Debunking the Stundies - March Edition

Again I politely ask you to stop berating me to make an apology that is not deserved. The scenarios I present are just as likely in the context with the facts we know. Again I politely ask to stop telling me I am wrong and show me I am. the nomination was not mine, you are the prosecution so prove the case beyond reasonable doubt. I have given plenty of reasonable doubt.

Question: You are aware that as you are essentially accusing me of slander, that in this situation YOU would be the representative for the plaintiff, and I would be the defendant, right?

Another Question: You do realise that slander is not a criminal offence, it is a tort?

Another Another Question: You do realise that "beyond reasonable doubt" is only applicable to criminal cases, and that the term used in a torts case is "balance of probabilities"?

Another Another Another Question: You do realise that the scenarios you presented are only even mildly probably given your version of the context surrounding the quote, which I have shown above that you deliberately falisified?
 
Again, I will politely point out that I will not be berated by aggressive posting into making a false apology. I am on record in this thread for apologising for an unintendedly misleading post.

I have calmly and politely explained my rational position on it and again I politely point out that because I was incorrect about the posting does not make me incorrect regarding the central tenet of the incorrect nomination.

I'm sorry, but I don't believe you when you say it was unintentional. You managed to copy the actual content of the posts exactly, which means you had the page open and were copying from it. So I don't believe it's plausible that you mistakenly attributed Killtowns reply to Jarroyo's post, because Killtown's post had a quote box, and in that quote box was WWGHA's post, not Jarroyo's. If you had to lie in order to make your case, your case can't be all that strong.

Now I'll ask you to review some other of Killtown's nominations to get an idea of what you're dealing with.
 
Let's see what you said...

Let's see what you originally posted.....attempted to mislead the members of the JREF forums and also possible lurkers. An apology for what you actually did would go a long way to restoring your credibility. And a withdrawal of your accusation would go even futher in restoring your credibility.

I don't understand why you are adopting such an aggressive posting manner and constantly berating me to apologise for something I have already apologised for as well as to incorrectly apologise for something I have no need to apologise for.

I am politely withdrawing from responding to your posts now as this has stepped way beyond the realms of normality. If you wish to have a more agreeable exchange of views I will then be more than happy to resume corresponding with you.
 
Again, I will politely point out that I will not be berated by aggressive posting into making a false apology. I am on record in this thread for apologising for an unintendedly misleading post.

Except that it wasn't unintentionally misleading. It was deliberate.

Or are you saying that you just "didn't notice" that Jarrayo's post occured five posts before the one the Killtown was nominated for?

And that you "didn't notice" WWGHA's post that occurred directly above Killtown's nominated post?

And that you "didn't notice" that Killtown had quoted WWHGA's post in his own post, and that when you cut-and-pasted Killtown's response from Loose Change into the first page of this thread that you "didn't notice" that you "accidentally deleted" the part of the post where Killtown quotes WWGHA?

And that you "didn't notice" WWGHA's post directly after Killtown's, where WWGHA expresses that he can't post a link to a video that isn't on the internet?

And that you "didn't notice" Killtown not correcting WWGHA on this matter, but instead concluding that all the videos are faked anyway?

Face it, William. You're busted. Now own up and apologise before I lose even more respect for you than I already have.
 
I'm sorry, but I don't believe you when you say it was unintentional. You managed to copy the actual content of the posts exactly, which means you had the page open and were copying from it. So I don't believe it's plausible that you mistakenly attributed Killtowns reply to Jarroyo's post, because Killtown's post had a quote box, and in that quote box was WWGHA's post, not Jarroyo's. If you had to lie in order to make your case, your case can't be all that strong.

Now I'll ask you to review some other of Killtown's nominations to get an idea of what you're dealing with.

You don't have to accept my sincerety, that is up to you. I have to accept that you now no longer trust my posts and I will have to strive harder to regain that trust. I can only recall what I believe I saw, and I believe that despite not having access to the original thread (for some obscure reason) and in the face of the Google facsimile (which has a disclaimer on it) that my given apology was adequate.

My error does not alter the logic of the argument, attacking my personal honesty does not undermine the facts as they stand.
 
Last edited:
I don't understand why you are adopting such an aggressive posting manner and constantly berating me to apologise for something I have already apologised for as well as to incorrectly apologise for something I have no need to apologise for.

William, one does not apologise for "accidentally" misleading people if it was in fact deliberate. I see that you have conveniently deleted a large part of my post where I analysed your original claim and demonstrated that you had to have been deliberately lying in your original post.

You complain about my "aggressive" posting manner - was it not you who posted in The Stundies for the sole purpose of stating that you were not participating because you believed them to be ad hominem attacks? Might I remind you that you claimed that "at least two" were ad hominem, a claim you have yet to provide any justification for? Was it not you that began this thread for the sole intention of attacking The Stundies and provoking the other members here?

And was it not you who had to deliberately falsify the context of a quote in order to give your accusation any grounds whatsoever?

Not to mention that you are STILL defending the ridiculous "gravitational energy...which is vertical" quote, despite the fact that it is just outright wrong???

My style may seem aggressive, but that is only because the best defence is a good offence. You began this, and now you are upset because the tables have turned on you?

Tough.

I am politely withdrawing from responding to your posts now as this has stepped way beyond the realms of normality. If you wish to have a more agreeable exchange of views I will then be more than happy to resume corresponding with you.

Translation:​

I am not going to reply to you anymore, as you have now repeatedly shown that I had to deliberately lie, falsify context and omit information in order to make my position seem more credible. By saying that I am "politely withdrawing" it seems as though I am taking the moral high ground, and by saying that, "...this has stepped way beyond the realms of normality..." I am subtly suggesting that you are mentally unbalanced. However, I concede that if you promise to stop exposing my intellectual dishonesty and if you stop asking me to apologise for the things that I have obviously done wrong but refuse to admit to then I will talk to you again.

Just a nice move there - running away when you're losing the argument, but trying to frame me as the bad guy. That's not going to make anybody here respect you more.
 
...I believe that despite not having access to the original thread (for some obscure reason)...

If you didn't have access to the thread, then how could you have produced Jarrayo's post with perfect fidelity, including typos?

My error does not alter the logic of the argument, attacking my personal honesty does not undermine the facts as they stand.

Except that the exact thing you were dishonest about were "the facts as they stand."
 
For those that have entered this at the last page and have not read the OP I would like to post this link so you may see the intent.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2490973#post2490973

I am hoping that my new calmer more rational demeanour will attract people who wish to post in the same manner and who wish to resolve issues calmly and without resorting to personal attacks.

That is my aspiration, and to achieve this my reaction will be to ignore aggressive posting and not to escalate it, even in the face of the most extreme provocation. I never use the ignore button so I will see all posts but I will select which ones I answer.

I also aspire to try to have conversations through the forum where ideas have a chance to evolve.

As my opinions are so often contrary to many on the board please understand that I will have to answer probably 10 times more posts than you will make, so if I do not respond immediately a polite reminder will always be acceptable to me.
 
The force of gravity makes stuff fall down. Gravitational energy does not.

Actually it is the work that gravitational energy does on the mass that makes stuff fall down.


Contradicting someone is not an argument. If my analysis is wrong I would prefer you to educate me as to how it is wrong.
Okay.

Your statement was: "the work that gravitational energy does on the mass...makes stuff fall down"

This is wrong. Stuff falls down because it's in the gravitational force field of the Earth. The force of gravity is acting on the mass.

The gravitational potential energy of the mass is a result of its position within this force field. GPE is not "acting on" the mass. The mass is storing GPE. The work done on the mass was done by whatever lifted it above the Earth's surface. This work was then stored in the mass as GPE. As the mass falls, no work is being done on the mass. Although the mass's GPE converts to kinetic energy as it falls, no energy is spent--the mass retains all of its energy until it collides with something (in an ideal system, that is--in reality some energy is converted to heat and sound, for instance.)

Think about it. If the Earth had to spend energy attracting things to it, it would run out of energy pretty quickly, wouldn't it?
 
If I take a bar of steel and increase the thermal energy in one end of it you're saying the thermal energy will not flow to the other end of the bar?
Your example only is (sort of) directional because of the shape you chose to heat and the way you chose to heat it. It's still just a thermal system tending towards equlibrium, though.

If you place a cold turkey in a hot oven, in which direction is the turkey going to be heated?
 
Just catching up with this thread. So did WR actually apologise for deliberately lying in the case of Killtown V WWGHA? All his obfuscation and condescending nonsense makes it hard to tell. It's pretty obvious that he lied, but he seems to be pretending that it was all some kind of innocent mistake.

I guess I now know just how much credibility to give his posts in the future. ie- Zero.

@ Mobyseven if I ever need a Lawyer in Vic. I'll look you up.
 
Just catching up with this thread. So did WR actually apologise for deliberately lying in the case of Killtown V WWGHA? All his obfuscation and condescending nonsense makes it hard to tell. It's pretty obvious that he lied, but he seems to be pretending that it was all some kind of innocent mistake.

I guess I now know just how much credibility to give his posts in the future. ie- Zero.

@ Mobyseven if I ever need a Lawyer in Vic. I'll look you up.

You'll have to wait about five years, as I'm still at law school (Melbourne Uni) and doing a double-degree...it takes some time, that's for sure. Especially if I'm accepted into the Dip. of Modern Languages which I'm going to apply for at the end of this year.

But depending on what type of legal issue it is, I could probably point you in the right direction to someone who could answer questions far better than me right now.

By the way - I'd like to point out that when William Rea talks about "personal attacks", he is talking about the fact that I have now repeatedly called him a liar.

This is because he is a liar. See my previous posts if you are not sure why he is a liar. But he is a liar.
 
You'll have to wait about five years, as I'm still at law school (Melbourne Uni) and doing a double-degree...it takes some time, that's for sure. Especially if I'm accepted into the Dip. of Modern Languages which I'm going to apply for at the end of this year.

But depending on what type of legal issue it is, I could probably point you in the right direction to someone who could answer questions far better than me right now.

By the way - I'd like to point out that when William Rea talks about "personal attacks", he is talking about the fact that I have now repeatedly called him a liar.

This is because he is a liar. See my previous posts if you are not sure why he is a liar. But he is a liar.


He is claiming people are personally attacking him now? Isn't that ironic. He is currently the sole occupant of my ignore list due to a personal attack.
 
He is claiming people are personally attacking him now? Isn't that ironic. He is currently the sole occupant of my ignore list due to a personal attack.

That is rather ironic. I make a point of not using my ignore list. Though there are members I've been tempted add to it, I have so far restrained.

Yes, William is currently upset at my having repeatedly called him a liar.

I did a brief summary of what happened that I think is on the bottom of page two.

Basically, he deliberately edited the context of one of the Stundie nominations by omitting relevant information and changing the order of some of the posts.

I don't know why he would do this other than it seems he likes to deliberately rile people up to get his jollies, but this time he's gone too far. If he apologises and withdraws his accusations then all is forgiven. Otherwise I'll just let him run his already ruined credibility further into the ground.

I have no idea how he thought he'd get away with this either. Deliberately trying to mislead the members of a forum who, by definition, are going to check your sources is just a bad idea from the outset.
 
Usually I have a fairly high tolerance for people, he is the only one I am ignoring, mostly since he seems to want to push things (as you mentioned), and I really haven't seen anything constructive from him. If he did acknowledge errors and apologize to people, I would probably change my mind. As it is, judging by the responses from people in this thread, I don't feel as though I am missing all that much.
 
Yes he does like to push things.

The second irony here being that now that I am pushing for an apology he is complaining about my aggressive posting style.
 
Yes he does like to push things.

The second irony here being that now that I am pushing for an apology he is complaining about my aggressive posting style.

So are you saying that William Rea is a lying liar who tells lies, as well as a whingeing whiner who whinges?
 
So are you saying that William Rea is a lying liar who tells lies, as well as a whingeing whiner who whinges?

The "whinging whiner" part is required, as Truthseeker1234 has a trademark on being a "lying liar who tells lies" (just ask LossLeader).

But more to the point, I think that he knows he is in the wrong but is giving his all to trying to both retain some form of credibility while not admitting to being wrong.

Needless to say, it isn't working.
 
I was hoping to enjoy an exchange of posts with you because you came across as very reasonable in the previous couple of posts we exchanged. I am afraid to say that this post has reversed that opinion which is a little sad.

I'm disappointed myself, but I cannot logically reconcile

1) Your claim to be a civil engineer

with the following:

A) Your claim that Gravitational Potential Energy is a vector. (Or having a "vectoral quality," which is what you backed off to - whatever that means)
B) Your claim that Thermal Energy is a vector by example of heat transfer along a linear conductor. (Counter example: Heat the center of a metal disk. In which direction is the "vector" pointing?)
C) Your mixing "work" with "energy" (and most notably your failure to use the term "force" which is a vector)

All of this is taught in any first semester advanced high-school physics class. This is pre-engineering stuff - so basic that there are really only two probable explanations.

Your formal education was so long ago and is so far removed from your day-to-day work as a civil engineer that you no longer remember parts of it well enough to discuss with any authority

or

You did not receive a 4-year engineering degree from an accredited institution of higher learning.

(Well, there is a third, but)

Be reassured that if I am wrong I apologise, I have a record for doing this on the forum, in fact I believe that I am probably one of a handful of people on here with the humility to do so when proven wrong.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom