Merged Discussion of femr's video data analysis

I have the picture on a 24" LCD Monitor @ 1920x1200 AND Old age (ozeco41) requires 2 dioptre $AU19.00 glasses - Does that qualify for naked eye? ;)
Sure. Using a magnifying glass with 20:20 vision on a 7" tablet would also be quite acceptable...as would viewing via projector with about 4m diagonal on t'wall. Only way to watch t'telly you know :)

And that early motion seems to say something which could be important in the polarised "truthers v debunkers" debates.
I should highlight that "early motion" starts a lot "earlier" than both the GIF's provided.

I chose the two frames from me simply to highlight obvious motion before NIST T0. As indicated, earlier motion is rather more subtle but still obvious to the naked eye when scrubbed back and forth smoothly.

Tracing does of course reveal detail which is very difficult to spot with the naked eye...which is one reason it's useful.

Meanwhile I've just mowed the lawn - record heavy rains over recent weeks but blue sky very evident today. Occasionally partly obscured by clouds. :rolleyes:
Not many neddies imbibing dihydrogen monoxide by the billabong.

I would direct carlitos towards NCStar 1-9 vol2 Appendix C, but what would be the point in that ?!
 
Last edited:
Sure. Using a magnifying glass with 20:20 vision would also be quite acceptable :)
Great - I will remeber that over the coming years.

At this stage I can still pass the eyesight tests to drive public passenger vehicles.
bus250low.jpg


...I should highlight that "early motion" starts a lot "earlier" than both the GIF's provided...
Which counts against certain claims???

...Bot many neddies imbibing dihydrogen monoxide by the billabong.
Multiple reasons why "clouds" are mentioned.
 
Yes. Apologies if you became confused.
He's not the only one you've confused in this forum due to your poor wordings and subject changes, and usage of unrelated examples.


No. I use the common definition of "how." I meant "how." Did it lean, rotate, jump off the ground, stretch, what?
When ? (be specific please. some motion I cannot define in such terms, and not particularly interested.[...]
Are you complaining about lack of precision in his post?

:i:
 
He's not the only one you've confused in this forum
Oh what a surprise. Perhaps you should consider that you may be easily confused.

Are you complaining about lack of precision in his post?
No, I'm asking "when" in order to be able to give a more precise answer.

I note you chopped my general answer...
If you want a basic understanding of the early motion it's twisting around the central core oscillating North and East to South and West (basically).
...from your requote.

Is that really the best you can do ? Make unsubstantiated petty insinuations ? Oh... :rolleyes:
 
I have viewed the hi-res video more than once, and I still don't see the "early motion" or the building flexing and twisting. I see where femr2 zoomed in on a tiny spot and he claims to measure movement from that. I guess I'm an idiot.

As before, my comments were on what femr2 calls "early motion" and he replied with a mashup of the building collapsing and two non-adjacent video frames that appear to show the building moving.

No time for this today. I trust the thread will still be here when I have time. :)
 
I have viewed the hi-res video more than once, and I still don't see the "early motion" or the building flexing and twisting. I see where femr2 zoomed in on a tiny spot and he claims to measure movement from that.
FYI, my naked eyes did not "easily see the twisting flexure of the building" femr2 described as "blatantly obvious."

I guess I'm an idiot.

As before, my comments were on what femr2 calls "early motion" and he replied with a mashup of the building collapsing and two non-adjacent video frames that appear to show the building moving.
If you're an idiot, it's only because you expected femr2 to use words with their ordinary meanings. That's not how femr2 rolls. femr2 uses words to mean whatever he wants them to mean, depending on the audience.
 
Last edited:
I have viewed the hi-res video more than once, and I still don't see the "early motion" or the building flexing and twisting. I see where femr2 zoomed in on a tiny spot and he claims to measure movement from that. I guess I'm an idiot.

As before, my comments were on what femr2 calls "early motion" and he replied with a mashup of the building collapsing and two non-adjacent video frames that appear to show the building moving.

No time for this today. I trust the thread will still be here when I have time. :)
I don't think there's any doubt the building was moving and twisting. What you see as the building moving up is likely the building tilting toward the camera.

The building is moving around. this is kind of one of those no **** moments. This is all about exactly when and how it relates to the NIST timeline. No all that interesting in my opinion.
 
Last edited:
I have viewed the hi-res video more than once
Well done ! :rolleyes:

and I still don't see the "early motion" or the building flexing and twisting.
With one "oscillation" taking 100s you're not going to see much watching realtime, are you :rolleyes:

Which is why I keep suggesting you scrub through the video.

I see where femr2 zoomed in on a tiny spot
Half the building is a tiny spot ?

and he claims to measure movement from that.
Of course. Plain as day.

two non-adjacent video frames that appear to show the building moving.
Of course I used non-adjacent frames. To do otherwise would be dumb as a box of frogs...and the building is clearly moving.
 
Last edited:
With one "oscillation" taking 100s you're not going to see much watching realtime, are you :rolleyes:

The problem is, without making the time line for this obvious it can be more deceiving than useful. I had a "truther" show me that same clip and ask me how a building could move that way without explosives*. Yes, I know, you can't predict how morons will use your useful information.

For this example. Show the whole clip first with reference lines to show the extent of movement (in real time) and then the "scrub". Much less confusing. ;)

ETA: I showed him the clip it came from and he said I altered it. :)
 
Last edited:
I don't think there's any doubt the building was moving and twisting.
There are a few folk here who are putting on a good show of thinking otherwise, though quite why they'd want to deny early motion is somewhat bizarre.

What you see as the building moving up is likely the building tilting toward the camera.
There's not much pisitive vertical axis motion in the traces. I suggest that, rather than tilting, the "upward" motion is caused by the flexure of the building (or twisting with a torsional mode if you like) combined with perspective implications from the cam#3 iewpoint. Motion of the NW corner in a SW will appear on traces as increment in vertical axis position.

The building is moving around. this is kind of one of those no **** moments.
Seems to be rather a lot of resistance from some folk here. It's like they've never read any of the 13 pages comprising NCStar 1-9 vol2 Appendix C. Shock. Horrors.

This is all about exactly when and how it relates to the NIST timeline.
No it's not. That might be how you view it, but not I.

No all that interesting in my opinion.
Really should be of interest to those wanting to "educate" folk who think an "event->immediate descent" scenario ocurred.
 
The problem is, without making the time line for this obvious it can be more deceiving than useful.
I've provided graphs showing motion -vs- time, whith time being from the start of the clip to the end of the clip.

I had a "truther" show me that same clip and ask me how a building could move that way without explosives*. Yes, I know, you can't predict how morons will use your useful information.
Oh dear :(

For this example. Show the whole clip first with reference lines to show the extent of movement (in real time) and then the "scrub". Much less confusing. ;)
Would make for quite a large animated GIF that :) A few gig like. Not sure mod team would be too happy about that.

ETA: I showed him the clip it came from and he said I altered it. :)
:rolleyes:
 
Really should be of interest to those wanting to "educate" folk who think an "event->immediate descent" scenario ocurred.
Experience in these threads says otherwise.

Whilst:
....I had a "truther" show me that same clip and ask me how a building could move that way without explosives*....
...even truthers can be "so near and yet so far". :(
 
Well done ! :rolleyes:


With one "oscillation" taking 100s you're not going to see much watching realtime, are you :rolleyes:

Which is why I keep suggesting you scrub through the video.


Half the building is a tiny spot ?


Of course. Plain as day.


Of course I used non-adjacent frames. To do otherwise would be dumb as a box of frogs...and the building is clearly moving.

I was going to get back to this, screencap the 'tiny spot,' show where you think "naked eye" means magnified/processed video with time altered and frames spliced out of continuity, etc. etc. etc. But never mind. Yes, the building was moving long before it fell. It was moving at noon and it was moving at 5pm. Yes, that movement *changed* just before it fell. Good luck in your continued pursuit of ___________.
 
There are a few folk here who are putting on a good show of thinking otherwise, though quite why they'd want to deny early motion is somewhat bizarre.

I'm not sure if people are denying it or just your representation of it. It's got me confused.


There's not much pisitive vertical axis motion in the traces. I suggest that, rather than tilting, the "upward" motion is caused by the flexure of the building (or twisting with a torsional mode if you like) combined with perspective implications from the cam#3 iewpoint. Motion of the NW corner in a SW will appear on traces as increment in vertical axis position
.

I thought I explained it better. ;)

Seems to be rather a lot of resistance from some folk here. It's like they've never read any of the 13 pages comprising NCStar 1-9 vol2 Appendix C. Shock. Horrors.


No it's not. That might be how you view it, but not I.

Reading these two answers together seems to support what I'm saying. Even if that's not how you see it. It's how you seem to be presenting it. More clearity on your part could help prevent this confusion. ;)




Really should be of interest to those wanting to "educate" folk who think an "event->immediate descent" scenario occurred

Would that be as described by who? :p
 
...Yes, that movement *changed* just before it fell...
That is the core finding which is of potential significance in identifying what caused collapse of WTC7.

The distinction between looking at processed video data using "naked eyes" rather than technical tools of measurement is secondary in the real discussion.

However one theme which has been left behind in this thread is the set of claims that somehow femr's methods are subject to errors (wow - a big revelation) AND the so far unsupported claim that the errors are big enough to matter. (Because if they are not "big enough to matter" they are irrelevant to most of the reasons for this discussion thread.)

Hence inspecting processed video data by eye (naked or assisted by glasses in my case - see my earlier query) totally removes the reliance on technology based measurement of the motion which is visually observable.

Thereby declaring allegations of significant measuring error moot.

And leaving the scene open for the valid finding that there was significant movement well before the main release and rapid collapse. Which, in turn, is significant for those arguing for or against 'an "event->immediate descent" scenario'. :rolleyes:
 
And leaving the scene open for the valid finding that there was significant movement well before the main release and rapid collapse. Which, in turn, is significant for those arguing for or against 'an "event->immediate descent" scenario'. :rolleyes:

I think the whole idea of "main release" is the origin of much of this confusion.

If this point was described as x amount of seconds after the start of the collapse it would translate better. This "release" point is really of no importance.
 
I think the whole idea of "main release" is the origin of much of this confusion....
It is one of the issues.

However IMO the real confusion comes from a couple of main sources. The technical confusion because there are many unclearly stated issues and no coherent approach to how the relate to each other or even if they do.

The biggest one which is directly on topic for this thread is the claims that somehow femr's measurements contain errors and somehow are "not good enough".

There is a lot of posturing over that including personal animosity.

The core technical facts are two - one with two main subsets. The two are:
A) The first one which by itself is meaningless. Allegations that femr's measurements are subject to errors, the errors in two main areas of "noise" and "processing artefacts". Well Whoopee. That is a truism and of zero value if intended as a stand alone claim. Yet we see "strawman" arguments attempting to rest on that true claim; hence my several challenges in previous posts.

B) The second is the question of whether or not the errors are big enough to matter. This is the factor which counts. Waffling on about alleged errors as if the presence of errors was in dispute whilst failing to address the real issue of "are the errors big enough to matter".

Now if we were to clarify what is under discussion at that basic level most of the other "confusions" would be left without support - whether the confusions are genuine or pretended for purposes of debating tactics.

And the next step is equally simple.

Are the errors "big enough to matter" depends on:
1) Who wants to use the data; AND
2) For what purpose.

Now if I focus on the specific issue you raise - that of the significance of "release point".

As I see it you are fully correct from one perspective - if your focus is on your needs if you don't need it it is of no value to you. BUT that does not mean that everybody else shares your focus. I don't for one.

So the "other perspective" belongs to people other than you. For some of them it is vital to understand if there was a gradual build up towards collapse for minutes before the rapid falling down OR there was no gradual build up and there was, in femr's words, 'an "event->immediate descent" scenario'. That distinction is rather central to most discussion of WTC collapses on 9/11.

I agree with you that the precise location of the release point is not the critical issue. Rather, IMO, it is that there was clearly a period of some minutes of gradual and increasing deterioration of the structure but no total collapse. Indicative that some parts of the structure were failing but there was still support for the gross structure. Then there was a change - around the concept of a release point but not necessarily timed to or agreed to the microsecond. And then followed collapse characterised by rapid descent and strong evidence of removal of most support.

So the two stages is the interesting aspect. Precise location of "release" not so important for my perspective. And of no current interest to you for whatever your reasons are.

...If this point was described as x amount of seconds after the start of the collapse it would translate better. This "release" point is really of no importance.
If it is of no importance to you then specifying it in a different way should make no difference. For myself I am more interested in the obvious difference of "two stages" - and definition of the change point to the fraction of a second is of no concern to me.

And others may have different needs but so far we have not seen them defined by anyone IIRC. Which brings me full circle to:
Are the errors "big enough to matter" depends on:
1) Who wants to use the data; AND
2) For what purpose.
 
Last edited:
There are a few folk here who are putting on a good show of thinking otherwise, though quite why they'd want to deny early motion is somewhat bizarre.
For the record, and to avoid confusion, in my particular case I have not been denying anything, much less wanting to deny anything. I've been merely expressing my doubts about your conclusions from the data, without reaching the point yet of evaluating whether these conclusions are right, "right for the wrong reasons", or wrong. I saw room for them falling within either of the last two categories. Which is not nearly similar to denying them or wanting to deny them.

Yet some people here (I'll leave the collective indefinite as one in particular uses to do) misrepresent my position often.
 
I agree with you that the precise location of the release point is not the critical issue. Rather, IMO, it is that there was clearly a period of some minutes of gradual and increasing deterioration of the structure but no total collapse. Indicative that some parts of the structure were failing but there was still support for the gross structure.
(Emphasis added.)

How have you discarded that if there was movement it might be due to (recoverable) heat dilation/contraction? E.g. a girder pushing on the structure while dilating without anything failing, or pulling when becoming colder after the fire has left the area.

(And should I add the disclaimer that I am not denying deterioration of the structure, much less wanting to deny it?)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom