Merged Concerns over baby killer ignored? / Nurse Lucy Letby killed babies in her care

I agree, Letby isn't guilty because I wish it were so. Letby is guilty because that is the factual objective legal status.

So you say that a person is factually guilty because they are legally guilty.

In your world, there is no such thing as a miscarriage of justice, because verdicts are always right.
 
So you say that a person is factually guilty because they are legally guilty.

Rule of So - and no, that is NOT what Vixen said!

I agree, Letby isn't guilty because I wish it were so. Letby is guilty because that is the factual objective legal status.

https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/1468-2230.12876

"A distinction is often drawn between a person being ‘factually’ guilty, meaning that they have carried out an act that breaches the law, and ‘legally’ guilty, meaning the prosecutor can prove that they committed a crime in court. The idea that a clear guilt status exists independently of trial is at the heart of the Criminal Procedure Rules in England and Wales, which commit all official participants in the criminal justice process to ‘acquitting the innocent and convicting the guilty’ as they seek to deal with cases ‘justly’."​
 
Last edited:
Rule of So - and no, that is NOT what Vixen said!



https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/1468-2230.12876

"A distinction is often drawn between a person being ‘factually’ guilty, meaning that they have carried out an act that breaches the law, and ‘legally’ guilty, meaning the prosecutor can prove that they committed a crime in court. The idea that a clear guilt status exists independently of trial is at the heart of the Criminal Procedure Rules in England and Wales, which commit all official participants in the criminal justice process to ‘acquitting the innocent and convicting the guilty’ as they seek to deal with cases ‘justly’."​

Nobody is denying she has been convicted so of course she has been found guilty. That is not in dispute.
 
I followed the case daily. I followed the live tweets from the court room from the official BBC court room correspondent and the DM podcast bod.
:rolleyes:
And yet you can't manage to get the jury verdict correct.

Your references to 'miscarriages of justice' in historical cases informs me that you consider it a trendy fun past-time to claim Letby is innocent,
:rolleyes: made-up nonsense.

when there is zero evidence of unfairness. You are unable to articulate in which way it is a miscarriage other than to refer to other people.
And now you're engage din outright lies.

So much easier to say, 'see Dr Hammond in Private Eye' or 'Dr Adams in the New Yorker',
Except I've never done this. You have failed to do any research of yoru own.

Dr Lee, whose embolism 'fresh evidence' was looked at by the Appeal Court and dismissed as 'misguided'.
Actually it wasn't.

Unless you can spell out how it is a miscarriage or unfair, I can't take your claim as being in good faith.
How hypocritical. :rolleyes:
 
:rolleyes:
And yet you can't manage to get the jury verdict correct.


:rolleyes: made-up nonsense.


And now you're engage din outright lies.


Except I've never done this. You have failed to do any research of yoru own.


Actually it wasn't.
How hypocritical. :rolleyes:

Actually it was:

187. But even if the applicant could persuade us that there was a reasonable explanation for the failure to adduce Dr Lee’s evidence at trial, she faces a further – and in our view, insuperable – obstacle. Even accepting for present purposes that Dr Lee is correct in his opinion that only one form of discolouration is sufficient in itself to diagnose air embolus in a neonate, the proposed fresh evidence cannot assist the applicant because it is aimed at a mistaken target. The core of the proposed evidence is that, save for that one very specific form of discolouration, it would be wrong to diagnose air embolus on the basis of skin discolouration alone. But as we have said when considering ground 2, there was no prosecution expert evidence diagnosing air embolus solely on the basis of skin discolouration. Dr Evans and Dr Bohin relied on the differing forms of skin discolouration observed in individual babies as consistent with air embolus. Their evidence in that regard was in our view entirely consistent with the observational study in the Lee and Tanswell paper, and with Dr Lee’s review of 64 cases since that paper was written. Indeed, Mr Myers realistically accepts that skin discolouration – other than the one type which Dr Lee states is pathognomonic of air embolus – is indicative of circulatory collapse which may be associated with air embolus, and that air embolus may be associated with a variety of skin discolouration. In short, the prosecution witnesses did not fall into the error which the proposed fresh evidence seeks to assert they made. The proposed evidence is therefore irrelevant and inadmissible. 188. For that reason, we think it unnecessary to say anything about the issue between the parties as to the extent to which Dr Lee was or was not informed of the evidence about each baby which did not relate to skin discolouration. 189. Similarly, Dr Lee’s evidence would provide a basis for challenging a witness who diagnosed air embolus on the basis of excluding other causes and then asserting that it must be a case of air embolus because no other explanation could be identified. But again, that was not the basis on which the prosecution witnesses reached their opinions: they made findings which were consistent with air embolus and which collectively could not be explained by natural causes or any other possible alternative explanation. Still less was it the basis on which the jury had to reach their verdicts, which required them to consider all the evidence, both clinical and non-clinical.

<snip>

190. For that reason, we see considerable force in Mr Johnson’s submission that the evidence relating to Baby A illustrates why the applicant’s approach is misguided.
https://www.judiciary.uk/judgments/r-v-letby-3/

So, you see, the Appeal Court did say Dr Lee's approach was misguided.
 
Was Dr Lee the applicant?

No, so the judgment did not say his approach was misguided.
I think we've all long since given up expecting Vixen's posts to be factually accurate. Do you remember the battery fire thread?
 
That is an excellent summary of the situation. Too bad certain people will ignore it.

I'm become increasingly convinced that if there were any wrongful deaths, they was most likely due to incompetence on the two doctors who dobbed her in in the first place. They were the ones that came up with the spurious spreadsheet after all and they both had motive to falsely accuse Ms Letby after being found in a previous enquiry to have made malicious and untrue accusations against her in the first place.

And I was never convinced that those notes so heavily depended on were a confession. They read as PTSD induced guilt for something you couldn't have prevented, like the soldier who spends the rest of his life feeling guilt for not saving the life of his squadmate who was taken out by a sniper a mile away.
 
Yes I am, because it is self-evident. I doubt it’s worth trying to explain it to you, though.

It is entirely possible that there was mismanagement, shortages, a superbug and Letby was killing babies. We have no idea exactly how many and who Shipman killed. It could be the same with Letby.
 
It is entirely possible that there was mismanagement, shortages, a superbug and Letby was killing babies. We have no idea exactly how many and who Shipman killed. It could be the same with Letby.
Quite possibly.
 
You would think that we would find all the murders. But, how many missing people are actually murdered? How many deaths that were murder have been wrongly assessed by the police and medics to be otherwise explainable? Serial killers are often secretive about who and how many they have killed, or prepared to say where the bodies are.
 
Sally Clark and Lindy Chamberlain come to mind.

I can't see the point in continuously listing historical 'cases of miscarriage of justice', for example, referring to the Birmingham Six. Nobody is arguing that unsafe convictions never happen. Sally Clark is relevant insofar her case is linked to Dewi Evans (the main doctor in the Letby case) and the rogue statistics of Roy Meadows, who erroneously calculated the odds of two children dying from SIDS without taking into account the genetic factor and that the two babies being brothers might have the same genetic predisposition, unlike two random samples in the population.

Lindy Chamberlain was an Australian case, and in common with Sally Clark, it is impossible to know one way or the other what really happened other than by inference.


Both cases are different from Letby, which relates to a serial killer of children not personally related or known to her.
 
They're only mentioned to counter the point that YOU keep making, which is that a jury found her guilty, therefore she must be guilty. If you could stop saying or implying that, nobody would respond with mention of other miscarriages of justice. Hope this helps!
 
They're only mentioned to counter the point that YOU keep making, which is that a jury found her guilty, therefore she must be guilty. If you could stop saying or implying that, nobody would respond with mention of other miscarriages of justice. Hope this helps!

If you are going to give credence to the idea of a miscarriage of justice, you need to explain why you believe that. Simply pointing to articles by Peter, Nadine and Sara (sounds like a folk group!) indicates a lack of knowledge of how courts work, unless you can explain preferably in your own words, where you think the miscarriage might arise.

Simply saying, 'she might be innocent' is a meaningless statement and doesn't make it so. Unless you provide a point for discussion, I am going to concentrate on the Thirlwall Inquiry instead. Interestingly, it appears to reflect the same issues we see here, people utterly resistant to the idea that a nurse could have harmed babies in her care, hence Letby was able to carry on.
 
Dr Dewi Evans has now changed his mind about the way in which Baby C was killed.

https://archive.is/2024.10.01-20365...s/2024/10/01/lucy-letby-witness-changed-mind/

At Letby’s trial, the jury was told that Baby C had been killed “by air inserted into his stomach via the nasogastric tube, not into his bloodstream”.

However, it then emerged that Letby was not working, and had not been in the hospital for two days when the X-ray showing this bubble was taken.

Dr Evans now says Letby killed Baby C by air in the bloodstream.

Prof Colin Morely, a retired professor of neonatology from the University of Cambridge, told the BBC he believed Baby C had died from natural causes.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom