Death was the least that she deserved

We westerners are trying to supplant their babaric moral codes with our own which in our eyes are a much better moral code. It will take time if it will ever happen. It takes generations to change such barbarism. Remember, these are the same people who were there before the war.
 
If you read the article, I don't think there is any other description for the father than barbarian. He certainly does have a barbaric moral code and it certainly seems to be shared by quite a few other Iraqis and Muslims.

Of course, that does not mean that every Iraqi or every Muslim shares that code or that our code is necessarily better in every way.
 
Islamic Family Values are an important cultural component of the religious experience in certain parts of the world.
 
So there are murderous psychos in Iraq, besides the usual suspects. What's the point of this thread?
 
Was this kind of behaviour allowed under Saddam's regime?

I am not sure but it sounds typical of the mindset of various Islamic communities in the middle east who are basically a bunch of destitute poor people ruled by filthy rich people. Life has little value. These people were probably Saddam supporters. Saddam himself has done worse.
 
Was this kind of behaviour allowed under Saddam's regime?

I don't really know, but I'm going to guess that it would have depended on the political connections of the perp. Saddam and his cronies could kill anyone with impunity. Less connected or important people, probably could not. But I don't know about the special case of honour killings.
 
I am not sure but it sounds typical of the mindset of various Islamic communities in the middle east who are basically a bunch of destitute poor people ruled by filthy rich people. Life has little value. These people were probably Saddam supporters. Saddam himself has done worse.

Sure he did. Not sure we can draw that the people were supporters of him. As far as I can gauge, Iraq wasn't a typical mid-east country and there was very little poverty under Saddam. Again, I'll stand to be corrected, but that impression comes from talking to Iraqis who were there.

What is YOUR point?

That this is stupid, wrong, and avoidable.

What's yours?

I don't really know, but I'm going to guess that it would have depended on the political connections of the perp. Saddam and his cronies could kill anyone with impunity. Less connected or important people, probably could not. But I don't know about the special case of honour killings.

Pretty sure honour killings were a strict no-no. Can't have competition for the killing fields.
 
What is YOUR point?

I believe that T_A's point is that the chaos caused by the invasion and the new regime (supported by the allies, including my country, Australia) has allowed people such as this father to murder their children without penalty. He is implying that under Saddam, such things would not have occurred. He is condemming this person and their beliefs, not all Iraqis and their beliefs and not all Muslims and their beliefs.

I agree with the first part, but don't know enough to be able to say whether this would or would not have happened under Saddam. Certainly, the intervention has not changed the heart and mind of this man and has not led to a better life for his daughter. While I support the overthrow of Saddam, I can no longer say that I am convinced that the intervention has improved things for the Iraqis overall or made the Middle East and the West safer overall.
 
A single, simple, solution does not always answer a complex problem, and Basra Iraq is one of those kinds. An answer might lie in a multifaceted approach that balances several strategies. If any of the parts are neglected, the problem would continue unresolved, or even grow worse.

Law enforcement
If the police are cheerleaders to murder as a solution, then murder will be done. Equality under secular law is a basic foundation of a civilized society - whatever else we think of its religion or other cultural values. The people will get what they reward or punish by their laws. Let law rule, and enforce it. Murderers are punished not rewarded.

Education
Stop teaching hate. Start it young. Persist for generations.

Protection
Provide shelter or refuge for the implementers if they need it. Do not underestimate the potential for violence in defense of the status quo. The reaction to attempts at change is to kill you. Deal with that option by providing a protected environment that people can flee to if needed. (The environ needs to incorporate Law, Education, and perhaps even more layers of social protection). Weaken your enemies, strengthen and protect your friends.
 
I believe that T_A's point is that the chaos caused by the invasion and the new regime (supported by the allies, including my country, Australia) has allowed people such as this father to murder their children without penalty. He is implying that under Saddam, such things would not have occurred. He is condemming this person and their beliefs, not all Iraqis and their beliefs and not all Muslims and their beliefs.

I agree with the first part, but don't know enough to be able to say whether this would or would not have happened under Saddam. Certainly, the intervention has not changed the heart and mind of this man and has not led to a better life for his daughter. While I support the overthrow of Saddam, I can no longer say that I am convinced that the intervention has improved things for the Iraqis overall or made the Middle East and the West safer overall.
The only thing I can see is that there are nutball psychopaths all over the world, and there's nothing particularly surprising that they exist in Iraq. America has a pretty significant number of this kind of loser, and I'm sure every country on Earth can say the same.
 
I believe that T_A's point is that the chaos caused by the invasion and the new regime (supported by the allies, including my country, Australia) has allowed people such as this father to murder their children without penalty. He is implying that under Saddam, such things would not have occurred. He is condemming this person and their beliefs, not all Iraqis and their beliefs and not all Muslims and their beliefs.

I agree with the first part, but don't know enough to be able to say whether this would or would not have happened under Saddam. Certainly, the intervention has not changed the heart and mind of this man and has not led to a better life for his daughter. While I support the overthrow of Saddam, I can no longer say that I am convinced that the intervention has improved things for the Iraqis overall or made the Middle East and the West safer overall.

I suggest you get an application in for the mio before it's retired!
 
A basic difference is that in America the psychopaths are not revered.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom