Merged Concerns over baby killer ignored? / Nurse Lucy Letby killed babies in her care

Their verdicts were found to be 'unsafe'. There are plenty of people who still believe Siôn Jenkins, Barry George (see the Netflix documentary for the opinion of the lead detective), Judith Ward, Patrick Hill, the so-called IRA bombers are not at all innocent but because of flaws in the trial, their convictions were deemed 'unsafe'. As was the case of the guy who killed two little girls - got off first time and then modern forensic techniques managed to match a fibre found on one of the little girls to his jumper and he was convicted some many years later. This proves that there are safety nets for flaws in procedures. The system is biased in favour of defendants because no right thinking person wants to see a potentially innocent person receive a whole life sentence.
:rolleyes: Just pathetic.

Flailing all over the place. :rolleyes:
Still averse to facts then?
 
What you fail to realise is that the prosecution represented the Crown vs each victim (x 20 charges, of which five were either, 'not guilty' or 'could not reach a verdict and dropped'). The police and the CPS were determined to bring justice to each of the victims and thus they were discrete cases, each tried on its own merits (some, of course, including attempted murder plus murder of one victim were amalgamated into one case). So the probability of 15 x guilty verdicts out of 20 can indeed be calculated it the same way as tossing a coin, give or take one or two adjustments to the calculations and taking into account degrees of freedom. It provides a rough idea of the vanishingly remote odds of the jury having come to a guilty verdict by chance.
Sweet jeebus this is utter nonsense.

<drivel snippage>
she was found guilty by her peers of 'twelve men goode and true' fifteen times.
Not actually true, as I pointed out. But then you know bugger all about the trial, do you?
 
There are two grounds that Letby can appeal on. One is her defence was incompetent. The other, is that the prosecution's expert witness, Dr Evans, fails the Bolam Test. That test was from a legal case about medical negligence, which failed because the doctor did what the majority of doctors would have done in the same situation. If it can be shown that the majority of doctors, when shown the medical evidence Evans was shown, would reach a different conclusion, and that Evans is an outlier, then his opinion that it was murder, can be dismissed.

https://x.com/drphilhammond/status/1832666572298518828
 
There are two grounds that Letby can appeal on. One is her defence was incompetent. The other, is that the prosecution's expert witness, Dr Evans, fails the Bolam Test. That test was from a legal case about medical negligence, which failed because the doctor did what the majority of doctors would have done in the same situation. If it can be shown that the majority of doctors, when shown the medical evidence Evans was shown, would reach a different conclusion, and that Evans is an outlier, then his opinion that it was murder, can be dismissed.

https://x.com/drphilhammond/status/1832666572298518828
There have been a lot of experts expressing critical views of Bolam's theories regarding air injections, especially via a nasogastric tube. Terms like 'nonsensical', 'rubbish', 'ridiculous', and 'fantastical" were used.
Likewise his claims regarding skin discolorations.
 
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news...epth-failures-at-lucy-letby-hospital-revealed

A superbug, doctor shortages and a neonatal unit ‘out of its depth’: failures at Lucy Letby hospital revealed

"Our investigation reveals a hospital unit operating beyond its skills and capacity – one that was understaffed and suffering from low morale, lacking the expertise to deal with babies with serious needs, and operating from a tired building struggling with a superbug and with sewage backing up into its rooms."
 
There have been a lot of experts expressing critical views of Bolam's theories regarding air injections, especially via a nasogastric tube. Terms like 'nonsensical', 'rubbish', 'ridiculous', and 'fantastical" were used.
Likewise his claims regarding skin discolorations.

From the Appeal Court written reasons for rejecting the four grounds of appeal:

190. For that reason, we see considerable force in Mr Johnson’s submission that the evidence relating to Baby A illustrates why the applicant’s approach is misguided. The evidence showed that in life, Baby A had air bubbles in his brain and lungs; and immediately after his death, a lot of air was found in his great vessels. All those findings were consistent with, though not diagnostic of, air embolus. Baby A collapsed and died in circumstances very similar to those of his twin sister the following night. The applicant was present on both occasions. There was ample evidence on which the jury were entitled to find that she had poisoned two other babies with insulin. In short, the circumstantial evidence and medical evidence has to be considered in its totality, not reduced to a single issue as to skin discolouration as a basis for diagnosis.
judiciary.uk

Letby put forward four grounds of appeal, each of which involved the submission that the trial judge wrongly refused applications she made during the trial at Manchester crown court. She was refused permission by Dame Victoria Sharp and Lord Justice Holroyde.

Sharp, the president of the King’s Bench Division, noted: “This court, having heard that application, has decided to refuse leave to appeal on all grounds and to refuse all associated applications."

And yes, the Appeal Court spent weeks looking at the issue.
 
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news...epth-failures-at-lucy-letby-hospital-revealed

A superbug, doctor shortages and a neonatal unit ‘out of its depth’: failures at Lucy Letby hospital revealed

"Our investigation reveals a hospital unit operating beyond its skills and capacity – one that was understaffed and suffering from low morale, lacking the expertise to deal with babies with serious needs, and operating from a tired building struggling with a superbug and with sewage backing up into its rooms."

Are you able to explain how this lets Letby off the hook?

Bear in mind, this Felicity Lawrence is one of the 'miscarriage of justice' campaigners.
 
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news...epth-failures-at-lucy-letby-hospital-revealed

A superbug, doctor shortages and a neonatal unit ‘out of its depth’: failures at Lucy Letby hospital revealed

"Our investigation reveals a hospital unit operating beyond its skills and capacity – one that was understaffed and suffering from low morale, lacking the expertise to deal with babies with serious needs, and operating from a tired building struggling with a superbug and with sewage backing up into its rooms."
Yes, the CoC appears to have been a bit of disaster area. Quite probably many of the supposed murders, weren't.
 
Last edited:
From the Appeal Court written reasons for rejecting the four grounds of appeal:

judiciary.uk

Letby put forward four grounds of appeal, each of which involved the submission that the trial judge wrongly refused applications she made during the trial at Manchester crown court. She was refused permission by Dame Victoria Sharp and Lord Justice Holroyde.

Sharp, the president of the King’s Bench Division, noted: “This court, having heard that application, has decided to refuse leave to appeal on all grounds and to refuse all associated applications."

And yes, the Appeal Court spent weeks looking at the issue.
Like your take on the verdict, this isn't true. But it seems like you don't care.
 
Yes I am, because it is self-evident. I doubt it’s worth trying to explain it to you, though.

So you believe it is 'self evident' that there was a miscarriage of justice or that the convictions are unsafe because the CoC Hospital had staff shortages, 'superbugs' and plumbing issues.

It is no surprise at all that you are unable to explain how that equates to a miscarriage of justice or an unsafe verdict.
 
Yes, the CoC appears to have been a bit of disaster area. Quite probably many of the supposed murders, weren't.

A guilty verdict doesn't become a miscarriage of justice just because you wish it were so. Saying it is a miscarriage of justice doesn't make it so.

I note you are incapable of explaining how it is 'a miscarriage of justice' apart from referring us all to sundry mysterious 'experts' who 'wrote an article which said it was'.
 
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news...epth-failures-at-lucy-letby-hospital-revealed

A superbug, doctor shortages and a neonatal unit ‘out of its depth’: failures at Lucy Letby hospital revealed

"Our investigation reveals a hospital unit operating beyond its skills and capacity – one that was understaffed and suffering from low morale, lacking the expertise to deal with babies with serious needs, and operating from a tired building struggling with a superbug and with sewage backing up into its rooms."
The revelations from Great Ormond Street aren't reassuring either.
https://www.theguardian.com/society...r-children-suffered-severe-harm-under-surgeon
 
So you believe it is 'self evident' that there was a miscarriage of justice or that the convictions are unsafe because the CoC Hospital had staff shortages, 'superbugs' and plumbing issues.

Rule of so applies. That's not what I said, nor is it what I meant.

The fact that you can't figure this out only makes me more confident that you don't know what you're talking about in practically any context.
 
A guilty verdict doesn't become a miscarriage of justice just because you wish it were so. Saying it is a miscarriage of justice doesn't make it so.

I note you are incapable of explaining how it is 'a miscarriage of justice' apart from referring us all to sundry mysterious 'experts' who 'wrote an article which said it was'.
:rolleyes:
Sigh. I've listed several eminent experts who have raised concerns over the Letby case. You are determined to ignore these facts.
Other than that, you're spouting your usual drivel.
 
A guilty verdict doesn't become a miscarriage of justice just because you wish it were so. Saying it is a miscarriage of justice doesn't make it so.

A guilty verdict doesn't become correct just because you wish it were so, or even just by its very existence. Saying the jury found someone guilty doesn't make them factually guilty. Do you disagree?
 
Rule of so applies. That's not what I said, nor is it what I meant.

The fact that you can't figure this out only makes me more confident that you don't know what you're talking about in practically any context.
Vixen has clearly and obviously not bothered to do even basic research. She even gets the jury verdict wrong.
 
Vixen has clearly and obviously not bothered to do even basic research. She even gets the jury verdict wrong.

I followed the case daily. I followed the live tweets from the court room from the official BBC court room correspondent and the DM podcast bod.

Your references to 'miscarriages of justice' in historical cases informs me that you consider it a trendy fun past-time to claim Letby is innocent, when there is zero evidence of unfairness. You are unable to articulate in which way it is a miscarriage other than to refer to other people.

Put it in your own words. Explain why it is a miscarriage of justice in your view, otherwise I'll continue to assume that you put more stock in an article that takes less than an hour to read than you did in actually following the trial over eight months. So much easier to say, 'see Dr Hammond in Private Eye' or 'Dr Adams in the New Yorker', or even Dr Lee, whose embolism 'fresh evidence' was looked at by the Appeal Court and dismissed as 'misguided'.

Unless you can spell out how it is a miscarriage or unfair, I can't take your claim as being in good faith.
 
A guilty verdict doesn't become correct just because you wish it were so, or even just by its very existence. Saying the jury found someone guilty doesn't make them factually guilty. Do you disagree?

I agree, Letby isn't guilty because I wish it were so. Letby is guilty because that is the factual objective legal status.
 
I agree, Letby isn't guilty because I wish it were so. Letby is guilty because that is the factual objective legal status.

No.

Being found guilty doesn't make a person guilty, it means they were found guilty.


I'm not arguing whether Letsby is guilty or not, she could very well be, but that has nothing to do with the result of the trial.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom