Merged Discussion of femr's video data analysis

While drawing sight lines onto an image certainly doesn't tell the whole story it does give useful information.
Ignoring the third dimension in two separate places, then also ignoring perspective effects resulted in your images being just...wrong.

Useful perhaps to those folk, such as pgimeno, who love to jump on such (incorrect) assertions in order to cast doubt on mine, but beyond that...

I could never get the sightlines to quite work with your foreground buildings so I stitched together a map and checked their position and the camera position against yours. You may want to double check a few things.
Building position was determined on unstitched 8192px*8192px maps, both satellite and vector.

With the buildings in their correct location
Correct ? I think perhaps you should also "double check" your stitched-up map.

and the cameraman on land the sightlines worked out much better.
I'm afraid you can't just place things where you choose.

I've placed the camera as far back as possible but he could have been closer along that line.
:rolleyes: No, he could not. He was on the bleedin' ferry, docked.

I'm not sure why you're complaining about the lack of 3D
You are converging towards my results by gradual introduction of 3D elements.

The lack od 3D is why your results are still incorrect.

Obviously there's a bit of wiggle room with the orientation
Of course, though not a lot.

I'm just saying you might not want to be quite so adamant about your position on the aircraft orientation while you only have draft work on it
I'm adamant about the NIST orientation being significantly wrong, obviously. As you suggest, there's slight "wriggle room" on exact orientation, but not much.

and some fairly easily spotted errors.
Such as ?

Given you think:

a) Building locations are wrong

and

b) camera placement is wrong

isn't it amazing that everything matches up so well...

938786605.gif
 
Last edited:
It appears that the thread started over two years ago explicitly as an effort to discredit femr2's work. But it doesn't have to stay that way.
There are occasional flurries of productive discussion, but there are very few members actually posting within the thread, most of whom have quite lengthy posting "histories" with myself.

One can but hope :)

It has more potential for that than most of what happens in this subforum. I am still rooting for y'all.
Cheers.

Given that the same folk are raising the same "objections" 2 years on, I can't promise you...
 
Last edited:
Whilst I've not finalised the study (as I'm very satisfied with the results I have) there's no reason for you to assume the early draft linked to was not progressed...

[qimg]http://femr2.ucoz.com/_ph/6/938786605.gif[/qimg]
Why do you show that now, given that the complaints were against this other image?

image082.gif


Why didn't you point out before that the difference in the projected width of the south wall has been corrected later?

The core of our objection (Reactor Drone and myself) was that wall.

My doubts about camera placement stemmed in this, regardless of any confirmation by witnesses or parallax effect:

femr2 in the911forum.freeforums.org said:
Don't trust Google Earth 3D buildings.

The scale is incorrect.
The positioning is incorrect.
The physical proportions are incorrect.
That's why I didn't think the parallax analysis proved anything, if either the buildings or the camera or both were probably misplaced. Which the obvious difference in projected width suggested they were.

No point in continuing with my analysis, which was going to consist in determining a range of plausible camera locations depending on the relative width of the projection of the east wall with respect to the south wall.


I already told you.
No, you didn't say explicitly. Only a vague reference to "a number of real-world optical behaviours".


Why don't you answer? That paper hints that it could be done:

When determining the lens parameters, all programs rely on the same paradigm: the ideal perspective mapping should map real world straight lines to straight lines in the image. So if a set of points P0, P1, ..., Pn is known to lie on a straight line, their images p0, p1, ..., pn should also fall onto a straight line [...]​

But rectification of lines is not the method I've used, anyway.


No. Depends upon the lens. Not necessarily in the center.
My bad, "minimized" was a poor choice of a word. Let me rephrase the question as I meant it:

Can we at least agree that lens distortion is greatly reduced around the center of the image?
 
Why do you show that now, given that the complaints were against this other image?
Because:

a) the difference to results is minimal, as I told you
b) it's all stuff done a couple of years ago
c) I've discussed it numerous times in numerous different conversations
d) there are entire threads, not very difficult to find, that contain even more additional detail
e) ...

Why didn't you point out before that the difference in the projected width of the south wall has been corrected later?

The core of our objection (Reactor Drone and myself) was that wall.
Reactor drone quoted that image himself 9th July 2011.

You simply refused to accept my advice.

Given you're fully aware that these discussions have ensued over multiple years, why would you not have a quick root around before jumping in ?

My doubts about camera placement stemmed in this, regardless of any confirmation by witnesses or parallax effect
Well, as I said, it makes minimal difference to the scale of error identified with the NIST orientation.

That's why I didn't think the parallax analysis proved anything, if either the buildings or the camera or both were probably misplaced. Which the obvious difference in projected width suggested they were.
I've pointed out those issues as a warning to others. I don't use Google 3D building placement or scaling.

No point in continuing with my analysis, which was going to consist in determining a range of plausible camera locations depending on the relative width of the projection of the east wall with respect to the south wall.
Do you accept that the NIST parameters are "incorrect" ?

Do you accept that my parameters are "correct" ?

Why don't you answer?
I've provided you with a full paper about correcting lens distortion. What extra information do you need now ?!

That paper hints that it could be done
...and I have hinted at an obstacle...
femr2 said:
I do hope you're not going to make assumptions about the linearity of certain specific building features.

Anyway...

My bad, "minimized" was a poor choice of a word. Let me rephrase the question as I meant it:

Can we at least agree that lens distortion is greatly reduced around the center of the image?
In general.
 
It appears that the thread started over two years ago explicitly as an effort to discredit femr2's work. But it doesn't have to stay that way.

There are occasional flurries of productive discussion, but there are very few members actually posting within the thread, most of whom have quite lengthy posting "histories" with myself.

One can but hope :)
The only specific issue that tfk identified in the OP was 'sub-pixel resolution'. It seems that is no longer in contention - it was resolved to the satisfaction of several members in the early pages of the thread. I realise that my opinion (i.e. 'was resolved' - past tense - finito - done with -) could be too optimistic given the tendency for 'resolved' issues to keep resurfacing...:o

My own reason for entering the discussion is similar to Mark's sentiment that "...it doesn't have to stay that way". There could, IMO, be a lot of benefit in some members having a deeper grasp of the technicalities underlying femr's work. Naturally that applies to those members who have an interest in these aspects of 9/11 research and not those whose technical interests lie elsewhere. And not those whose agenda is personal denigration of femr or anyone who supports him.

If you read my recent posts on this topic you will see that I have been attempting to get active participants to focus on what should be IMO the central issue about femr's work - I have stated it several ways with words to the effect of "...are femr's data and analyses accurate enough to be useful". I have laid out a lot of explanatory reasoning to support that aim.

However responses from currently active participants in the thread have ranged across the negative spectrum from "Ignore" through to fairly transparent and untruthful personal attacks directed at me.

So, if we are to see positive outcomes from the thread, we need some participants who are interested in pursuing the issues rather than the dominating personal agendas.

It could well be that most of the members who are interested, like me, are already convinced of the value of femr's work and have no difficulty discarding strawman opposition arguments and relating the accuracy inherent in the work to the range of purposes which have emerged.

Meanwhile I see that yet another of my posts has been...."misunderstood" :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
The only specific issue that tfk identified in the OP was 'sub-pixel resolution'. It seems that is no longer in contention - it was resolved to the satisfaction of several members in the early pages of the thread. I realise that my opinion (i.e. 'was resolved' - past tense - finito - done with -) could be too optimistic given the tendency for 'resolved' issues to keep resurfacing...:o

My own reason for entering the discussion is similar to Mark's sentiment that "...it doesn't have to stay that way". There could, IMO, be a lot of benefit in some members having a deeper grasp of the technicalities underlying femr's work. Naturally that applies to those members who have an interest in these aspects of 9/11 research and not those whose technical interests lie elsewhere. And not those whose agenda is personal denigration of femr or anyone who supports him.

If you read my recent posts on this topic you will see that I have been attempting to get active participants to focus on what should be IMO the central issue about femr's work - I have stated it several ways with words to the effect of "...are femr's data and analyses accurate enough to be useful". I have laid out a lot of explanatory reasoning to support that aim.

However responses from currently active participants in the thread have ranged across the negative spectrum from "Ignore" through to fairly transparent and untruthful personal attacks directed at me.

So, if we are to see positive outcomes from the thread, we need some participants who are interested in pursuing the issues rather than the dominating personal agendas.

It could well be that most of the members who are interested, like me, are already convinced of the value of femr's work and have no difficulty discarding strawman opposition arguments and relating the accuracy inherent in the work to the range of purposes which have emerged.

Meanwhile I see that yet another of my posts has been...."misunderstood" :rolleyes:

Useful for what?

What is it's value?

What purposes?
 
Yet you won't say what that claim actually is.
Correct and for several reasons. I will briefly outline one of them. Their are several more but one is sufficient to justify my "won't say" position.

This current discussion involves pgimeno disagreeing with femr's claim (or 'not accepting' or 'not yet convinced' or several other ways he describes his position)

There are two legitimate ways to rebut femr's claim which are:
a) directly show that femr's claim is wrong; OR
b) present a better counter claim;
(OR "c) Both of the above")

Pgimeno has positioned himself in a false middle ground where he denies the explanations which femr has already posted clearly and on many occasions WHILST refusing to set out his own counter claim. So neither "a)" nor "b)" (or "c" which logically follows the preceding inclusive 'or'). That is a debate tactic we normally see from truthers. From that false middle ground position he has been:
1) Pretending that femr's claims and supporting explanations do not exist - cutely re-framed as a reverse burden of proof that it is femr's responsibility to regurgitate long and repeatedly published explanations.
2) "JAQing off" in a perpetually never ending demands that femr persuade pgimeno that femr is correct.
3) (several more truther style tricks but those two will do.)

(BTW femr has been patiently doing quite a bit of the regurgitating as well as pointing out the error of pgimeno's position/tactics.)

Remember that pgimeno has clearly stated that he will ignore reasoned arguments and focus only on nit picked details which he disagrees with. (If you need to see his admissions in that regard go back to his responses to my earlier posts - about a week back from memory.)

So what would happen if I attempted to restate femr's claims for those who haven't been following the thread AND are too lazy to look for themselves?

In the current climate of the thread it would only offer pgimeno another opportunity to nit pick my inaccuracies in explaining femr when femr's originals are here for all to see. A totally non productive process. And, BTW, that is yet another truther tactic - keep the discussion from progressing. :rolleyes:

That is a derail opportunity which I will not give him - so one reason why I did not explain femrs claim.

And, as I said, there are several other reasons. Any one of them sufficient to warrant me not intruding.

BTW I see that you have commented on a negative aspect of something I did not say. Why not help the thread move forward by addressing what I did say rather than what I didn't say? :)
 
Useful for what?

What is it's value?

What purposes?
clap.gif
clap.gif

Spot on! Exactly the questions that I have been laying before pgimeno. He (and W D Clinger BTW) have been ignoring those aspects whilst focussed on their strawman rebuttals of femr. The good news - light at the end of the tunnel - is that recent posts by pgimeno show that he is getting closer to facing those real issues. (Code word "quantification" when reading his posts.)

So read the thread please. We already have a thread overloaded by pgimeno asking for things already explained many times to be explained by femr yet again. So I don't want to add to the duplication by repeating my already posted comments - if we can avoid it.

Your inquiry is very close to the target - I have identified the generic class answers to your questions many times - and copped personal attacks from those who don't want the discussion to progress. I have deliberately not posted the details for obvious reasons - the burden of proof is not mine and I have been urging pgimeno to accept his responsibility in that regard. You cannot have it both ways - If you want me to do the leg work and let pgimeo off then say so and I will probably do it. I would probably have to frame my explanation as "This is what pgimeno should be saying not what ozeco should be saying" and even that has risks that I will be misunderstood or "misunderstood". :D.

Otherwise if pgimeo would follow the progressive discusion I keep advocating we would see all the specific examples of purposes, value and "who to" laid out and assessed. And it wouldn't matter who "laid them out" - BTW there are sufficient examples in the thread already.
 
Let me try the brief answers - remember that all three questions have already been explained in precise, almost legally pedantic language several times already in this thread. In my posts which pgimeno et al are ignoring:
Useful for what?
For use by those who want to use it in support of their arguments. That was one reason that members asked femr for the WTC7 data. They asked. He supplied. Their decision what they want to use it for....I'm starting to go over the ground explained in previous posts.. :o

What is it's value?
Depends on which user wants to use it. If YOU don't want it it is of zero value to you. But that does not mean that I cannot use it. I don't have any use for the Millette ThermXte Dust research but that does not give me the right to tell Oystein, Ivan or Sunstealer they are wrong. BTW why is no-one from the debunker side attacking Mohr et all for that bit of precise measurement whilst femr faces these mostly personal attacks against his bits of precise measurement. Do we see double standards at play???
What purposes?
One obvious one here related to WTC7 is that those members who requested femr's data clearly wanted to use it in the Chandler v NIST setting of "free fall" allegations and the related sub topic of 'over "G"'. Again that is their purpose and their choice. I found it interesting - and I took a leading role in helping ChrisMohr explain 'over "G"' for his Gage rebuttals website. If you want it it would be for your purposes - I don't know if you have any need - it is none of my business what you want to use it for - if you do. If you don't then you don't. simple as that.
 
Last edited:
Useful for what?...
For The Logic Pedants

I just made a minor misjudgement - or slightly missed the target.
:o:blush::o:blush::mad:

See my previous couple of posts.

The context for "useful" within the setting of this current discussion is actually defined by those opposing femr - so principally pgimeno at this stage.

Why is that?

Because their claim is essentially that "femrs data is not accurate enough to be useful". That claim implicitly requires that there be "useful" "purposes" OTHERWISE their counter claim is meaningless.

So their counter claim requires that data be useful - that there exists a use or uses for the data.

..and I don't have to bear burden of proof to show that it is useful....


...and a legitimate and even briefer response to tsig would have been "Don't ask me - ask pgimeno..." ;)

(I suspect that this could be way too subtle for the audience....but...couldn't resist the temptation....having fun...with logic...)

:runaway
 
Last edited:
Do you accept that the NIST parameters are "incorrect" ?

Do you accept that my parameters are "correct" ?
No, I won't put a threshold on the error to consider something correct or not.

Yours are probably more accurate. Even if you got them with a 0.00001° error, the nature of the event makes the effects over the inner columns chaotic and unpredictable.


I've provided you with a full paper about correcting lens distortion. What extra information do you need now ?!
My question was: "out of curiosity, what would be wrong with that [= a manual by hand lens correction]?"


...and I have hinted at an obstacle...
Again, not doing that.

My idea makes use of "CBS-Net NIST Dub #7/CBS-Net Dub7 19.avi".

In that video, the cameraman has the camera in place (not sure if it's the final place, if not it seems pretty close, but that doesn't matter), and he zooms on WTC7, from about 40° to about 15° angle of view, in two steps.

That gives an unique opportunity to calibrate lens distortion, because:

- He zooms over the center of the image. The focal point position doesn't change, or the change is negligible. That means that the perspective does not change, only the FOV, even if he reorients the camera slightly (too little to matter).
- Therefore the change should be equivalent to magnifying a rectangle in the image. Since lens distortion is (presumed to be) very small near the center, any mismatch between the magnified version and the post-zoom image is due to lens distortion.
- The final FOV is similar to the FOV in the collapse view, therefore the lens distortion is similar too.

Therefore, by applying lens correction to the zoomed image until it matches the magnified image, you are also deriving the lens correction necessary for the collapse video. I have done that.
 
Because their claim is essentially that "femrs data is not accurate enough to be useful". That claim implicitly requires that there be "useful" "purposes" OTHERWISE their counter claim is meaningless.
Straw man. My main claim has been, "without information of how accurate the data is, we don't know if femr2's claim of over-g is true". I have not said it is too inaccurate to be useful.

If someone gives a proof of the existence of God, and claims that God exists because his proof is correct, and I see a flaw in the proof, the existence of God doesn't need to be useful for me to claim that the proof is invalid and therefore the existence of God remains unproven.

And since I've had problems with the theorem metaphor already, the above is just an example to illustrate my point of view on where the burden of proof is.
 
@pgimeno
I am pressed for time but will get back to responding to your post alleging a "straw man" later this evening.

Thanks for being so definitive - it gives me a clear object for my comments.

Meanwhile my whimsical sense of humour cannot let this bit pass:
No, I won't put a threshold on the error to consider something correct or not...
So you decline to apply a binary status to an analogue value? Says the person who took the reverse position when calling ozeco wrong. Mmm....
scratch.gif


...Yours are probably more accurate. Even if you got them with a 0.00001° error,...
"Probably more accurate"? So "more accurate" - an analogue assessment - says the person who insisted(insists) that ozeco's identification of analogue measurement realities is "Not a misunderstanding"?.....Mmmm (again)
scratch.gif


Would you please muse on why such inconsistencies in a nit picking environment make some of us (me specifically) abandon our attempts to assist you in discussion?
 
My main claim has been, "without information of how accurate the data is, we don't know if femr2's claim of over-g is true". I have not said it is too inaccurate to be useful....
Preparatory work.

could you explain how "without information of how accurate the data is, we don't know if femr2's claim of over-g is true" is not a subset of
"[don't know if it is] too inaccurate to be useful...."

I can see two possible reasons for your confusion. Your answer to my question will help me identify which one I need to respond to.

(Or if there is a third, fourth....;))
 
No, I won't put a threshold on the error to consider something correct or not.
And there you are in glorious black and white.

It occurs to me that that is your chosen exit point from these "discussions".

I am not "into" unending discourse.

Yours are probably more accurate.
:rolleyes: I "guess" you are not going to choose to justify why you consider mine only "probably" more accurate ?

You could have said "definitely" more accurate, whilst still complaining about error threshhold, yet you have chosen not to.

The information such choices provide is most illuminating.

It doesn't gain respect, nor credibility.

I'll leave posting the camera position change necessary to force the erronious NIST orientation to line up for another time. It's good for a hearty giggle...though perhaps Reactor Drone would care to give that a whirl ;)

Even if you got them with a 0.00001° error, the nature of the event makes the effects over the inner columns chaotic and unpredictable.
LOL. And with the other hand you cast out any reasonable discussion of the implications of the obvious NIST error you don't want to concede.

Priceless :D

The fact is, that your assertion of "chaotic and unpredictable" has two primary implications. One you'll "like", the other you won't.

1) If even 0.00001 degree of error renders the subsequent simulation "chaotic and unpredictable", then the NIST simulations are completely worthless chaotic and random number generators, especially if you consider that the scale of error of one impact parameter (of several that are wrong) is around nine hundred thousand times larger than your offered "threshold".

2) The resultant behaviour is not as "chaotic and unpredictable" as you'd like to infer, and the NIST error of one impact parameter (of several that are wrong) nine hundred thousand times your offered "threshhold" for change in behaviour has significant and tangeable effect upon subsequent simulation behaviour.

Oh, wait. I don't think you'll like either :D

You don't know the consequencies. Neither do I.

However, in terms of having a "key" effect upon the simulations...I think you may have reached a point where you understand why I mentioned this NIST error in the other thread, before you climbed aboard the attempt to "prove femr2 wrong version the umpteenth" train again.

My question was: "out of curiosity, what would be wrong with that [= a manual by hand lens correction]?"
Ah, switchback to a separate "argument". Canter :)

And did you learn nothing from the document supplied and my numerous other responses ?

Short answer...inaccurate. Lens parameters are given to 6dp for a reason. If you can't achieve accurate correction you might as well not bother.

I'm sure you're aware that lens distortion varies between barrel, complex and pincushion types as zoom level is changed ?

How were you planning on separating change in perspective distortion during zooming at the same time ?

How are you planning on performing lens correction upon the Dan Rather footage, as you're planning on using both... ?
 
Could you explain how "without information of how accurate the data is, we don't know if femr2's claim of over-g is true" is not a subset of
"[don't know if it is] too inaccurate to be useful...."

I can see two possible reasons for your confusion. Your answer to my question will help me identify which one I need to respond to.

(Or if there is a third, fourth....;))

The facts are...

a) Raw numerical displacement data has been available for years
b) Variance estimation has been available for years...though of course folk are quite able to reject my value there and determine their own from the data
c) Scaling metric methods and error estimation have been available for years
d) pgimeno has generated his own velocity and acceleration derivative plots
e) pgimeno's acceleration plot includes an over-g period
f) pgimeno requires nothing from me to perform error analysis of his own acceleration plot
g) EVEN IF I were to provide the most detailed error analysis known to mankind...it would not stop the endless meandering nonsense from others who would of course disagree with it in some way.

To repeat...

pgimeno requires nothing from me to perform error analysis of his own acceleration plot
 
The facts are...

a) Raw numerical displacement data has been available for years
b) Variance estimation has been available for years...though of course folk are quite able to reject my value there and determine their own from the data
c) Scaling metric methods and error estimation have been available for years
d) pgimeno has generated his own velocity and acceleration derivative plots
e) pgimeno's acceleration plot includes an over-g period
f) pgimeno requires nothing from me to perform error analysis of his own acceleration plot
g) EVEN IF I were to provide the most detailed error analysis known to mankind...it would not stop the endless meandering nonsense from others who would of course disagree with it in some way.

To repeat...

pgimeno requires nothing from me to perform error analysis of his own acceleration plot
Sure.

Look to how my approach complements yours. (And has for many months.)

You continue to show "their" errors at detail level - where "the bits they suggest" are wrong.

I deliberately focus on the "bigger picture" where the errors are purely logical or evasion of accepted protocols of debate procedure. That happens to be one of my areas of expertise derived from a long career managing engineers and other professionals and dealing with their failings in reasoning. Such goes with the managers and trainer's job.

So you knock down the bits and comment on the logical/procedural issues. I knock down the logical or procedural issues in the bigger picture using examples from the "bits".

Fully complementary. (That's fully complementary for those who may have difficulties with "complimentary" v "complementary")

I'm glad to see the comment that you are 'not "into" unending discourse' - though I both appreciate your patience in face of the persistent nonsense and appreciate why you could find it necessary to rebut the repeated nonsense.

I still have some residual of patience to explain the logical framework - but much more of this denial and resistance and I should pull the plug.
 
And your result...?

I strongly suggest that you think carefully about your response.
If you suggest 'think carefully about your response' for that bit of posting what comment do I make on this astonishing confession?
...The misunderstanding of analogue measurement as a "theorem" is only one of those faulty foundations.
There's no such misunderstanding.
It was in response to one of my as usual detailed and legally pedantic/precise posts. pgimeno had made multiple untrue claims in response to my post. At least six untruths in the brief paragraph I referred to and I posted proof of the untruth for three leaving three or four not rebutted.

And I offered "misunderstanding" as the diplomatic way out.

Nope. He says " There's no such misunderstanding." which leads inevitably to one conclusion. The multiple untruths were deliberately posted. There is one three letter word to describe the deliberate publishing of a single untruth and one four letter word to describe the person who deliberately tells untruths. I prefer not to use those words...

..but, back to the point. The advice "that you think carefully about your response" was surely needed in that instance.

Still I remember the proverb about navigating equus into proximity with fluid refreshment but inability to cause imbibing of same......
 
So you decline to apply a binary status to an analogue value? Says the person who took the reverse position when calling ozeco wrong. Mmm....[qimg]http://conleys.com.au/smilies/scratch.gif[/qimg]
What position was that, exactly? Can you quote?

Binary status when applied to "correct" or "incorrect" needs a very clear and unmistakable threshold. If the plane hit the wrong building, for example, that would obviously be "incorrect". We're talking precision here, not correctness.

Let me put it in radians. femr2 is saying that the error in NIST's estimation is about 0.166 radians, and he gives an estimation with an error of... wait, how much? Oh, yes, he doesn't give it, but claims (without proof) that it's less than 0.018. To me, that counts as precision.


Preparatory work.

could you explain how "without information of how accurate the data is, we don't know if femr2's claim of over-g is true" is not a subset of
"[don't know if it is] too inaccurate to be useful...."
Moving goalposts? Seems you got that part finally right, this time. But it's not what you've been saying before. Regardless, my argument doesn't have anything to do with either the graph or the claim being useful or not, therefore no, it is not a subset of your amended version either.

I'll explain my argument very clearly.

1. Femr2 claims the NW corner went over g.
2. As a proof of that claim, he shows a graph where the NW corner went over g.
3. For the graph to constitute a proof, the error in it must be less than ~6.7 ft/s² (the difference between g and the peak his graph shows). If the error is bigger than that, the claim can't be sustained.
4. He doesn't show the error in his graph. ETA: Indeed he shows a different graph differing in over 10 ft/s² at some points from that one.
5. Without an error estimation, the proof in (2) is invalid.
6. Therefore we don't know if the claim in (1) holds, because femr2 has given no valid proof. It can be true or false; we just don't know.

The argument has nothing to do with the usefulness of over-g. It has nothing to do with the usefulness of the graph either, other than "useful as a proof that over-g happened". Without an error estimation, per my argument above, it is clearly insufficient (and therefore useless) for the purpose of serving as a proof of over-g. It just puts the claim of over-g back from a truth status to an uncertainty status. Useful or not, is not the matter. Usefulness has nothing to do with it.

Just in case the usefulness you refer to applies to the claim of over g, well, if we don't know whether it's true or false, how useful can it ever be for any purpose? What is a false statement useful for, other than as an example for a lesson in logic maybe? The possibility that it's false destroys any usefulness in it.

Still, that's beating a dead horse. It's quite close to a proof now by a different method that eliminates the graph production algorithm as a source of potential error.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom