does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

None of the WTC buildings collapsed at free fall speed nor did they fall within their own footprints.

FF is supposed to be one of the (unsubstantiated) hallmarks of CD. Yet even the 2.25 second period of +/- free fall of WTC 7 occurs 1.7 seconds AFTER the entire structure is moving. IF FF=CD then we would be required to believe that the CD occurred 1.7 seconds AFTER the entire structure was already moving and thus doomed ALREADY to global collapse.


Then there is the "WHY?" of CD for WTC 7. The towers, not so tough a case to establish. In fact the same reasons given for why Al Qada attacked them. They (the towers) were symbols of American economic power, the tallest structures in NYC and only recently surpassed in height world wide. They were attacked while thousands of people were inside. Hundreds were killed on impact(inside the towers and on the planes).

WTC 7 however, was not a highly recognizable structure and while tall, it was not particularly noteworthy, was not widely known, had ample time for complete evacuation, and collapsed 7 hours after the towers with no loss of life. So NO shock and awe in the same way as for the towers.
"Oh" truhrthers tell us, "it was done to destroy evidence contained in the emergency control room, or in offices." OR they tell us "It was done to make L.Silverstein a richer man, in payment for his cooperation in the destruction".
Both patently ridiculous of course. Bringing down a building is most certainly one of the worst ways to ensure complete destruction of documents or equipment in the structure, and enlisting a property developer in the single most treasonous plot in modern USA history..............:rolleyes: The Jew-paranoia is strong with that one, and I must conclude the driving force behind such a ridiculous fiction.
 
Last edited:
Which seems to me rather more indicative of an error in fundamental understanding than, for example, a simple spelling mistake. I wonder whether Tony's able to admit he's wrong even when it's this obvious.


I predict Tony will come back and claim that Rayleigh scattering is a type of refraction, and that I am merely indulging in semantic nit-picking.

Because as we all know, Tony can never be wrong...
 
I predict Tony will come back and claim that Rayleigh scattering is a type of refraction, and that I am merely indulging in semantic nit-picking.

Because as we all know, Tony can never be wrong...

To be fair, I have seen the refraction nonsense being presented to children in schools. It is one of those "easier to make up plausible crap for kids" answers. This makes a little modicum of educational sense when dealing with 6-7-8 year olds. There is no chance in hell of explaining Rayleigh Scattering to that age group. Refraction is a pseudo-explanation which simply suffices for the time being. A stop gap, if you will.

My own personal revelation moment happened 4 decades ago when I thought "Wait a minute, if blue light is refracted in and all the rest is refracted out, how could we be able to perceive red?" and one can follow that line into energy content of various wavelengths to then prove plants could not exist were it true that refraction was the thing.

I suppose one could call it "lazy teaching" but I am almost certain it would be a most challenging task to have to explain Rayleigh Scattering to children.

This is all well and good as far as it goes however, there is a caveat. Surprisingly, many who never have occasion to move along beyond the superficial explanations of childhood retain those superficial explanations as though they were facts. This is not a failing. I am certain that you, I or anyone else could dredge up childhood factoids that are retained which are patently false. Happens to me at least once a week that someone will state some obscure fact leaving me in a "Wait? What? Really?" and some intense googling later in a state of "Wow, I had always believed that...". I relish that. And therein lies the rub. Is one prepared to accept that some treasured pseudo-fact is flat out wrong? Or is one going to double down on evident nonsense?

In any context, I prefer to have my cherished beliefs challenged and to concede given a sufficient evidentiary case. Tony does not. Tony has faith in the impossible CD scenario and I do not need to rehash the many reasons that it is impossible. It is simply an article of faith for Tony. Like all other faiths, reason doesn't even get to peek in the door. This, of course, is a well worn tactic. For example, creationists think that if they can somehow disprove evolution then their particular mythos becomes true. While it is trivially easy to kick the creationist baloney out of the park, the parallels between CD proponents and creationists are truly fascinating.

TL;DR version.
Tony talks a big load of old bollocks but he has me on ignore he claims, so I expect no response from him.
 
I think Tony lost the debate he claims he wants to have by default - he ignores a plain and repeated offer multiple times.

Once again, Tony Szamboti's fundamental cowardice and dishonesty are layed bare.
Cowardice: Afraid to state straight what his conviction is (that explosive CD caused the WTC7 collapse).
Dishonesty: Calling me out for a debate, and then pretending I didn't respond.


Tony started this thread, hoping to find someone to debate him 1-on-1 at the other forum.
Strange that he ignores my taking the bait despite him saying explicitly he would debate me:


So I gotta repeat:

Three days ago, Tony had claimed he would debate me on the 911 free forum. I took him up on that offer - and he ignored that!
Why? Because I asked preliminary questions, expecting straight and honest answers, to see if he is actually willing and able to debate honestly. I repeat:



Do you promise to answer questions in such a debate? If yes, why don't you answer questions when asked? Such as...

[1] as for the value of debating on the internet:
The entire rason d'etre, it appears, of AE911T, is education about the events of 9/11.

EXACTLY how has the cause been advanced by having tfk withdraw from an internet forum debate?

EXACTLY how has tfk withdrawing from debate increased the technical veracity of the claims?

EXACTLY how would debating a different internet poster further the cause of AE911T, or increase the veracity of the claims that AE911T make?


[2] There exists no testable CD hypothesis for WTC7. <- Tony, is that correct? If you disagree, then please provide the URL to the site that hold this hypothesis, so we can test it!
[In the meantime, Tony has admitted that neither he nor AE911Truth nor anyone else in the entire Truth Movement has a CD hypothesis for WTC7. But since he subsequently tried to deflect attention from his and the TM's failure to provide a viable hypothesis, I keep that question open until he gives a straight answer, which can only be: "Yes, that is correct. There exists no testable CD hypothesis for WTC7."]


[3]Tony, more than 15 years after 9/11, and after you have spent so many years reviewing all of the evidence, what is, in your opinion today, the most likely ultimate cause of the WTC7 collapse?
(Remember, a straight and honest answer could easily be a single word, or a brief sentence )​
It's most puzzling that you are so obviously mortally afraid of such simple questions. As if you had no convictions at all.




I propose one of the following topics for a debate:

  1. The data in Harrit et al (2009) proves the red layer is "Active Thermitic Material" (That would be your proposal to present and justify)
  2. All of the "Whereas" clauses in AE911Truth's 2017 AIA resolution proposal are both relevant to the cause of WTC7's collapse and factually correct. (You, Tony, promise to write an open letter to Richard Gage, informing him of all the CRAP in the proposal that we'll find)
  3. Your explosive CD hypothesis for WTC7 - you will actually spell out that hypothesis, we will scrutinize it to the level of detail that you scrutinize the existing WTC7 reports.

I will insist on one ground rule:
  • Per post, each of us can identifiy up to three (two? one?) questions which the other must respond to straight[*] and honestly in the very next post. The only excuse not to give a straight and honest answer will be an argument that the question is either not relevant or not straight. Failure to give a straight and honest answer to a straight and relevant question will end and lose the discussion.


[*]Where the idea of "straight" is: Brief (a short paragraph at most), to the point, to one point only, no evasions, no moving goal post, no second-guessing. A question must lend itself to being answered straight in order to count as straight itself.
 
Then there is the "WHY?" of CD for WTC 7. The towers, not so tough a case to establish. In fact, the same reasons given for why Al Qada attacked them. They (the towers) were symbols of American economic power, the tallest structures in NYC and only recently surpassed in height world wide. They were attacked while thousands of people were inside. Hundreds were killed on impact(inside the towers and on the planes).

WTC 7 however, was not a highly recognizable structure and while tall, it was not particularly noteworthy, was not widely known, had ample time for complete evacuation, and collapsed 7 hours after the towers with no loss of life. So NO shock and awe in the same way as for the towers.
"Oh" truthers tell us, "it was done to destroy evidence contained in the emergency control room, or in offices." OR they tell us "It was done to make L.Silverstein a richer man, in payment for his cooperation in the destruction".
Both patently ridiculous of course. Bringing down a building is most certainly one of the worst ways to ensure complete destruction of documents or equipment in the structure, and enlisting a property developer in the single most treasonous plot in modern USA history..............:rolleyes: The Jew-paranoia is strong with that one, and I must conclude the driving force behind such a ridiculous fiction.


It's a head-shaking experience when Truthers push CD in regard to the collapse of the WTC buildings. Are they so gullible as to ignore the fact that explosives generate very high noise levels when detonated?


CD Implosion Video

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8U4erFzhC-U


High detonation noise levels were not heard as WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7 collapsed. They've claimed the WTC buildings fell within their own footprints despite the fact the collapse of those buildings seriously damaged nearby buildings outside their footprints.


WTC Ground Zero Damage Photo 1

http://911research.wtc7.net/wtc/evidence/photos/docs/ground_zero_arial2_ort.jpg


WTC Ground Zero Damage Photo 2


http://911research.wtc7.net/wtc/evidence/photos/docs/gzd_059.jpg


WTC Ground Zero Damage Photo 3

http://911research.wtc7.net/wtc/evidence/photos/docs/gzd_050.jpg


WTC Ground Zero Damage Photo 4

http://911research.wtc7.net/wtc/evidence/photos/docs/zomb/financial_ctr.jpg


Truthers claim the WTC buildings fell at free-fall speed despite the fact that dust plumes and debris were seen outpacing the collapse of those buildings.


WTC Collapse Photo 1

http://911myths.com/assets/images/WTC7Hit1.jpg


WTC Collapse Photo 2


http://www.911myths.com/assets/images/Collapse.jpg


It boggles the mind to think how Truthers were easily misled by disinformation, misinformation, and outright lies. I'd posted a warning regarding a doctored video that depicted a false CD representation of WTC 7 and amazingly, there were Truthers who eventually came back later and posted that same video as their evidence that WTC 7 was demolished by CD explosives. Simply amazing!!
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by benthamitemetric View Post
... And you are comically misreading the '93 Cardington Study compartmental fire if you think that those fires burned for anywhere near 3 hours (or were a "double fuel fire"). Check your eyes and reading comprehension if you want to have an adult conversation or just go back to scamming people.
Originally Posted by Ziggi
- U cite F47 which cuts out at 170 min...10 min short of 3 hours- F47 caption for graph says Test 4...Table 2 p17 says fuel load for that is 40kg...which is double the 20kg/meter2 industry std office fire load.
Originally Posted by benthamitemetric View Post
Got me on one point--I meant that there weren't 3 hours of heating, not that there weren't three hours of fire! My bad!..
Originally Posted by Ziggi
The 40kg is indeed double the 20kg baseline used by Cardington and NIST...and the 170 min graph on F47 is indeed a heating curve for beams in test 4...if it is not obvious from the context u can simply read the caption for the graph


This argument is about
1) anywhere near 3 hours
2) near 3h of ... fire ..or ... heating

Conclusion: near 3 hours of heating


U denied anywhere near 3 hours of fire...but when I reminded u that your beloved graph on f47 is a 170min heating graph... u changed your story to say you meant it showed fire but not heating...but when I showed that it is obviously a heating graph...u changed story again and pretended to not remember what we were talking about
Originally Posted by benthamitemetric View Post
Couldn't refute what argument? LOL....
Originally Posted by Ziggi
Oh so u want to spend a few posts on pretending to not know what u are supposed to be responding to, again? Thats original. Your lies and evasions just make u look silly. You just tried to cover up your bs by lying that F47 was not about heating, and now that my reply made u look like a stupid liar u are trying to pretend u dont know what this is about..again..like u always do.

And now u are once again... trying to pretend u dont know what this is about..again..changing your story once again..
LOL, so you still think there is 170 minutes of heating shown on page F47? That's your position and you're sticking with it? Good lord you are a waste of time..

...and this time u forgot all about having denied f47 is about heating...You the guy that brought the f47 graph to this forum to back up your wish about 750C WTC7 beam heating ended up trying to deny it shows heating, to try to cover up your bs, and u are seriously deluding yourself if u think everyone has not seen what a fool u made of yourself, and seen how dishonest you are. U want to give more angry lectures about need for others to show intellectual honesty? Ohh, u going to change the subject again...
 

This argument is about
1) anywhere near 3 hours
2) near 3h of ... fire ..or ... heating

Conclusion: near 3 hours of heating


U denied anywhere near 3 hours of fire...but when I reminded u that your beloved graph on f47 is a 170min heating graph... u changed your story to say you meant it showed fire but not heating...but when I showed that it is obviously a heating graph...u changed story again and pretended to not remember what we were talking about



And now u are once again... trying to pretend u dont know what this is about..again..changing your story once again..


...and this time u forgot all about having denied f47 is about heating...You the guy that brought the f47 graph to this forum to back up your wish about 750C WTC7 beam heating ended up trying to deny it shows heating, to try to cover up your bs, and u are seriously deluding yourself if u think everyone has not seen what a fool u made of yourself, and seen how dishonest you are. U want to give more angry lectures about need for others to show intellectual honesty? Ohh, u going to change the subject again...
You know how to spell "you". Do you post the way you do simply out of laziness?

By the way, how is that "Dust" study going? You are the official spokesperson, right?
 
You know how to spell "you". Do you post the way you do simply out of laziness?

By the way, how is that "Dust" study going? You are the official spokesperson, right?

I wonder if Mark imbecile will be testing the dust in Iran for thermite?
 

This argument is about
1) anywhere near 3 hours
2) near 3h of ... fire ..or ... heating

Conclusion: near 3 hours of heating


U denied anywhere near 3 hours of fire...but when I reminded u that your beloved graph on f47 is a 170min heating graph... u changed your story to say you meant it showed fire but not heating...but when I showed that it is obviously a heating graph...u changed story again and pretended to not remember what we were talking about



And now u are once again... trying to pretend u dont know what this is about..again..changing your story once again..


...and this time u forgot all about having denied f47 is about heating...You the guy that brought the f47 graph to this forum to back up your wish about 750C WTC7 beam heating ended up trying to deny it shows heating, to try to cover up your bs, and u are seriously deluding yourself if u think everyone has not seen what a fool u made of yourself, and seen how dishonest you are. U want to give more angry lectures about need for others to show intellectual honesty? Ohh, u going to change the subject again...

I already told you two days ago I meant "not three hours of heating" in the original post. Guilty of writing imprecisely in an internet debate, I guess. And it's not even a point that has any negative impact on any of my arguments as the longer the heating time frame in the study, the greater the magnitude of Korol's error. I could harp on and on about how you didn't even know and then couldn't even read the temperatures reached in the NIST model or how you somehow managed to completely misread my defense of Tony's nexus with AE911Truth, but I'd rather focus on what you're wrong about in the context of this discussion, which is Korol's clearly erroneous methodologies.

So how many minutes of heating do you see in F47? Do you think that number helps or hurts Korol's and Tony's flawed heating methodologies?

Re fuel load, 40 kg/m3 was not outside of what was possible in the areas in question around column 79 and was not double of the amount NIST estimated to be there for the purposes of their model (which was supposed to be the basis for Korol's). And your "double fuel load" claim isn't just wrong--it's irrelevant to the flaws in Korol's paper.

You've now wasted four or five days saying nothing and failing to address the flawed methodologies. How terribly insightful and interesting you've proven.

You also continue to dodge addressing the flawed methodologies in Tony's girder connection model.

And your extremely weak dodge on Oystein's offer to debate is just lame.
 
I already told you two days ago I meant "not three hours of heating" in the original post. Guilty of writing imprecisely in an internet debate, I guess. ...
.

No, changing your story every 5 min is lying, not being imprecise.

Originally Posted by Ziggi
Your F47 nears 3 hours of heating and does not start to go over 600C until after about 1 hour of heating. http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11670281&postcount=1477
Originally Posted by benthamitemetric View Post
... And you are comically misreading the '93 Cardington Study compartmental fire if you think that those fires burned for anywhere near 3 hours (or were a "double fuel fire"). Check your eyes and reading comprehension if you want to have an adult conversation or just go back to scamming people.

If u had really meant to say
if you think f47 shows anywhere near 3 hours of heating

..instead of..
if you think that those fires burned for anywhere near 3 hours

...then you would have conceded your mistake and my point right away instead of spending days on trying to cover up your bs with more bs

Graph on f47 shows heating for 160 out of 170 min before it cuts out, meaning there is 160 plus min of heating or "near 3 hours" of heating just as I said.. It also shows results for test w double the base fuel load..that 93 paper is on several tests, some with 20kg std load (nist also has 20 kg as base) and others with a 40 kg double fuel load.

More to come of that which you have been evading from here . http://www.internationalskeptics.com...postcount=1477
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom