BasqueArch
Graduate Poster
- Joined
- Jan 11, 2009
- Messages
- 1,871
Threw together a slightly higher resolution map and ran the sightlines method agian on the Carmen Taylor and Michael Hezarkhani images. Camera location was again fairly close to Femr2's although it's hard to be precise since his grid only contains WTC 1 and 2 and the foreground buildings and needed some scaling and rotation to get a reasonable match. I did notice Femr2's WTC buildings are rotated about 2.5° clockwise compared to my map. The results were similar to the lo res check and again, nothing to suggest the 12° figure is too far off. Since Femr2 argued that the method is flawed when analysing 3d imagery (or at least 2d imagery of 3d space) I thought I'd test it out against a shot from much closer with a higher look up angle. Again the method results in pretty accuate matching of sightlines across the plane of the image so unless the method gives a similar degree of error regardless of the viewing angle I'm not seeing anything that would suggest an 8-9° error.
![]()
![]()
This is a valid sanity check.
Representing 3D space on a 2D surface has been known since the Renaissance.
A more accurate way of drawing the perspective lines is as shown on the sketch below. In school we learned how to draw 2 point perspectives in the following manner. Drawings are rough and not to scale.
The picture plane (PP2-blue) and station point can be any place.
A to A1 along the sight line. A1 to perspective, perpendicular to picture plane. And so on.
You can take femr's plan sight lines and NIST photo, put the picture plane, say where you had it on the first post, and take it from there.
2 point perspective FLWright and subsequent photo.
Last edited:
