does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

[/HILITE]
Pure trolling of nonsense to create a perception that "they" are still active which they can the spin for the masses of gullible potential believers. A decreasingly market these days

However - within that limited goal they are succeeding. Members are still responding to the trolling as if T Sz et al are wanting serious discussion on the topic(s). They don't. All they want and need is people treating them as IF they were serious

Tony is following his SOP of many years - episodic visits to this and other forums accompanied by his "tag team troll" of the day - on this occasion two of them.

And all three enjoying their childish game of throwing insults for whatever effect.

Why feed their egos by jumping as they continue to jerk chains?

Why give them exactly what they want?

As long as they do the Orange Walk through Ulster, we will throw tomatoes at them.
 
My entire post outlined why they are not to be taken seriously.

IMHO we should continue to point out to them in every thread, what it is they have to do to actually be taken seriously.
Your call. I see no sign that they want to be taken seriously which was the thrust of my comment. The game they are playing is here and IMO the likely benefits to the audience of the "wider world" are minimal.

..For instance, in this thread, Oystein and my own questions pertaining to the OP.
I have no problem with staying "On Topic" ... but I'm sorry that you see only you and Oystein supporting that goal.

I've dropped a few unsubtle hints myself. Including extensive suggestions as to a valid process and topics for debate with Tony - which would NOT go along with his goal of game playing.
 
As long as they do the Orange Walk through Ulster, we will throw tomatoes at them.
:thumbsup: Of course. I understand the processes, and the motivations/temptations.

But I have a contrary attitude - If someone is trying to get my attention for their own ego serving purposes - I am strongly motivated to NOT feed their ego. Unless there is a demonstrably overwhelming benefit to some significant third party. Weigh up BOTH sides of the cost benefit.

I've been making the same - or similar - comments about "troll feeding" for many years. Most - if not all - times framed in "cost benefit".

I don't expect much support. I'm well aware that I am outnumbered. ;)
 
Last edited:
:thumbsup: Of course. I understand the processes, and the motivations/temptations.

But I have a contrary attitude - If someone is trying to get my attention for their own ego serving purposes - I am strongly motivated to NOT feed their ego. Unless there is a demonstrably overwhelming benefit to some significant third party. Weigh up BOTH sides of the cost benefit.

I've been making the same - or similar - comments about "troll feeding" for many years. Most - if not all - times framed in "cost benefit".

I don't expect much support. I'm well aware that I am outnumbered. ;)
You sure seem to post a lot for someone who doesn’t “feed the trolls”.

These mutant epistemologists are electronically infecting the world with their viral delusions. I don’t care about the ego thing. I and my family have been personally affected by these True Believer types, that’s why I counter. I hope this might improve the world that I and other rationals have to share with this breed.
 
:thumbsup: Of course. I understand the processes, and the motivations/temptations.

But I have a contrary attitude - If someone is trying to get my attention for their own ego serving purposes - I am strongly motivated to NOT feed their ego. Unless there is a demonstrably overwhelming benefit to some significant third party. Weigh up BOTH sides of the cost benefit.

I've been making the same - or similar - comments about "troll feeding" for many years. Most - if not all - times framed in "cost benefit".

I don't expect much support. I'm well aware that I am outnumbered. ;)

At this point it isn't Troll feeding it is Insect stomping, Troll feeding ended long ago.
 
You sure seem to post a lot for someone who doesn’t “feed the trolls”.

These mutant epistemologists are electronically infecting the world with their viral delusions. I don’t care about the ego thing. I and my family have been personally affected by these True Believer types, that’s why I counter. I hope this might improve the world that I and other rationals have to share with this breed.

Actually they are not a breed, they are a disease, a virus, knowledge, and information are the vaccine and the cure.
 
You sure seem to post a lot for someone who doesn’t “feed the trolls”.
.

He has his position on the matter... you have yours. Leave it at that. I agree with Ozeco for different reasons. I've watched and participated in these discussions off and on for almost 9 years. I have seen nothing in their arguments deviate to something more rational. The OP nowadays chooses only to respond to posts it can easily bait. I've determined since a long time ago that no amount of rational discussion or proper berratement of criticism will change their positions. You know this, and I know this. Continue criticizing as you see fit... but know that beyond satisfying your own interest in the topic it is otherwise a waste of time.

And I say none of this to be condescending. I used to be interested enough to spend my time on these discussions knowing they would go nowhere. Because it interested me. I got tired of it. You and others will too at some point. The only difference between the ones saying to stop feeding the "trolls" and those pushing back is that there are different stages of "having been down that road". Case in point... as newer generations arrive into the discussion they will have a chance to learn about and discuss the issue... i'm fine with spending a little time sharing information for that benefit. On the other hand criticizing the same people for years for basic errors they have never ever corrected at some point has dininishing returns and to that extent the OP deserves no further time or explanation than to place a condition that he corrects his errors or face never being taken seriously for the time of day.

He still wants his little discussion about the NIST errors? Not until he corrects his false premise. I feel absolutely no obligation to discuss or feed such issues until that minimum criteria is met. Of course if others choose to give the attention... i can understand the angle... but i dont agree with it personally
 
Last edited:
He has his position on the matter... you have yours. Leave it at that. I agree with Ozeco for different reasons. I've watched and participated in these discussions off and on for almost 9 years. I have seen nothing in their arguments deviate to something more rational. The OP nowadays chooses only to respond to posts it can easily bait. I've determined since a long time ago that no amount of rational discussion or proper berratement of criticism will change their positions. You know this, and I know this. Continue criticizing as you see fit... but know that beyond satisfying your own interest in the topic it is otherwise a waste of time.

And I say none of this to be condescending. I used to be interested enough to spend my time on these discussions knowing they would go nowhere. Because it interested me. I got tired of it. You and others will too at some point. The only difference between the ones saying to stop feeding the "trolls" and those pushing back is that there are different stages of "having been down that road". Case in point... as newer generations arrive into the discussion they will have a chance to learn about and discuss the issue... i'm fine with spending a little time sharing information for that benefit. On the other hand criticizing the same people for years for basic errors they have never ever corrected at some point has dininishing returns and to that extent the OP deserves no further time or explanation than to place a condition that he corrects his errors or face never being taken seriously for the time of day.

He still wants his little discussion about the NIST errors? Not until he corrects his false premise. I feel absolutely no obligation to discuss or feed such issues until that minimum criteria is met. Of course if others choose to give the attention... i can understand the angle... but i dont agree with it personally

The error in your thinking is you assume he has made an error, at this time and with the history of claims it is not an innocent error, but deliberate fraud for personal gain.
 
I get your point, but, even though I am not a scientist, I understand science, and respect the scientific method. If AE911Truth and their ilk were to produce a peer-reviewed paper detailing their claims, that would be a good step in the direction of convincing me and those like me. I am in no way qualified to produce such a report, nor to understand the minutiae therein, but if such a report was to be produced, and it gained the acceptance and respect of the expert community, I in turn would respect that.
Yes, while I am somewhat versed in the science I do not posses the training to produce such a report. I too will accept the judgement of professional organizations.
Some call it an appeal to authority, and indeed it is. That is however justified when one can justify the validity of the authority. I would consider the ASCE as having such authority. I would consider peer review in a respected engineering journal a step in that direction.
But AE911T cannot even garner the support of the AIA or the CTBUH, let alone structural or mechanical engineering societies, or those devoted to fire engineering.
That means they are outliers, fringe believers, and thus the veracity of their claims is suspect at best.

The complete lack of evidence of CD, the obvious lies and errors in the literature, videos and memes they have produced so far, and the absence of a coherent narrative outlining a scenario that includes both their theories and the known facts of the event, lead one to conclude that no serious attempt is being made to educate,,,,
... WTC 7 collapsed in less than 7 seconds, being imho, the most bald faced lie they tell.

Yes to all that. We might also point out the many instances of accusations leveled by AE911T signatories, of fraud, and complicity in mass murder, and cover up, against NIST and anyone at all, who disagree with them concerning their POV on the events of 9/11/01.
THAT is not conducive to garnering the attention and respect that AE911T says it wants from the professional community.
 
The error in your thinking is you assume he has made an error, at this time and with the history of claims it is not an innocent error, but deliberate fraud for personal gain.

Error or lie makes no difference to me. I have no sympathy to give the time of day to debate an issue whose base premise is wrong or intentionally distorted. The error/lie is long established and oft repeated. And you misunderstand where my lack of sympathy is directed. Its squarely at anyone who continues to push these false premises irregardless of the motivation... because neither scenario speaks well for the originator
 
Last edited:
Error or lie makes no difference to me. I have no sympathy to give the time of day to debate an issue whose base premise is wrong or intentionally distorted. The error/lie is long established and oft repeated. And you misunderstand where my lack of sympathy is directed. Its squarely at anyone who continues to push these false premises irregardless of the motivation... because neither scenario speaks well for the originator

True, but it has always been a lie from the start, most truthers are guilty in the very least of intentional intellectual, and academic dishonesty. That will hopefully shortly very shortly
be coming to an end, and the hammer of truth, is about to fall squarely on Ziggi, and Tony,
Soon they will have the last bases of claim yanked out from under them.
I know something that is unknown to the truthers here, and I would say more but I can't at this time. When everything is done though I will post the facts here.
 
That will hopefully shortly very shortly
be coming to an end, and the hammer of truth, is about to fall squarely on Ziggi, and Tony,
Soon they will have the last bases of claim yanked out from under them.

While I applaud the sentiment, I think you are being unduly optimistic.

One could undermine a tenet of AE911T's claims and it would not faze them for long. They would just move the goalpost.

This can be demonstrated by the explosive vs. thermite issue.
It started as "Bombs in the towers". It was pointed out that there were no sounds sufficient to be ascribed to high explosives that could sever the columns of the towers.
Response was to invoke thermite.
But thermite while quiet is also slow, too slow to offer a timed demolition.
Ok truthers said, it's thermite laced explosives and thus was born the hush-a-boom.
Nope, still would be very loud we said. A high explosive designed to cut large columns in millisecond HAS to produce a supersonic pressure wave, ie. LOUD
Thus was born the 'thermite as a fuse for conventional explosives' as if this answered any of the previous questions.

Then there is "NIST must release it's data set on WTC 7 so it can be verfied".
But then it was revealed that several other full reports on WTC 7 had been done. Those organizations did not seem to require NIST's FEA data set to do their analysis.
AE911T has been quiet about NIST data since then.

So as much as you may be able to drive another, larger nail in the coffin of 911 truth, I doubt you will be able to get the coffin buried yet.
 
While I applaud the sentiment, I think you are being unduly optimistic.

One could undermine a tenet of AE911T's claims and it would not faze them for long. They would just move the goalpost.

This can be demonstrated by the explosive vs. thermite issue.
It started as "Bombs in the towers". It was pointed out that there were no sounds sufficient to be ascribed to high explosives that could sever the columns of the towers.
Response was to invoke thermite.
But thermite while quiet is also slow, too slow to offer a timed demolition.
Ok truthers said, it's thermite laced explosives and thus was born the hush-a-boom.
Nope, still would be very loud we said. A high explosive designed to cut large columns in millisecond HAS to produce a supersonic pressure wave, ie. LOUD
Thus was born the 'thermite as a fuse for conventional explosives' as if this answered any of the previous questions.

Then there is "NIST must release it's data set on WTC 7 so it can be verfied".
But then it was revealed that several other full reports on WTC 7 had been done. Those organizations did not seem to require NIST's FEA data set to do their analysis.
AE911T has been quiet about NIST data since then.

So as much as you may be able to drive another, larger nail in the coffin of 911 truth, I doubt you will be able to get the coffin buried yet.

What we may be looking at is dirrect proof of either gross incompetent behavior, so bad it most likely contitues, academic fraud on Jones, Harrit, Tony, Ziggi, and possibly more.
Publishing in the European Physics Journal might have been there biggest mistake the truth movement ever made.
If everything turns out as I expect it will, this will be a stake though the heart of AE/9/11 truth.
Remember one Truther filing fraud charges can bring down Gage, all he has to prove is that members of the organization know they are lying.
However it takes a truther a supporter to do it.
I know a former Truther who wants to do just that, and the evidence looks like it very may support his claim.
Can you Imagine if the AE/9/11 truth had to return the donations they received what that would do to them?
 
They have had defections before, didn't faze them.

A fraud lawsuit might shake things up, if successful, but that could take months or years. Until then expect yhe ramping up of "they are attacking us becauee e sre close. We need funds for our defence.

Afterwards though..... could take down the forefront truther org, ok.

If this is in the works, I suggest we wait until it materializes. Really nothing to discuss until then.
 
They have had defections before, didn't faze them.

A fraud lawsuit might shake things up, if successful, but that could take months or years. Until then expect yhe ramping up of "they are attacking us becauee e sre close. We need funds for our defence.

Afterwards though..... could take down the forefront truther org, ok.

If this is in the works, I suggest we wait until it materializes. Really nothing to discuss until then.

I agree he might calm down and decide they are not worth the trouble.
He is pretty upset, but either way I have Tony to thank for my new former truther Friend.

Thank You Tony, your a great truth movement debunker.:D
 
They have had defections before, didn't faze them.

A fraud lawsuit might shake things up, if successful, but that could take months or years. Until then expect yhe ramping up of "they are attacking us becauee e sre close. We need funds for our defence.

Afterwards though..... could take down the forefront truther org, ok.

If this is in the works, I suggest we wait until it materializes. Really nothing to discuss until then.

They don't many claims which a court would deem worthy of a action/case proceeding. Their whole pitch is to sow disbelief and claim NIST made a case which was incorrect and that would make it fraud as well as a cover up of something nefarious they call CD.

So they carry on making these pitches which to the naive sound good... but are basically rubbish. And if you show this they consider your take down just a part of the conspiracy. They are like the eveready bunny or whatever... they keep on going.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom