does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

his obsession to control the narrative by insisting on taking any 'debate' off site is hilarious as he keeps running into roadblocks. there is absolutely no need to go 'debate' on a site where one's posts that aren't liked would be deleted and user probably banned.
Seems to be the end game. Move the "debate" to a venue which will protect him, garner a ban, declare victory. Anyone want to fall for such a transparent tactic? Didn't think so.
 
his obsession to control the narrative by insisting on taking any 'debate' off site is hilarious as he keeps running into roadblocks. there is absolutely no need to go 'debate' on a site where one's posts that aren't liked would be deleted and user probably banned.
Please show evidence that the 9/11 forum deletes post and bans members for disagreement. I post there and have never been censored.
 
Please show evidence that the 9/11 forum deletes post and bans members for disagreement. I post there and have never been censored.

never been there. can't see any other reason any 'debate' with anyone from here has to be done there.
 
Hello Guys. New here, joined ages ago, but I mainly just read the debate threads and don't join in much. I have long followed the WTC7 issue and am conversant with NIST/ARUP/Nordenson etc. I actually have met and conversed with some of the authors, mainly at Edinburgh University, which as you will know is a centre of excellence for fire sciences.
I have studied the drawings for the building and there are some serious issues and conflicts with these reports at many levels. I am not affiliated to ae911truth or any other organisation and wouldn't ever describe myself as a "conspiracy theorist". I am coming from a position of entirely independent study and research, and regardless of what you assert here, you must surely see that there are some very serious issues when it comes to this building and it's collapse. Whatever caused this collapse, it most certainly did not happen in the manner that NIST describe in their report - it is impossible for this girder to fail to the West, as it is clearly going to expand to the inside of the built up column 79. No analysis shows this happening, yet it is widely believed to be a possible failure mechanism by many, and in my opinion, NIST avoided this issue by way of the removal of elements from their model on a presumed failure basis rather than an observed viable mechanism.
I would also happily debate any one of you real time, or here in text or elsewhere, but I do have some misgivings about the manner in which you approach this issue.
You appear to be willing to accept the impossible from NIST, as far as their failure mechanism is concerned. That's not just contradictory as far as ARUP and others have illustrated, but it's offensive to anyone in the industry who has looked at the evidence in the various reports and come to the inevitable conclusion that the failure mechanism presented by NIST is not a valid one. If it were even possible, I wouldn't be writing this. So, I guess that is my question - Do those here, who are in opposition to Tony really believe that it is possible for the girder to have failed via the mechanism proffered by NIST ?
I would love to explore the issue here, but let's please remove the impossible from the table before we commence.

I hope you don't mind me crashing this thread, as I do not want to distract anyone away from Tony's offer of a debate. I looked at the first debate that he had with "TFK" and frankly, the weakness of your position was laid bare for all to see.
 
I would be willing to discuss this with you.

First, I need to know, Is cause outside of fire and damage on the table? If yes, how so?

I'd like to clear the table of the impossible ie NIST's preferred mechanism of failure of the girder to the West first. I am certainly open to looking at other fire based mechanisms if you so wish, but clearly the impossible should not be considered.
I don't see how fire could do this, and the obvious conclusion is that the building was brought down in a controlled demolition if and when fire is discarded as a possibility.
If you don't have a fire based mechanism that is viable then CD is a debate that should be had, but not until the possibility of fire doing this has been thoroughly investigated and discarded. So, if you have such a mechanism, I am open to hearing it, and if not, I am happy to move onto the CD issue and discuss that.
 
I'd like to clear the table of the impossible ie NIST's preferred mechanism of failure of the girder to the West first. I am certainly open to looking at other fire based mechanisms if you so wish, but clearly the impossible should not be considered.
I don't see how fire could do this, and the obvious conclusion is that the building was brought down in a controlled demolition if and when fire is discarded as a possibility.
If you don't have a fire based mechanism that is viable then CD is a debate that should be had, but not until the possibility of fire doing this has been thoroughly investigated and discarded. So, if you have such a mechanism, I am open to hearing it, and if not, I am happy to move onto the CD issue and discuss that.
Sorry, not interested.
 
Sorry, not interested.

No problem, and entirely understandable. Thank you.

I should add : Why would I want a debate with someone who is willing to entertain the impossible as plausible anyway.
Again, the weakness of your position is laid bare.
 
Last edited:
No problem, and entirely understandable. Thank you.

I should add : Why would I want a debate with someone who is willing to entertain the impossible as plausible anyway.
Again, the weakness of your position is laid bare.
Not the case. You could not answer my simple question.

You stay open to a cause (CD) that has never been presented in a plausible hypothesis.
 
Last edited:
Not the case. You could not answer my simple question.

You stay open to a cause (CD) that has never been presented in a plausible hypothesis.

100% correct. I have never seen a hypothesis presented that illustrates the specific CD of WTC7. Neither have I ever seen a specific hypothesis presented that plausibly indicates that fire could have brought the building down.

I do however know that controlled demolition has the ability to bring down such structures, and presume you do too. It is obvious that you do not have a plausible hypothesis for fire though, and this is the weakness in your position that is laid bare.
 
100% correct. I have never seen a hypothesis presented that illustrates the specific CD of WTC7. Neither have I ever seen a specific hypothesis presented that plausibly indicates that fire could have brought the building down.

I do however know that controlled demolition has the ability to bring down such structures, and presume you do too. It is obvious that you do not have a plausible hypothesis for fire though, and this is the weakness in your position that is laid bare.
Do you doubt fire can bring down a building? The exact specifics are not important absent an plausible alternative. Do you not agree?
 
...
I have studied the drawings for the building and there are some serious issues and conflicts with these reports at many levels. I am not affiliated to ae911truth or any other organisation and wouldn't ever describe myself as a "conspiracy theorist". I am coming from a position of entirely independent study and research, and regardless of what you assert here, you must surely see that there are some very serious issues when it comes to this building and it's collapse. Whatever caused this collapse, it most certainly did not happen in the manner that NIST describe in their report - it is impossible for this girder to fail to the West, as it is clearly going to expand to the inside of the built up column 79. No analysis shows this happening, yet it is widely believed to be a possible failure mechanism by many, and in my opinion, NIST avoided this issue by way of the removal of elements from their model on a presumed failure basis rather than an observed viable mechanism.
I would also happily debate any one of you real time, or here in text or elsewhere, but I do have some misgivings about the manner in which you approach this issue.
You appear to be willing to accept the impossible from NIST, as far as their failure mechanism is concerned. That's not just contradictory as far as ARUP and others have illustrated, but it's offensive to anyone in the industry who has looked at the evidence in the various reports and come to the inevitable conclusion that the failure mechanism presented by NIST is not a valid one. If it were even possible, I wouldn't be writing this. So, I guess that is my question - Do those here, who are in opposition to Tony really believe that it is possible for the girder to have failed via the mechanism proffered by NIST ?
I would love to explore the issue here, but let's please remove the impossible from the table before we commence.

I hope you don't mind me crashing this thread, as I do not want to distract anyone away from Tony's offer of a debate. I looked at the first debate that he had with "TFK" and frankly, the weakness of your position was laid bare for all to see.

How do you debate an idiotic fantasy of CD?

Fire caused the collapse, and there is no evidence for explosives or thermite.

NIST probable cause, is what you call, a probable cause (look up probable). Don't worry, less than 0.1 percent of all engineers have signed up for 9/11 truth BS, mostly in the form of signing a petition, or adding their name to a nutcase group based on paranoia and ignorance. What caused the collapse in your version, a nuke, silent explosives, or the no product thermite, which does not leave behind iron.

You make up the BS claim NIST probable cause is not valid, and you offer talk. A made up opinion based on nothing.

What year did you graduate from engineering school? What next, JFK, Moon landing denial, OKC, Bigfoot? Chemtrails?
 
Last edited:
Do you doubt fire can bring down a building? The exact specifics are not important absent an plausible alternative. Do you not agree?

I have never seen a plausible mechanism presented that would indicate that fire or fire + damage can bring down such a structure no. If you have one, I would be open to looking at it.
 
Do you doubt fire can bring down a building? The exact specifics are not important absent an plausible alternative. Do you not agree?
[Truther mode]Nope. Sorry. Unless you can specifically detail every point of failure, down to the specific rivet, and whether it was bearing, shear,tear-out or tooth fairies, and the specific causes of the failure (buckling, impact (Frequency and mode shape, please), creep, and mode (brittle, plastic, elastic), along with a FEM proving your case, and place them on a time line that we agree with, you are absolutely wrong in every particular and generalized case.[/truther]
 
100% correct. I have never seen a hypothesis presented that illustrates the specific CD of WTC7. Neither have I ever seen a specific hypothesis presented that plausibly indicates that fire could have brought the building down.

I do however know that controlled demolition has the ability to bring down such structures, and presume you do too. It is obvious that you do not have a plausible hypothesis for fire though, and this is the weakness in your position that is laid bare.

Tony's FEA requires bolt sheer on the girder without damage to the seat, or girder edge,

If ductile deformation failure occurs the the seat, and girder edge, as well as the stiffener can be damaged and the girder will walk off, as in NISTs model.

The other models also point to fire induced collapses.

The temperatures of the fire could have easily reached 1400C in air for sustained periods.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom