Death was the least that she deserved

All those police officers congratulating him rather than imprisoning him really turned my stomach as well.

Certainly, the fact that he was some sort of folk hero should give us pause. It is easy to SAY that 'we" are better than "them"... as long as we ignore the "we" that are just like "them"...
 
If you read the article, I don't think there is any other description for the father than barbarian. He certainly does have a barbaric moral code and it certainly seems to be shared by quite a few other Iraqis and Muslims.

Of course, that does not mean that every Iraqi or every Muslim shares that code or that our code is necessarily better in every way.

The police "congratulated him" and sent him on his way after 2 hours.

Some are probably opposed, but they're hiding out of necessity at the moment. I wouldn't hold my breath for much cultural shift in my lifetime.





On the positive side, if you can think there is one, you are seeing evolution in action. Slaughtering your offspring is not the way to perpetuate yourself.
 
Wasn't it only around two generations ago that in some places in the USA, you could publically beat, castrate, hang and even burn alive a Negro in public, without getting arrested? Even get congratulated for taking an "uppity ******" off the streets?
So cultural shifts can happen. Course, it needs a big push from above.
 
Well, at least when a Colleen ended up in bed with a Para, the IRA girls only used to beat the girl senseless, shave her head and completely ostracise her.

Iraqi girls aren't quite so lucky.

Great to see such a humane regime installed in Iraq.
I do hope the mother poisons all three of the feces eating products of a camel's digestive system - something really painful and lingering. Or the British lad and some of his friends do it better.:mad:



VD W18
 
So there are murderous psychos in Iraq, besides the usual suspects. What's the point of this thread?
Possibly the point that these murderous psychos get off because they are supported by many other syphilitic rectal orifices.
 
Wasn't it only around two generations ago that in some places in the USA, you could publically beat, castrate, hang and even burn alive a Negro in public, without getting arrested? Even get congratulated for taking an "uppity ******" off the streets?
So cultural shifts can happen. Course, it needs a big push from above.

It was a family event.

But the civil rights movement that ended it didn't actually come from, "above," it actually came from the people who got the government to get their **** together and enforce the 14th Amendment. Then they sent out the National Guard to take kids to school.
 
It was a family event.

But the civil rights movement that ended it didn't actually come from, "above," it actually came from the people who got the government to get their **** together and enforce the 14th Amendment. Then they sent out the National Guard to take kids to school.

And for that to happen took 100 years or so. Not very encouraging.


On the other hand, stopping certain things from happening in my country took some very determined action from "above" (from across the Atlantic, more precisely), but ugly things stopped happening pretty much immediately after the "Mission Accomplished" signs went up.

All it took was the will to apply the appropriate kind of pressure, and of course the manpower to do so.
 
This is terribly depressing. Murdered for talking to a Christian.
 
I am not sure but it sounds typical of the mindset of various Islamic communities in the middle east who are basically a bunch of destitute poor people ruled by filthy rich people. Life has little value. These people were probably Saddam supporters. Saddam himself has done worse.

Actually, part of the problem, as I see it, is that in that culture life does have a specific calculable value. Had Rand survived to be married, the groom would have been required to pay her father a bride-price that would be calculated based on her family's social standing among other things. If she were publicly believed to have carried on with this British soldier, the money her father could have "sold" her for would have been substantially reduced, if he were able to marry her off at all, and she certainly could never have married into a family that would raise her own family's social standing. This wasn't just religious delusion, it was a cold business decision.

The notion that we could ever have walked in and installed a Jefersonian democracy on top of this centuries old cultural norm is total woo.
 
Last edited:
The father is convinced that God is blessing him for what he did. The mother has a different idea of God's view of the matter:

"Now, my lovely Rose is in her grave. But, God will make her father pay, either in this world ... or in the world after."

Both are convinced that God is on their side.

This is not an isolated example: the article state that more than thirty 'honour' killings have been registered in Basra since January. In the name of Allah.
 
I do hope the mother poisons all three of the feces eating products of a camel's digestive system - something really painful and lingering. Or the British lad and some of his friends do it better.:mad:

The mother already divorced him and left the area. She's in hiding because she's received death threats from other members of the family.
 
You say that it is your custom to burn widows. Very well. We also have a custom: when men burn a woman alive, we tie a rope around their necks and we hang them. Build your funeral pyre; beside it, my carpenters will build a gallows. You may follow your custom. And then we will follow ours.

General Sir Charles James Napier
 
I believe that T_A's point is that the chaos caused by the invasion and the new regime (supported by the allies, including my country, Australia) has allowed people such as this father to murder their children without penalty. He is implying that under Saddam, such things would not have occurred. He is condemming this person and their beliefs, not all Iraqis and their beliefs and not all Muslims and their beliefs.
No, but some sects beleive in versions of Islam which do support it; which is practically all of the more radical fundamentalist versions.
I agree with the first part, but don't know enough to be able to say whether this would or would not have happened under Saddam. Certainly, the intervention has not changed the heart and mind of this man and has not led to a better life for his daughter. While I support the overthrow of Saddam, I can no longer say that I am convinced that the intervention has improved things for the Iraqis overall or made the Middle East and the West safer overall.
It did happen, but was not necessarily without penalty, depending on whether you belonged to the state-sanctioned version of Islam or not.

And honor killings exist even in the enlightened West.
http://www.humanevents.com/article.php?id=24329
http://www.canada.com/vancouversun/story.html?id=d05e437f-4661-4965-9455-ff30c6b9d4a5&k=20265
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/london/3149030.stm
 
This is terribly depressing. Murdered for talking to a Christian.

Makes a change friom being whipped for being raped, I guess.

The father is convinced that God is blessing him for what he did.

This is not an isolated example: the article state that more than thirty 'honour' killings have been registered in Basra since January. In the name of Allah.

Certainly the strangest use of the word "honour". Maybe we should refer to them as "sharia law murders".

You say that it is your custom to burn widows. Very well. We also have a custom: when men burn a woman alive, we tie a rope around their necks and we hang them. Build your funeral pyre; beside it, my carpenters will build a gallows. You may follow your custom. And then we will follow ours.

General Sir Charles James Napier

That's beautiful.

Except it doesn't work in reality.

Dunno whether you know, but the burning widows are usually self-immolatory deaths. I don't think Hinuds burn the women, they just tell the women to burn themselves.

Humans.
 
Certainly, the fact that he was some sort of folk hero should give us pause. It is easy to SAY that 'we" are better than "them"... as long as we ignore the "we" that are just like "them"...
Should give us pause? Are you seriously suggesting that western (for want of a better term) cultures would tolerate this?
 
Should give us pause? Are you seriously suggesting that western (for want of a better term) cultures would tolerate this?
Should give us pause about calling them barbarians. Nowhere has it been suggested or even implied that this sort of behavior should be tolerated anywhere. Just that it can take place anywhere.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom