does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

He was logged in earlier today, so he's still about.
He's a fearless truth-seeker, so he couldn't be hiding from all the questions. Must be another reason why he's not responding.

He is preparing his peer reviewed paper on CD, so he can stun us all with his brilliance.:D
 
He is preparing his peer reviewed paper on CD, so he can stun us all with his brilliance.:D

Instead of finishing an actual substantive conversation on the heating model of WTC 7 here (a conversation he now avoids like the plague because he knows he was fundamentally wrong and that correcting that error demolishes his claims of fire induced collapse being "impossible") or addressing the many other legitimate questions raised by others in this thread or others or even responding adequately to pgimeno's offer to debate him in a dedicated thread, Tony thinks it's a better use of his considerable talents to post over at /r/911truth, where the the hottest topic is currently a lively debate over whether or not planes were involved in the 9-11 attacks. Enjoy hiding from progress with the masterminds who seek fit to follow someone who hides from progress, Tony. So long as none of them stumble upon exchanges like this and figure out how full of it you are, they will keep giving you lots of internet points, which is the only sort of "progress" you seem to actual care about--getting your ego through another day.
 
Last edited:
Instead of finishing an actual substantive conversation on the heating model of WTC 7 here (a conversation he now avoids like the plague because he knows he was fundamentally wrong and that correcting that error demolishes his claims of fire induced collapse being "impossible") or addressing the many other legitimate questions raised by others in this thread or others or even responding adequately to pgimeno's offer to debate him in a dedicated thread, Tony thinks it's a better use of his considerable talents to post over at /r/911truth, where the the hottest topic is currently a lively debate over whether or not planes were involved in the 9-11 attacks. Enjoy hiding from progress with the masterminds who seek fit to follow someone who hides from progress, Tony. So long as none of them stumble upon exchanges like this and figure out how full of it you are, they will keep giving you lots of internet points, which is the only sort of "progress" you seem to actual care about--getting your ego through another day.

It's not fair to kick your knocked out opponent in the head while he's unconscious on the ground ;)
 
Instead of finishing an actual substantive conversation on the heating model of WTC 7 here (a conversation he now avoids like the plague because he knows he was fundamentally wrong and that correcting that error demolishes his claims of fire induced collapse being "impossible") or addressing the many other legitimate questions raised by others in this thread or others or even responding adequately to pgimeno's offer to debate him in a dedicated thread, Tony thinks it's a better use of his considerable talents to post over at /r/911truth, where the the hottest topic is currently a lively debate over whether or not planes were involved in the 9-11 attacks. Enjoy hiding from progress with the masterminds who seek fit to follow someone who hides from progress, Tony. So long as none of them stumble upon exchanges like this and figure out how full of it you are, they will keep giving you lots of internet points, which is the only sort of "progress" you seem to actual care about--getting your ego through another day.

Benthamitemetric = a lawyer with zero training in heat transfer but lots in bombast who had his head handed to him after crowing that the ARUP report validated NIST before being shown Nordenson's little problem.

Oystein = a self trained bombastic sort and occasional cheerleader for more advanced bombastic types.

I think any rational person can see why I don't answer you two here in your bombastic little piranha tank. I would debate either one of you one-on-one on the 911 free forum.
 
Last edited:
Benthamitemetric = a lawyer with zero training in heat transfer but lots in bombast

Oystein = a self trained bombastic sort and occasional cheerleader

I think any rational person can see why I don't answer you two.

I think any rational person can see you're as fond of argumentum ad hominem as you are the argument from ignorance and the appeal to your own authority.

Dave
 
I think any rational person can see you're as fond of argumentum ad hominem as you are the argument from ignorance and the appeal to your own authority.

Dave

How about you Dave? Do you want to debate one-on-one or do you prefer just making irrelevant wise cracks and trying to bite from the sidelines in the piranha tank here?
 
How about you Dave? Do you want to debate one-on-one or do you prefer making wise cracks and trying to bite from the sidelines in the piranha tank here.

I see no point in appearing to validate your fantasies any more, having seen how incapable you are of abandoning them however many times they are proven impossible.

Dave
 
Benthamitemetric = a lawyer with zero training in heat transfer but lots in bombast who had his head handed to him after crowing that the ARUP report validated NIST before being shown Nordenson's little problem.

Oystein = a self trained bombastic sort and occasional cheerleader for more advanced bombastic types.

I think any rational person can see why I don't answer you two here in your bombastic little piranha tank. I would debate either one of you one-on-one on the 911 free forum.

I doubt That you would understand heat transfer Tony if you were in the suns Corona.

You obviously did not understand steel heating, you proformed a marvelous feat of self debunking.:D
 
Benthamitemetric = a lawyer with zero training in heat transfer but lots in bombast who had his head handed to him after crowing that the ARUP report validated NIST before being shown Nordenson's little problem.

Oystein = a self trained bombastic sort and occasional cheerleader for more advanced bombastic types.

I think any rational person can see why I don't answer you two here in your bombastic little piranha tank. I would debate either one of you one-on-one on the 911 free forum.

Then correct me on heat transfer, Tony. You ran away from our discussion weeks ago. You've had plenty of time to review the relevant literature.

It didn't take me long to learn enough about heat transfer did figure out the fundamental error you and Korol were making. If you are such an expert on the subject, why didn't you realize it sooner? Do you still defend Korol's approach? If so, why do you still insist on believing in something for which there is no experimental or even theoretical support in the literature? You can still summon some intellectual honesty and move towards reality, Tony.
 
Last edited:
Benthamitemetric = a lawyer with zero training in heat transfer but lots in bombast who had his head handed to him after crowing that the ARUP report validated NIST before being shown Nordenson's little problem.

Oystein = a self trained bombastic sort and occasional cheerleader for more advanced bombastic types.

I think any rational person can see why I don't answer you two here in your bombastic little piranha tank. I would debate either one of you one-on-one on the 911 free forum.

Do you promise to answer questions in such a debate? If yes, why don't you answer questions when asked? Such as...

[1] as for the value of debating on the internet:
The entire rason d'etre, it appears, of AE911T, is education about the events of 9/11.

EXACTLY how has the cause been advanced by having tfk withdraw from an internet forum debate?

EXACTLY how has tfk withdrawing from debate increased the technical veracity of the claims?

EXACTLY how would debating a different internet poster further the cause of AE911T, or increase the veracity of the claims that AE911T make?


[2] There exists no testable CD hypothesis for WTC7. <- Tony, is that correct? If you disagree, then please provide the URL to the site that hold this hypothesis, so we can test it!


[3]Tony, more than 15 years after 9/11, and after you have spent so many years reviewing all of the evidence, what is, in your opinion today, the most likely ultimate cause of the WTC7 collapse?
(Remember, a straight and honest answer could easily be a single word, or a brief sentence )​
It's most puzzling that you are so obviously mortally afraid of such simple questions. As if you had no convictions at all.




I propose one of the following topics for a debate:

  1. The data in Harrit et al (2009) proves the red layer is "Active Thermitic Material" (That would be your proposal to present and justify)
  2. All of the "Whereas" clauses in AE911Truth's 2017 AIA resolution proposal are both relevant to the cause of WTC7's collapse and factually correct. (You, Tony, promise write an open letter to Richard Gage, informing him of all the CRAP in the proposal that we'll find)
  3. Your explosive CD hypothesis for WTC7 - you will actually spell out that hypothesis, we will scrutinize it to the level of detail that you scrutinize the existing WTC7 reports.

I will insist on one ground rule:
  • Per post, each of us can identifiy up to three (two? one?) questions which the other must respond to straight[*] and honestly in the very next post. The only excuse not to give a straight and honest answer will be an argument that the question is either not relevant or not straight. Failure to give a straight and honest answer to a straight and relevant question will end and lose the discussion.


[*]Where the idea of "straight" is: Brief (a short paragraph at most), to the point, to one point only, no evasions, no moving goal post, no second-guessing. A question must lend itself to being answered straight in order to count as straight itself.
 
Last edited:
Then correct me on heat transfer, Tony. You ran away from our discussion weeks ago. You've had plenty of time to review the relevant literature.

It didn't take me long to learn enough about heat transfer did figure out the fundamental error you and Korol were making. If you are such an expert on the subject, why didn't you realize it sooner? Do you still defend Korol's approach? If so, why do you still insist on believing in something for which there is no experimental or even theoretical support in the literature? You can still summon some intellectual honesty and move towards reality, Tony.

You simply don't know much about heat transfer. I am sure you never had a course in it and everything is not instinctive. Discussing it on a forum like this with all of the noise and barbs from anonymous posters isn't the way to have a legitimate debate. I can do that with you on the 911 free forum in a one-on-one debate.
 
How about you Dave? Do you want to debate one-on-one or do you prefer just making irrelevant wise cracks and trying to bite from the sidelines in the piranha tank here?
I agreed to have a one-on-one discussion. But you didn't like my conditions, and I don't like yours.

You basically said it was going to be like any other forum discussion, except one-on-one. So I proposed a set-up that was exactly like any other forum discussion, except one-on-one, and you didn't want that.

You want to play with loaded dice. Everyone can now see that.

Oystein has offered you a debate as well, in message #1352. I know you're going to reject that offer too.
 
I agreed to have a one-on-one discussion. But you didn't like my conditions, and I don't like yours.

You basically said it was going to be like any other forum discussion, except one-on-one. So I proposed a set-up that was exactly like any other forum discussion, except one-on-one, and you didn't want that.

You want to play with loaded dice. Everyone can now see that.

Oystein has offered you a debate as well, in message #1352. I know you're going to reject that offer too.

So did I, and Tony promptly put me on ignore, as he so gleefully informed everyone. My only conclusion can be that Tony doesn't actually want a debate at all.

It matters not. Since he has declined such to everyone here for various spurious reasons, his game is obvious. Doesn't matter, he will not be reading this, since he has me on ignore. I simply am amused at his flailing about.
 
So did I, and Tony promptly put me on ignore, as he so gleefully informed everyone. My only conclusion can be that Tony doesn't actually want a debate at all.

It matters not. Since he has declined such to everyone here for various spurious reasons, his game is obvious. Doesn't matter, he will not be reading this, since he has me on ignore. I simply am amused at his flailing about.

his obsession to control the narrative by insisting on taking any 'debate' off site is hilarious as he keeps running into roadblocks. there is absolutely no need to go 'debate' on a site where one's posts that aren't liked would be deleted and user probably banned.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom