Merged Concerns over baby killer ignored? / Nurse Lucy Letby killed babies in her care

Dr Dewi Evans has now changed his mind about the way in which Baby C was killed.

https://archive.is/2024.10.01-20365...s/2024/10/01/lucy-letby-witness-changed-mind/

At Letby’s trial, the jury was told that Baby C had been killed “by air inserted into his stomach via the nasogastric tube, not into his bloodstream”.

However, it then emerged that Letby was not working, and had not been in the hospital for two days when the X-ray showing this bubble was taken.

Dr Evans now says Letby killed Baby C by air in the bloodstream.

Prof Colin Morely, a retired professor of neonatology from the University of Cambridge, told the BBC he believed Baby C had died from natural causes.
Given how many experts rubbished his idea, a change of mind isn't unexpected.
 
Last edited:
Anyone can assert anything when not under cross-examination. It makes me laugh when sympathetic journalists refer to 'experts' and then cite ordinary GP's (who signed some petition) or more recently a doctor sitting in his armchair in New Zealand. It's ridiculous. Both my son and his dad are chartered statisticians and his dad is also a Royal Society member, with two PhD's and a handful of Masters, yet neither of them would dream of claiming to know anything whatsoever about the Letby trial, as "experts" (like Dr. Gill), although I dare say Dr Hammond of PRIVATE EYE and the well-funded organised innocence campaigners would refer to them as 'experts' who know better than the Cheshire police and the Crown Court and the Appeal Courts, were they to express any interest.

It's a joke.
 
Andy Lewis has a Quackometer blog post on cognitive biases and reasoning errors in relation to the evidence in the Letby case.

As if Year One university science students aren't taught about confirmation bias or the halo effect as a matter of course. And in fact, the whole point of Analysis of Variance (statistical ANOVA) is to iron out random results that aren't significant.

But hey, let's get Justice Goss to read the article by Andy Lewis, who has only just discovered the perfect defence,

LOL.
 
As if Year One university science students aren't taught about confirmation bias or the halo effect as a matter of course. And in fact, the whole point of Analysis of Variance (statistical ANOVA) is to iron out random results that aren't significant.
But hey, let's get Justice Goss to read the article by Andy Lewis, who has only just discovered the perfect defence,

LOL.

Really? Do you know who ran this ANOVA test and what data was put into it? I assume that you are using some conventional notion of statistical significance here, are you, where if the p-values are less than 0.05, there is only a one in twenty chance that the deaths apparently lining up with Letby's shifts is random.
 
Anyone can assert anything when not under cross-examination. It makes me laugh when sympathetic journalists refer to 'experts' and then cite ordinary GP's (who signed some petition) or more recently a doctor sitting in his armchair in New Zealand. It's ridiculous. Both my son and his dad are chartered statisticians and his dad is also a Royal Society member, with two PhD's and a handful of Masters, yet neither of them would dream of claiming to know anything whatsoever about the Letby trial, as "experts" (like Dr. Gill), although I dare say Dr Hammond of PRIVATE EYE and the well-funded organised innocence campaigners would refer to them as 'experts' who know better than the Cheshire police and the Crown Court and the Appeal Courts, were they to express any interest.

It's a joke.

Right. But what happens when an "expert" claims Letby inflated a baby's stomach with air, as evinced by an X-ray, even though Letby was not on shift between the baby's birth and the X-ray being taken?

Key to the case was an X-ray taken on 12 June - it was referred to repeatedly during the first trial. In pre-trial reports two prosecution witnesses said it showed the baby had a swollen stomach “most likely due to deliberate” pumping of air into his feeding tube.
However, neonatologist Dr Michael Hall - who has spoken publicly about his concerns before, and has written to the chair of the public inquiry - told the BBC: “There are a number of possible explanations for there being excess gas there.”

Dr Hall, who was consulted by the defence but never called to give evidence, said it is likely to have been caused by the respiratory support the baby was receiving and said the X-ray suggested there was a bowel obstruction.
Letby was not working on the day the X-ray was taken and had not been on shift since before the baby was born - information the jury heard in her first trial. Letby’s former barrister Ben Myers also highlighted these details in his closing argument.

In his summing up the judge made clear to the jury this X-ray had been taken the day before Baby C collapsed, though he didn’t remind them Letby hadn’t been on shift. At appeal, the prosecution said Letby could have visited the hospital while off shift, but didn’t put forward any evidence that she was there.

Link
 
Dr Phil Hammond is ... NOT, repeat NOT an expert or a specialist in the paediatics of premature births.


...

His opinions are at odds with those of his colleagues who DID testify at the trial and those doctors ARE experts in the paediatrics of premature births.

One of those was Dr Dewi Evans....

Maybe YOU should DM Dr Hammond and tell him to contact his colleague Dr Evans, who will explain it all to him!

I get it. You've got your panties in a bunch because I found a more qualified medical expert than yours. Well Boo Hoo!

Hmmm...




Dr Dewi Evans has now changed his mind about the way in which Baby C was killed.

At Letby’s trial, the jury was told that Baby C had been killed “by air inserted into his stomach via the nasogastric tube, not into his bloodstream”.

However, it then emerged that Letby was not working, and had not been in the hospital for two days when the X-ray showing this bubble was taken. Dr Evans now says Letby killed Baby C by air in the bloodstream. Prof Colin Morely, a retired professor of neonatology from the University of Cambridge, told the BBC he believed Baby C had died from natural causes.

Dr Evans told The Telegraph he no longer believed air injected into the stomach was the cause of the death.

“The stomach bubble was not responsible for his death,” he said. “Probably destabilised him though. His demise occurred the following day, around midnight, and due to air in the bloodstream.

“Letby was there. I amended my opinion after hearing the evidence from the local nurses and doctors. Baby C was always the most difficult from a clinical point of view. So I understand the confusion.”
 
Really? Do you know who ran this ANOVA test and what data was put into it? I assume that you are using some conventional notion of statistical significance here, are you, where if the p-values are less than 0.05, there is only a one in twenty chance that the deaths apparently lining up with Letby's shifts is random.

I was scoffing at the idea that Cheshire Police and the prosecutors had no idea of 'confirmation bias' and if only they had read Andy Lewis' rambling article. I pointed out that whilst confirmation bias might be a new light bulb revelation to Andy Lewis, an eighteen-year-old science student will be aware of such a phenomenon and thus comes in the use of statistical analysis. So you have a typical hospital and whilst it is not unusual for trends not to follow convention, nonetheless when you have a case where, say, three babies die in one week when normally say, it is three per annum, then it is not 'confirmation bias' to investigate it further. Even then, it was not just a case of looking for someone to pin the blame on, as the pro-Letby campaigners want people to believe. As the Thirlwall Inquiry is discovering, quite the reverse: there was huge resistance from the hospital executives (earning handsome remuneration) to do anything about the Letby question.
 
Right. But what happens when an "expert" claims Letby inflated a baby's stomach with air, as evinced by an X-ray, even though Letby was not on shift between the baby's birth and the X-ray being taken?



Link

You didn't highlight the following properly. You just highlighted the first bit:

"Letby was not working on the day the X-ray was taken and had not been on shift since before the baby was born - information the jury heard in her first trial. Letby’s former barrister Ben Myers also highlighted these details in his closing argument."


In other words, the issue of whether Letby was officially present WAS brought up at the trial - the proper place - and her defence silk, Myers, DID mention this in his closing arguments. Thus it is clear, the jury considered ALL of the arguments and preferred that of the prosecution to the level of being sure of Letby's guilt. In addition, I note the latest 'propaganda' tries to make out that Dr Dewi Evens is now contrite and has now changed his mind, cleverly evading the fact that all of this uncertainty took place at the investigation level not post-conviction.
 
There is zero chance Letby got a fair trial for any reasonable definition of the word "fair".

The average juror or judge would not be knowledgeable enough to assess the complex statistical and medical evidence presented to them. Her original defence team appear to have been incompetent and called no experts to offer alternative interpretations to that of the prosecution witnesses.

A killer nurse is so much easier on the brain as an explanation than the hospital, as with so many parts of the NHS and wider society, is a slow motion disaster. Systemic failures are not very satisfying as explanations: humans want heroes and villains!

Is she guilty or innocent? I have no idea, but I have yet to hear any evidence against her that is beyond reasonable doubt. Weak evidence does not magically become strong evidence if you combine enough of it.

If you think she's guilty, what would convince you she's innocent?

If you think she's innocent, what would convince you she's guilty?
 
Anyone can assert anything when not under cross-examination.
:rolleyes:

It makes me laugh when sympathetic journalists refer to 'experts' and then cite ordinary GP's (who signed some petition) or more recently a doctor sitting in his armchair in New Zealand.
Bollocks. And has been shown many of those who don't share your views are genuine experts. You are not.

Both my son and his dad are chartered statisticians and his dad is also a Royal Society member, with two PhD's and a handful of Masters,
:rolleyes:

yet neither of them would dream of claiming to know anything whatsoever about the Letby trial,
Maybe they should do some research? Or is it anathema to them as well as to you?

... the well-funded organised innocence campaigners would refer to them as 'experts'
Evidence for this claim?


As if Year One university science students aren't taught about confirmation bias or the halo effect as a matter of course.
Jurors aren't.

And in fact, the whole point of Analysis of Variance (statistical ANOVA) is to iron out random results that aren't significant.
:rolleyes:

But hey, let's get Justice Goss to read the article by Andy Lewis, who has only just discovered the perfect defence,
:rolleyes:
 
I was scoffing at the idea that Cheshire Police and the prosecutors had no idea of 'confirmation bias'
I rather suspect they don't know and don't care. I've worked with police and prosecutors, as an expert and ordinary witness, and many are frighteningly stupid and ignorant.

and if only they had read Andy Lewis' rambling article.
It's vastly less "rambling" than your assertions.

So you have a typical hospital and whilst it is not unusual for trends not to follow convention, nonetheless when you have a case where, say, three babies die in one week when normally say, it is three per annum, then it is not 'confirmation bias' to investigate it further.
Oh good grief....
 
There is zero chance Letby got a fair trial for any reasonable definition of the word "fair".

The average juror or judge would not be knowledgeable enough to assess the complex statistical and medical evidence presented to them. Her original defence team appear to have been incompetent and called no experts to offer alternative interpretations to that of the prosecution witnesses.

A killer nurse is so much easier on the brain as an explanation than the hospital, as with so many parts of the NHS and wider society, is a slow motion disaster. Systemic failures are not very satisfying as explanations: humans want heroes and villains!

Is she guilty or innocent? I have no idea, but I have yet to hear any evidence against her that is beyond reasonable doubt. Weak evidence does not magically become strong evidence if you combine enough of it.

If you think she's guilty, what would convince you she's innocent?

If you think she's innocent, what would convince you she's guilty?
The parallels to the Lucia de Berk case (not forgetting Sally Clark et al when it comes to dubious statistics) are distinct and worrying.
 
I was scoffing at the idea that Cheshire Police and the prosecutors had no idea of 'confirmation bias' and if only they had read Andy Lewis' rambling article. I pointed out that whilst confirmation bias might be a new light bulb revelation to Andy Lewis, an eighteen-year-old science student will be aware of such a phenomenon and thus comes in the use of statistical analysis. So you have a typical hospital and whilst it is not unusual for trends not to follow convention, nonetheless when you have a case where, say, three babies die in one week when normally say, it is three per annum, then it is not 'confirmation bias' to investigate it further. Even then, it was not just a case of looking for someone to pin the blame on, as the pro-Letby campaigners want people to believe. As the Thirlwall Inquiry is discovering, quite the reverse: there was huge resistance from the hospital executives (earning handsome remuneration) to do anything about the Letby question.

This is ridiculous. Confirmation bias is not new to Andy Lewis, obviously. Your belief that the police cannot fall prey to it is hopelessly naive.

Anyway, it was you who raised ANOVA. What was the point of that if it wasn’t even relevant? There are all kinds of scientific papers which abuse statistical analyses such as ANOVA. The replication crisis was essentially caused by the very same logical fallacies and poor reasoning which is alleged to be at play here, namely finding evidence which fits a conclusion. Its like declaring that Colonel Mustard’s fingerprints were all over the revolver so the victim must have been shot, but then when the victim turns out not have been shot but to have died of a heart attack assuming that Colonel Mustard must have jumped out of the cupboard to scare the victim to death.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom