Merged Concerns over baby killer ignored? / Nurse Lucy Letby killed babies in her care

I have looked up Baby C's press report as of the time of the trial (circa 1 Nov 2022, Chester Standard). Letby was on shift on the evening of 13 June 2015 going into 14th June when Baby C died at 5:58am. At 11:15pm on 13 June Baby C's nurse heard the baby's monitor alarm go off and found Letby standing next to his cot.

It was Dr Bohin and Dr Evans who testified. In common with many babies born prematurely, Baby C developed pneumonia in one lung, which was the purpose of the X-Ray on 12 June 2015: standard procedure. He was on a nasal tube plus CPAP. He was given antibiotics and transferred onto Optiflow, due to improvement in his condition. Dr. Bohin said Baby C died with pneumonia but not of it.

Dr. Evans said that the babies diaphragm appeared to be split with the stomach distended in the Xray dated 12 June 2015 (bile problems also being commonplace, as according to Dr. Evans, all premature babies are slightly affected by jaundice). When the Baby collapsed and died on 14 June 2015, Evans said that he virtually suffocated because his diaphragm was collapsed due, he believe to an injection of air.

https://www.chesterstandard.co.uk/news/23092103.recap-lucy-letby-trial-tuesday-november-1/

Police have the opinion on of Letby's favourite Modus Operandi was to dislodge babies' feeding tubes, and she was present, alone at Baby C's cot when the alarm went off, on 13 June 2015, having just six minutes earlier sent a social media message to a colleague saying she wanted to be with Baby C (because of what happened to Baby A) but had been allocated to a different room and then first thing she did on awaking after finishing her night shift at 8:00am, was to search baby C's parents on FB. The mother of Baby C said a nurse with a ponytail told her she didn't think the baby was going to make it, with the mother telling the court via a statement she thought it was a very odd thing for a nurse to say as she expected that prognosis should have come from a doctor, not a nurse.

We only have the Daily Telegraph saying she had never been at the hospital for the period 8th June 2015 to 12 June 2015, with their sources being called 'experts', so is there any firm confirmation that Letby had not been working between those dates?

From the same hearing, Dr Evans claims that air had been deliberately injected into the stomach, and that this showed up on the X-ray of June 12th:

12:38am
Mr Myers says the x-ray from June 12 had helped form Dr Evans's initial view that there had been an air injection into the stomach. "That was an opinion I have expressed, yes." Mr Myers asks Dr Evans what evidence there is to support that air had been injected into the stomach on June 13.

Dr Evans: "The baby collapsed and died."

Asked to explain further, Dr Evans says it was part of a differential diagnosis.

He said there were three clinical scenarios - injecting air into the stomach that interfered with his breathing, or that air was injected intraveneously, or from a combination of the two, which Dr Evans says "sounds awful".

Dr Evans says, from his perspective, from an academic point of view, he would not be able to rule out any one of those three scenarios.

And then on June 13th?

Vixen, you have questioned whether the Telegraph has accurately reported that Letby had not been on shift from the time of Child C's birth, to the time of the X-ray.

If this turns out to be corroborated, then will this change your opinion, somewhat about how sure you can be that Letby killed Child C?

Or would you just assert that she probably killed him a different way? Or that she snuck in while off-shift and somehow was responsible for the air bubble?
 
It seems the BMJ had an article which initially referenced Letby, but was then edited to remove her name because of a restriction order.

I earlier linked to some reddit posts which showed that nurses and other medical professionals apparently do Google names of their patients. This was scoffed at as though it was a worthless source. Fair enough, maybe the people on reddit were not actually medical professionals, but just trolls.

However, the BMJ piece shows that this is surprisingly common. I assume that the initial reference to the Letby trial was to show that as weird as some people thought her Facebook searches were, they don't seem to be uncommon at all. And honestly, that does not surprise me.

At home, Priya googled the patient’s name and found she was an adult film performer. “It raised questions: was she still working in that industry? Was the sex protected? Were they testing her regularly? I also knew she wasn’t taking her antiretroviral drugs.”
Priya wanted to discuss this with a senior colleague, in case of potential safeguarding problems. “I didn’t know how to raise it,” she says. “I was scared of getting into trouble.”

Priya isn’t alone in this quandary. A 2015 survey of Canadian emergency physicians and medical students found that, of 530 responses, 64 (13%) admitted to using Google to research a patient (10 respondents said they had searched using Facebook).1 The following year, a study of 207 German psychotherapists found that 82 (40%) had looked for patient information on the internet.2 A 2018 survey of 392 genetic counsellors and trainees in the US revealed that 130 said they had searched or considered searching a patient’s name online (110 said they had visited a patient’s social media site),3 while another 2018 survey found over half (47) of 88 psychiatrists, clinical psychologists, and psychotherapists questioned in New Zealand admitted to doing so.4

Link
 
Speaking of Reddit, I noticed that someone there had linked to a letter in the BMJ in which another expert witness, Dr Sandie Bonhim, responds to Dr Mike Hall.

Dr Hall first notes that Dr Evans's claims about air embolism are insufficiently supported by the literature that he cites, namely the Lee and Tanswell paper.

He also questioned Evans and Bonhim's expertise given that they had both effectively retired in 2009 from neonatal intensive care.

The second issue relates to the suitability of the two prosecution neonatal expert witnesses to interpret for the Court neonatal practice as it was in 2015-2016. Dr Evans had retired from full-time clinical practice in neonatal intensive care in 2009 and Dr Bohin also in 2009, although she continued to practise in Guernsey as a consultant paediatrician with neonates – that is in each case 13 years before the start of the trial. In all, five judges determined that the two expert witnesses were suitably qualified to give evidence and that it was for the jury to assess the validity of their evidence. But, first, on what basis were the judges qualified to make this decision? Second, as no medical expert witnesses were called for the defence, how could the jury assess the validity of the prosecution medical expert evidence, in the absence of any peer comparators offered by the defence?

Bonhim's response is two-fold. First, off citing her credentials, which is fair, but then ... weirdly petulant, in my view... accusing Dr Hall of having "sour grapes" that he didn't get a chance to be in the trial.

I wish to address some misleading and untrue comments about me and my suitability to be a medical expert in this case. I am accredited in neonatology and from 1996-2009 worked as a consultant in a tertiary centre neonatal unit. From 2009 I have worked in Guernsey undertaking both paediatric and neonatal work, including neonatal intensive care. I also have an honorary contract with a regional neonatal intensive care unit in the UK. I continue to work full time in clinical practice, unlike Professor Hall who retired from clinical work in 2018, long before the Letby trial came to court.

Those who instructed me were clearly satisfied that I had the necessary expertise to act as an expert. It is wrong of Professor Hall to publicly discredit a professional colleague in this way. I’m not entirely sure of his motive. Is it a case of sour grapes because he was not called by the defence to take the stand? It certainly appears that way.

Link

I think it's strange that she immediately assumes Hall himself wanted to be there and then got annoyed at being left out.

But I note that she says nothing about the medical evidence, which is also strange, in my view.
 
From the same hearing, Dr Evans claims that air had been deliberately injected into the stomach, and that this showed up on the X-ray of June 12th:



And then on June 13th?

Vixen, you have questioned whether the Telegraph has accurately reported that Letby had not been on shift from the time of Child C's birth, to the time of the X-ray.

If this turns out to be corroborated, then will this change your opinion, somewhat about how sure you can be that Letby killed Child C?

Or would you just assert that she probably killed him a different way? Or that she snuck in while off-shift and somehow was responsible for the air bubble?

Please can you reproduce the TELEGRAPH article where it specifically states Letby was not on duty from 8 June 2015 (Baby C's birth date) all the way through to 12 June 2015, when the X-Ray was taken, and to whom the source is attributed.

First point re Dr. Evan's initial prognosis (in retrospect); he initially believed air had been injected via the stomach but he later came round to thinking it was via the naso-gastric tube. It needs to be remembered that the point of the X-Ray was not suspected harm, but a standard procedure for premature babies suspected of having pneumonia (or to discover the cause of observable breathing difficulty). Dr. Evans observed that the diaphragm was split and the abdomen extended. The collapse of Baby C was sudden and was not due to pneumonia as the monitors would have registered and increase in heart rate and desaturation signals and there was none of that. The collapse was sudden. Baby C died after hours of resuscitation attempts at 5:58am 14 June 2015, when Letby had been on shift and when the alarm initially sounded at 11:15pm 13 June 2015 Letby was discovered standing at Baby C's cot even though she was not on duty in that room (but was on duty in another room). Six minutes before the alarm sounded, Letby had sent a text to a colleague expressing a desire to be with Baby C because of what happened to twins Baby A and B. Which ever was the ultimate cause of Baby C's death, it was the incident of 14 June 2015 in which he collapsed and died having been stable.

As for your second point, this is a hypothetical question. The problem with many of the doubters of Letby's guilt is that they approach the issue in this piecemeal way. It amuses me to see letters in PRIVATE EYE and elsewhere in which people assert, "I am a nurse and I've taken home medical notes, either accidentally or for study notes" or similar. The piecemeal check list then looks something like this:

  • Letby took home medical notes - but so have other nurses. Tick - reject evidence
  • Letby looked up the baby's parents on FaceBook after they died. Other nurses have doen the same. Tick - reject evidence
  • Letby made a note in her diaries of the names and date of death of the babies involved. Other nurses have done something similar. Tick - reject evidence
  • Letby wrote Post-It notes confessing. People doodle all kinds of things under stress. Tick - reject evidence
  • Letby volunteered to work nights so she could be alonne with the babies. Hospital was understaffed, this was admirable of her. Tick - reject evidence
  • The baies were premature, or weak as evidenced in their being in the neonatal unit at all. Tick - reject evidence
  • Nobody saw her doing it. Tick - reject evidence
  • The hospital recorded them as natural deaths at the time. Tick - reject evidence

VERDICT: Innocent or insufficient evidence - must acquit as miscarriage of justice.

The correct method, or method as used in a criminal court of law:

  • Give chronology of events, date, time, sequence. - do not come to an opinion yet!
  • Note sequence of events: this happened and then that happened. Reserve opinion.
  • Hear all of the witnesses in testimony and in cross-examination, both prosecution and defence. Wait before you decide anything.
  • Look carefully at all of the evidence presented. Ask questions if you do not understand. Reserve opinion.
  • Listen to he summing up by the prosecution and the defense. Wiat for it.
  • Listen to the judge's summing up and instructions. Ready?
  • Only when you have been told to go and deliberate with ELEVEN of your fellow RANDOM jurors should you start deciding your verdict.

Once you have seen the WHOLE picture and DISCUSSED the issues in details can you possibly make a good decision.

It is pointless to say, 'suppose Letby hadn't worked before 12 June or since Baby C was born' that must mean a re-trial is needed. This is because the X-Ray on the 12th June 2015 was a standard procedure and not done to spot whether anyone had caused any harm. Baby C did not collapse and die until 14th June 2015. This is the salient date.

I am sceptical that the air bubble in the stomach and split diaphragm had an innocent explanation because, as Dr. Evans explained under cross-examination, nurses are trained to feel the abdomen and note bile appearance, so given Baby C was strong enough to be taken off ventilation to spend skin-to-skin time with his mother before then I would certainly be curious as to who was around during that time and whether Letby ever popped in to visit when off duty.

Bear in mind, Letby didn't kill all her babies. However, at Chester there were 40% dislodged nasal tubes associated with Letby, when the normal incidence of babies dislodging their own tubes was 1%. You recall Baby K, when Dr. Jayaram says he caught Letby at the cot side. Baby K was resuscitated and Letby then made a point of telling her colleagues that Baby K kept on dislodging her own nasal tubes several times after that; Dr. Jayaram believes to preclude the fact he caught her having just dislodged Baby K's tube causing the medical emergency. In addition, someone turned the alarm off.
 
It seems the BMJ had an article which initially referenced Letby, but was then edited to remove her name because of a restriction order.

I earlier linked to some reddit posts which showed that nurses and other medical professionals apparently do Google names of their patients. This was scoffed at as though it was a worthless source. Fair enough, maybe the people on reddit were not actually medical professionals, but just trolls.

However, the BMJ piece shows that this is surprisingly common. I assume that the initial reference to the Letby trial was to show that as weird as some people thought her Facebook searches were, they don't seem to be uncommon at all. And honestly, that does not surprise me.



Link

As I said, this is just a piecemeal way of looking at it.

You have to look at ALL of the evidence as a whole. For example, in your TELEGRAPH piece, all that was looked at was the date of the X-Ray of Baby C. But it doesn't mention the events leading up to Baby C's collapse nor what happened next (the texting beforehand, where Letby was standing when the alarm went off, what she did immediately on awaking, what she said to the parent, etc.) It is no surprise the innocence campaigners leave out huge chunks of details, such as whether Letby had worked prior to 12 June, when we can be sure it would have been shouted from the house tops, if not. Instead we get reams of stuff about 'erroneous statistics', when the prosecution never even mentioned statistics once in the trial.

And as if the Cheshire Police didn't have the same thoughts as the man on the street. Note Letby wasn't charged with professional negligence manslaughter, a much easier crime to convict - they were 100% sure it was murder or attempted murder!
 
Speaking of Reddit, I noticed that someone there had linked to a letter in the BMJ in which another expert witness, Dr Sandie Bonhim, responds to Dr Mike Hall.

Dr Hall first notes that Dr Evans's claims about air embolism are insufficiently supported by the literature that he cites, namely the Lee and Tanswell paper.

He also questioned Evans and Bonhim's expertise given that they had both effectively retired in 2009 from neonatal intensive care.



Bonhim's response is two-fold. First, off citing her credentials, which is fair, but then ... weirdly petulant, in my view... accusing Dr Hall of having "sour grapes" that he didn't get a chance to be in the trial.



Link

I think it's strange that she immediately assumes Hall himself wanted to be there and then got annoyed at being left out.

But I note that she says nothing about the medical evidence, which is also strange, in my view.

Yes, a lot of this is to do with medics fighting amongst themselves, with a lot of score settling over past issues.

As for no defence offered: maybe no amount of defence could have changed the guilty verdicts.

If Ben Myers KC 'plan' was to offer little defence, apart from the plumber, then it's a bad strategy as people writing for the New York Post, wordpress blogs by people called, 'Andy' about 'confirmation bias' and some eccentric in the Netherlands, really do not have any sway over the UK law courts.
 
Last edited:
The problem with many of the doubters of Letby's guilt is that they approach the issue in this piecemeal way. It amuses me to see letters in PRIVATE EYE and elsewhere in which people assert, "I am a nurse and I've taken home medical notes, either accidentally or for study notes" or similar. The piecemeal check list then looks something like this:

  • Letby took home medical notes - but so have other nurses. Tick - reject evidence
  • Letby looked up the baby's parents on FaceBook after they died. Other nurses have doen the same. Tick - reject evidence
  • Letby made a note in her diaries of the names and date of death of the babies involved. Other nurses have done something similar. Tick - reject evidence
  • Letby wrote Post-It notes confessing. People doodle all kinds of things under stress. Tick - reject evidence
  • Letby volunteered to work nights so she could be alonne with the babies. Hospital was understaffed, this was admirable of her. Tick - reject evidence

VERDICT: Innocent or insufficient evidence - must acquit as miscarriage of justice.

This! Its rather the same approach that conspiracy theorists use when claiming something is fake or false. They look at one or two things that "don't look right to them" and claim that brings the whole edifice down...

No stars in the sky = the whole Apollo program was faked!
Some Jewish people didn't turn up to work on the morning of 9/11 = inside job, the Jews did it!
Jack Ruby killed Lee Harvey Oswald = JFK was murdered by (insert three letter agency here)

NONE of the items in your list quoted above are exculpatory. There may have been other nurses who have done some of those things at various times in their careers, but how often do those other nurses do ALL of them, ALL over the same period of time, and CONTINUE to do them in an environment in which babies are dying at a much higher rate than expected? Not many I'll bet!
 
This! Its rather the same approach that conspiracy theorists use when claiming something is fake or false. They look at one or two things that "don't look right to them" and claim that brings the whole edifice down...

No stars in the sky = the whole Apollo program was faked!
Some Jewish people didn't turn up to work on the morning of 9/11 = inside job, the Jews did it!
Jack Ruby killed Lee Harvey Oswald = JFK was murdered by (insert three letter agency here)

NONE of the items in your list quoted above are exculpatory. There may have been other nurses who have done some of those things at various times in their careers, but how often do those other nurses do ALL of them, ALL over the same period of time, and CONTINUE to do them in an environment in which babies are dying at a much higher rate than expected? Not many I'll bet!

Huh? It’s actually the other way round.

I think a piecemeal approach is a much better way to do things. It is the conspiracy theorist who says “what about x,y,x…?” And is keen to jump from one to another without looking in detail at any one point.

It is the skeptic who looks at each point piecemeal and shows how each part of the Gish Gallop being offered up has an explanation that doesn’t further the conspiracy theory.
 
Please can you reproduce the TELEGRAPH article where it specifically states Letby was not on duty from 8 June 2015 (Baby C's birth date) all the way through to 12 June 2015, when the X-Ray was taken, and to whom the source is attributed.

First point re Dr. Evan's initial prognosis (in retrospect); he initially believed air had been injected via the stomach but he later came round to thinking it was via the naso-gastric tube. It needs to be remembered that the point of the X-Ray was not suspected harm, but a standard procedure for premature babies suspected of having pneumonia (or to discover the cause of observable breathing difficulty). Dr. Evans observed that the diaphragm was split and the abdomen extended. The collapse of Baby C was sudden and was not due to pneumonia as the monitors would have registered and increase in heart rate and desaturation signals and there was none of that. The collapse was sudden. Baby C died after hours of resuscitation attempts at 5:58am 14 June 2015, when Letby had been on shift and when the alarm initially sounded at 11:15pm 13 June 2015 Letby was discovered standing at Baby C's cot even though she was not on duty in that room (but was on duty in another room). Six minutes before the alarm sounded, Letby had sent a text to a colleague expressing a desire to be with Baby C because of what happened to twins Baby A and B. Which ever was the ultimate cause of Baby C's death, it was the incident of 14 June 2015 in which he collapsed and died having been stable.

As for your second point, this is a hypothetical question. The problem with many of the doubters of Letby's guilt is that they approach the issue in this piecemeal way. It amuses me to see letters in PRIVATE EYE and elsewhere in which people assert, "I am a nurse and I've taken home medical notes, either accidentally or for study notes" or similar. The piecemeal check list then looks something like this:

  • Letby took home medical notes - but so have other nurses. Tick - reject evidence
  • Letby looked up the baby's parents on FaceBook after they died. Other nurses have doen the same. Tick - reject evidence
  • Letby made a note in her diaries of the names and date of death of the babies involved. Other nurses have done something similar. Tick - reject evidence
  • Letby wrote Post-It notes confessing. People doodle all kinds of things under stress. Tick - reject evidence
  • Letby volunteered to work nights so she could be alonne with the babies. Hospital was understaffed, this was admirable of her. Tick - reject evidence
  • The baies were premature, or weak as evidenced in their being in the neonatal unit at all. Tick - reject evidence
  • Nobody saw her doing it. Tick - reject evidence
  • The hospital recorded them as natural deaths at the time. Tick - reject evidence

VERDICT: Innocent or insufficient evidence - must acquit as miscarriage of justice.

The correct method, or method as used in a criminal court of law:

  • Give chronology of events, date, time, sequence. - do not come to an opinion yet!
  • Note sequence of events: this happened and then that happened. Reserve opinion.
  • Hear all of the witnesses in testimony and in cross-examination, both prosecution and defence. Wait before you decide anything.
  • Look carefully at all of the evidence presented. Ask questions if you do not understand. Reserve opinion.
  • Listen to he summing up by the prosecution and the defense. Wiat for it.
  • Listen to the judge's summing up and instructions. Ready?
  • Only when you have been told to go and deliberate with ELEVEN of your fellow RANDOM jurors should you start deciding your verdict.

Once you have seen the WHOLE picture and DISCUSSED the issues in details can you possibly make a good decision.

It is pointless to say, 'suppose Letby hadn't worked before 12 June or since Baby C was born' that must mean a re-trial is needed. This is because the X-Ray on the 12th June 2015 was a standard procedure and not done to spot whether anyone had caused any harm. Baby C did not collapse and die until 14th June 2015. This is the salient date.

I am sceptical that the air bubble in the stomach and split diaphragm had an innocent explanation because, as Dr. Evans explained under cross-examination, nurses are trained to feel the abdomen and note bile appearance, so given Baby C was strong enough to be taken off ventilation to spend skin-to-skin time with his mother before then I would certainly be curious as to who was around during that time and whether Letby ever popped in to visit when off duty.

Bear in mind, Letby didn't kill all her babies. However, at Chester there were 40% dislodged nasal tubes associated with Letby, when the normal incidence of babies dislodging their own tubes was 1%. You recall Baby K, when Dr. Jayaram says he caught Letby at the cot side. Baby K was resuscitated and Letby then made a point of telling her colleagues that Baby K kept on dislodging her own nasal tubes several times after that; Dr. Jayaram believes to preclude the fact he caught her having just dislodged Baby K's tube causing the medical emergency. In addition, someone turned the alarm off.

What? You are not reserving opinion. What you are doing is closer to the Gish Gallop where you know that nothing by itself is sufficient so maybe all of it together adds up to guilt.

And no, you are not “reserving opinion” at all. You are 100% sure of your opinion. In fact you and smartcooky are acting as though the very act of looking at this skeptically is an immoral act.

Gish Galloping and shaming those who are not completely convinced is not the tactic of a skeptic.
 
Okay, looks like it he claim of Letby not being there came from a BBC link relating to the BBC series about it…

Letby was not working on the day the X-ray was taken and had not been on shift since before the baby was born - information the jury heard in her first trial. Letby’s former barrister Ben Myers also highlighted these details in his closing argument.
In his summing up the judge made clear to the jury this X-ray had been taken the day before Baby C collapsed, though he didn’t remind them Letby hadn’t been on shift. At appeal, the prosecution said Letby could have visited the hospital while off shift, but didn’t put forward any evidence that she was there.


https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c89l05e97vqo
 
This! Its rather the same approach that conspiracy theorists use when claiming something is fake or false. They look at one or two things that "don't look right to them" and claim that brings the whole edifice down...

No stars in the sky = the whole Apollo program was faked!
Some Jewish people didn't turn up to work on the morning of 9/11 = inside job, the Jews did it!
Jack Ruby killed Lee Harvey Oswald = JFK was murdered by (insert three letter agency here)

NONE of the items in your list quoted above are exculpatory. There may have been other nurses who have done some of those things at various times in their careers, but how often do those other nurses do ALL of them, ALL over the same period of time, and CONTINUE to do them in an environment in which babies are dying at a much higher rate than expected? Not many I'll bet!

I'd say it's not. If you can find a way to shoot down every single piece of evidence, even if it is a different way for each piece of evidence, then the evidence is gone, no matter what. It doesn't necessarily exonerate the defendant, but it does introduce reasonable doubt.
 
Huh? It’s actually the other way round.

I think a piecemeal approach is a much better way to do things. It is the conspiracy theorist who says “what about x,y,x…?” And is keen to jump from one to another without looking in detail at any one point.

It is the skeptic who looks at each point piecemeal and shows how each part of the Gish Gallop being offered up has an explanation that doesn’t further the conspiracy theory.

You might want to reconsider that method as it is also known in legal circle as the logical fallacy of petitio prinicipii, a form of begging the question. So, for example, when you say, as you did, 'Lucy Letby took home medical notes of babies; lots of nurses take home notes they shouldn't', you are answering the hidden question: "Is taking medical notes home of patients proof of murder?" when the question isn't 'Is Letby guilty of taking home medical notes?' but rather, building up a WHOLE picture of the circumstances around each particular case of 17 in all, of which she was convicted of 15. By brushing it off as, 'lots of nurses tkae home medical stuff they shouldn't' you are conveniently ignoring the salient point being made that she kept the final medical notes of the babies who died on her watch as a form of trophy in a bag under her bed (is the prosecution argument). You have to look at that TOGETHER with the fact of (a) the babies collapsing suddenly and unexpectedly on her watch and (b) the sheer number of occasions and (c) eye witness Dr Jayaram who caught her red-handed at the side of Baby K, and Nurse Sophie Ellis who caught her at the side of Baby C, who suddenly and unexpectedly died shortly after.

Consider this, a person A is accused of assaulting person B. As the judge, your written reasons written in your preferred piecemeal method would read something like this:

  • Person A walked down Oxford Street (say); lots of people walk down Oxford Street. Tick: reject evidence.
  • Lot os people carry a knife on their person. Tick: reject evidence as any proof.
  • Person B walking alog Oxford street,: lots of people walk along Oxford Street. Tick: reject evidence as any proof.

VERDICT: 'not guilty'.

Correct method:

  • Circumtantial evidence: Person A was walking along Oxford street AT 10:00AM ON THE MORNING OF 10 JUNE 2015. point noted.
  • Person B approached person A from the opposite direction at 10:00 on that date. Point noted.
  • Person B collapsed with stab wounds at precisely the point the pair passed. Point noted.

VERDICT: These constitute my facts found and supports the guilty verdict as being sure as possible as found by the jury of twelve members of the jury randomly selected from the electorate after due deliberation and a fair trial.

If you prefer the petitio prinicipii method you are likely to be struck off as a judge.

I think it is mainly people who didn't follow the trial, which was largely relegated to the back pages as it went on for such a long time who cannot get their heads around the murder and attempted murder verdicts so they are easy fodder for mischievous journalists such as Peter Hitches, Sarah Vine and Nadine Dorries, for example, who see an opportunity for cheap populism based on the gullible tabloid readers because sensationalist controversy sells and they earn huge amounts of money for churning this stuff out.
 
Okay, looks like it he claim of Letby not being there came from a BBC link relating to the BBC series about it…




https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c89l05e97vqo

The source of the information there is neonatologist Dr Michael Hall, who bears a well-publicised grudge that he wasn't called to give evidence.

It is well-known that Letby on one occasion slipped in early to harm a baby and then only swiped her card fifteen minutes later, to make it look as though she cannot have been there. OK, so there have been some issues about the accuracy of the door swiping but even if we disregard those, we only have the claim of Dr. Hall. It was pointed out at the trial that Letby was not on shift on 12 June or leading up to it, and Ben Myers, KC for the defence did mention it in his summing up, so the jury did have that information when they entered their deliberations.
 
You might want to reconsider that method as it is also known in legal circle as the logical fallacy of petitio prinicipii, a form of begging the question. So, for example, when you say, as you did, 'Lucy Letby took home medical notes of babies; lots of nurses take home notes they shouldn't', you are answering the hidden question: "Is taking medical notes home of patients proof of murder?" when the question isn't 'Is Letby guilty of taking home medical notes?' but rather, building up a WHOLE picture of the circumstances around each particular case of 17 in all, of which she was convicted of 15. By brushing it off as, 'lots of nurses tkae home medical stuff they shouldn't' you are conveniently ignoring the salient point being made that she kept the final medical notes of the babies who died on her watch as a form of trophy in a bag under her bed (is the prosecution argument).

Dude! YOU are the one begging the question!

I say “is it so unusual?” You say “yes, because it is a murder trophy!”


Seriously, the fallacy seems to be yours. You admit that none of these points by themselves are necessarily suspicious but argue that they all are when put together. It sounds more like the “no smoke without fire” argument.


It is not adequately established that these medical records are murder trophies is it? Not unless you have already concluded that she is guilty. You can’t use the presumption of guilt as evidence of guilt. That is what begging the question is!

Jeez Louise!
 
The source of the information there is neonatologist Dr Michael Hall, who bears a well-publicised grudge that he wasn't called to give evidence.

Begging the question once again! Evidence that he bears a well-publicised grudge? Well, the evidence is the fact that he is the source of the information!

Eleventy11!!!

Also, your Latin is as terrible as your judgment - it's not "petitio prinicipii", which I would put down as a typo, if you hadn't written it twice.
 
I'd say it's not. If you can find a way to shoot down every single piece of evidence, even if it is a different way for each piece of evidence, then the evidence is gone, no matter what. It doesn't necessarily exonerate the defendant, but it does introduce reasonable doubt.

As in, "If the glove doesn't fit, you must acquit'...?
 
As if Year One university science students aren't taught about confirmation bias or the halo effect as a matter of course.
I very much doubt that. I have taught many Year 1, 2 & 3 students studying social sciences like criminology and the majority have never heard of it before. I doubt that students studying natural or hard sciences have either, since many get no coverage of science versus pseudoscience.

And in fact, the whole point of Analysis of Variance (statistical ANOVA) is to iron out random results that aren't significant.

Statistical significance does not tell you the probability that an effect occurred by chance, unless you are using Bayesian analysis. Which is what Lewis' post was about.
 
Last edited:
The source of the information there is neonatologist Dr Michael Hall, who bears a well-publicised grudge that he wasn't called to give evidence.
Bollocks. Or will you be providing actual evidence for this claim? :rolleyes:

It is well-known that Letby on one occasion slipped in early to harm a baby and then only swiped her card fifteen minutes later, to make it look as though she cannot have been there. OK, so there have been some issues about the accuracy of the door swiping but even if we disregard those, we only have the claim of Dr. Hall. It was pointed out at the trial that Letby was not on shift on 12 June or leading up to it, and Ben Myers, KC for the defence did mention it in his summing up, so the jury did have that information when they entered their deliberations.
:rolleyes:
 
I very much doubt that. I have taught many Year 1, 2 & 3 students studying social sciences like criminology and the majority have never heard of it before. I doubt that students studying natural or hard sciences have either, since many get no coverage of science versus pseudoscience.



Statistical significance does not tell you the probability that a effect occurred by chance, unless you are using Bayesian analysis. Which is what Lewis' post was about.
Of course. But then Vixen spouts a lot of irrelevant nonsense she doesn't understand.
 
There is zero chance Letby got a fair trial for any reasonable definition of the word "fair".

The average juror or judge would not be knowledgeable enough to assess the complex statistical and medical evidence presented to them. Her original defence team appear to have been incompetent and called no experts to offer alternative interpretations to that of the prosecution witnesses.

A killer nurse is so much easier on the brain as an explanation than the hospital, as with so many parts of the NHS and wider society, is a slow motion disaster. Systemic failures are not very satisfying as explanations: humans want heroes and villains!

Is she guilty or innocent? I have no idea, but I have yet to hear any evidence against her that is beyond reasonable doubt. Weak evidence does not magically become strong evidence if you combine enough of it.

If you think she's guilty, what would convince you she's innocent?

If you think she's innocent, what would convince you she's guilty?

The worst thing about the whole trial, in a whole bevy of bad things happening, was that the prosecution's "expert" "witness" was a retired doctor, who was expounding on medical procedures and crises he never himself experienced in his career and using medical papers that he frankly didn't understand (as attested by the authors of those papers, I'm no expert on medicine or the literature). It's another in a long line of obviously bad convictions by the British courts and like it's predecessors the courts system will uphold it for years, for as Denning said (apropos of the Birmingham Six):
If the six men win, it will mean that the police were guilty of perjury, that they were guilty of violence and threats, that the confessions were involuntary and were improperly admitted in evidence: and that the convictions were erroneous.

“hat would mean that the Home Secretary would have either to recommend they be pardoned or he would have to remit the case to the Court of Appeal under section 17 of the Criminal Appeal Act 1968 .

This is such an appalling vista that every sensible person in the land would say: It cannot be right that these actions should go any further.

The British system is not about justice, it's about maintaining the system.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom