to say my analysis is overly simplistic. Of course, you do it in a general way, because you obviously can't get into the specifics.

The simple reality is that you can't use an infinite stiffness like Nordenson did and the actual stiffness is not nearly high enough to cause enough of an amplification during impact to generate the load needed. It probably wasn't a mistake as he needed a lot of amplification to get to 632,000 Lbs. of dynamic load from a static load of about 20,000 lbs. He simply can't get there as the girder will deflect too much to deliver the high amplification he needs.

Everything needed to show Nordenson's floor collapse analysis was impossible was included in mine. The stiffness, mass, and height of the falling beam and girder mass and the girder and its seat below. It is the seat that needs to be sheared to cause a cascade and by that I mean the 14" deep support plate that is welded to column 79 and is under the horizontal bearing plate.
 
Last edited:
The difference in the level of technical sophistication here can be understood with a little analogy below.

Tony Szamboti (mechanical design engineer with 31 years of experience): the sky appears blue on earth during the day without clouds due to the way the atmosphere refracts sunlight.

benthamitemetric (fairly recent law school graduate): How do you know? Did you color it? If you didn't color it you can't say what color it is.
 
Last edited:
This from a man who spells "prior" as pryer. Oh come on.

One can't make this stuff up. Thanks for the laugh.

Just remember, every evasive insult you give is another admission that your wrong and you know it.

Keep it up.
 
Just remember, every evasive insult you give is another admission that your wrong and you know it.

Keep it up.

How does that logic work? I never read where insults and wrongness are correlatable.

If you want to talk insults why don't you take a look at what some of your buddies have said. I was also responding to an insult from Crazy Chainsaw in that post.

I have never seen you shy away from insults though. I seem to remember you telling me to wear a shirt that has an arrow pointing up with a statement saying I am with stupid. That was all that was in your post. It was your response to my asking why there didn't seem to be much discussion of the Europhysics article and my wondering if the shills thought it was better to not mention it so as not to let it overwhelm.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom