Debunking the Stundies - March Edition

Engineers use speed all the time--when they're doing energy calculations. In KE = ½*m*v2, you can ignore the directional component of the velocity v, treating it as a scalar speed.
No it's not, because saying that energy has a "vectoral quality" is meaningless gibberish.
When a pole bent back in tension (storing PE) is released, in which direction does the PE convert to KE?

If I may elaborate on your model, assuming you are meaning the pole is a simple cantilever then it will bend around an internal neutral axis. On one side of the neutral axis there is tension and on the other is compression. Both involve storage of elastic strain energy at a microstructural level in the pole.

The PE will convert to KE in the direction that returns the pole to equilibrium.
 
Last edited:
You're still confused about the terms. In the example I posted, the direction is irrelevant to the speed. The speed is 50mph. The velocity is a vector quantity consisting of the 50mph and the direction. In rough terms, you could say the velocity is 50mph to the north.
If I suddenly started going 50mph to the south, my speed would be the same, but my velocity would be different.
It's not about having "vector qualities" or anything, there are words for things like "speed plus direction." In that case, it's "velocity."
You misunderstand energy. Energy moving towards equillibrium does not give it a direction that can be quantified as a vector. Another poster mentioned the bar's orientation changing, and asked if this would affect the direction of energy transfer.
Vectors need a precise, mathematically defined direction. You can't simply say "it moves in a direction, therefore it is a vector!" No, that doesn't make energy a vector, or give it a "vectoral quality" (which is a meaningless term, by the way).
By the way, stating something has a "vectoral component" or whatever is equivalent to saying it's a vector, just in a more weasel-esque way.
I didn't say anything about PE and KE transfer, I said you are mixing force and energy. Those aren't terms that describe force, they describe energy. Force is work done on an object, energy is the amount of work something can do. A term like PE or KE addresses the total work present in an aspect of a system. That energy can be released in different forms.
I implied no such thing.
What the hell are you talking about? You at least claimed to be an engineer of some kind, if not a civil engineer (it really isn't that important):
Here, you explicitly claim to be an engineer.
Your joke implicitly states that you are some kind of engineer.
You still show a misunderstanding of simple physics concepts, or a complete inability to state your understanding in a way that anyone but you can comprehend. Your apparent lack of comprehension does not jive with your stated profession.
Unless, of course, "engineer" means something like "railroad engineer" or "hamburger flipping engineer" or something.

I'm sorry that you felt the need to deviate from a civilised discussion and enter into personalising this and attacking me as I felt we could get somewhere between us without resorting to that. Now that you have there seems little point in any further exchanges of posts.
 
@ forum.

With respect, if I have to explain it it will lose impact but because it seems to be such a big deal with the forum I'll explain so we can move on. I was joking that when I get mad I might lose civility and hence be an uncivil engineer. I did not expect that making a joke would become a major thread topic.

It is on record on the forum as I have stated it before, I am a Mechanical Engineer but in the US sense I majored in Structures. I have worked in Industry for 20 years or so and have obtained specialist knowledge of certain areas of Metallurgy related to my work. As also stated before I didn't pursue any Post-Graduate Studies but have built my reputation as an Engineer on hard work and results which is reflected in my salary and the constant calls I get from Head Hunters to move to competitors.

I can say no more or less than what I have written above and politely suggest that if you do not accept the sincerity of it then you are wasting your time and mine exchanging posts. It seems to me that there is little point in making posts to me if you do not have any trust that I am what I say I am.
Thanks for clearing that up. I get the joke now--I didn't catch the play on words. It probably would have worked if delivered orally.

I will take you at your word that you are a ME.

On the more pertinent topic, is it possible that when you are writing "energy" you are envisaging momentum?
 
To be fair to killtown (woah! I need to take a shower, now), I think he was saying "Huh ? A link to a "normal" video ? Why, that's not possible." Of course. That's still a stupid thing to post, but it's not the same level of stupid, assuming I'm correct.

This is a reasonably fair post Belz. Thanks for the contribution.
 
Consider the following situation.

A spherical shell of material is placed somewhere in interstellar space, sufficiently far from any other masses that the effect of gravity other than its own may be considered negligible. The object has mass, and all parts of it are therefore attracted towards its centre of mass. If the material is shattered into small particles, all will fall into the centre, converting their gravitational potential energy into kinetic energy as they fall. The entire system has spherical symmetry.


What is the direction of the gravitational potential energy?

Dave

Interesting, can I just clarify that the sphere is a closed system and has spontaneously shattered with no energy or work entering the system boundaries? Can the sphere also be considered to be neutral in terms of internal stresses and any pressure differences between the inside volume and outside?
 
If I may elaborate on your model, assuming you are meaning the pole is a simple cantilever then it will bend around an internal neutral axis. On one side of the neutral axis there is tension and on the other is compression. Both involve storage of elastic strain energy at a microstructural level in the pole.

The PE will convert to KE in the direction that returns the pole to equilibrium.
Let's complete the scenario, then. Picture this:

The bent pole, as you said, stores PE in the form of elastic energy through both compression and tension (which are themselves scalar, BTW). [edit: strike-through--I was thinking of pressure, but we're talking stress]

The tension is directed "inward" toward the center of the pole along the convex side of the arc, while the compression is directed "outward" toward the ends of the pole along the concave side of the arc.

When the pole is released, the tension "pulls in" and the compression "pushes out" as PE converts to KE.

But the potential for this system to do work is in the force at the free end of the pole, perpendicular to the pole.

In what sense, practical, theoretical, or otherwise, does it make sense to assign a "vectoral quality" to this energy?
 
Last edited:
I'm sorry that you felt the need to deviate from a civilised discussion and enter into personalising this and attacking me as I felt we could get somewhere between us without resorting to that. Now that you have there seems little point in any further exchanges of posts.

Contrary to your opinion, I wasn't actually attacking you. I was pointing out that your understanding of physics does not appear to coincide with your profession, and I would appreciate some kind of reconcilliation of those conflicting pieces of information.

As you have lied about other matters in this thread (or, at the least, been intellectually dishonest... if I am being charitable), I don't place a very high value on your unsupported word at this point.

I also did not say that you were, in fact, a hamburger flipping engineer, I was merely pointing out that there are other uses of the word "engineer" (the "railroad engineer" example was a genuine one, the other was a joke) that a dishonest person could play on to legitimately claim to be "an engineer," without being the sort of engineer that is at all relevant to the matter at hand.
 
Who has a opinion the steel beams could not be ejected?????????????????? I wonder where the 248 tons of TNT energy released by each tower went?


Edited to remove insults and gave an infraction as per the new CT specific forum rules. I am leaving the remainder of the post content that is both germane to the discussion and adds value.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: jmercer
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hey, William Rea, how do you explain my nomination? Doesn't that kinda show the impartiality of Teh Stundies? I've done my share of debunking the Conspiracy Fantasies, but I get my lumps for a stupid post, just like the troofers.

Care to comment?

ETA: And I even got four votes.
 
Last edited:
Hey, William Rea, how do you explain my nomination? Doesn't that kinda show the impartiality of Teh Stundies? I've done my share of debunking the Conspiracy Fantasies, but I get my lumps for a stupid post, just like the troofers.

Care to comment?

ETA: And I even got four votes.

If I get the chance I will examine your nomination to assess if it needs debunking. I won't comment upon the equality of nominations at this stage.
 
Let's complete the scenario, then. Picture this:
The bent pole, as you said, stores PE in the form of elastic energy through both compression and tension (which are themselves scalar, BTW). [edit: strike-through--I was thinking of pressure, but we're talking stress]
The tension is directed "inward" toward the center of the pole along the convex side of the arc, while the compression is directed "outward" toward the ends of the pole along the concave side of the arc.

When the pole is released, the tension "pulls in" and the compression "pushes out" as PE converts to KE.

But the potential for this system to do work is in the force at the free end of the pole, perpendicular to the pole.

In what sense, practical, theoretical, or otherwise, does it make sense to assign a "vectoral quality" to this energy?

It is not stress energy, it is internal strain energy.

The PE is stored in the internal strain of the microstructure of the pole very much as it is in a spring. The work done has created a new equilibrium state in the strained pole in which the work input is equal to the internal strain energy. You don't say how the pole was bent but assuming it was by a human then the energy trail for the human input is chemical energy (food intake) to kinetic energy (muscle action) to potential energy (internal strain energy).

I know where you are going with the force at the end of the tip but in energy terms until the strained pole is released it is in a new state of energy equilibrium.
 
Thanks for clearing that up. I get the joke now--I didn't catch the play on words. It probably would have worked if delivered orally.

I will take you at your word that you are a ME.

On the more pertinent topic, is it possible that when you are writing "energy" you are envisaging momentum?

Face to face I'm sure I would have been able to successfully signal the joking nature. I do accept and try to give latitude to people on the basis that it is difficult to translate everyday signals we use when talking face to face to flag things like "hey I'm kidding you". Rather than attacking I am now trying to either ask for clarification if I am unsure or just responding neutrally to say I am not interested in hostility.

I have questioned myself several times about whether I am very effective at communicating on forums because I seem to attract so much hostility that I feel is unwarranted. I have read back several times to check this and have come to the conclusion that it deosn't matter what I say to some people on here I will only get hostility back. Having decided that it would be more fun to actually have a civillised debate rather than just keep pressing the obvious buttons that get the obvious responses I am going to offer no fuel to the flames, until I get bored with it that is.

Could you offer more explanation of you momentum comment?
 
Last edited:
It is not stress energy, it is internal strain energy.

The PE is stored in the internal strain of the microstructure of the pole very much as it is in a spring. The work done has created a new equilibrium state in the strained pole in which the work input is equal to the internal strain energy. You don't say how the pole was bent but assuming it was by a human then the energy trail for the human input is chemical energy (food intake) to kinetic energy (muscle action) to potential energy (internal strain energy).

I know where you are going with the force at the end of the tip but in energy terms until the strained pole is released it is in a new state of energy equilibrium.
"...thereby demonstrating that energy [ has / does not have ] a 'vectoral quality.'"

Please complete your response in terms of the context of the discussion.
 
Of that, I have little doubt! :)

I've considered the somewhat frightening possibility that he was being truthful about being an engineer AND was being indeliberately muddle-headed about force vs. energy.

There is, after all, at least one practicing engineer by that name. This one works on relatively small-scale projects, and I suppose it's possible that certain basic physics concepts don't play all that big of a role in his day-to-day practical work. I suppose it's also possible that he made a career in engineering without ever having really understood some of those basic concepts. He may get by just fine merely by being familiar with local building codes.

I guess I owe that William Rea an apology for being linked to my crazy posting.

William Rea = Bill Rea = liBeRal
 
Could you offer more explanation of you momentum comment?
It occurred to me that a common conceptual error people make is confusing kinetic energy with momentum. They both are directly related to mass and velocity. I don't think that's what you're doing, though, now that I think of it, because you seem to be ascribing directionality of some sort to all types of energy.
 
The terms used in the figures are all the same. There is no place in the text that he specifically addresses the details of Fig. 2, but you'll note:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/attachment.php?attachmentid=6282&d=1175726372
The terms are all consistent with the forces displayed in Figure 2. Note the terms "m(z)g" used in Figure 2. Also note the mathematically equivalent term "gm(z)" term used in the quoted passage:
Also note the use of the term Fc in both figures 2 and figures 3 and 4. Fc is a point on the Y axis, which axis is clearly labelled "Force". There is simply no other reasonable interpretation of Fig. 2, except that it is depicting forces.
For someone who claims to be an engineer to claim otherwise, or to claim that they could not have figured this out themselves, is simply unbelievable. It must be a deliberate attempt to mislead those who don't know how to understand such figures.
And that makes it another lie.
So, I concur: William Rea is a lying liar who lies. He lied about the context of the KT quote, and now he's lying about what the linked paper is showing.
Mr. Rea, you are a stinking liar!
And no apology will be accepted. You apologize for accidents, not for things you did with deliberate intent. From now on, all who have read this thread will know, William Rea is an honourless liar, who cannot be trusted. You have sold your reputation for a lie that lasted less than a week. I hope you're happy with that.
Liar.

I'm sorry that you felt compelled to join the detractors instead of engaging with me. I only asked you to address your comments to figure 2 and you berated me for lying about it in a baseless manner.

Your post was extremely aggressive and with repect, I found very little honorable intent on your side in it. Since you find me so disagreeable I suggest we do not exchange any further posts.

Hopefully you will not ascribe my removal of the spaces between your posting paragraphs to some malicious intent on my part as others seem to have to my habit of putting ... in the middle of long posts when replying to save space.
 
Last edited:
It occurred to me that a common conceptual error people make is confusing kinetic energy with momentum. They both are directly related to mass and velocity. I don't think that's what you're doing, though, now that I think of it, because you seem to be ascribing directionality of some sort to all types of energy.

Indeed, although once again I have been accused of malicious intent I felt that the universality of Conservation of Energy could be broadened out by introducing thermodynamic energy to show energy flow. As energy is a universal concept in all branches of engineering and science I didn't feel that it was a major leap or even an obfuscation. Maybe, I was wrong.

I now understand what you meant by momentum, thanks for the clarification.

I get the impression that it is not being comprehended that all of these theoretical situations can be analysed purely in terms of Conservation of Energy without using forces. Forces have uses but they are not essential unless you want to know the dynamics.

I still contend that whatever euphemism you use gradient or vertical there is an instinctively directional or vectorial nature to energy.

It was interesting to see how much underlying principle was understood on the forum though.
 
To be fair to killtown (woah! I need to take a shower, now), I think he was saying "Huh ? A link to a "normal" video ? Why, that's not possible." Of course. That's still a stupid thing to post, but it's not the same level of stupid, assuming I'm correct.



A normal person might respond in that way, but remember we're talking about Killtown. Asking for an internet link to a non internet video is precisely the sort of thing I would expect Killtown to do.

-Gumboot
 
It's kind of late here now so time to leave but tomorrow night I will tackle my third debunking following on from the success of the previous two in this thread.

Night Y'all.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom