does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Really? How could it be left out?

Some of you guys are trying to make something out of nothing.

You have some nerve talking about leaving anything out.

You leave out fully 50% of the plane crashes and 2/3rds of the locations.

There can be no more dishonest "debater" than you, Mr.
 
You have some nerve talking about leaving anything out.

You leave out fully 50% of the plane crashes and 2/3rds of the locations.

There can be no more dishonest "debater" than you, Mr.

It's as if he fears telling the truth will prove him a fraud.;)
 
That's a great rant coming from the author of the Mark Basile Fraud.

Just what bank, account, or trust fund, did you say that $5000USD was deposited in?

What happened to the promised study?
AE911T proponents railed on and on about how long it took NIST to complete the WTC7 final report (ignoring, of course, the stated reasons for it) yet not a peep from them regarding Basile.
For that matter what about the promises made concerning Hulsey's report? Will this take 7 years too?
 
@Tony Szamboti - what would be wrong with a debate between yourself and ozeco41, on the 911 Free Forum, but without any of the restrictions imposed by your list of rules? The thread could be called, 'Were the Twin Towers and WTC7 destroyed by controlled demolition or not?'

Ozeco41 has all but explicitly offered to do this and is qualified to debate you. The only rule that makes any kind of sense would be that nobody can post twice in a row.

Your list of rules feels designed to ensure that the debate becomes about who has and hasn't followed the rules.
 
@Tony Szamboti - what would be wrong with a debate between yourself and ozeco41, on the 911 Free Forum, but without any of the restrictions imposed by your list of rules?

The thread could be called, 'Were the Twin Towers and WTC7 destroyed by controlled demolition or not?'

Ozeco41 has all but explicitly offered to do this and is qualified to debate you. The only rule that makes any kind of sense would be that nobody can post twice in a row.

Your list of rules feels designed to ensure that the debate becomes about who has and hasn't followed the rules.

Does your alter ego Oystein feel incapable of defending his views on this subject?
 
Does your alter ego Oystein feel incapable of defending his views on this subject?
I think you misread 'ozeco41' as 'Oystein'.

ETA: By 'alter-ego' are you saying that you think I'm Oystein?
 
Last edited:
Tony--it's been three days since you wrote, "[t]he Weidlinger Associates report has a provably unsupportable and ridiculous assumption of two floors being heated to 850 degrees C simultaneously through 4 hour long preheating."

Where is your proof of your claim?

Try to fill in the blank with something other than a bare assertion: The maximum temperature that a given steel beam in a fully involved multistory office fire could reach is ______. Please reference the Cardington report you already cited or any other major office fire experiment (including the one that was specifically done on a scale model of wtc 1) when coming up with this number.

Muster up an ounce of intellectual honesty, Tony. Once you accept there were reasonably plausible scenarios in which fire alone could have caused WTC 7 to collapse, you can move on with your life. You also have a responsibility to all the people you've been misleading for years to correct the record now that you realize you've been mistaken all this time. They trusted you because of your credentials. You owe it to them to just admit you do not have an actual engineering critique of the WAI report. (It's obvious to anyone who isn't completely epistemologically crippled, but, unfortunately, many of your fellow travelers are.)

You should also write Dr. Abboud and his team of professional forensic engineers a thank you note for doing the hard work you claimed for years to have wanted.
 
”How will one on one debates further your desire for a new investigation?”

It eliminates the flood of obscure posts from fanatics.

”What is it's purpose?”

Visitors with open minds can better see both sides of each issue. Wading through mountains of ‘cut ’n paste’ garbage and rant posts tends to keep visitors away.

”All studies of WTC7's collapse converge on fire induced multifloor collapses that are the first step in progressive collapse that leads to global involvement.”

You could argue that the first bird that flew into WTC7 was “the first step in a ‘progressive collapse’. The term is really quite meaningless.

”As I recall it, most if not all debunkers here did not so much defend NIST's initiating event as point out that it was described as a "most probable" first event but that many other factors would have been in play such as column spreading, stresses induced due to loss of SW corner and other impact damage, and stresses due to fires on other floors.”

CD describes well what was observed.

Office cubicle fires heating fire-proofed structural steel to the point of sudden global collapse was only observed by the minds of those who desperately cling to the NIST hypothesis.

”WRT the towers, many here distinctly describe collapse and include how jolt could not happen and how internal collapse led perimeter peel, and core destruction.”

A colourful ability to describe one’s chosen hypothesis that fails to be supported by engineering science has zero credibility.

”NIST was not alone in studying any if these three buildings. There are numerous professional engineering organizations that have, and exactly none have deduced that anything other than impact and fire was responsible for the demise of theee buildings. A point made numerous times in this forum's pages.”

‘Study’ is another term that has little meaning unless it comes with a full description of the ’study’ and is authored by non-anonymous peoples with arguable professional credentials.

”OTOH, the extreme paucity of any engineering study from those who deny the commonly accepted history of the events of 9/11, has been pointed out.”

Since when is the majority always right?

The problem is a lazy, acceptance of history as it is published by the mainstream media.

”The fact that the leading "9/11truth" group, while loudly touting support of 2000+ engineers and architects, has chosen to spend funds raised not on engineering, but to concentrate on sending Gage and a few others on speaking tours for the general public.

Little effort has been made to ellicit support from recognized professional organizations.”

Lie much?

Do you not believe that any of those “2,000+ engineers and architects” belong to “recognized professional organizations”?

On the investigation side, Dr. Hulsey’s study is being funded by AE911T.

It is one thing to believe whatever you wish, but when you state your unsupported opinion as fact you are lying, and insulting readers.

AE911T have made no secret about their belief that the most effective way to inform the public, is to ‘inform the public’.

”Lately Tony Sz. has declared that the steel temperatures used in the WAI report are ridiculoys despite not having any research to back his declaration up ( since neither he or any other professional at AE911T has been bothered to produce a fire spread/intensity study) , nor bothering to try to find the fire engineering study that is cited by Abboud.”

Dr. Hulsey and his team, as part of their ongoing study, have declared unequivocally that fire was not the cause of WTC7’s collapse.
 
Originally Posted by jaydeehess View Post
”How will one on one debates further your desire for a new investigation?”


It eliminates the flood of obscure posts from fanatics.

So you're saying that a debate with fewer obscure posts will what - be forwarded to NIST?

Office cubicle fires heating fire-proofed structural steel to the point of sudden global collapse was only observed by the minds of those who desperately cling to the NIST hypothesis.

I love those posts that have zero basis in reality. Not a single syllable of that post is in any way accurate. None of it.
 
Last edited:
Dr. Hulsey and his team, as part of their ongoing study, have declared unequivocally that fire was not the cause of WTC7’s collapse.

Did they announce this "conclusion" before or after they finished the necessary modeling work to actually reach it? (Feel free to reference Dr. Hulsey's comments here re the ongoing research he is actually still doing, for example.)
 
Last edited:
@Tony Szamboti - what would be wrong with a debate between yourself and ozeco41, on the 911 Free Forum, but without any of the restrictions imposed by your list of rules? The thread could be called, 'Were the Twin Towers and WTC7 destroyed by controlled demolition or not?'

Ozeco41 has all but explicitly offered to do this and is qualified to debate you. The only rule that makes any kind of sense would be that nobody can post twice in a row.

Your list of rules feels designed to ensure that the debate becomes about who has and hasn't followed the rules.
You seem to be the only member who has recognised that Georgio.

It wont happen - Tony is well aware that I have his measure and won't fall for his SOP debating tricks.
 
Did they announce this "conclusion" before or after they finished the necessary modeling work to actually reach it? (Feel free to reference Dr. Hulsey's comments here re the ongoing research he is actually still doing, for example.)

Sure, of course he did. Tony decides that WAI used false fire temp data before he even knows how their cited study was done, Hulsey concludes what did not cause collapse while having barely started his study.

Dat's hows enjeerin's dun innit?
 
It eliminates the flood of obscure posts from fanatics.

That is not what I asked Criteria. Not that you did not know it. Given the number of times I have asked this or similar questions it really appears that you, and Tony and Ziggi et al, simply do not want to answer the question. I assume that is because you all know that you would have to admit that it will not, and cannot, further the cause for a new investigation in any way shape or fashion.
 
On going study makes conclusion... fraud in 9/11 truth fools followers

... Do you not believe that any of those “2,000+ engineers and architects” belong to “recognized professional organizations”?
Math explains the fringe few who can't do math. With less than 0.1 percent of all engineers on board the train to BS, lies of CD, and the fantasy of silent explosives. ... why can't 9/11 truth do math?

Go, debate your fantasy with your peers in 9/11 truth, there is still one Boston bomber who was fooled by 9/11 truth lies; team up with your peers in paranoid conspiracy theorist. Report back when you have evidence for CD. (bye, bye)

Dr. Hulsey and his team, as part of their ongoing study, have declared unequivocally that fire was not the cause of WTC7’s collapse.
A CT nut leading students? His student know he is a nut, and since he is their advisor, they are stuck with woo. Graduate, or tell Hulsey he is nuts.
Thus you believe a nut. How can an on going study make a conclusion before the "ON Going" study is done? lol, 9/11 truth followers, the faithful few, fall for the dumbest claims.

On going study has conclusion first... sounds like fraud, and exposes another failed nut in 9/11 truth. Wait til the school finds out Hulsey is a CT nut.


Then you bring weak personal attacks and chitchat to a debate; try evidence next time.
Does your alter ego Oystein feel incapable of defending his views on this subject?

Weak personal attacks presented because there is no evidence. Failed to prove CD, 9/11 upset and attacking the truth, it was fire. Darn, 9/11t lost the debate, personal attacks, sign of failure. Try evidence next time and don't fall for the fantasy of CD made up by old men who are BS artists. Why are 9/11 truth followers gullible? Where is the evidence?

Learn what evidence is, and evidence is not make up conclusions by old men with delusions of an inside job. Don't be gullible
 
Last edited:
That is not what I asked Criteria. Not that you did not know it. Given the number of times I have asked this or similar questions it really appears that you, and Tony and Ziggi et al, simply do not want to answer the question. I assume that is because you all know that you would have to admit that it will not, and cannot, further the cause for a new investigation in any way shape or fashion.
clap.gif
clap.gif

They are trolling to make sure that discussion goes round in circles. And - as always - feeding trolling gives them the three things they are after - (1) ego stroking; (2) activity they can spin for their sycophants; AND (3)
zero progress.

"Remember that the goal of conspiracy rhetoric is to bog down the discussion, not to make progress toward a solution" Jay Windley
 
A CT nut leading students? His student know he is a nut, and since he is their advisor, they are stuck with woo. Graduate, or tell Hulsey he is nuts.
clap.gif
clap.gif


A tough call for PhD students in Alaskan relative isolation. Do you abort? Go elsewhere? Restart? or put up with a blot on the validity of your PhD?

And all of that presuming they can see reality. Remember that most of us in forum discussions are way ahead of academia in understanding the bigger picture aspects of WTC Collapse Woo.

... Wait til the school finds out Hulsey is a CT nut.
Yes - but don't count on anything dramatic. UNIs are well known for tolerance of "way out" ideas.
 
Originally Posted by jaydeehess View Post
”What is it's purpose?”
Visitors with open minds can better see both sides of each issue. Wading through mountains of ‘cut ’n paste’ garbage and rant posts tends to keep visitors away.
Ok
Seems this might be the only point i raised you managed to actually address.
Originally Posted by jaydeehess View Post
”All studies of WTC7's collapse converge on fire induced multifloor collapses that are the first step in progressive collapse that leads to global involvement.”
You could argue that the first bird that flew into WTC7 was “the first step in a ‘progressive collapse’. The term is really quite meaningless
.
I am quite sure you are the only person who would characterise the first step in collapse sequence that way.:rolleyes:
After impact of WTC1 debris the building was seriously damaged, possibly a write off at that point. But if that was the end of it, it would have stayed upright, suffering perhaps only further SW corner partial collapse.
There WAS a progressive collapse sequence though and you seem to wish to ignore the above statement I made, even though you quoted it.
All reports done by professional, qualified engineering groups concluded that floor failures led to column instability and continuing progressive failures eventually taking the entire structure dow. There ya go I reiterated it, try again to address it. Or not, it would again underline your dishonesty in replies.
Originally Posted by jaydeehess View Post
”As I recall it, most if not all debunkers here did not so much defend NIST's initiating event as point out that it was described as a "most probable" first event but that many other factors would have been in play such as column spreading, stresses induced due to loss of SW corner and other impact damage, and stresses due to fires on other floors.”
CD describes well what was observed.

Office cubicle fires heating fire-proofed structural steel to the point of sudden global collapse was only observed by the minds of those who desperately cling to the NIST hypothesis.
Magical bald assertion that some handwaving theory of explosive CD, versus several professional engineering reports concluding that heat damage began the collapse sequence, backed up by sophisticated computer FEA analysis of building response.

Gee,,,, if I am to choose which is the more authoritive source,,, what to do, what to do.....
Originally Posted by jaydeehess View Post
”WRT the towers, many here distinctly describe collapse and include how jolt could not happen and how internal collapse led perimeter peel, and core destruction.”
A colourful ability to describe one’s chosen hypothesis that fails to be supported by engineering science has zero credibility.
As opposed to the colourful, unsubstantiated claims of Tony Szamboti. As opposed to the magical, bald assertions of explosive CD.
Tell us again how many professional engineering orgs have objected to the idea of internal collapse, unsupported columns sequence and NISTstating that once collapse began collapse would continue? How many have endorsed the AE911T paper explaining a CD demolition?
Originally Posted by jaydeehess View Post
”NIST was not alone in studying any if these three buildings. There are numerous professional engineering organizations that have, and exactly none have deduced that anything other than impact and fire was responsible for the demise of these buildings. A point made numerous times in this forum's pages.”
‘Study’ is another term that has little meaning unless it comes with a full description of the ’study’ and is authored by non-anonymous peoples with arguable professional credentials.
How anonymous are the people who wrote the NIST, ARUP, WAI, Nordenson, Purdue U. Etc.,etc., etc., reports/studies?
You are arguing that these people have arguable credentials! You must really hate Chris Sarns' fire intensity "study"!:eek:

Originally Posted by jaydeehess View Post
”OTOH, the extreme paucity of any engineering study from those who deny the commonly accepted history of the events of 9/11, has been pointed out.”
Since when is the majority always right?
How wonderful of you to once again ignore the subject of a statement of mine.

The problem is a lazy, acceptance of history as it is published by the mainstream media.
Where did I ever mention a MSM article? I continuously have referred to engineering professionals. How did you make the leap to general public and MSM?
Nevermind, I note yet again your desire to completely ignore, to twist, to obfuscate every and all questions.

Originally Posted by jaydeehess View Post
”The fact that the leading "9/11truth" group, while loudly touting support of 2000+ engineers and architects, has chosen to spend funds raised not on engineering, but to concentrate on sending Gage and a few others on speaking tours for the general public.

Little effort has been made to ellicit support from recognized professional organizations.”
Lie much?

Do you not believe that any of those “2,000+ engineers and architects” belong to “recognized professional organizations”?

On the investigation side, Dr. Hulsey’s study is being funded by AE911T.

It is one thing to believe whatever you wish, but when you state your unsupported opinion as fact you are lying, and insulting readers.

AE911T have made no secret about their belief that the most effective way to inform the public, is to ‘inform the public’.

Yes, I would expect those 2000 to belong to professional organizations. ,,,and yet again you either deliberately or erroneously misrepresent what I said. Try again.
As for trying to garner support from professional engineering organizations, tell me, aside from the recent tries to get AIA on board, just what has been done?
AFAIK, no recognized professional engineering organization has endorsed AE911T. If I am in error, I am sure you can correct me. IIRC, at least two, ASCE, and CTBUH have unequivocably rejected AE911T's contentions.
Hulsey? The Hulsey that it took AE911T over a decade to even bother to approach? <<insert laughing dog gif>>. Come on man, AE911T complained and complained, shouting fraud and obfuscation with NIST taking years with WTC7 (Again, ignoring the stated reason), but it's just peachy for AE911T to take longer to even pretend to begin a serious engineering study.
Originally Posted by jaydeehess View Post
”Lately Tony Sz. has declared that the steel temperatures used in the WAI report are ridiculoys despite not having any research to back his declaration up ( since neither he or any other professional at AE911T has been bothered to produce a fire spread/intensity study) , nor bothering to try to find the fire engineering study that is cited by Abboud.”
Dr. Hulsey and his team, as part of their ongoing study, have declared unequivocally that fire was not the cause of WTC7’s collapse.
Does not address what I stated.

On your tangent to what I said:
Hulsey has released "conclusions" without having completed his study.

Dats how enjineerin's dun innit.
 
Last edited:
[qimg]http://conleys.com.au/smilies/clap.gif[/qimg] [qimg]http://conleys.com.au/smilies/clap.gif[/qimg]
They are trolling to make sure that discussion goes round in circles. And - as always - feeding trolling gives them the three things they are after - (1) ego stroking; (2) activity they can spin for their sycophants; AND (3)
zero progress.

"Remember that the goal of conspiracy rhetoric is to bog down the discussion, not to make progress toward a solution" Jay Windley

I have lost count of the number of times I have had to post, pointing out that Criteria et al, while quoting me, have utterly failed to address what they quote me posting.

ETA: (this happens with others quoted by the same posters as well)

It has gone beyond credible that these are all mistakes, and misreading, and would instead imply deliberate misrepresentation and obfuscation.
 
Last edited:
Tony,

I have some time right now and am wondering if anyone here who supports the statements from ae911truth made about the three high-rise collapses in NYC on Sept. 11, 2001, would want to debate me one-on-one as I contend that the statements made by ae911truth are deliberately false and misleading and do not indicate evidence of controlled demolition.

The debate would take place on the 911 free forum, like the one Tony did with tfk, and the rules would be the same as those for that debate shown below.

1. The debate is restricted to the ae911truth statements on the collapses of WTC 1, 2 & 7 in NYC on September 11, 2001, and any additional objectively verifiable information and analyses in the public domain about them, including the NIST reports.

2. Each person shall make an opening statement (of no more than 500 words) about the ae911truth statements concerning the collapse of WTC1,2,7 and identify those which are true or false and describe the strongest or weakest pieces of verifiable evidence for/against Controlled Demolition, as "Controlled Demolition vs. No Controlled Demolition".

3. One participant will go first after both participants make an opening statement on June 21, 2016.

4. Each person shall make no more than one post per day and cannot make another until it is responded to.

5. If a post is not responded to within a week the person not responding is considered to have forfeited his turn & the other person will proceed with his next statement.

6. Individual posts are limited to 1,000 words. If it is deemed necessary to exceed that limit, justification shall be provided by the person wanting to exceed it and agreement to by the other participant received prior to doing so. This should be done by private messaging, so as not to interrupt the flow of the debate, and should be the exception rather than the rule.

7. Each post will discuss one principle topic. Each topic consists of 4 posts. Person A will state a topic post, Person B replies, Person A counters, then Person B counters, and that topic is closed. Person B then leads off the next sequence.

8. Every point that either person brings up must be addressed in some manner by the other. Both parties will do their best to stay focused on the original topic point.

9. There shall be no name calling, denigration, or defamatory language used. Each person shall bring only technical arguments to the debate. If any derogatory comments are used they shall be addressed to arguments only, not to individuals.

10. The debate will end after a maximum of 12 topics and 4 posts each, or earlier if the participants mutually agree to an earlier termination, or whenever either participant decides to stop responding.
 
[qimg]http://conleys.com.au/smilies/clap.gif[/qimg] [qimg]http://conleys.com.au/smilies/clap.gif[/qimg]

A tough call for PhD students in Alaskan relative isolation. Do you abort? Go elsewhere? Restart? or put up with a blot on the validity of your PhD?

And all of that presuming they can see reality. Remember that most of us in forum discussions are way ahead of academia in understanding the bigger picture aspects of WTC Collapse Woo.


Yes - but don't count on anything dramatic. UNIs are well known for tolerance of "way out" ideas.

I had to switch advisors for my Mech E MS thesis, because the original guy was unsatisfactory.

And no, neither the original or the replacement was Bazant, although I probably bumped into him at some point.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom