Debunking the Stundies - March Edition

To be fair, IIRC the energy of an object subject to a force field can be defined as the "charge" (mass, if we're speaking of gravity) times the potential function of the field. And the force is defined as the curl of that potential function, again multiplied by the "charge". So there is a way to make a vector quantity from the potential energy, but it's a lot less intuitive than you'd think.

(There are probably better ways of expressing this, but it's after midnight where I'm posting. I tried "the curl of the energy", but that isn't a meaningful physical quantity despite being fairly easily defined mathematically )

This being said, it still doesn't make either the energy, potential or charge anything but scalar quantities.
 
So there is a way to make a vector quantity from the potential energy, but it's a lot less intuitive than you'd think.

The word you're looking for is gradient. (The context of this conversation is Newtonian, not GR)

"Curl" comes into play with E&M type fields. (F on a point charge 'e' is perpendicular to the plane formed by the velocity of the point charge 'v' and the electric field 'E' and proportional to the magnitude of the vectors and the sine of the angle between them)
 
Last edited:
D'oh. Guess I should stay with SR or basic QM. At least I keep that stuff fairly fresh in my head (though I don't use it for anything much)
 
Odd how memory works isn't it?

In the last ten years, I've probably not used the word 'curl' in the E&M / field math sense of the word at all, whereas I've probably used it in other contexts (curly hair, or referencing the linux/unix command line program of the same name) hundreds or thousands of times.

Yet as soon as I saw your post I knew instantly what you were writing about.

For me, it makes Mr. Rea's 'vectorial quality' of Gravitational PE argument a very hard one to swallow.
 
The figure referred to in your quote is not Figure 2. I would appreciate if you could address figure 2 with your answer.



The terms used in the figures are all the same. There is no place in the text that he specifically addresses the details of Fig. 2, but you'll note:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/attachment.php?attachmentid=6282&d=1175726372

The terms are all consistent with the forces displayed in Figure 2. Note the terms "m(z)g" used in Figure 2. Also note the mathematically equivalent term "gm(z)" term used in the quoted passage:

F = gm(z) represents the inertia force that must be generated by acceleration or deceleration of the block of tower mass m(z) above level z of the top floor of the story.


Also note the use of the term Fc in both figures 2 and figures 3 and 4. Fc is a point on the Y axis, which axis is clearly labelled "Force". There is simply no other reasonable interpretation of Fig. 2, except that it is depicting forces.

For someone who claims to be an engineer to claim otherwise, or to claim that they could not have figured this out themselves, is simply unbelievable. It must be a deliberate attempt to mislead those who don't know how to understand such figures.

And that makes it another lie.

So, I concur: William Rea is a lying liar who lies. He lied about the context of the KT quote, and now he's lying about what the linked paper is showing.

Mr. Rea, you are a stinking liar!

And no apology will be accepted. You apologize for accidents, not for things you did with deliberate intent. From now on, all who have read this thread will know, William Rea is an honourless liar, who cannot be trusted. You have sold your reputation for a lie that lasted less than a week. I hope you're happy with that.

Liar.
 
And no apology will be accepted. You apologize for accidents, not for things you did with deliberate intent. From now on, all who have read this thread will know, William Rea is an honourless liar, who cannot be trusted. You have sold your reputation for a lie that lasted less than a week. I hope you're happy with that.

Liar.

I disagree that no apology will be accepted.

However, it must be a sincere apology for what actually occured.

Apologising for an "accident" or "mistake" will be viewed in much the same light as Computer Science graduates view those enrolled in TAFE IT.*

William, while your reputation will not return to where it was when this all began you will at least be going part way to repairing these bridges you have burnt if you own up to what you have done and accept responsibility.

If you disagree, actually go and address my argument and reasoning. Don't resort to subtle ad hominem attacks that you hope people won't notice.

And before you protest - yes, ignoring my argument and instead subtly implying that I am obsessed and unstable IS an ad hominem. Which also makes you a hypocrite.
 
I'm disappointed myself, but I cannot logically reconcile

1) Your claim to be a civil engineer

with the following:

A) Your claim that Gravitational Potential Energy is a vector. (Or having a "vectoral quality," which is what you backed off to - whatever that means)
B) Your claim that Thermal Energy is a vector by example of heat transfer along a linear conductor. (Counter example: Heat the center of a metal disk. In which direction is the "vector" pointing?)
C) Your mixing "work" with "energy" (and most notably your failure to use the term "force" which is a vector)

All of this is taught in any first semester advanced high-school physics class. This is pre-engineering stuff - so basic that there are really only two probable explanations.

Your formal education was so long ago and is so far removed from your day-to-day work as a civil engineer that you no longer remember parts of it well enough to discuss with any authority

or

You did not receive a 4-year engineering degree from an accredited institution of higher learning.

(Well, there is a third, but)

I am having an issue with this as well. I am not an engineer, having taken only high school and basic university physics, but those concepts do not confuse me. I find it very difficult to believe that someone with a four year engineering degree who works as an engineer is confused about such basic physics concepts.

Perhaps there is another explanation. I would like to hear it.
 
I am having an issue with this as well. I am not an engineer, having taken only high school and basic university physics, but those concepts do not confuse me. I find it very difficult to believe that someone with a four year engineering degree who works as an engineer is confused about such basic physics concepts.

Perhaps there is another explanation. I would like to hear it.

It is possible for someone to qualify as a Professional Engineer without having completed an accredited four year engineering program. They still have to demonstrate proficiency in the engineering sciences in a series of tests, though.
 
It is possible for someone to qualify as a Professional Engineer without having completed an accredited four year engineering program. They still have to demonstrate proficiency in the engineering sciences in a series of tests, though.

I didn't know that.

Do those tests, by any chance, involve basic physics?
 
I disagree that no apology will be accepted.

However, it must be a sincere apology for what actually occured.

Apologising for an "accident" or "mistake" will be viewed in much the same light as Computer Science graduates view those enrolled in TAFE IT.*


Well, that is for each of us to decide, of course.

But consider: He started out with the premise that he could "debunk" the Stundies (whatever that really means). To do this, he deliberately lied about both on his examples.

When I caught him on the forces question, he initially implied I had manufactured the quote, then, when shown to again be wrong, implied that the quote meant something else. These are "errors" that an engineer who had read the paper with a mind willing to understand simply could not have made, three times in a row. He lied, he knew he had lied, and he tried to smear me as a liar rather than admit it.

As for the KT quote, well, I agree with your analysis, it was a lie from the start, defended by lies, and, when trapped in a corner on that issue, he gave out his fake "I'm sorry, honest mistake" "apology".

He's shown a willingness to lie, to defend those lies with more lies, to attempt to smear other posters as liars to distract attention from his own lies, and to even lie about his willingness to admit errors.

Even if he were to admit to everything, from first lie to last, and to promise never to do it again, how could we trust that promise? A liar will lie about never lying again, just to get off the hook.

You're free to disagree, but I'm also free to never trust his word again, and I won't.
 
I didn't know that.

Do those tests, by any chance, involve basic physics?

You could say that.

I can't speak for other states, although I imagine they don't depart significantly from this system, but in Arizona the first test is the Engineer In Training (EIT) Exam, which tests general engineering principles along with physics, math, chemistry, etc (all the foundational sciences). After accumulating enough work experience under the supervision of a Registered Professional Engineer you get to take one (or in the case of structural, two) more test called (strangely enough) the Professional Engineer (PE) Exam, which is discipline-specific (Arizona recognizes something like 27 different disciplines). The first exam is widely held to be the more difficult one, and is (according to what I've been told) the largest hurdle for non-degreed engineers to overcome.

I know several PEs who don't have engineering degrees. They have a different perspective on things, to say the least (especially the one with a degree in journalism) but they are still conversant with general science.
 
Well, that is for each of us to decide, of course.

But consider: He started out with the premise that he could "debunk" the Stundies (whatever that really means). To do this, he deliberately lied about both on his examples.

When I caught him on the forces question, he initially implied I had manufactured the quote, then, when shown to again be wrong, implied that the quote meant something else. These are "errors" that an engineer who had read the paper with a mind willing to understand simply could not have made, three times in a row. He lied, he knew he had lied, and he tried to smear me as a liar rather than admit it.

As for the KT quote, well, I agree with your analysis, it was a lie from the start, defended by lies, and, when trapped in a corner on that issue, he gave out his fake "I'm sorry, honest mistake" "apology".

He's shown a willingness to lie, to defend those lies with more lies, to attempt to smear other posters as liars to distract attention from his own lies, and to even lie about his willingness to admit errors.

Even if he were to admit to everything, from first lie to last, and to promise never to do it again, how could we trust that promise? A liar will lie about never lying again, just to get off the hook.

You're free to disagree, but I'm also free to never trust his word again, and I won't.
I agree with everything you said above (including never trusting his word again) except I don't think he lied about the forces question. I believe he lied about being an engineer.

Habitual liars are often cowards, too, so we may never see him again. For now, I'll give him the benefit of the doubt and assume that he took an Easter holiday.
 
You could say that.

I can't speak for other states, although I imagine they don't depart significantly from this system, but in Arizona the first test is the Engineer In Training (EIT) Exam, which tests general engineering principles along with physics, math, chemistry, etc (all the foundational sciences). After accumulating enough work experience under the supervision of a Registered Professional Engineer you get to take one (or in the case of structural, two) more test called (strangely enough) the Professional Engineer (PE) Exam, which is discipline-specific (Arizona recognizes something like 27 different disciplines). The first exam is widely held to be the more difficult one, and is (according to what I've been told) the largest hurdle for non-degreed engineers to overcome.

I know several PEs who don't have engineering degrees. They have a different perspective on things, to say the least (especially the one with a degree in journalism) but they are still conversant with general science.

Enlightening!

So we would expect someone that had passed through this process to have a similar level of familiarity with basic concepts of physics to a degreed engineer?
 
I agree with everything you said above (including never trusting his word again) except I don't think he lied about the forces question. I believe he lied about being an engineer.


Well, that may be the case. But I still find it hard to believe anyone would honestly dispute that a big "F" indicates a "Force"!

F=ma is one of the twoofer's favourite equations to misuse, after all.
 
Well, that may be the case. But I still find it hard to believe anyone would honestly dispute that a big "F" indicates a "Force"!

F=ma is one of the twoofer's favourite equations to misuse, after all.
Heh. Yeah.

What makes me most suspect of his claim that he's an engineer was when he "corrected" my statement: "The force of gravity makes stuff fall down. Gravitational energy does not."
with: "Actually it is the work that gravitational energy does on the mass that makes stuff fall down."

I suppose it's possible that he lied both by claiming to be an engineer and by deliberately misrepresenting a diagram. I get the feeling, though, that he truly doesn't understand what energy and force mean in Newtonian terms.
 
I suppose it's possible that he lied both by claiming to be an engineer and by deliberately misrepresenting a diagram. I get the feeling, though, that he truly doesn't understand what energy and force mean in Newtonian terms.

I think you're right about this.
 
I suppose it's possible that he lied both by claiming to be an engineer and by deliberately misrepresenting a diagram. I get the feeling, though, that he truly doesn't understand what energy and force mean in Newtonian terms.

I think you're right about this.



I guess we'll all have to agree that he's both a liar, and an ignoramus, then?

Okay by me!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom