femr2's claim of over g is not supported by the his analysis of his data
How about
your acceleration plots ? Or W.D.Clinger's ? Or tfk's ?
...or NISTS ? (Remember, their linear regression is over-g, and their function for velocity, if derived to acceleration, also includes a long period over-g)
Perhaps you'd care to explain how the same general trend profile emerges from multiple SG plots by multiple persons, multiple poly fits, multiple symmetric difference plots, ... ?
Error and noise all biased in one direction to artificially increase acceleration with multiple methods ?
Your focus on "what femr2 has claimed" seems to shift with the breeze.
Since when has over-g been the bee in your bonnet ?
Frankly I don't care whether you trust the data. I don't really care about absolute magnitude either. If you're more comfortable with the indicated over-g period being nearer to or even under g...go for it. Makes little difference to me. Quite funny to then look back through extensive discussion about the actual causes of over-g behaviour though (and how it is to be expected)
The "claims" I have made about acceleration behaviour are quite conservative and based upon trend and general magnitude.
You think their is an error, go prove it.
You have your own plots, your own methods (and similar results).
Quantify the propogated error in your own methods.
(There have already been discussions on the topic within this thread, but I'll be damned if I'm going to waste my time finding them for you)
Given the extra information available by inspection of the trend views, there's a really simple way to "test the hypothesis", since you know "when" to look
