does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Here is basicly Tony's problem in a but shell, if the energy to fail the girder was 1,000,000 PSI, which would be impossible, then a one foot off center strike would reduce that to 100,000 PSI.
100,000 psi is 2600 pounds dropped a distance of 12 feet.

Girders and beams bend under stress and apply leverage effects on joints, the higher the temperatures the more leverage applied by a factor equal to the increase in ductile behavior.
 
Why would anyone want to debate an individual who has already demonstrated intellectual dishonesty?

That would be an exercise in futility.

forest...trees

First let Tony establish how debating one, two, twenty, or every single ISF 9/11 debunker would further the cause of AE911T, which is, as advertised, to garner a new investigation into the 9/11/01 collapses of three of the buildings destroyed at the WTC complex.
 
You are just blowing smoke and rambling incoherently here, throwing anything you can think of at the wall in your attempt to rehabilitate Nordenson, and it is obvious you don't know what matters.

It is actually the girder seat that needs to be sheared to break through the next floor down. and it is welded to column 79's side plates. The columns never get hotter than 300 degrees C in NIST's thermal analysis. That is because they are transferring heat to cooler areas.

At 300 degrees C steel has lost virtually no yield strength, so the ambient temperature analysis is actually representative. The reality is the seat couldn't even be sheared at 600 degrees C as even then there would still be a factor of safety of 1.5.


At what temperature does the lower floor girder in your simulation fail without impact from the floor above such that it, like the girder above it, would fall onto a lower floor even without being impacted?

Do you really not get this fundamental problem? You actually cannot and do not criticize ARUPs conclusion that the fires alone can cause the girders on a given floor to fail. Now you propose, using a horribly over-simplified model that omits the entire floor structure except for a single girder and connection, that a girder connection could never fail despite a combination of fire and impact?
 
Last edited:
It is a suckers game and Tony is looking for suckers to fleece, for his master Gage.

He has no interest in Investigation of the truth and never has, that is what is clear from his years of posting.

agreed. it's all bout the grift
 
agreed. it's all bout the grift

I don't think there is any evidence that Tony receives any substantial financial benefits from his role in AE911Truth, though AE911Truth's financial disclosures are not sufficiently detailed or even current to determine much of anything about how they spend their funds for sure. I'd bet that Tony likely at least gets compensated for attending their conferences and putting together newsletters for them, but I doubt that he gets paid much for those things. We ultimately don't know for sure and AE911Truth is not publicly accountable for its spending.

Anyone can see AE911Truth's filings here:
http://rct.doj.ca.gov/Verification/Web/Search.aspx?facility=Y

Search for FEIN "261532493"
 
I hear what you're saying but there really is no other rational reason to be fighting from a losing position for so long.
 
At what temperature does the lower floor girder in your simulation fail without impact from the floor above such that it, like the girder above it, would fall onto a lower floor even without being impacted?

Do you really not get this fundamental problem? You actually cannot and do not criticize ARUPs conclusion that the fires alone can cause the girders on a given floor to fail. Now you propose, using a horribly over-simplified model that omits the entire floor structure except for a single girder and connection, that a girder connection could never fail despite a combination of fire and impact?

Yeah, that one's been amusing me for a while. Tony seems to need the floor girder below the initial failure to maintain enough strength to arrest the impact even when it's hotter than the girder that failed first.

Dave
 
I don't think there is any evidence that Tony receives any substantial financial benefits from his role in AE911Truth, though AE911Truth's financial disclosures are not sufficiently detailed or even current to determine much of anything about how they spend their funds for sure. I'd bet that Tony likely at least gets compensated for attending their conferences and putting together newsletters for them, but I doubt that he gets paid much for those things. We ultimately don't know for sure and AE911Truth is not publicly accountable for its spending.

Anyone can see AE911Truth's filings here:
http://rct.doj.ca.gov/Verification/Web/Search.aspx?facility=Y

Search for FEIN "261532493"

How much does Gage pay to have his lawn mowed?

Given the expertise in Mechanical engineering Tony has shown here, that's probably the most complex engineering feat he is capible of.

He definitely is not some one I would want working with me on anything, complicated, doubt he could build a good camera simple camera stick for a game camera.

Or build anything that involves steel and fires, I sincerely doubt his ability to understand simple physics because of his own Pryer statement which he refuses to acknowledge were untrue.

Tony Claims that he is not paid by AE/911truth, he does not claim that Gage or others connected with the group are not slipping him money under the table.

I doubt he would be in this for personal reason other wise and make such obviously false claims other wise.
 
Last edited:
I will post mine and Oystein's thread specific questions again later of course, but in the mean time, I note that both Tony and Ziggi, seem oddly bothered by benthamitemetric's attempt to get a justification for Korol to ignore pre-heating.

Steel begins major heating phase at 20C versus begins major heating phase at 400+C.
 
Last edited:
I will post mine and Oystein's thread specific questions again later of course, but in the mean time, I note that both Tony and Ziggi, seem oddly bothered by benthamitemetric's attempt to get a justification for Korol to ignore pre-heating.

Steel begins major heating phase at 0C versus begins major heating phase at 400+C.

That's because the they both know that they have been caught being intellectual dishonest anyone who has read any competent fire research papers or has lit a match understands why.
 
Benthamitemetric = a lawyer with zero training in heat transfer but lots in bombast who had his head handed to him after crowing that the ARUP report validated NIST before being shown Nordenson's little problem.

Oystein = a self trained bombastic sort and occasional cheerleader for more advanced bombastic types.

I think any rational person can see why I don't answer you two here in your bombastic little piranha tank. I would debate either one of you one-on-one on the 911 free forum.

Yet you inexplicably keep coming to the same "little piranha tank" to complain about the low quality of the debate it offers. Why not seek a better tank and more proficient fish? Why haven't you authored a paper on NIST's apparently grievous errors, had it properly peer-reviewed, and published it in one of the flagship journals in the relevant fields? Surely the tenor of debate in that venue would be far less "bombastic," and the people far better trained. I simply don't understand the utility of coming to a forum filled with laymen and complaining about how lay they are. Seems so very unproductive to me.
 
Yet you inexplicably keep coming to the same "little piranha tank" to complain about the low quality of the debate it offers. Why not seek a better tank and more proficient fish? Why haven't you authored a paper on NIST's apparently grievous errors, had it properly peer-reviewed, and published it in one of the flagship journals in the relevant fields? Surely the tenor of debate in that venue would be far less "bombastic," and the people far better trained. I simply don't understand the utility of coming to a forum filled with laymen and complaining about how lay they are. Seems so very unproductive to me.

Seems a good seque to reiterating :
[1] as for the value of debating on the internet:
The entire rason d'etre, it appears, of AE911T, is education about the events of 9/11.

EXACTLY how has the cause been advanced by having tfk withdraw from an internet forum debate?

EXACTLY how has tfk withdrawing from debate increased the technical veracity of the claims?

EXACTLY how would debating a different internet poster further the cause of AE911T, or increase the veracity of the claims that AE911T make? If you debated every single ISF 9/11 debunker poster, and "won" every time, EXACTLY how would this further the cause of AE911T to garner a new investigation?


[2] There exists no testable CD hypothesis for WTC7. <- Tony, is that correct? If you disagree, then please provide the URL to the site that hold this hypothesis, so we can test it!
 
Yet you inexplicably keep coming to the same "little piranha tank" to complain about the low quality of the debate it offers. Why not seek a better tank and more proficient fish? Why haven't you authored a paper on NIST's apparently grievous errors, had it properly peer-reviewed, and published it in one of the flagship journals in the relevant fields? Surely the tenor of debate in that venue would be far less "bombastic," and the people far better trained. I simply don't understand the utility of coming to a forum filled with laymen and complaining about how lay they are. Seems so very unproductive to me.

The Orange Walk, it does stir the blood. Is it really supposed to accomplish anything? This is a hobby for TSz, with dividends, after all. Why March to a solution, when marching to incite keeps the ball rolling?
 
Quite interesting that in this thread, which seeks debate a debate partner, and in which Ziggi pretended he is interested in debating the thermite hoax, he ignored this offer to debate him on the thermite hoax:

I want to debate you [i.e. Ziggi] on the 911freeforum about thermite!

I have one ground rule: Straight questions must be answered straight and honestly.

As for the rest of the rules, we can discuss that.
I propose to introduce as material to discuss all the studies on WTC red-gray chips that have been done so far:
  • "Active Thermitic Material..." (Harrit et al, 2009)
  • "Why the red/gray chips aren't paint" (Harrit, 2009)
  • Mark Basile's 2010 presentation
  • James Millette's 2012 report to Chris Mohr.
Rules: No poisoning the well. Anyone wanting to dismiss any of the data as tampered or fabricated must show proof it's tampered and fabricated.


ETA: If this thread continues to swell and explode like it did the last 24 hours or so, there's a chance I might miss your response to this. If you still have my email address, drop me a one-liner with a link to your response if you seriously consider doing that discussion on the other forum.

I think Ziggi is intelligent enough to understand that I completely own him on that hoax, of which he is known as a major perpetrator. He has previously proven to be mortally afraid of the demand to answer straight questions straight and honestly.
 
Last edited:
Two days ago, Tony had claimed he would debate me on the 911 free forum. I took him up on that offer - and he ignored that!
Why? Because I asked preliminary questions, expecting straight and honest answers, to see if he is actually willing and able to debate honestly. I repeat:


Tony Szamboti said:
Benthamitemetric = a lawyer with zero training in heat transfer but lots in bombast who had his head handed to him after crowing that the ARUP report validated NIST before being shown Nordenson's little problem.

Oystein = a self trained bombastic sort and occasional cheerleader for more advanced bombastic types.

I think any rational person can see why I don't answer you two here in your bombastic little piranha tank. I would debate either one of you one-on-one on the 911 free forum.
Do you promise to answer questions in such a debate? If yes, why don't you answer questions when asked? Such as...

[1] as for the value of debating on the internet:
The entire rason d'etre, it appears, of AE911T, is education about the events of 9/11.

EXACTLY how has the cause been advanced by having tfk withdraw from an internet forum debate?

EXACTLY how has tfk withdrawing from debate increased the technical veracity of the claims?

EXACTLY how would debating a different internet poster further the cause of AE911T, or increase the veracity of the claims that AE911T make?


[2] There exists no testable CD hypothesis for WTC7. <- Tony, is that correct? If you disagree, then please provide the URL to the site that hold this hypothesis, so we can test it!
[In the meantime, Tony has admitted that neither he nor AE911Truth nor anyone else in the entire Truth Movement has a CD hypothesis for WTC7. But since he subsequently tried to deflect attention from his and the TM's failure to provide a viable hypothesis, I keep that question open until he gives a straight answer, which can only be: "Yes, that is correct. There exists no testable CD hypothesis for WTC7."]


[3]Tony, more than 15 years after 9/11, and after you have spent so many years reviewing all of the evidence, what is, in your opinion today, the most likely ultimate cause of the WTC7 collapse?
(Remember, a straight and honest answer could easily be a single word, or a brief sentence )​
It's most puzzling that you are so obviously mortally afraid of such simple questions. As if you had no convictions at all.




I propose one of the following topics for a debate:

  1. The data in Harrit et al (2009) proves the red layer is "Active Thermitic Material" (That would be your proposal to present and justify)
  2. All of the "Whereas" clauses in AE911Truth's 2017 AIA resolution proposal are both relevant to the cause of WTC7's collapse and factually correct. (You, Tony, promise to write an open letter to Richard Gage, informing him of all the CRAP in the proposal that we'll find)
  3. Your explosive CD hypothesis for WTC7 - you will actually spell out that hypothesis, we will scrutinize it to the level of detail that you scrutinize the existing WTC7 reports.

I will insist on one ground rule:
  • Per post, each of us can identifiy up to three (two? one?) questions which the other must respond to straight[*] and honestly in the very next post. The only excuse not to give a straight and honest answer will be an argument that the question is either not relevant or not straight. Failure to give a straight and honest answer to a straight and relevant question will end and lose the discussion.


[*]Where the idea of "straight" is: Brief (a short paragraph at most), to the point, to one point only, no evasions, no moving goal post, no second-guessing. A question must lend itself to being answered straight in order to count as straight itself.
 
Last edited:
Benthamitemetric = a lawyer with zero training in heat transfer but lots in bombast who had his head handed to him after crowing that the ARUP report validated NIST before being shown Nordenson's little problem.

Oystein = a self trained bombastic sort and occasional cheerleader for more advanced bombastic types. I think any rational person can see why I don't answer you two here in your bombastic little piranha tank. I would debate either one of you one-on-one on the 911 free forum.

Sounds like piranha-Bethamitemetric and piranha-Oystein have taken painful bites out of mute TS’s rear.
 
Benthamitemetric = a lawyer with zero training in heat transfer but lots in bombast who had his head handed to him after crowing that the ARUP report validated NIST before being shown Nordenson's little problem.

Oystein = a self trained bombastic sort and occasional cheerleader for more advanced bombastic types.

I think any rational person can see why I don't answer you two here in your bombastic little piranha tank. I would debate either one of you one-on-one on the 911 free forum.
Really? In the last 3 pages alone you have replied to them 6 times.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom