angrysoba
Philosophile
I have looked up Baby C's press report as of the time of the trial (circa 1 Nov 2022, Chester Standard). Letby was on shift on the evening of 13 June 2015 going into 14th June when Baby C died at 5:58am. At 11:15pm on 13 June Baby C's nurse heard the baby's monitor alarm go off and found Letby standing next to his cot.
It was Dr Bohin and Dr Evans who testified. In common with many babies born prematurely, Baby C developed pneumonia in one lung, which was the purpose of the X-Ray on 12 June 2015: standard procedure. He was on a nasal tube plus CPAP. He was given antibiotics and transferred onto Optiflow, due to improvement in his condition. Dr. Bohin said Baby C died with pneumonia but not of it.
Dr. Evans said that the babies diaphragm appeared to be split with the stomach distended in the Xray dated 12 June 2015 (bile problems also being commonplace, as according to Dr. Evans, all premature babies are slightly affected by jaundice). When the Baby collapsed and died on 14 June 2015, Evans said that he virtually suffocated because his diaphragm was collapsed due, he believe to an injection of air.
https://www.chesterstandard.co.uk/news/23092103.recap-lucy-letby-trial-tuesday-november-1/
Police have the opinion on of Letby's favourite Modus Operandi was to dislodge babies' feeding tubes, and she was present, alone at Baby C's cot when the alarm went off, on 13 June 2015, having just six minutes earlier sent a social media message to a colleague saying she wanted to be with Baby C (because of what happened to Baby A) but had been allocated to a different room and then first thing she did on awaking after finishing her night shift at 8:00am, was to search baby C's parents on FB. The mother of Baby C said a nurse with a ponytail told her she didn't think the baby was going to make it, with the mother telling the court via a statement she thought it was a very odd thing for a nurse to say as she expected that prognosis should have come from a doctor, not a nurse.
We only have the Daily Telegraph saying she had never been at the hospital for the period 8th June 2015 to 12 June 2015, with their sources being called 'experts', so is there any firm confirmation that Letby had not been working between those dates?
From the same hearing, Dr Evans claims that air had been deliberately injected into the stomach, and that this showed up on the X-ray of June 12th:
12:38am
Mr Myers says the x-ray from June 12 had helped form Dr Evans's initial view that there had been an air injection into the stomach. "That was an opinion I have expressed, yes." Mr Myers asks Dr Evans what evidence there is to support that air had been injected into the stomach on June 13.
Dr Evans: "The baby collapsed and died."
Asked to explain further, Dr Evans says it was part of a differential diagnosis.
He said there were three clinical scenarios - injecting air into the stomach that interfered with his breathing, or that air was injected intraveneously, or from a combination of the two, which Dr Evans says "sounds awful".
Dr Evans says, from his perspective, from an academic point of view, he would not be able to rule out any one of those three scenarios.
And then on June 13th?
Vixen, you have questioned whether the Telegraph has accurately reported that Letby had not been on shift from the time of Child C's birth, to the time of the X-ray.
If this turns out to be corroborated, then will this change your opinion, somewhat about how sure you can be that Letby killed Child C?
Or would you just assert that she probably killed him a different way? Or that she snuck in while off-shift and somehow was responsible for the air bubble?