Oh. My. Days 

Plan View Examples (though not from the "final" setup)...
Top:

Front:

Left:

White - NIST
Green - Draft femr2
Do you really think I'd have the bleedin' towers in the wrong place, oriented incorrectly and scaled incorrectly ?
Can you not think of another reason why your overlay might not match what you expect it to ?
Ye gads man. Hint: There's a difference between clearly indicated draft non-final camera location and camera location for the last rotoscope
You now accept near to this location...
Fine.

3DSMax is rather good at rendering three dimensional environments.
The towers are in the right place.
The other buildings are in the right place.
The camera is in the right place.
The render matches almost perfectly with video taken from the camera location, pointed at the same place, with the secondary buildings in the right place.
The ONLY thing that's out of place is the NIST oriented aircraft.

Figured out that the Carmen Taylor viewpoint is slightly different to the Hezarkhani viewpoint yet, and that the aircraft in the Carmen Taylor photo has not yet made contact with the building ?
Enough of this nonsense.
The aircraft is not at the same vertical level.Seriously though, the location of the observer is placed on the map and sightlines are drawn between him and various vertical surfaces in the frame.
I very much doubt you are accounting for perspective correctly when orienting your "map".The blue line representing the fuselage length and orienta[t]ion are the[n] placed on the map
Plan View Examples (though not from the "final" setup)...
Top:

Front:

Left:

White - NIST
Green - Draft femr2
Your "sightlines" do not all stem from the same vertical level.the proportions of the baseline will remain consistent
Good.Not in dispute
Good.Not in dispute
Oh. My. Days.although your layout differs from the map and satellite imagery
Do you really think I'd have the bleedin' towers in the wrong place, oriented incorrectly and scaled incorrectly ?

Can you not think of another reason why your overlay might not match what you expect it to ?
Ye gads man. Hint: There's a difference between clearly indicated draft non-final camera location and camera location for the last rotoscope
Good.Not in dispute.
You were wrong to suggest my secondary building placement was incorrect. Fine.I thought your position might have been wrong because I was initially aligning the camera and WTC which threw off the position of the intermediate buildings.
You've changed camera position several times.I'm not changing the camera position and if you looked at the images of my sightlines you'd have seen that we're within a few metres of other.
You now accept near to this location...
Fine.
In your virtual word the aircraft doesn't line up, not necessarily the case in the real world.

3DSMax is rather good at rendering three dimensional environments.
The towers are in the right place.
The other buildings are in the right place.
The camera is in the right place.
The render matches almost perfectly with video taken from the camera location, pointed at the same place, with the secondary buildings in the right place.
The ONLY thing that's out of place is the NIST oriented aircraft.

Yes. A problem between your keyboard and your seat.Figured out how the tail of the aircraft lies within the visual edge of the building from that other camera angle yet?
Figured out that the Carmen Taylor viewpoint is slightly different to the Hezarkhani viewpoint yet, and that the aircraft in the Carmen Taylor photo has not yet made contact with the building ?
Done a long time ago.Maybe you could cross check how your 3d world looks from other camera locations.
Enough of this nonsense.
Last edited:
