Tony, I'm not an engineer. I'm not an architect. I'm not even a scientist. I'm an English teacher. In other words, I'm representative of the exact kind of people you should be trying to convince. I'm the public, I'm the masses, yet despite this you refuse to show me any kind of evidence for your claims of CD. Why not? Am I not important enough, as a mere layman, to merit your attention?
With all due respect CY, that has been the push that AE911T has undertaken for over a decade now, informing the non-science masses. That is what Gage's world jaunts have been, speaking tours aimed at people such as you.
The actual engineering and science based forays, as lacking in detail and focus as they are, by AE911T have been here, on internet forums.
How many times have ISF posters suggested to Tony et al that they put together a report on the level of detail of NIST's (or WAI, ARUP, Nordenson, etc.) and submit it to a mainstream engineering journal?
Public speaking tours aimed at the general masses are one thing, but they would be much more effective if supported by a truly professional organization such as ASCE. They have tried twice, or is it three times now, just to get the architectural community represented by AIA to officially back a new investigation, so apparently they know this is the way to go. Do we see a report? Do we see a scenario for CD? No, and no. AE911T wants to be taken seriously but seem unwilling or incapable of doing the work required to garner such respect. Couple that with the continuous accusations of "fraud" , "treason", "mass murder" and "cover up" directed at, but not limited to; Silverstein, NIST, ARUP, WAI, FDNY, and various politicians and their approach is set up for failure. Not that people such as Tony or Ziggi, can even comprehend that it is.
To your main point though, yes, in order to claim CD one must have a CD scenario backed by evidence. Instead of evidence we have things like this from Ziggi; "
My point is that you all accept that without precise gov documentation with timestamped listing of cut beams, and further that you assume that ALL the cut beams found must have been cut during the clean up and that no beam could have been cut via thermitic cutter charges prior to building collapse.". Unadulterated conjecture, pure fictional thinking.