does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

19. Why demolish WTC 7? It contributed little to 'shock and awe' since no one died and it was a relatively unknown structure. Demolition most certainly would be an extremely inefficient form of document destruction(would have been better to just have all floors eventually burn out). Other (barely) surviving WTC structures had gov't and security offices including WTC 5 which did burn out.

Indeed, the classic AE911T tag line "Did you know a 3rd tower fell on 9/11" is in fact self debunking.

Most people don't even know it happened. Never heard of 7, don't remember it given all the other more important stuff that happened. Far from the smoking gun 7 is in fact a mostly irrelevant sideshow, of academic interest to a few engineering and fire safety types and nothing more in the grand scheme of events from that day.
 
If 7wtc was an inside job intended destruction....what would be the motive? This makes no sense at all.

One could see that staging the destruction of the iconic buildings like the twin towers, the pentagon, the capital, white house.... CIA and so forth can be understood at hitting symbolic targets as well as actually causing serious chaos to the US... But 7wtc? Absolutely makes no sense at all.

And it looks like collateral damage from the strike to the twin towers was what led to its collapse.

Yep, "smoking collateral" is more apt than "smoking gun".
 
Indeed, the classic AE911T tag line "Did you know a 3rd tower fell on 9/11" is in fact self debunking.

Most people don't even know it happened. Never heard of 7, don't remember it given all the other more important stuff that happened. Far from the smoking gun 7 is in fact a mostly irrelevant sideshow, of academic interest to a few engineering and fire safety types and nothing more in the grand scheme of events from that day.

"Smoking Gun 7"
Tarantino's next movie?
Seven hired guns must learn to work together when forced into a covert CIA operation.
 
You have the upper section of the North Tower in free fall between floor impacts from the beginning. That most certainly couldn't have happened in the first story as columns had to buckle there and they can't do that over one or two stories as there is still a significant resistance.
Does anyone think Tony's objective enough to notice that he's just debunked his Missing Jolt theory (yet again!)?

Dave
The "debunking Missing Jolt" effort I find most amusing was the Szuladzinski, Szamboti and Johns paper.

Its claims - neither validly falsified AFAIK - in effect rebut BOTH Bazant (the quantification of energy in the "Limit Case" of B&Z) and Szamboti (the two false premises of "Missing Jolt")

And the multiple ironies that flow from that seem to have attracted little interest - from either "side".
 
...
I am glad you brought up debates, as that is what this thread is about. Do you want to debate me on the 911 free forum? Let's see if what you have to say is really non-nonsense.

Do you promise to answer questions in such a debate? If yes, why don't you answer questions when asked? Such as...

[1] as for the value of debating on the internet:
The entire rason d'etre, it appears, of AE911T, is education about the events of 9/11.

EXACTLY how has the cause been advanced by having tfk withdraw from an internet forum debate?

EXACTLY how has tfk withdrawing from debate increased the technical veracity of the claims?

EXACTLY how would debating a different internet poster further the cause of AE911T, or increase the veracity of the claims that AE911T make?


[2] There exists no testable CD hypothesis for WTC7. <- Tony, is that correct? If you disagree, then please provide the URL to the site that hold this hypothesis, so we can test it!


[3]Tony, more than 15 years after 9/11, and after you have spent so many years reviewing all of the evidence, what is, in your opinion today, the most likely ultimate cause of the WTC7 collapse?
(Remember, a straight and honest answer could easily be a single word, or a brief sentence )
 
Do you promise to answer questions in such a debate? If yes, why don't you answer questions when asked? Such as...

[1] as for the value of debating on the internet:
The entire rason d'etre, it appears, of AE911T, is education about the events of 9/11.

EXACTLY how has the cause been advanced by having tfk withdraw from an internet forum debate?

EXACTLY how has tfk withdrawing from debate increased the technical veracity of the claims?

EXACTLY how would debating a different internet poster further the cause of AE911T, or increase the veracity of the claims that AE911T make?


[2] There exists no testable CD hypothesis for WTC7. <- Tony, is that correct? If you disagree, then please provide the URL to the site that hold this hypothesis, so we can test it!


[3]Tony, more than 15 years after 9/11, and after you have spent so many years reviewing all of the evidence, what is, in your opinion today, the most likely ultimate cause of the WTC7 collapse?
(Remember, a straight and honest answer could easily be a single word, or a brief sentence )
I seem to recall a couple people posting something very similar to this.:cool:
 
Tony Szamboti: Good to see you back after your little holiday. While you were away, did you have time to put together the evidence for CD we've been asking for? Have you finalised the research paper proving NIST et al wrong, that you are going to submit for peer review? Have you decided which, of the many offers to debate you that were made here, you are going to accept?
I really hope the answer is "yes" to all of these, because I really want to see proper science in action. You're all about the science, right, Tony?

Tony, I'm not an engineer. I'm not an architect. I'm not even a scientist. I'm an English teacher. In other words, I'm representative of the exact kind of people you should be trying to convince. I'm the public, I'm the masses, yet despite this you refuse to show me any kind of evidence for your claims of CD. Why not? Am I not important enough, as a mere layman, to merit your attention?
If you cannot, or will not, make any attempt to convince one member of one minor internet forum that you have a valid case to make, what hope do you think you will have of making a difference out there in the real world?
 
Tony, I'm not an engineer. I'm not an architect. I'm not even a scientist. I'm an English teacher. In other words, I'm representative of the exact kind of people you should be trying to convince. I'm the public, I'm the masses, yet despite this you refuse to show me any kind of evidence for your claims of CD. Why not? Am I not important enough, as a mere layman, to merit your attention?

With all due respect CY, that has been the push that AE911T has undertaken for over a decade now, informing the non-science masses. That is what Gage's world jaunts have been, speaking tours aimed at people such as you.

The actual engineering and science based forays, as lacking in detail and focus as they are, by AE911T have been here, on internet forums.
How many times have ISF posters suggested to Tony et al that they put together a report on the level of detail of NIST's (or WAI, ARUP, Nordenson, etc.) and submit it to a mainstream engineering journal?

Public speaking tours aimed at the general masses are one thing, but they would be much more effective if supported by a truly professional organization such as ASCE. They have tried twice, or is it three times now, just to get the architectural community represented by AIA to officially back a new investigation, so apparently they know this is the way to go. Do we see a report? Do we see a scenario for CD? No, and no. AE911T wants to be taken seriously but seem unwilling or incapable of doing the work required to garner such respect. Couple that with the continuous accusations of "fraud" , "treason", "mass murder" and "cover up" directed at, but not limited to; Silverstein, NIST, ARUP, WAI, FDNY, and various politicians and their approach is set up for failure. Not that people such as Tony or Ziggi, can even comprehend that it is.

To your main point though, yes, in order to claim CD one must have a CD scenario backed by evidence. Instead of evidence we have things like this from Ziggi; "My point is that you all accept that without precise gov documentation with timestamped listing of cut beams, and further that you assume that ALL the cut beams found must have been cut during the clean up and that no beam could have been cut via thermitic cutter charges prior to building collapse.". Unadulterated conjecture, pure fictional thinking.
 
...Unadulterated conjecture, pure fictional thinking.
Pure trolling of nonsense to create a perception that "they" are still active which they can the spin for the masses of gullible potential believers. A decreasingly market these days

However - within that limited goal they are succeeding. Members are still responding to the trolling as if T Sz et al are wanting serious discussion on the topic(s). They don't. All they want and need is people treating them as IF they were serious

Tony is following his SOP of many years - episodic visits to this and other forums accompanied by his "tag team troll" of the day - on this occasion two of them.

And all three enjoying their childish game of throwing insults for whatever effect.

Why feed their egos by jumping as they continue to jerk chains?

Why give them exactly what they want?
 
[/HILITE]
All they want and need is people treating them as IF they were serious

My entire post outlined why they are not to be taken seriously.

IMHO we should continue to point out to them in every thread, what it is they have to do to actually be taken seriously.

For instance, in this thread, Oystein and my own questions pertaining to the OP.
 
My sense is a lot of people are swayed by the AE marketing materials... seeds of doubt and deception are planted. Naive have to trust and either decide it's PR rubbish... unsupported.... or it makes sense. If you want it to make sense... it does. Those minds will not change. That is unless and until they get smart enough to understand the con.
 
[/HILITE]
Pure trolling of nonsense to create a perception that "they" are still active which they can the spin for the masses of gullible potential believers. A decreasingly market these days

However - within that limited goal they are succeeding. Members are still responding to the trolling as if T Sz et al are wanting serious discussion on the topic(s). They don't. All they want and need is people treating them as IF they were serious

Tony is following his SOP of many years - episodic visits to this and other forums accompanied by his "tag team troll" of the day - on this occasion two of them.

And all three enjoying their childish game of throwing insults for whatever effect.

Why feed their egos by jumping as they continue to jerk chains?

Why give them exactly what they want?
My personal goal is to ensure that these folks never achieve a position in engineering/science where they are in a position of public trust and/or responsibility.
Getting their name out there helps in that regard.
I also have issues and want to make it known that a FEM/FEA is not the be-all and end-all of analysis, but another tool in the arsenal. Those who don't know or care to know how to use it must be stopped.
 
My personal goal is to ensure that these folks never achieve a position in engineering/science where they are in a position of public trust and/or responsibility.
Getting their name out there helps in that regard.
I also have issues and want to make it known that a FEM/FEA is not the be-all and end-all of analysis, but another tool in the arsenal. Those who don't know or care to know how to use it must be stopped.

The fraud of Tony, Jones, and Gage is about to be exposed, so I doubt that we will have to worry about them much longer.
I can't say anymore, If Tony were smart, he would jump ship before it sinks.
I don't expect that to happen though, I expect him and the rest to go down with the ship.
 
With all due respect CY, that has been the push that AE911T has undertaken for over a decade now, informing the non-science masses. That is what Gage's world jaunts have been, speaking tours aimed at people such as you.

The actual engineering and science based forays, as lacking in detail and focus as they are, by AE911T have been here, on internet forums.
How many times have ISF posters suggested to Tony et al that they put together a report on the level of detail of NIST's (or WAI, ARUP, Nordenson, etc.) and submit it to a mainstream engineering journal?

Public speaking tours aimed at the general masses are one thing, but they would be much more effective if supported by a truly professional organization such as ASCE. They have tried twice, or is it three times now, just to get the architectural community represented by AIA to officially back a new investigation, so apparently they know this is the way to go. Do we see a report? Do we see a scenario for CD? No, and no. AE911T wants to be taken seriously but seem unwilling or incapable of doing the work required to garner such respect.

I get your point, but, even though I am not a scientist, I understand science, and respect the scientific method. If AE911Truth and their ilk were to produce a peer-reviewed paper detailing their claims, that would be a good step in the direction of convincing me and those like me. I am in no way qualified to produce such a report, nor to understand the minutiae therein, but if such a report was to be produced, and it gained the acceptance and respect of the expert community, I in turn would respect that.
I agree with you that the details should be debated among qualified individuals, but there should also be a parallel push by truthers to persuade non-experts of the validity of their cause. The complete lack of evidence of CD, the obvious lies and errors in the literature, videos and memes they have produced so far, and the absence of a coherent narrative outlining a scenario that includes both their theories and the known facts of the event, lead one to conclude that no serious attempt is being made to educate, if that is the mot juste intelligent, educated non-engineers like myself.

Tony Szamboti, and the other truthers on this forum are, of course, free to correct this deficiency at any time. I am baffled as to why they have so far neglected to do so.
 
My personal goal is to ensure that these folks never achieve a position in engineering/science where they are in a position of public trust and/or responsibility.
Getting their name out there helps in that regard.
I comprehend the goals. I'm not persuaded - either way. I agree responding to serious material could help - but I'm a long way from persuaded that responding to trolling insults and technical nonsense is the way to go.

....I also have issues and want to make it known that a FEM/FEA is not the be-all and end-all of analysis, but another tool in the arsenal.
One of my constant foundation themes since my first post. Not limited to FEA - but the reliance on poorly founded numeric solutions is an endemic risk... I've seen it and confronted it through four era's of technology - slide rule >> calculator>>computer>>>FEA. Whatever the tool of the day using it BEFORE properly defining the problem will always be..."risky". And it is SOP for T Sz >> I needn't reflect on the long history of my interactions with Tony where I point out a fundamental error of logic and he asks "Where is your maths or FEA"?

....Those who don't know or care to know how to use it must be stopped.
Mmmmm...... :rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom