Death was the least that she deserved

Interesting viewpoint.



Some things paint a different picture, including a couple of hadith I've seen and something which was mentioned in Tabari's recordings of Islam's history. I'm currently reading a bit here and this. Unfortuneately it's hard to verify Tabari and to own the collection is even harder, but maybe it can be found online. Maybe I will find some things once the Sira by Ibn Ishaq arrives, which I could finally order. :)

Thanks very much for the links. Those are very helpful. :)
 
Here's a link that claims honour killing is not justified anywhere in the Koran or the Hadiths:

Good link.

Interesting that it answers one of my earlier questions - were they legal under Saddam, to which the answer is "no":

"The law was amended in 2002 to allow 'honour' killings to be treated in the same way as murder"

and also of interest:

"'Honour' crimes in Iraq have risen sharply since the 2003 invasion as the Iraqi state disintegrated and people became more reliant on conservative tribal authorities to settle disputes and mete out justice."
 
Here's a link that claims honour killing is not justified anywhere in the Koran or the Hadiths:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2008/may/11/iraq.humanrights1

Ah, I don't know about articles, or statements rather, like that. You'll be having a hard time finding the word honour killing in either that compilation or in the terms we perceive it as in there I guess, yes. But this is, in my view, just dodging the issue though. What defines honour or "honour killing" as a compound and when does religion play a role when it comes to rectifing honour?

I can't remember what it was, but I've come across a similar thing where it said "you can't find word x in scripture y". I think it was stoning as a punishment, which you can't find in the Quran but in the ahadith.

Like the father was pointing out subconsciously with the way he described the matter, it was a highly religious one with a lot of things intertwined like the current "Christian invader enemy".

I wouldn't even say, like you, prometheus, said, her monetary value played a role here, but rather the family's reputation if you really want to go with the honour aspect.

Look at what he said about his two remaining children when they would become "contaminated" with homosexuality. He said he'd also put them to death the way he put Rand to death - most likely for "honour reasons" and the family's honour again - and one could call it a honour killing; yet, it would be fine by Quran and Sunnah to kill off homosexuals. This mixed together with your good point the people there strongly assume sex has to take place when they, Rand and the soldier, met, or in general (unmarried) two of the opposite sex meet when not accompanied by a "male guardian" was reason enough to get her killed.

There's been a case in Saudi Arabia recently where a university professor is to be flogged for meeting a(n unmarried) woman in public for coffee. Link.

Now, from a Sunni perspective I can understand why people would object, since for a charge of fornication you need four whitnesses who saw the penis enter the vagina, then again, I read you can be (with some restrictions if I remember correctly, like being upright; ie being a good as in devout Muslim) also turn into four people by repeating the charge four times. This does not matter though, since this is merely a technicality of who puts her to death. This is why I noted I don't know how Shias deal with things like this. I wonder if they got a crane operator over in Iran appointed by the state, hm.

Anyway, the important thing in my opinion is that the notion alone, of flogging or putting someone to death for "shameful behaviour" (read: un-Islamic; invoking physical damage), is existent and in my opinion does not stem from some adapted cultural tradition (unless you want to assume the position the Quran is humbug and made up by Muhammad, who used many things - a position you could support) but instead can be sourced back to Islam. And since we're talking about a religious family the case seems to be highly afflicted by Islam.
 
Last edited:
Good link.

Interesting that it answers one of my earlier questions - were they legal under Saddam, to which the answer is "no":

But that's just a short time, isn't it? Plus "cases are often not investigated, or any sentence is light and commuted if the defendant has no criminal background.". The behaviour of the police supports this claim.
 
I think the problem is that religion is defined by the practioners rather than the founders. This man clearly believes that his actions were justified by Islam, even if the founders of Islam did not intend it to embrace honour killings. Of course it works the other way too as not all Muslims embrace the violent passages which do appear in the Koran.

Islam certainly has a problem in that fundamentalists, who do embrace the violent passages, and those who seek religious justification for offensive cultural practices do seem to have quite a bit of traction in Islamic communities.
 
This is fairly old and I don't know how it is now over there in Jorda (article from September 2003) but still interesting:

Jordan’s Parliament has rejected the senate’s recommendation to uphold a law providing stiffer penalties for men who kill women in so-called "honour killings".

...

Murder cases carry stiff penalties in Jordan, but honour killers usually receive reduced sentences since their crimes are considered to be committed in “fits of rage” or as a “crime of passion”, sparked by “unlawful action” on the part of the victim.
 
Last edited:
Hindu Honor Killing in the News Today

Indian village proud after double "honor killing"
Fri May 16, 2008 5:46pm EDT

By Simon Denyer

BALLA, India (Reuters) - Five armed men burst into the small room and courtyard at dawn, just as 21-year-old, 22-week pregnant, Sunita was drying her face on a towel.

They punched and kicked her stomach as she called out for her sleeping boyfriend "Jassa", 22-year-old Jasbir Singh, witnesses said. When he woke, both were dragged into waiting cars, driven away and strangled.

Their bodies, half-stripped, were laid out on the dirt outside Sunita's father's house for all to see, a sign that the family's "honor" had been restored by her cold-blooded murder.

A week later, the village of Balla, just a couple of hours drive from India's capital New Delhi, stands united behind the act, proud, defiant almost to a man.

Among the Jat caste of the conservative northern state of Haryana, it is taboo for a man and woman of the same village to marry. Although the couple were not related, they were seen in this deeply traditional society as brother and sister.

"From society's point of view, this is a very good thing," said 62-year-old farmer Balwan Arya, sitting smoking a hookah in the shade of a tree in a square with other elders from the village council or panchayat. "We have removed the blot."

Growing economic opportunities for young people and lower castes in Haryana have made "love marriages" more common, experts say, and the violent repression of them has risen in tandem as upper caste Jat men fight to hold on to power, status and property.

. . .

"The people who have done this should get an award for it," said 48-year-old Satvir Singh. "This was a murder of morality."

At least the Indian Government has arrested the perpetrators, although whether they will get justice in the end is not clear yet.
 
Last edited:
You know... considering the amount of senseless violence in many countries, it seems ridiculous to me to single out so-called "Muslim violence" for special scrutiny and judgment. It would be a sign of intelligence to note the fact that violence and criminal behavior is widespread and universal, and not simply associated with one group or another. We don't condemn all Catholics as pedophiles, no matter how endemic child abuse might be amongst the Catholic clergy. We ignore the football hooligans who riot, over a stupid sport, all across Europe. Homosexuals are beaten and/or murdered everywhere, including throughout the Western world. Minorities face bigotry and discrimination everywhere in the world, not just in the Middle East.

It is easy to blame and attack the "other"... but a few moments of serious examination of our own cultures shows that we're not blameless, and that the issues surrounding violence are more complex than most people give credit to. It is easy to feel good about yourself by ignoring the flaws in your own culture, and attacking the flaws in other cultures. That whole "nuance" thing is tough, but we're mostly intelligent people here, and we can do better than what has been displayed in threads like these. We do not have to EVER accept or condone evil in other cultures, but it is hypocrisy to declare ourselves free of fault, even relatively, when we condemn that evil.
 
And the Islamist apologist strikes again. :rolleyes: Who the hell ever said "we are free of fault"? The fact of the matter is that a culture that supports honour killings is inherently inferior.

Come back when British policemen encourage hooligans to riot. In the meantime, your pitiful "b-but we're violent too!" whining is going to sound far more hypocritical than the imaginary behaviour you attack in others.
 
It is easy to feel good about yourself by ignoring the flaws in your own culture, and attacking the flaws in other cultures. That whole "nuance" thing is tough, but we're mostly intelligent people here, and we can do better than what has been displayed in threads like these.

I have read the thread again and I really can't see that many if any of the people who have posted in this thread are actually ignoring the flaws in our cultures and merely attacking the flaws in other cultures.

The bottom line is that people who commit honour killings and people who support them are acting barbarically. This doesn't mean that I don't think that soccer hooliganism or segragation are also problems.

I don't feel that people who post in this thread are wrong for focussing on the drinking problems in my culture while ignoring the problems with drinking in their cultures. I realise that it is a safe assumption that they probably also condemn alcohol problems in their own culture.
 
And the Islamist apologist strikes again. :rolleyes: Who the hell ever said "we are free of fault"? The fact of the matter is that a culture that supports honour killings is inherently inferior.

Come back when British policemen encourage hooligans to riot. In the meantime, your pitiful "b-but we're violent too!" whining is going to sound far more hypocritical than the imaginary behaviour you attack in others.

You have a rather twisted and moronic definition of "apologist", since I not only condemn the violence and criminal behavior in the "name of Islam", but also find the entire religion to be yet another moronic fairy tale of ignorant people. Sorry I'm not the bigot you'd prefer me to be, but not being a bigot doesn't make me an apologist.
 
I have read the thread again and I really can't see that many if any of the people who have posted in this thread are actually ignoring the flaws in our cultures and merely attacking the flaws in other cultures.

The bottom line is that people who commit honour killings and people who support them are acting barbarically. This doesn't mean that I don't think that soccer hooliganism or segragation are also problems.

I don't feel that people who post in this thread are wrong for focussing on the drinking problems in my culture while ignoring the problems with drinking in their cultures. I realise that it is a safe assumption that they probably also condemn alcohol problems in their own culture.

I find that people tend to foolishly pretend that the problems in countries where there are many Muslims live are an excuse to vent their childish and hateful bigotries. People in general seem to find it a little too easy to trick themselves into a feeling of cultural superiority... sad but true.
 
I find that people tend to foolishly pretend that the problems in countries where there are many Muslims live are an excuse to vent their childish and hateful bigotries. People in general seem to find it a little too easy to trick themselves into a feeling of cultural superiority... sad but true.

I don't think we need to trick ourselves into feeling superior to that culture. Our culture is superior to that culture. Does that make it perfect? No. If you are attempting to rank two things, does one of the things have to be perfect in order to make a decision between the two? No.
 
You know... considering the amount of senseless violence in many countries, it seems ridiculous to me to single out so-called "Muslim violence" for special scrutiny and judgment. It would be a sign of intelligence to note the fact that violence and criminal behavior is widespread and universal, and not simply associated with one group or another. We don't condemn all Catholics as pedophiles, no matter how endemic child abuse might be amongst the Catholic clergy. We ignore the football hooligans who riot, over a stupid sport, all across Europe. Homosexuals are beaten and/or murdered everywhere, including throughout the Western world. Minorities face bigotry and discrimination everywhere in the world, not just in the Middle East.

It is easy to blame and attack the "other"... but a few moments of serious examination of our own cultures shows that we're not blameless, and that the issues surrounding violence are more complex than most people give credit to. It is easy to feel good about yourself by ignoring the flaws in your own culture, and attacking the flaws in other cultures. That whole "nuance" thing is tough, but we're mostly intelligent people here, and we can do better than what has been displayed in threads like these. We do not have to EVER accept or condone evil in other cultures, but it is hypocrisy to declare ourselves free of fault, even relatively, when we condemn that evil.

You know this would be a nice argument IF you could find ANY catholic doctrine or even ANY people CLAIMING to practice Catholicism who advocate child molestation based on their faith!

But UNLIKE the universal (yea yea yea I know there is some muslim SOMEWHERE who is hiding under his camel who is really appalled by this behavior) approval of the Muslim world for this behavior you are going to be hard pressed to find any cop or even the general public in the west(note I also recognize that there are a lot of sicko's who secretly approve) who will condone this publicly much less CLAIM it as a righteous part of their society and religion.
And again - one can argue that this isn't the religion of (fill in the blank) but a large part of what defines a religion is how the practitioners who claim to practice religion X behave.

Yes, western society has a lot of crime and there is a lot of violence but basically the equivalent western society of the current muslim one is the 15 and 1600s NOT the 21st century. AND yes I call my ancestors of that era brutish, barbarians as well.
 
I find that people tend to foolishly pretend that the problems in countries where there are many Muslims live are an excuse to vent their childish and hateful bigotries. People in general seem to find it a little too easy to trick themselves into a feeling of cultural superiority... sad but true.

I find that people tend to foolishly pretend that the problems in countries where there are many slave holders live are an excuse to vent their childish and hateful bigotries.

I find that people tend to foolishly pretend that the problems in countries where there are many Nazis live are an excuse to vent their childish and hateful bigotries.

I find that people tend to foolishly pretend that the problems in countries where there are many racists who believe in apartied live are an excuse to vent their childish and hatefull bigotry.

Please explain how the above 3 are ANY different then applied to these magical muslims of yours?
 
You know... considering the amount of senseless violence in many countries, it seems ridiculous to me to single out so-called "Muslim violence" for special scrutiny and judgment. It would be a sign of intelligence to note the fact that violence and criminal behavior is widespread and universal, and not simply associated with one group or another. We don't condemn all Catholics as pedophiles, no matter how endemic child abuse might be amongst the Catholic clergy. We ignore the football hooligans who riot, over a stupid sport, all across Europe. Homosexuals are beaten and/or murdered everywhere, including throughout the Western world. Minorities face bigotry and discrimination everywhere in the world, not just in the Middle East.

It is easy to blame and attack the "other"... but a few moments of serious examination of our own cultures shows that we're not blameless, and that the issues surrounding violence are more complex than most people give credit to. It is easy to feel good about yourself by ignoring the flaws in your own culture, and attacking the flaws in other cultures. That whole "nuance" thing is tough, but we're mostly intelligent people here, and we can do better than what has been displayed in threads like these. We do not have to EVER accept or condone evil in other cultures, but it is hypocrisy to declare ourselves free of fault, even relatively, when we condemn that evil.

I have searched and I can't find any instances in the west where Catholic priests are exempted or face lesser punishment from laws against pedophilia. I also can't find any laws that exempt sports fans from being punished if they riot, or laws that allow you to commit a crime against a homosexual, simply because they are homosexuals. I can find laws that punish you more severly for the same crime against a minority or homosexual than if the same crime is commited agianst a straight, white male. In the middle east/muslim world, the honor killing is often institutionalized into law. I think we can easily say that there is nothing comparable to honor killing institutionalized in the western world today.
 
You know this would be a nice argument IF you could find ANY catholic doctrine or even ANY people CLAIMING to practice Catholicism who advocate child molestation based on their faith!

<snip>

I don't think I would even go that far. This thread is about the practice of honour killing, specifically, and not about any other atrocities that may or may not occur more or less in various cultures.

I don't think it's even necessary to have an opinion about the relative merits of different cultures in order to discuss this specific practice, how it has arisen in the places where it exists, and what, if anything, should be done about it.

Let's try to stay on topic here, and perhaps start a new thread if you really want to discuss which culture may be better or worse than others.
 
I doubt that, since this "concept of honour" has been around since the early days of Islam and for about 1400 years now.

In fact, from my reading of various Muslim and non-Muslim sources, the practice appears to have been endemic in pre-Islamic tribal Arabic societies. The introduction of Islam did nothing to stop the practice, or many other similar pre-Islamic "female purity" practices, such as female genital mutilation; and different Islamic sects appear to have adopted them wholesale.

Something a lot of non-Muslims don't realize is just how variable and amorphous Islam really is. Christianity, Buddhism, Judaism, and most other major religious have a fairly well-defined set of holy scriptures and/or dogmas. Most of the schisms between the sects typically come as a result of differences of interpretation of the texts, rather than arguments over what exactly constitutes the holy texts themselves. There are exceptions, but not many. Islam, by contrast, has no well-defined set of texts outside the Quran. Like much of the rest of the Arabic world, the religion depends heavily on cult of personality. Schisms originally came about from disagreements over who would be the religio-political successor to Mohammad, and the leader of the world of Islam. On a relatively equal footing with the Quran is the hadith, the collected oral history of Mohammad's actions and teachings. Since the hadith were predominantly oral for over a century after Mohammad's death, there is a huge amount of debate over which ones are authentic, whether they should be accepted, and what the proper interpretation should be. The problem is that, unlike the relationship between the Torah and the Talmud, the Quran cannot be understood and interpreted seperately from the hadith. While they're not actually necessary for the religion, they are critical for application of the holy scripture to jusrisprudence and everyday life, and are thus inextricably linked to it. There is a strong belief by many secular Arabic and Persian scholars that few of them are authentic, and most were created long after the time of Mohammad to justify various practices not mentioned in the Quran or more reliable traditions.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom