does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

The difference in the level of technical sophistication here can be understood with a little analogy below.

Tony Szamboti (mechanical design engineer with 31 years of experience): the sky appears blue on earth during the day without clouds due to the way the atmosphere refracts sunlight.

benthamitemetric (fairly recent law school graduate): How do you know? Did you color it? If you didn't color it you can't say what color it is.

Actually a better analogy is from the the kids show "Arthur"

From episode "Prove it", a conversation where Arthur represents a debunker, DW represents Tony, and Timmy represents a represents gullible truther follower
DW: Why is the sky blue?

Because brown was already taken by dirt; green was already taken by grass; yellow by bananas and red by apples.

Arthur: D.W., the sky is blue because air particles reflect blue light.

DW: Prove it.

Arthur: I will after you "prove" yours.

DW: Is dirt brown?

Is grass green?

Are bananas yellow?

Is the sky blue?

Timmy: She's right again!

Arthur: Ohh! (facepalm)
 
Last edited:
It is painful to even try to read your inanities. You don't even know what is necessary and have the nerve to say my analysis is overly simplistic. Of course, you do it in a general way, because you obviously can't get into the specifics.

The simple reality is that you can't use an infinite stiffness like Nordenson did and the actual stiffness is not nearly high enough to cause enough of an amplification during impact to generate the load needed. It probably wasn't a mistake as he needed a lot of amplification to get to 632,000 Lbs. of dynamic load from a static load of about 20,000 lbs. He simply can't get there as the girder will deflect too much to deliver the high amplification he needs.

Everything needed to show Nordenson's floor collapse analysis was impossible was included in mine. The stiffness, mass, and height of the falling beam and girder mass and the girder and its seat below. It is the seat that needs to be sheared to cause a cascade and by that I mean the 14" deep support plate that is welded to column 79 and is under the horizontal bearing plate.

Tony, we know that WAI specifically corrected Nordenson's error and found the floor collapses propagated in reasonable scenarios where the lower floor was damaged. You can keep throwing out BS, back-of-the-envelope numbers till you are blue in the face, but they actually did the analyses that you did not. How is that not specific enough for you? Here is a link to the WAI report again.
(You may want to check the temperatures of the lower floor before you try to reprise your BS heating model critique to restart your loop of squirming.)


And I've been plenty specific about how you are clearly wrong about Korol's heat model and about how your girder model is almost laughably flawed. And you have absolutely zero specific responses.

If you can't apply your experience towards thinking critically and making progress, what good is it? You are not and have never been a fire expert, a tall building expert, or even a structural engineer. To the extent your engineering background gives you insight into these issues, that's great, but you are not an expert on them. And if you want to compare resumes, why don't you compare yours to Dr. Abboud's?

You and I both know that there has never been an actual tall building or fire science expert who has gone on record agreeing with any of the truther nonsense. Not one. So keep bringing up "expertise"; it won't get you any farther than your inability to directly address the points I raise, but maybe it'll give you cover for a few more nonresponsive posts.
 
For someone with 31 years "Mechanical Design Engineering Experience", Tony has a simplistic view of "Shared" and "Model"
From a 40 Year "Structural Systems Engineering Analyst" and a PE:
"You got a lot to learn, son..."
 
For someone with 31 years "Mechanical Design Engineering Experience", Tony has a simplistic view of "Shared" and "Model"
From a 40 Year "Structural Systems Engineering Analyst" and a PE:
"You got a lot to learn, son..."

I think he should start with precisely modeling how many marbles are in a mason jar at a marble in the jar contest, and having someone go on a witch hunt against him if he is off by a marble.
 
Last edited:
How does that logic work? I never read where insults and wrongness are correlatable.

If you want to talk insults why don't you take a look at what some of your buddies have said. I was also responding to an insult from Crazy Chainsaw in that post.

I have never seen you shy away from insults though. I seem to remember you telling me to wear a shirt that has an arrow pointing up with a statement saying I am with stupid. That was all that was in your post. It was your response to my asking why there didn't seem to be much discussion of the Europhysics article and my wondering if the shills thought it was better to not mention it so as not to let it overwhelm.

It's over Tony, you can't even understand heating in fires you have made very dumb claims and been caught!

Just like Jones made dumb claims about fly ash Microspheres and paint chips, I only insult those people who are intellectually dishonest, and will not. Admit the mistake!

You act like someone making clearly fraudulent claims just left me Jones did!

Come clean admit your mistake a very dumb mistake and move on!
I work with fire Tony, any fool knows the power of convection and conduction vs radiation,
Your own post debunked you and made you look foolish, no amount of speaking to your own
Authority, or postering can change that!
You have not only shown yourself incompetent in engineering but in the most basic
Science as well, and that I did not do you did!
 
Tony you have made several claims in this thread that have been addressed and debunked repeatedly. So either admit that you were wrong when you the claims or:
-Prove that 2 floors in WTC 7 could not have reached temperatures of 850 degrees C

-Prove that Nist omitted pertinent structural features from the NIST WTC 7 report, that would invalidate their failure initiation mechanism hypothesis

-Prove that the simultaneous free fall collapse of all four corners of the roofline of WTC 7 is not indicative of a progressive east to west interior collapse

-Prove that the less than one second horizontal propagation, from the southwest to northeast corners, of the collapse initiation across the entire 98 is an indication of anything

-Prove that The lack of deceleration, in the measurements of the fall of the upper section of WTC 1, is an indication of anything

-Prove that there is no published analysis purporting to explain the collapse of WTC 7 that is consistent with observation.

-Prove that a falling girder can't break through the next floor down.

-Prove that fuel will not last long enough and the heat will transfer to cooler areas long before 850 degrees C is achieved in the steel.

-Prove that the fires in WTC 7 were intentionally stated by arsonist on the floors where the charges were

-Prove that the maximum steel temperatures found anywhere in the NIST WTC 7 analyses were no more than 675 degrees C (1,247 F)

-Prove that the stiffeners on girder A2001 stop the flange from folding as NIST claimed

-Prove that peak gas temperatures above 900 degrees C only lasted for about 22 to 25 minutes.

-Prove that the fall of the east penthouse is not indicative of where columns 77 and 79 failed vertically, only that they did so and that they only failed high in the building and that the east penthouse only fell a couple of stories into the building.
 
Last edited:
Tony, in regards to your claim that NIST analysis showed that temperatures were no hotter than 675 degrees C. I honestly do not have an answer to this claim NOW since I've never heard it before. However, during a conversation I had with someone a couple years ago I was asked something similar realted to the Twin Towers. He claimed that NIST analysis of steel from the TT showed that fires only reached temperatures of less than 1000 degrees F. This isn't surprising. The hottest zones in the towers were at the floor trusses (IE, the ceilings, remember heat rises), not the core columns or perimeter columns. NIST was only able to analyze core and perimeter columns. They weren't able to test the floor trusses I THINK because they needed to actually test the paint and the floor trusses were not painted. In any case, details about the temperatures the columns reached tell us nothing about the temperatures the floor trusses reached. I suspect something similar is with the WTC 7 tests. But to be honest I thought that steel from WTC 7 showed that there were indeed high temps. Indeed, analysis of steel beams in WTC7 by FEMA that showed that they maximum temperature they had reached was 1832 degrees F.
 
Also, Tony. I have several questions for you

1. Truthers claim that the steel beams were "ejected" with some landing 400 feet away. They cite this as evidence of a controlled demolition. Please list all controlled demolitions in history where the cutting charges have launched 160ton massive steel beams 400 feet away from the building.
2.How does the WTC core collapsing 15-20 seconds AFTER the rest of the building due to being unstable indicate controlled demolition? When do demolitions ever demolish the rest of the building, and then wait 15-20 seconds to take down the core?
3. Truthers claim that molten metal and hot spots of "thousands of degrees" were found underneath the debris piles many weeks after the attacks. They cite this as proof of a controlled demolition.(Even though molten metal was found underneath WTC 6 and many vehicles (that were covered by the debris in the intial collapse) were found to have had their wheels melted.) List all of the controlled demolitions in history that resulted in flowing rivers of molten steel 6 weeks after the demolition and Even if Thermate were used what kept the molten steel/iron from solidifying within seconds and kept it molten for over 6 weeks?
4. The next 6 questions are related to the molten metal dripping from the South Tower: If the molten metal were indeed a byproduct of a thermite reaction, then the amount of molten metal observed would require 10 full dump truck loads of thermite. How did they get all of this into the building past security and why did no office workers notice 10 fuxing dump truck loads of thermite in that corner?
5. Is it really just coincidence that the molten metal is dripping from the EXACT floor and the EXACT corner where tons of aluminum from the plane are known to have piled against and can be seen in photos?
6. The collapse of 2WTC began with the buckling of the columns on the east side of the building, not the north side (we usually say the NE corner for simplicity but it's really entirely on the north).Why the inconsistency?
7. How come the photos and videos of that corner (many of which are in excellent resolution) show the molten metal dripping out through the spaces between columns whereas there isn't a single cut through even one of the columns? (And mind you, causing a collapse via severing through enough perimeter columns would require probably about 50% of them to be cut through, not just one or two, so we would have to see huge amounts of perimeter columns being severed through. Even if you think that one or two WERE cut through and that the photos don't show it, then you still can't deny that the flow never leaves that one corner!Even severing, say, 5 or 6 columns would do nothing.)
8. Why is the same phenomena not observed in the North Tower? Or WTC7?
9. Thermite can only be ignited at temperatures hundreds of degrees higher than the hottest temp that jet fuel can burn. What exactly set off that charge?
10. Thisis basically Steven Jones' history of his theory... "It was thermite. No wait, I mean it was thermate. No wait, I mean it was nano-thermite. No wait, I mean it was actually just traditional explosives all along, nanothermite was just used to ignite the explosives." That's right, Steven Jones himself doesn't even support the thermite/thermate/nanothermite theory anymore. He now claims it was traditional explosives and nanothermite was just used to ignite the explosives... which makes absolutely zero sense. Why would they use some superhigh-tech theoretical "nanothermite" when there are already existing ignitions for demolition explosives which work perfectly well and have been around for decades and proven effective?
11. According to Professor Jones's analysis of World Trade Center steel and dust samples, high traces of sulfur and iron were found. Also found were traces of zinc, manganese, and titanium. Since most of these are ingredients for thermite truthers say that its evidence that thermite was used. But these same chemical signatures are also found in cheerios. Please explain why these elements couln't be found in the WTC dust but but have no problem accepting that these elements are found in everyday objects like cereal?
12. During its collapse WTC 7 experienced 2.25 seconds of freefall. From the instant of collapse initiation, it took 3 seconds for the collapse to spread from the 7th floor all the way to the roof. Then it takes another 8 seconds for the collapse to progress throughout the entire core. Once the core is completely gone, there's no lateral support for the perimeter columns. Also,the collapsing core pulls in on the floor beams, which pulls in on the perimeter columns. The collapse simulation predicted a bowing inward of the perimeter columns between the 8th and 14th floor (7 floors) when the shell began to collapse.Once they bowed inward enough, they just snapped at both ends and the 14th floor was free to fall onto the 8th floor with no resistance. Once the top hit other debris, it began slowing down again. Also, we can do a simply calculation to see if the collapse prediction matches with the observation. The loss of perimeter columns between the 8th and 14th floorsmeans a 7 floor drop. Each office floor was 12.5 feet in height (3.8 meters).3.8x7=(1/2)9.8t^2 calculates out to a free-fall time of 2.33 seconds. This prediction is nearly identical to what it observed, further verifying the computer simulation and the NIST report. If WTC 7 really was a controlled demolition how did the conspirators make sure that the building fell in a way that would support a (supposedly made up) conclusion made 7 years later?
13. What is the difference, if any, between heat and temperature?
14. What is the difference between iron microspheres and iron-rich microspheres?
15. How hot does Jet fuel and hydrocarbon office contents in an open air environment? Now how hot would it burn given the estimated amount of oxygen inside the WTC?
16. If a 100k ton mass is descending straight down, what does Newton's 1st law of motion and Inertia say about the path of that object?
17. How much weight could one floor slab of the World Trade Center Hold?
18. Les Robertson designed the WTC towers, and has stated repeatedly that the buildings were capable of sustaining only ONE hit from a slow speed, low on fuel aircraft. A repeat of the Empire State Crash. As such, he has also stated that the design never contemplated the fuel fires, since it was assumed the low fuel load (and due to less momentum, almost all the fuel would explode outside). He has also stated that he knew that if a collapse like we saw on 911 ever started, there would be no stopping it. Please provide proof that he was coerced to lie about his design.
 
Originally Posted by Ziggi
- U cite F47 which cuts out at 170 min...10 min short of 3 hours
- F47 caption for graph says Test 4...Table 2 p17 says fuel load for that is 40kg...which is double the 20kg/meter2 industry std office fire load.
So talking about comical lack of reading comprehension, u have been ranting and raving about a report even though u did not understand the MOST BASIC data.
Originally Posted by benthamitemetric View Post
Got me on one point--I meant that there weren't 3 hours of heating, not that there weren't three hours of fire! My bad!...
The 40kg is indeed double the 20kg baseline used by Cardington and NIST...and the 170 min graph on F47 is indeed a heating curve for beams in test 4...if it is not obvious from the context u can simply read the caption for the graph
Couldn't refute what argument? LOL....

Oh so u want to spend a few posts on pretending to not know what u are supposed to be responding to, again? Thats original. Your lies and evasions just make u look silly. You just tried to cover up your bs by lying that F47 was not about heating, and now that my reply made u look like a stupid liar u are trying to pretend u dont know what this is about..again..like u always do. Once you face that this is really the guy u are, u may start to realize that the only result from your bombastic and authoritative tirades against Tony is to make you look just about as stable as Tony Montana.

Want to tell everyone why you are dodging Oystein's offer to debate you?

No need to mention why I ignore him, all the regulars know that he is trolling. Besides, no need for debate, Oystein operates under the assumption that I agree with everything he says if I do not respond to it. To learn more about this story and Oystein's condition, start here: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11542138&postcount=2562

If you want to learn more about why Dave Thomas does not want a debate, read that thread from p 1 and ask around via PMs about Chris Mohr

Originally Posted by benthamitemetric
Tony--when will you garner enough intellectual honesty to just say what we already know--that it was possible that fire caused the collapse of WTC7? We can keep working on likely or probable, but you know it's at least established that it is possible. Know-nothings like Ziggi may not grasp the significance of the established possibility of two or more consecutive floors collapsing at once, but I know you do.

U gonna lecture about intellectual honesty? U are too ignorant about this subject to realize that you have only been arguing about if a particular initiation for collapse sequence of a very limited section of the building is possible in theory.

Even if it were proven possible, the hard part would remain, which is proving that it could lead to the total collapse seen that day, including the distinguishing features that made it look like a professional controlled demolition. NIST choked badly on that one and tried to cover it up, and your WAI report does not even try to plug up those holes.
 
Last edited:
the 40kg is indeed double the 20kg baseline used by Cardington and NIST...and the 170 min graph on F47 is indeed a heating curve for beams in test 4...if it is not obvious from the context u can simply read the caption for the graph

LOL, so you still think there is 170 minutes of heating shown on page F47 then? That's your position and you're sticking with it? Good lord you are a waste of time. Better write to Korol and tell him he needs to add 140 minutes of direct heating to his horribly flawed model that you can't otherwise address. At least you're wrong in the right direction now, I guess. Still no comment on Tony's horribly flawed girder connection model?

And if you can't figure out the significance of the possibility of fire induced collapse to a man who's entire world view depends on said collapse being impossible (and, yes, we know that's a ridiculous position, but it's Tony's whole basis for believing in CD), there is really nothing I can do to help you.
 
Last edited:
Tony Szamboti (mechanical design engineer with 31 years of experience): the sky appears blue on earth during the day without clouds due to the way the atmosphere refracts sunlight.


I find it amusing that even your example is wrong. Google "Rayleigh Scattering".

This is precisely why no one takes you seriously any more.
 
Even if it were proven possible, the hard part would remain, which is proving that it could lead to the total collapse seen that day, including the distinguishing features that made it look like a professional controlled demolition.


Nothing in common with controlled demolition implosions except that the WTC buildings collapsed downward.

Controlled demolition implosions generate high noise levels from explosive detonation, which didn't happen as the WTC buildings collapsed, and controlled demolitions leave behind physical CD evidence in the rubble, none of which was ever found in the WTC rubble. None of the WTC buildings collapsed at free fall speed nor did they fall within their own footprints.

To sum it up, there was no evidence of any kind the WTC buildings collapsed due to CD. Fire has been known to collapse steel frame buildings as was the case when the steel-framed Kader buildings collapsed due to fire.
 
Last edited:
The difference in the level of technical sophistication here can be understood with a little analogy below.

Tony Szamboti (mechanical design engineer with 31 years of experience): the sky appears blue on earth during the day without clouds due to the way the atmosphere refracts sunlight.


You say the "sky appears blue on earth during the day without clouds?"

Let's take a look at the following photo to see if there are clouds visible in the blue sky.


White Clouds, Blue Sky

http://www.wallcoo.net/nature/blue_...s/[wallcoo_com]_blue_sky_white_clound_001.jpg


You say you have 31 years experience as a mechanical design engineer yet you cannot explain the significance of structural load redistribution in the presence of uncontrolled fires and buckling of WTC 7 prior to its collapse?!

I might add that it doesn't take someone with 31 years experience as a mechanical engineer to determine that the collapse of WTC 7 had nothing to do with explosives. Firefighters had determined that WTC 7 was in danger of collapsing due to visual and audio indicators that had nothing to do with CD explosives.
 
Which seems to me rather more indicative of an error in fundamental understanding than, for example, a simple spelling mistake. I wonder whether Tony's able to admit he's wrong even when it's this obvious.

Dave

The interesting thing is Tony and Ziggi seem to have been abandoned here by other truthers,
we have not heard from any in a long Time, Criteria has not even posted in a while.
 
The interesting thing is Tony and Ziggi seem to have been abandoned here by other truthers,
we have not heard from any in a long Time, Criteria has not even posted in a while.

I'm sure Criteria will be here soon to tell us that Tony is a great American hero and a brilliant engineer whose word should never be doubted, and that his misunderstandings of basic optics should be ignored as they're nothing to do with his field of expertise, unlike structural engineering which mechanical engineers obviously understand better than structural engineers.

One wonders why AE911T didn't hire a mechanical engineer instead of Leroy Hulsey for their highly technical and evidence-based study that's reached a conclusion on WTC7 before doing any of the actual investigative work.

Dave
 
I'm sure Criteria will be here soon to tell us that Tony is a great American hero and a brilliant engineer whose word should never be doubted, and that his misunderstandings of basic optics should be ignored as they're nothing to do with his field of expertise, unlike structural engineering which mechanical engineers obviously understand better than structural engineers.

One wonders why AE911T didn't hire a mechanical engineer instead of Leroy Hulsey for their highly technical and evidence-based study that's reached a conclusion on WTC7 before doing any of the actual investigative work.

Dave

Probably couldn't afford Tony's high hourly rate, for his vast experience and wisdom.:D
 
I think he should start with precisely modeling how many marbles are in a mason jar at a marble in the jar contest, and having someone go on a witch hunt against him if he is off by a marble.

Actually a case can be made for a similar metaphor.
If the question was which marble went in the jar first you would definitely be able to say that the ones in the top 3/4 of the jar were not the first. Then if you proposed the one at the bottom center, Tony would argue that it couldn't be, argue it's the one next to that, Tony would argue that it couldn't be, etc., etc., etc., and never opine on which one he believed went in first.
 
Tony, I have a used human powered push mower for sale, know you and Gage might be short on funds, after
The building collapse in Tehran, so I will let you have it cheap.
Wouldn't want you too lose your job mowing Gage's Lawn.

Because he can't afford a riding mower with a gas engine.

Can't think of anyone allowing you to use anything complicated or motorized!

Looks like you and Gage both might be unemployed without help!
 
Even if it were proven possible, the hard part would remain, which is proving that it could lead to the total collapse seen that day, including the distinguishing features that made it look like a professional controlled demolition. NIST choked badly on that one and tried to cover it up, and your WAI report does not even try to plug up those holes.

I think that is the FIRST time I have ever seen a truther question the progression to global collapse.
Ziggi, Ziggi. Ziggi, every single one of the reports done on WTC 7 (you guys wanted a new investigation, you got several) demonstrates that multiple floor failures leads to column instability which in turn (the definition of progression) eventually has the entire structure come down.

As for CD. It's a fantasy with absolutely no evidence other than the "could'a beens" of you and your ilk.
........ focus the null hypothesis, that the only known, and patently obvious, driving mechanisms for the initiation of collapse are the impact damage from WTC 1, and the fires in the structure.
ALL studies conclude that impact damage could not have initiated the collapse as observed. That leaves fire as THE ONLY demonstrated possible mechanism of initial failure in the progressive collapse. If it's the only possibility left then it IS the Null. It can only be supplanted with extraordinary evidence of another mechanism.
So far CD has ..... "well it could'a been"
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom