Debunking the Stundies - March Edition

i feel his use of "normal" in quotes indicates a direct response to amputees instructing him to find a "normal video" your free to ask to killtown what he meant by it, but i think any "normal" person will take it this way

You are free to make your analysis. I am confident with mine.

I think it would have been more in keeping for the context to have been asked BEFORE the nomination.
 
Yes. He makes it quite clear that he believes that GPE can contribute ONLY to a vertical force vector.
This statement actually gives us a little insight into how little you understand the concept of GPE. It in no way "releases in a vectorial manner." That makes absolutely no sense. It shows no insight on Griffin's part at all. Everyone knows that gravity makes stuff fall down. His confusion about the physics behind it is embarrassing.
:yikes: In its full context, it's even clearer that he has NO IDEA how it works. Let's see that again:
"At the onset of each tower’s collapse, steel beams were ejected out as far as 600 feet; to believe that these horizontal ejections could be explained by gravitational energy, which is vertical, is to believe in magic."
He not only vectorializes (it's a word, I swear) energy, but also implies that NONE of the GPE in a collapsing structure can be spent on lateral force components (except by "magic").
Judging by this sentence alone, he is completely inept in the realm of physics.
So you say. Examples? Found that Bazant quote yet?

In comment to your post, I am being told that energy has no vectoral element so it appears that whilst it is apparent that everyone knows that gravitational energy makes stuff fall down this is simply not so. I also infer that thermal energy doesn't flow from hot to cold since it has no sense of direction.
 
Last edited:
You are free to make your analysis. I am confident with mine.

I think it would have been more in keeping for the context to have been asked BEFORE the nomination.
a link to the thread should be available on the nomination page, its one of the requirements for finalists,so theres your context, included at the time of the nomination
 
Please refer to the section on page 14 that analyses the Potential and Kinetic Energies and related equations.

I cannot find your reference text.



It's on page 5 of the pdf. Search on "inertia force", it was the first hit I got.

This is the full paragraph:

Deceleration and Acceleration During the Crushing of One Story. The two intersections of the horizontal line F = gm(z) with the curve F(u) seen in Fig. 3 and 4a (top) are equilibrium states (there is also a third equilibrium state at intersection with the vertical line of rehardening upon contact). But any other state on this curve is a transient dynamic state, in which the difference from the line F = gm(z) represents the inertia force that must be generated by acceleration or deceleration of the block of tower mass m(z) above level z of
the top floor of the story.



And the page you reference doesn't seem to be refering to vectors. It is discussing energy, but that's not the same as vectors. Do you know what a vector is? Focre is a vector, it has magnitude and direction. Energy is a scalar, it has only a magnitude.

This is pretty basic stuff.

Totally aside from that, the passage I quoted shows quite clearly that the vectors that you highlighted in the figure are not "energy vectors", they are force vectors, as defined above. You might be able to find some other reference to support your position, but you simply must acknowledge that that figure does not support your position.
 
In comment to your post, I am being told that energy has no vectoral element so it appears that whilst it is apparent that everyone knows that gravitational energy makes stuff fall down this is simply not so.



No, it is gravitational force that makes things fall down. No one disputes that force is a vector.

Consider a ball rolling down one side of a U-shaped valley, and up the other. Just before it reaches the bottom, it has almost all the kinetic energy it will have, as a result of being accelerated by the force of gravity. If this energy is a vector, with a direction, how then does it use that energy to roll up the other side of the valley? Is there some instantaneous impulse that completely reverses the energy of the ball into "upward energy" just as it reaches/passes the lowest point?
 
In comment to your post, I am being told that energy has no vectoral element so it appears that whilst it is apparent that everyone knows that gravitational energy makes stuff fall down this is simply not so.
The force of gravity makes stuff fall down. Gravitational energy does not.
I also infer that thermal energy doesn't flow from hot to cold since it has no sense of direction.
Again, this makes no sense. Heat transfers internal energy from one system to another, but it's not a directional transfer. You can't say: the flame heats the pot of water 100 Joules to the left. It's a scalar transfer. Think of it like taking a chunk out of one ball of clay and adding it to another. This transfer of mass is a scalar transfer.
 
In comment to your post, I am being told that energy has no vectoral element so it appears that whilst it is apparent that everyone knows that gravitational energy makes stuff fall down this is simply not so. I also infer that thermal energy doesn't flow from hot to cold since it has no sense of direction.

Are you saying that the energy holding Earth in orbit around the sun is a downward force? Or is the gravitational energy caused by the mass of the Earth different from the gravity caused by the Sun? Also remember that "down" is a subjective concept judged from your placement in the system. If you observed the collapse from space, the "direction" would be inward toward the center of the mass, not down.


Also, about the Killtown quote, wouldn't the best thing to do be asking Killtown to clarify what he meant? If he says that he was indeed replying to the intervening posts between his and the first post, then obviously we cannot prove him wrong in any way at all. It wouldn't matter whether or not most people here believe he is a lying scumbag. If he supports your point of view on his context, obviously the quote would have to be removed from the voting. Wouldn't that be better than injecting your own speculation and inference into the situation? (Why does that sound familiar?)
 
Nominated by apathoid

[From a no-plane thread...Killtown has trouble understanding the limits of the internet; context provided]


Originally Posted by Why Won't God Heal Amputees
If you watch a normal video (not an internet video) of the plane hitting, you will see that after the plane 'disappears' there is in fact a cloud of shredded plane skin falling downward outside of the building on the same side that it hit.

Originally Posted by Killtown
link to a "normal" video?


=====================================================
Actual context of the posts in the thread cut and pasted from LCF...

Originally Posted by Jarrayo in LCF

Excellent observation Amputees.

Obviously the WTC wall is not a giant solid smooth mass. Strangely in the video, it seems so. Why?

Because this video was recorded by who-knows what camera (could have even been a crappy one, such as a camcorder), I doubt the person who recorded gave the original footage to the person who posted it on the internet, so most likely he recorded it from a TV. After that, he send it to the computer. After that he compressed it by an enormous degree to allow fast internet replay. And after that it was posted on YouTube (or GoogleVideo) where it looses even more resolution. And after that someone made a screen capture of the already crappy footage and in most cases blew up the image to focus on the plane.

If you know about videos and graphics, you'll know that every step of the translation of the recording makes the video loose resolution. So the NPTers are basing their "evidence" on already faulty videos.

Response by Killtown

1) link to a "normal" video?

2) Example?

====================================================

William, we are talking about Killtown here, not R.Mackey. His posting history would indicate that he deserves no benefit of the doubt. This is the same Killtown who won the Stundie last month with "The same way they did the evil faces" post in response to an inquiry as to how the perps wrote 911 in the WTC smoke. I also nominated his beautifully ironic "Saved for prosperity" quote in which he had the audacity to imply that what another poster had just written was soooo far out of touch with reality that he had to save a screenshot of the post[for prosperity]. I've also nominated his "You think those birds are real?" post this month which is sadly gone as the "alternative theories" section is now history.....Killtown emits Stundie material in nearly every thread he posts in. The guy is simply living in another world.

Yes, the "Link to a normal video?" quote is a little nitpicky but I nominated it specifically because of what WWGHA wrote in parenthesis "(not an internet video)".

Anyhow, as for your debunk of the nomination - the "alternate" theories section is now gone so there is no way to review the context. I don't recall Jarroyo's post falling between Killtown's post and WWGHA's post, but that could've been the case, I don't remember. However, it's funny you didn't include WWGHA's reply to Killtown because that's what sealed the nomination for me. He basically asked Killtown how he was "... supposed to provide a link to a non-internet video?" "{Some sarcastic remark}, go watch your Loose Change DVD of the second hit"

So it would appear that the original poster(WWGHA) agrees with myself, Moby, and the six people who voted for the quote that Killtown just had a "blond" moment.
 
Last edited:
me about an hour ago said:
Anyhow, as for your debunk of the nomination - the "alternate" theories section is now gone so there is no way to review the context. I don't recall Jarroyo's post falling between Killtown's post and WWGHA's post.....


William, you weren't trying to be intentionally deceptive just to spite us, were you?






9902461490b17b08d.jpg


Link from Googles cache.​



I don't see Jarroyo's post anywhere, do you William?
 
William, you weren't trying to be intentionally deceptive just to spite us, were you?

....

I don't see Jarroyo's post anywhere, do you William?

But but William is a serious and committed seeker of objective truth, he would never tell fibs. So I guess in this case reality must be wrong, or something.
 
What a Drama. I should start a new Thread called:
Debunking of the "debunking the debunkers Stundie". :rolleyes:
 
Nomination cut and pasted from the "Stundies"...

-11-

Nominated by Dave Rogers

[David Ray Griffin discovers that energy is a vector...]


Originally Posted by David Ray Griffin
...gravitational energy, which is vertical...


=====================================================

The paragraph as cut and pasted from....

Morons and Magic: A Reply to George Monbiot

By David Ray Griffin

"At the onset of each tower’s collapse, steel beams were ejected out as far as 600 feet; to believe that these horizontal ejections could be explained by gravitational energy, which is vertical, is to believe in magic."

=======================================================

To defend this one hurts me because Griffin is a Theologian and I am at the very least agnostic but here goes...

1. David Ray Griffin's language is not scientific but its intent is clear.

2. It actually shows a little insight into how Gravitational Potential Energy acts and releases in a vectorial manner.

3. In its correct context it is neither ignorant nor illogical nor fallacious, the man just doesn't have the knowledge of scientific language to express himself. Despite this he clearly shows an understanding of how it works.

4. Other scientists and engineers express energy and conversions in similar terms.

That Griffin mangles scientific language and concepts isn't surprising. It is the least of his errors.

Clearly when anything falls down, all or part can fall sideways. See Jenga for an example. What Griffin is claiming is that it can't fling things as far happened with the WTC. He's insisting that something is fundamentally impossible when all daily experience shows that to be entirely wrong.

That would be bad enough - but one of Griffin's chief arguments that the WTC was demolished is that it didn't fall sideways, like a tree falling in the forest. IOW his two chief arguments are that things shouldn't be hurled sideways, and that everything should be hurled sideways. That makes him special, even in the demanding context of 911 conspiracy theories.
 
To defend this one hurts me because Griffin is a Theologian and I am at the very least agnostic but here goes...

1. David Ray Griffin's language is not scientific but its intent is clear.

This is actually the exact point I would take issue with.

OK, confession time. I do, occasionally, as does practically every other scientist, from time to time express an idea in rather more scientific, rather than vernacular language, than is necessary. I shouldn't do it, but I'm only human. It's a kind of appeal to one's own authority, a way of implying that I'm right because I'm a scientist and you're not, and it's generally a very bad way of conducting an argument. We're none of us perfect.

What Griffin is trying to do here is exactly that. He could have said "gravity, which acts vertically", and though his overall statement would be a fallacy I would have no particular issue with that part of it; when dealing with relatively much smaller objects falling close to the surface of the Earth, it's so near to correct that the most sensitive instruments would be unable to measure the inaccuracy. But Griffin didn't say that; he said "gravitational energy". His use of the word "energy" in that quote is clearly included to carry the message "I know what I'm talking about because I'm using scientific-sounding words". So he was using BS to make his point, and in doing so he got it wrong.

In short, the essence of a Stundie.

4. Other scientists and engineers express energy and conversions in similar terms.

As we've seen from the example you included, you only think that because you don't understand what they're saying.

Now don't get me wrong, I have no issue with you continuing to hold, and state publicly, the opinions that GPE is a vector, and that Bazant agrees with you. Freedom of speech, after all, would be no freedom at all if it excluded the freedom to state the patently ridiculous. Just be warned that, when you state these opinions to someone who actually knows what they're talking about, you'll start at some point to see a look in their eyes that suggests that they feel their time would be more profitably spent talking with someone different.

I'm getting that exact look in mine right now. Enjoy your thread.

Dave
 
Last edited:
Yes, the "Link to a normal video?" quote is a little nitpicky but I nominated it specifically because of what WWGHA wrote in parenthesis "(not an internet video)".

...
So it would appear that the original poster(WWGHA) agrees with myself, Moby, and the six people who voted for the quote that Killtown just had a "blond" moment.

William, you weren't trying to be intentionally deceptive just to spite us, were you?


[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/9902461490b17b08d.jpg[/qimg]

Link from Googles cache.​



I don't see Jarroyo's post anywhere, do you William?


And it's interesting to note, just after WWGHA asks how to link to a non-internet video, KT posts, but does not correct WWGHA's interpretation of KT's post. So even KT himself agrees with our interpretation!

Busted on "normal videos", busted on "energy vectors". Care to try for a third strike?
 
What a Drama. I should start a new Thread called:
Debunking of the "debunking the debunkers Stundie". :rolleyes:

Don't you dare!! I await William Reas' attempt to debunk the one for which I was nominated. Impossible!
 
William, you weren't trying to be intentionally deceptive just to spite us, were you?

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/9902461490b17b08d.jpg[/qimg]

Link from Googles cache.​

I don't see Jarroyo's post anywhere, do you William?

Swing and a miss, eh William?

Not only would it seem that you lost out on challenging the David Ray nomination (unless you are willing to drastically alter the current understanding of energy and physical forces), but you have now been shown to have actively lied in an attempt to change the context surrounding the quote.

Not very intellectually honest now, is it? My only question is this - Will you own up, apologise, and withdraw your accusations?

And by the way - context is a REQUIREMENT for quotes to even be considered for the finals. Sorry to name names, but from memory - StateOfGrace, I had to disqualify a number of your posts automatically because you had failed to provide links. If I've gotten the person wrong I apologise, but I think it was you, and I hope you don't mind me using you as an example here.

Mobyseven
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom