Death was the least that she deserved

Should give us pause about calling them barbarians. Nowhere has it been suggested or even implied that this sort of behavior should be tolerated anywhere. Just that it can take place anywhere.

I feel perfectly justified calling the father and the people who facillitated or support his actions barbarians. If you can point to someone else who has done similar things then I will call them barbarians as well.

At the end of the day, I cannot see how people who believe that this is an acceptable part of their religion or culture can have a place in civillised society.
 
Was this kind of behaviour allowed under Saddam's regime?
Absolutely! In fact, in 1990 Saddam "reformed" the laws in Iraq to specifically exempt men from being charged for murder of a female relative if they suspected her of having sex outside of marriage. At least 4,000 Iraqi women were killed in this way in the 1990's.

And it's just like you to avoid the slightest bit of research before you blather away from your fortress of ignorance. But don't worry, my internet came with this thing called "Google", it's really cool! You should upgrade.

From Human Rights Watch:
Women and girls have also suffered from increasing restrictions on their freedom of mobility and protections under the law.26 In collusion with conservative religious groups and tribal leaders, the government issued numerous decrees and introduced legislation negatively impacting women's legal status in the labor code, criminal justice system, and personal status laws.27 In 2001, the U.N. Special Rapporteur for Violence against Women reported that since the passage of the reforms in 1991, an estimated 4,000 women and girls had been victims of "honor killings."28

From Amnesty International USA:
Take for example Zakkia Hakki, one of Iraq's first female judges, who worked for women's rights in the country's more liberal north before moving to Washington for work and scholarship. With her kohl-lined eyes and easy smile, she sits wrapped head to toe in black behind a desk in the temporary Ministry of Justice office in one of Saddam's former Baghdad palaces. Her job includes reforming the laws Saddam delivered in 1990, as he sought to consolidate power and appease demoralized men in the wake of the disastrous Iran-Iraq war. These changes blended tribal law and sharia to codify women's oppression, and to obliterate the Baathists' secular and fairly liberal legacy of gender parity.

Under Saddam's 1990 "reforms," a rapist's crime is erased if he marries his victim. A male relative is not guilty of murdering his female relative if she had sexual intercourse — including rape — that could dishonor the family. And a man is allowed to take up to four wives.
 
I feel perfectly justified calling the father and the people who facillitated or support his actions barbarians. If you can point to someone else who has done similar things then I will call them barbarians as well.

At the end of the day, I cannot see how people who believe that this is an acceptable part of their religion or culture can have a place in civillised society.
I agree. Considering the quotes around "them" in JoeEllison's post, however, I think he was referring to generalized cultural terms of them and us, as in "us = Westeners" and "them = Iraqis". You are referring to moral terms, as in "us = people who do not accept that behavior" and "them = people who do". I don't think he meant to object to that.

But I'll stop guessing what he means. He can speak for himself.
 
And I have a daughter too, and there is nothing she could ever do that would make me want to kill her, nothing.
Well... There is that one thing.

"Hey Dad guess what? I was exploring some washing machine cardboard boxes under the I-10 interchange and what did I find inside one? This really cool guy named Raidey! I felt sorry that he was living in such a small place so I invited him to live with us! Aren't I cool? Dad? Um... Dad??? You want to put down the John Deere riding mower? DAD!"
 
Absolutely! In fact, in 1990 Saddam "reformed" the laws in Iraq to specifically exempt men from being charged for murder of a female relative if they suspected her of having sex outside of marriage. At least 4,000 Iraqi women were killed in this way in the 1990's.

Do you make a career out of being wrong?

Hint: If we were talking about a girl being killed because she had had or was suspected of having sex, then you might even have a point. Since it's clear that wasn't the case, yet again, you're just wrong.

Note from linked article: "I don't have a daughter now, and I prefer to say that I never had one. That girl humiliated me in front of my family and friends. Speaking with a foreign soldier, she lost what is the most precious thing for any woman."

And it's just like you to avoid the slightest bit of research before you blather away from your fortress of ignorance. But don't worry, my internet came with this thing called "Google", it's really cool! You should upgrade.

I just thought that was worth repeating in the circumstances.

;)
 
I do not think it is adequate to dismiss this as barbarism. If we are serious about cultural difference then this is what we are talking about and what we need to try to understand. I do not wish anyone to think I defend it. I am not a cultural relativist and I have often used the Napier quote because I think it very well expresses the fact that we are equally wedded to our customs. Part of the problem I seem to see is that we tend to think our own values are right in some absolute sense, and to play down the fact that they are indeed cultural values, nonetheless.

What strikes me is the fact that the mindset is alien. I have seen it argued that this difference arises from the enlightenment, which elevated the individual above the group. This is very deeply embedded in my outlook and I think that is true for many of us to the extent that we cannot recognise it any more. It is very hard to imagine that someone can believe that they can be truly dishonoured by the action of another, and I think this is because we are individualistic and so we locate all fault and all consequence within the individual. If a member of my family committed a horrible crime I think I would be sad; and perhaps feel guilty that I had not done enough to prevent that. I might feel embarrassed and take some responsibility for it. But I would not truly be shamed. I would still think it was fundamentally that person's responsibility and not mine.

I do not think that was so true before the enlightenment and certainly there are old folk ballads about this kind of thing and also some literature which suggests it was at least recognisable in europe in the past: there are also some hangovers of this kind of thinking which can be seen even today: for example there was a recent study showing that quite a surprisingly high number of young people consider it legitimate to hit a partner who has been unfaithful. I am not saying this is the same but I do think we have some legacy now very dilute.

For this man he has actually been shamed in a profound way and he has taken the action he sees as necessary to expunge that shame. Many moslems do not agree with his views: but the incidence of honour killing suggests that this is quite a widespread view within that culture. I am not certain it is caused by the religion, though separating religion and culture can be difficult, and there are feminist moslem scholars who make the case very strongly that much of this is based on the values of an arabian society and not on islam at all. There is some reason to accept that analysis though I am not well educated in the arguments.

For us the task is to try to understand this. I have seen it described as a distinction between a "shame culture" and a "guilt culture" (though those terms are more often used to distinguish far eastern and western values) and I think that sheds some light here.

Then we need to think about what objective reasons we have to elevate the individual above the group, and why that is better in some absolute sense.

Again we need to spell out why this is not just a different conception of justice: after all in the US the death penalty has a lot of support (if I am wrong about that then I apologise) and arguably the difference here is only about who constitutes the legitimate authority for determining guilt and sentence when a person commits a serious offence. For the strand of his culture this man represents, the authority is the family and in particular the father. I find that wrong but I think it is important to elaborate why it is wrong in some objective way.

If we do not attempt to understand this mindset I think it unlikely we can ever find ways to live peaceably together.
 
Last edited:
Do you make a career out of being wrong?
Don't think so. And certainly not in this case.

Hint: If we were talking about a girl being killed because she had had or was suspected of having sex, then you might even have a point. Since it's clear that wasn't the case, yet again, you're just wrong.
Are you sure about that?

Note from linked article: "I don't have a daughter now, and I prefer to say that I never had one. That girl humiliated me in front of my family and friends. Speaking with a foreign soldier, she lost what is the most precious thing for any woman."
Wait, what was that last bit? The part right after your bolded part? Maybe the full quote will put it in context...

'I don't have a daughter now, and I prefer to say that I never had one. That girl humiliated me in front of my family and friends. Speaking with a foreign solider, she lost what is the most precious thing for any woman. 'People from western countries might be shocked, but our girls are not like their daughters that can sleep with any man they want and sometimes even get pregnant without marrying. Our girls should respect their religion, their family and their bodies.
Hmmm, doesn't seem like daddy thought she was just speaking to him!

I just thought that was worth repeating in the circumstances.
Indeed.
 
Last edited:
...

Dunno whether you know, but the burning widows are usually self-immolatory deaths. I don't think Hinuds burn the women, they just tell the women to burn themselves.

Humans.

And then there are bride burnings.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/programmes/crossing_continents/3071963.stm

And to a lesser degree bride abandonment

http://www.canada.com/theprovince/features/brides/story.html?id=a392f07a-6807-43be-83f1-b834f9568cf3

You see, I have a vagina, therefore I am the property of a man. There is a distinct monetary value to my life, my physical beauty, my virginity, and my fertility. I do not have a will of my own or thoughts of my own. I must be careful in everything I do lest I shame the man that owns me, be he my father, my brother, my husband. If I shame him or I am not worthy of the price that was paid, my life, my physical and emotional well-being are forfeit.

Patriarchy Gone Wild!

ETA: Expanding

So here I am, a liberated female in the West. I get to wear pants, hot pants, bustiers, clever T-shirts, long skirts, mini skirts, cute little dresses, and push-up bras. I can vote. I could drive if I wished. I can go to school and learn math. The only person expecting me to start pushing out babies is my mom, who also raised me to be an old-school feminist (equality, people, equality). I like, "guy," things. I enjoy sex. I occasionally enjoy finagling what tits I have to produce cleavage.

I have a flake of a father and a few... unstable ex-boyfriends.

The idea that there are people in the world who are absolutely certain that these people should dictate every facet of my being and not allow me to be who I amsimply because my gonads are closer to my kidneys is discomforting to say the least. Even with an utter saint of a lover now, I still wouldn't allow him to dominate me in such a way.
 
Last edited:
What strikes me is the fact that the mindset is alien. I have seen it argued that this difference arises from the enlightenment, which elevated the individual above the group. This is very deeply embedded in my outlook and I think that is true for many of us to the extent that we cannot recognise it any more. It is very hard to imagine that someone can believe that they can be truly dishonoured by the action of another, and I think this is because we are individualistic and so we locate all fault and all consequence within the individual. If a member of my family committed a
If we do not attempt to understand this mindset I think it unlikely we can ever find ways to live peaceably together.
I think the Muslim acceptance of Honor Killings may have been introduced from some of the cultures they conquered to allow for an easier conversion. Islam absorbed many cultures and like the Catholic Church it may have allowed the integration of certain rituals into the practice in some primitive areas. You see honor killings in several African tribes that are not Muslim and you see it in certain areas of India. At one time Texas had a "in the heat of passion" law that excused a husband for shooting his wife if he found her in bed with another man. He couldn't kill the guy however since he may have not known she was married. I doubt it is still in effect but it is a fairly modern western example of "honor killing" although it has been used as a defense in some murder trials.
 
You see, I have a vagina, therefore I am the property of a man. There is a distinct monetary value to my life, my physical beauty, my virginity, and my fertility. I do not have a will of my own or thoughts of my own. I must be careful in everything I do lest I shame the man that owns me, be he my father, my brother, my husband. If I shame him or I am not worthy of the price that was paid, my life, my physical and emotional well-being are forfeit.

You really do know your place!

At one time Texas had a "in the heat of passion" law that excused a husband for shooting his wife if he found her in bed with another man. He couldn't kill the guy however since he may have not known she was married. I doubt it is still in effect but it is a fairly modern western example of "honor killing" although it has been used as a defense in some murder trials.

"Crime passionnelle" was allowable as a complete defence in South Africa until the 1970s at least and it was certainly a partial defence in many other countries prior to that.
 
Don't think so. And certainly not in this case.


Are you sure about that?


Wait, what was that last bit? The part right after your bolded part? Maybe the full quote will put it in context...


Hmmm, doesn't seem like daddy thought she was just speaking to him!


Indeed.

One thing about the culture over there that may be lost on a lot of Westerners is that it is assumed (by men) that an adult man and an adult woman cannot actually be alone together without sex taking place.
 
You really do know your place!
...

Honestly, if I had my mental blocks up and wasn't so wigged out, I'd find that funnier. I know you're joking, and I'm fine with that, I just feel a bit ill at the whole dominance thing. Having an ex who would have a tantrum when I didn't share his opinion of some movie/CD/book was enough for me.
 
Honestly, if I had my mental blocks up and wasn't so wigged out, I'd find that funnier. I know you're joking, and I'm fine with that, I just feel a bit ill at the whole dominance thing. Having an ex who would have a tantrum when I didn't share his opinion of some movie/CD/book was enough for me.

At least you can be thankful he's the ex.
 
I think the Muslim acceptance of Honor Killings may have been introduced from some of the cultures they conquered to allow for an easier conversion.

I doubt that, since this "concept of honour" has been around since the early days of Islam and for about 1400 years now. Many things can affect the "family honour", like Prometheus said:

One thing about the culture over there that may be lost on a lot of Westerners is that it is assumed (by men) that an adult man and an adult woman cannot actually be alone together without sex taking place.

Another things that came to my mind is simply apostasy from Islam, which is - if the person is not insane or repents and goes back to being a Muslim - punished by death.

She died on March 16 after her father discovered she had been seen in public talking to Paul, considered to be the enemy, the invader and a Christian.

I'm pretty sure Muslims shouldn't do this, especially Muslim women.

"I don't regret it. I had the support of all my friends who are fathers, like me, and know what she did was unacceptable to any Muslim that honours his religion."
That girl humiliated me in front of my family and friends. Speaking with a foreign soldier, she lost what is the most precious thing for any woman.
Speaking with a foreign soldier, she lost what is the most precious thing for any woman.
Our girls should respect their religion, their family and their bodies.
I know God is blessing me for what I did
These crimes deserve death - death in the name of God

Anyone noticed how he blames his (ex-)wife?

He said his daughter's "bad genes were passed on from her mother"

Yes, Islam - religion of peace and tolerance. Peace when the non-Muslims are subjugated or dead, tolerant of killing others for their (un)belief. Yea. To think Muslims and Islam needed anyone from the outside to make them look bad.. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
some sects beleive in versions of Islam which do support it; which is practically all of the more radical fundamentalist versions.

I think it's easier to find versions which aren't for "honour killings", like killing apostastes or fornicators. So which would that be? I'm not familiar with Shiite law but I remember they draw their legislation from Quran and Sunnah. Same for Sunnis, although they got their fiqhs. Since the family here is Shiite and act this way, I don't see much of a difference between Sunnis and Shia right now.
 
Last edited:
I doubt that, since this "concept of honour" has been around since the early days of Islam and for about 1400 years now. Many things can affect the "family honour", like

I'm curious about this point. As has been pointed out, honour killings are common in several non-muslim societies. Also, muslim apologists often decry our (Westerners) complaints about the way they treat women, claiming that Islam actually represented a vast improvement in the plight of women over what they experienced in the culture that Islam supplanted. For instance, Islam prescribes that a man can have only four wives, and further limits polygamy by insisting that he pay a proper bride-price for each, and have the means to support each of them. Before Islam, there was no such limitation in some Arab cultures. Islam also specifically limits the sorts of punishments that men can apply to their women, whereas the earlier cultures basically allowed men to do whatever they wanted. Islam gave women several freedoms and rights that Western women did not achieve until centuries later.

Of course the West has mostly leapfrogged over these early Islamic advances, while muslim society has remained largely static.

Anyway, I'm not sure about honour-killing specifically, but I think it's at least plausible that it was even more common in nomadic desert societies, and that Islam may have limited its application.
 
Anyway, I'm not sure about honour-killing specifically, but I think it's at least plausible that it was even more common in nomadic desert societies, and that Islam may have limited its application.
I do think that there is a primitive strategy behind the culture.

In the arid countries of origin, the amount of resources are very limited and there is competition. To be successful a culture needs to maximize their striking power (% males). In such cultures males are preferred and females are regarded as a necessary evil. This could easily lead to practices to make women more obedient and kill those who aren't. The excess males will either die in battle or take women from the enemy.

A highly aggressive evolutionary strategy, that is quite harmful for the environment and culture.
 
I do think that there is a primitive strategy behind the culture.

In the arid countries of origin, the amount of resources are very limited and there is competition. To be successful a culture needs to maximize their striking power (% males). In such cultures males are preferred and females are regarded as a necessary evil. This could easily lead to practices to make women more obedient and kill those who aren't. The excess males will either die in battle or take women from the enemy.

A highly aggressive evolutionary strategy, that is quite harmful for the environment and culture.

Interesting viewpoint.

I'm curious about this point. As has been pointed out, honour killings are common in several non-muslim societies. Also, muslim apologists often decry our (Westerners) complaints about the way they treat women, claiming that Islam actually represented a vast improvement in the plight of women over what they experienced in the culture that Islam supplanted. For instance, Islam prescribes that a man can have only four wives, and further limits polygamy by insisting that he pay a proper bride-price for each, and have the means to support each of them. Before Islam, there was no such limitation in some Arab cultures. Islam also specifically limits the sorts of punishments that men can apply to their women, whereas the earlier cultures basically allowed men to do whatever they wanted. Islam gave women several freedoms and rights that Western women did not achieve until centuries later.

Some things paint a different picture, including a couple of hadith I've seen and something which was mentioned in Tabari's recordings of Islam's history. I'm currently reading a bit here and this. Unfortuneately it's hard to verify Tabari and to own the collection is even harder, but maybe it can be found online. Maybe I will find some things once the Sira by Ibn Ishaq arrives, which I could finally order. :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom