Kevin_Lowe
Unregistered
- Joined
- Feb 10, 2003
- Messages
- 12,221
There is nothing silly about it. If someone alleges, without a shred of evidence, that the black vote is being "suppressed," pointing to a huge increase in black voter turnout calls the allegation into question. Is it reasonable to infer the existence of a program if the effect is exactly the opposite of what the program is designed to accomplish?
Are you asking whether it's reasonable to take the alleged incident of vote suppression as fact (which nobody has done)? Or are you asking whether it's reasonable to take the alleged incident of vote suppression as plausible?
I'll be charitable and assume you are asking the second question, because the first question would be a foolish one to ask. It seems to me to be plausible firstly because organised vote suppression in Democratic-leaning areas within Republican-controlled electorates was proven elsewhere in the 2004 elections, and because a place where a major turnout increase in the Democratic party's favour was likely is exactly the kind of place where you would want to suppress the Democratic vote.
The mere fact that turnout increased compared to the previous year is not proof that no suppression occurred, any more than it would be proof that nobody was embezzling money if a company's profits went up in a given year.
The whole argument about voter suppression is a cynical ploy by Democrats to allow them to employ their time-tested techniques of vote fraud unhindered. Disenfranchisement not a difficult concept: a person attempts to register in the district where he or she resides and is prevented from doing so. That's all there is to it.
There's not a lot of non-partisan discussion of this issue, so you can be forigven for thinking that if most of your media exposure comes from pro-Republican sources.
The fact is in recent political history the number of proven pro-Republican incidents of vote suppression, and highly suspicious incidents circumstantially evidencing outright pro-Republican vote fraud, dwarf the number and scope of pro-Democratic incidents.
The pro-Democratic wrongdoing boils down to the tire-slashing incident (promptly reported by Demorcatic party members themselves and appropriately dealt with), and stories about zombie voters which despite a lot of talk always come to nothing, despite orders from the top for prosecutors to ferret out any such activity.
I just can't see how "zombie voting" can be used as an efficient way to steal an election anyway. The best payoff you ccould get would be a few votes per active conspirator, it would take a lot of organising and travel, everyone involved risks a criminal charge at every step, and assembling thousands (or tens of thousands) of known-good identities to assume and distributing them to the faithful would be a Herculean task. You seem to think it is plausible that this inefficient form of fraud could be incredibly widespread yet Republican prosecutors could never pin it on anyone, and I find that hard to believe.
Before you get started on party political talk, bear in mind I'm an Australian and in terms of policy I don't care for either of your two parties nor do I see a great deal of difference between them.
It's interesting that Greg Palast can continually shriek about the "millions" of voters who have had their voting rights stolen by the monstrous, racist Republicans without ever being able to produce even one such voter. Peter Kirsanow, a member of the Civil Rights Commission, has written extensively on this subject, thoroughly refuting Palast's fabrications.
I seem to recall that footage of people walking away from the long lines at certain Ohio polling stations was available at the time. At the same time, producing one or two people who claimed to have been disenfranchised would prove little with regard to a charge of millions being disenfranchised anyway.