...
I have studied the drawings for the building and there are some serious issues and conflicts with these reports at many levels. I am not affiliated to ae911truth or any other organisation and wouldn't ever describe myself as a "conspiracy theorist". I am coming from a position of entirely independent study and research, and regardless of what you assert here, you must surely see that there are some very serious issues when it comes to this building and it's collapse. Whatever caused this collapse, it most certainly did not happen in the manner that NIST describe in their report - it is impossible for this girder to fail to the West, as it is clearly going to expand to the inside of the built up column 79. No analysis shows this happening, yet it is widely believed to be a possible failure mechanism by many, and in my opinion, NIST avoided this issue by way of the removal of elements from their model on a presumed failure basis rather than an observed viable mechanism.
I would also happily debate any one of you real time, or here in text or elsewhere, but I do have some misgivings about the manner in which you approach this issue.
You appear to be willing to accept the impossible from NIST, as far as their failure mechanism is concerned. That's not just contradictory as far as ARUP and others have illustrated, but it's offensive to anyone in the industry who has looked at the evidence in the various reports and come to the inevitable conclusion that the failure mechanism presented by NIST is not a valid one. If it were even possible, I wouldn't be writing this. So, I guess that is my question - Do those here, who are in opposition to Tony really believe that it is possible for the girder to have failed via the mechanism proffered by NIST ?
I would love to explore the issue here, but let's please remove the impossible from the table before we commence.
I hope you don't mind me crashing this thread, as I do not want to distract anyone away from Tony's offer of a debate. I looked at the first debate that he had with "TFK" and frankly, the weakness of your position was laid bare for all to see.