Originally Posted by jaydeehess View Post
”What is it's purpose?”
Visitors with open minds can better see both sides of each issue. Wading through mountains of ‘cut ’n paste’ garbage and rant posts tends to keep visitors away.
Ok
Seems this might be the only point i raised you managed to actually address.
Originally Posted by jaydeehess View Post
”All studies of WTC7's collapse converge on fire induced multifloor collapses that are the first step in progressive collapse that leads to global involvement.”
You could argue that the first bird that flew into WTC7 was “the first step in a ‘progressive collapse’. The term is really quite meaningless
.
I am quite sure you are the only person who would characterise the first step in collapse sequence that way.

After impact of WTC1 debris the building was seriously damaged, possibly a write off at that point. But if that was the end of it, it would have stayed upright, suffering perhaps only further SW corner partial collapse.
There WAS a progressive collapse sequence though and you seem to wish to ignore the above statement I made, even though you quoted it.
All reports done by professional, qualified engineering groups concluded that floor failures led to column instability and continuing progressive failures eventually taking the entire structure dow. There ya go I reiterated it, try again to address it. Or not, it would again underline your dishonesty in replies.
Originally Posted by jaydeehess View Post
”As I recall it, most if not all debunkers here did not so much defend NIST's initiating event as point out that it was described as a "most probable" first event but that many other factors would have been in play such as column spreading, stresses induced due to loss of SW corner and other impact damage, and stresses due to fires on other floors.”
CD describes well what was observed.
Office cubicle fires heating fire-proofed structural steel to the point of sudden global collapse was only observed by the minds of those who desperately cling to the NIST hypothesis.
Magical bald assertion that some handwaving theory of explosive CD, versus several professional engineering reports concluding that heat damage began the collapse sequence, backed up by sophisticated computer FEA analysis of building response.
Gee,,,, if I am to choose which is the more authoritive source,,, what to do, what to do.....
Originally Posted by jaydeehess View Post
”WRT the towers, many here distinctly describe collapse and include how jolt could not happen and how internal collapse led perimeter peel, and core destruction.”
A colourful ability to describe one’s chosen hypothesis that fails to be supported by engineering science has zero credibility.
As opposed to the colourful, unsubstantiated claims of Tony Szamboti. As opposed to the magical, bald assertions of explosive CD.
Tell us again how many professional engineering orgs have objected to the idea of internal collapse, unsupported columns sequence and NISTstating that once collapse began collapse would continue? How many have endorsed the AE911T paper explaining a CD demolition?
Originally Posted by jaydeehess View Post
”NIST was not alone in studying any if these three buildings. There are numerous professional engineering organizations that have, and exactly none have deduced that anything other than impact and fire was responsible for the demise of these buildings. A point made numerous times in this forum's pages.”
‘Study’ is another term that has little meaning unless it comes with a full description of the ’study’ and is authored by non-anonymous peoples with arguable professional credentials.
How anonymous are the people who wrote the NIST, ARUP, WAI, Nordenson, Purdue U. Etc.,etc., etc., reports/studies?
You are arguing that these people have arguable credentials! You must really hate Chris Sarns' fire intensity "study"!
Originally Posted by jaydeehess View Post
”OTOH, the extreme paucity of any engineering study from those who deny the commonly accepted history of the events of 9/11, has been pointed out.”
Since when is the majority always right?
How wonderful of you to once again ignore the subject of a statement of mine.
The problem is a lazy, acceptance of history as it is published by the mainstream media.
Where did I ever mention a MSM article? I continuously have referred to engineering professionals. How did you make the leap to general public and MSM?
Nevermind, I note yet again your desire to completely ignore, to twist, to obfuscate every and all questions.
Originally Posted by jaydeehess View Post
”The fact that the leading "9/11truth" group, while loudly touting support of 2000+ engineers and architects, has chosen to spend funds raised not on engineering, but to concentrate on sending Gage and a few others on speaking tours for the general public.
Little effort has been made to ellicit support from recognized professional organizations.”
Lie much?
Do you not believe that any of those “2,000+ engineers and architects” belong to “recognized professional organizations”?
On the investigation side, Dr. Hulsey’s study is being funded by AE911T.
It is one thing to believe whatever you wish, but when you state your unsupported opinion as fact you are lying, and insulting readers.
AE911T have made no secret about their belief that the most effective way to inform the public, is to ‘inform the public’.
Yes, I would expect those 2000 to belong to professional organizations. ,,,and yet again you either deliberately or erroneously misrepresent
what I said. Try again.
As for trying to garner support from professional engineering organizations, tell me, aside from the recent tries to get AIA on board, just what has been done?
AFAIK, no recognized professional engineering organization has endorsed AE911T. If I am in error, I am sure you can correct me. IIRC, at least two, ASCE, and CTBUH have unequivocably rejected AE911T's contentions.
Hulsey? The Hulsey that it took AE911T over a decade to even bother to approach? <<insert laughing dog gif>>. Come on man, AE911T complained and complained, shouting fraud and obfuscation with NIST taking years with WTC7 (Again, ignoring the stated reason), but it's just peachy for AE911T to take longer to even pretend to begin a serious engineering study.
Originally Posted by jaydeehess View Post
”Lately Tony Sz. has declared that the steel temperatures used in the WAI report are ridiculoys despite not having any research to back his declaration up ( since neither he or any other professional at AE911T has been bothered to produce a fire spread/intensity study) , nor bothering to try to find the fire engineering study that is cited by Abboud.”
Dr. Hulsey and his team, as part of their ongoing study, have declared unequivocally that fire was not the cause of WTC7’s collapse.
Does not address what I stated.
On your tangent to what I said:
Hulsey has released "conclusions" without having completed his study.
Dats how enjineerin's dun innit.