[Closed]Active Thermitic Material Discovered in Dust from the 9/11 World Trade Center

Status
Not open for further replies.
scientific facts are dependent on where they are published?

Good one!

the truth will not be kept down for long!
It is true you can publish dirt dumb ideas in pay as you go journals of stupid and get dirt dumb followers to rise up and post stupid stuff on the Internet. What action can you see 911Truth doing but post the next smoking gun.

If not bad enough paying to publish tripe only incredibly stupid people can believe, you have the no feedback hearsay expert making up extremely stupid scenarios for 911.
The new ceiling tiles with embedded thin-film explosives and wireless ignitors are installed throughout every other floor of the Tower starting just below the planned crash zone. The South Tower gets the same treatment above the 95th floor. In all, each Tower gets 500,000 of the large tiles and 400,000 of the small tiles.
With workers swapping in new tiles at an average rate of ten tiles per minute per worker, it takes a team of twenty workers 50 hours to retrofit an entire Tower. The work is performed in a week and week-end of night shifts, emptying one truckload per night, with the truck parking inconspicuously in the WTC subterranean parking garage. ... http://911research.wtc7.net/essays/thermite/blasting_scenario.html
The 911Truth guru Hoffman now manufactures pathetically doltish ideas as he writes more fictional delusions on 911. Dr Jones and Hoffman continue to apologize for 19 terrorists. Nut case ideas don’t die, they find new hosts too dumb on 911 issues and topics so they repeat the nut case ideas and rejoice that this is it, the new super smoking gun to solve 911 and bring the bad guys to justice.

The irony is Hoffman based his factual tripe on the nut case made up work of Dr Jones.

Hoffman adds twenty new workers to the list of murderers. Thank you so very much Jones and Hoffman for apologizing for terrorism and spitting on those who died on 911 by making up lies and fictional accounts so you can mislead the ignorance and gullible on 911 issues.

Dr Jones is not crazy, he is the expert of experts and his new paper is the Messiah in a vanity journal article paid for with other nut case idea believer money. There is money in selling dirt dumb ideas on 911 but how can you be so disrespectful and take those who are ignorant on 911 issues, how can you take their money?

From Dr Jones (at least the poster calls himself jones)
I welcome SCIENTIFICALLY-BASED comments and scrutiny of this published paper.
As you see attacks, please note them here so that I can follow and respond (as I have time). My experience from a newspaper article on the "Fourteen Points" paper published in 2008 may be relevant. That article (in Deseret News) was published on a SATURDAY and there were hundreds of comments. But the comments were nearly all positive UNTIL THE NEXT MONDAY MORNING, then the negative comments poured in, mostly from "anonymous" persons who used mocking and straw-man arguments. That was an eye-opener for me.
This paper was published on FRIDAY, and I predict that the comments will turn negative mostly after the weekend, because I suspect from experience that there are "paid mercenaries" who will mount the attack when they get back to "work" after the weekend... And I predict that they will not have scientifically-sound rebuttals to this paper, just as they lacked scientifically-sound rebuttals to the FOURTEEN POINTS paper. They will attack the peer-review, the origins, etc.; maybe it's just paint (although THAT fallacious argument is rebutted already in the TOCPJ paper in detail) -- but they will lack solid SCIENTIFIC rebuttals. We'll see -- but let's keep track of the negative or scurrilous reports and the ratio of these to positive comments... Should be interesting.

2. Second author is Dr. Jeffrey Farrer of BYU. http://www.physics.byu.edu/images/people/farrer.jpg
3. Dr. Farrer is featured in an article on page 11 of the BYU Frontiers magazine, Spring 2005: “Dr. Jeffrey Farrer, lab director for TEM” (TEM stands for Transmission Electron Microscopy). The article notes: “The electron microscopes in the TEM lab combine to give BYU capabilities that are virtually unique… rivaling anything built worldwide.” The article is entitled: “Rare and Powerful Microscopes Unlock Nano Secrets,” which is certainly true as regards the discoveries of the present paper.
http://www.911blogger.com/node/19761?page=1

Wow, we are in trouble now, they have “real evidence” of nano nano super thermite! Oh noes. AHhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
 
I'm still waiting for an explanation of how the tons of Super Thermite works sideways. I see Metamars had a fantastic suggestion that super thermite paint could be used to heat up one side of a beam. Hey metamars, just how thick is this paint, six inches?

I didn't double-check this - caveat emptor. I also made no attempt to figure out any diluting effects inherent in sol-gel therm*te. It's just a rough calculation.


From http://www.journalof911studies.com/volume/200703/Sudden_collapse_initiation_impossible.pdf (Legge and Szamboti), max yield is decreased by over 50% at 600 deg C.

The specific heat of steel is 500 J/(Kg*K).


So, 1 kg steel, w/temperature raised by 600 deg C, needs 500 * 600 Joules
= 300,000 J


I guesstimate that we only need 1/4 of this this 1 kg of steel heated to 600 C, to get differential heating, sufficient to cause a tilt, as I outlined. So, I'll assume that we need ~ (300,000 J/ 4) = 75,000 J.

Energy density of thermite is 4MJ/kg. So we need 75 / 4,000 kg = 0.01875 kg thermite per kg of steel.

That's about 2%, by weight.

Since the mass density of steel is 7850 kg/m^3, and the mass density of thermite is 3474 kg/m^3, the volume ratio is roughly 4% thermite to steel.

(See http://physics911.net/thermite)


Say that a box column side is 1 inch thick, and x meters high, and y inches wide. Applying 4% thermite, by volume, to just this one side, over x meters times y inches, obviously is 4% of 1 inch, thick. (Applying over all 4 box column sides would give you just 1% for each side.)

4% of 1 inch is about 1 millimeter.
 
Last edited:
I think the plausibility is 0%. An airliner full of fuel exploding is going to give a big enough fireball.

Color me skeptical. There are lots of plane crashes every year. Ignoring military crashes of jets carrying napalm and/or exotic fuels and/or bombs that blow up at the instant of impact, if fireballs were the rule, any rare survivors would still be badly burned.

Plowing through a building with lots of columns to help aerosolize the kerosene jet fuel will change things, but how much?

Like I said, color me skeptical.
 
I
I guesstimate that we only need 1/4 of this this 1 kg of steel heated to 600 C, to get differential heating, sufficient to cause a tilt, as I outlined. So, I'll assume that we need ~ (300,000 J/ 4) = 75,000 J.
Please how much heat is needed to do the whole job in joules and how much thermite is use. The totals please. Can't do it can you?

Just more tripe and lies? How much total super thermite is needed, how much heat is needed in joules? Produce the numbers. You can't?
 
Okay, I will. I am not a Chemist, but I have worked with optics since I rebuilt my first telescope at age 12. So I know a thing or two about spectral analysis.

IIRC, Inconsistent and wildly misinterpreted spectra was one of Jones' major achilles heels for his original Cold Fusion claim way back when.
 
Please how much heat is needed to do the whole job in joules and how much thermite is use. The totals please. Can't do it can you?

Just more tripe and lies? How much total super thermite is needed, how much heat is needed in joules? Produce the numbers. You can't?

If my calculation of 2% therm*te to steel mass ratio is correct, then calculating the thermite weight is trivial, given the weight of columns in however many stories you want to calculate. (I'd probably go with 10, or reread Kevin Ryan's paper about the 'work' done on the towers to see what floors were mentioned.)

As for Joules, multiply 75,000 J by that same column weight in kg, and you'll have your answer.

What's so hard about doing that?
 
If my calculation of 2% therm*te to steel mass ratio is correct, then calculating the thermite weight is trivial, given the weight of columns in however many stories you want to calculate. (I'd probably go with 10, or reread Kevin Ryan's paper about the 'work' done on the towers to see what floors were mentioned.)

As for Joules, multiply 75,000 J by that same column weight in kg, and you'll have your answer.

What's so hard about doing that?

As a practical test, 1,000 pounds of thermite doesn't do all that much damage to a SUV.

Mythbusters Toast 1/2 Ton of Thermite
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PPAYZMzGMwQ
(notice slag falling off hood and that the SUV isn't melted into a puddle of liquid steel.)​

It appears that most of the thermite burns off with no effect. Any thermite not in contact with steel is wasted and that would be a limiting factor for how much damage could be done to a beam.
 
If my calculation of 2% therm*te to steel mass ratio is correct, then calculating the thermite weight is trivial, given the weight of columns in however many stories you want to calculate. (I'd probably go with 10, or reread Kevin Ryan's paper about the 'work' done on the towers to see what floors were mentioned.)

As for Joules, multiply 75,000 J by that same column weight in kg, and you'll have your answer.

What's so hard about doing that?
You can't do it! You failed to present the total joules of heat needed in your failed delusion world.

You can't do it! You failed to present the total amount of super duper thermite needed to do what you said happen in your failed pathetic delusion world of thermite junk ideas.

You can't do it! Why? Math a problem? Why can’t you guys in 911Truth do anything right? Why are you failing for over 7 years?

Do the numbers present the work or your junk ideas are exactly that, pure junk.

Do nothing 911Truth comes out and can't produce the totals. Math chanllenges or just failed frauds?

Answer the simple questions or be seen as the delusional nut case idea pushers of the failed 911Truth movement. Got math?
 
Last edited:
You can't do it! You failed to present the total joules of heat needed in your failed delusion world.

You can't do it! You failed to present the total amount of super duper thermite needed to do what you said happen in your failed pathetic delusion world junk ideas.

You can't do it! Why? Math a problem? Why can’t you guys in 911Truth do anything right? Why are you failing for over 7 years?

Do the numbers present the work or your junk ideas are exactly that, pure junk.

Do nothing 911Truth comes out and can't produce the totals. Math chanllenges or just failed frauds?

Answer the simple questions or be seen as the delusional nut case idea pushers of the failed 911Truth movement. Got math?

Can I make a suggestion? Why don't you put a link to your last 2 posts in your sig, and have the hyperlinked text read something like "Beachnut spanks deluded, math-challenged, 911 Truther"? A scintillating intellect such as yours is nothing to hide. I think that newcomers to JREF would appreciate the ability to quickly see a stellar JREF intellect, such as yours, in action against a lesser light, such as myself.
 
Can I make a suggestion? Why don't you put a link to your last 2 posts in your sig, and have the hyperlinked text read something like "Beachnut spanks deluded, math-challenged, 911 Truther"? A scintillating intellect such as yours is nothing to hide. I think that newcomers to JREF would appreciate the ability to quickly see a stellar JREF intellect, such as yours, in action against a lesser light, such as myself.
You can’t calculate the amount of thermite you said was needed to do the job; you posted the stuff, but you can’t say the total joules you need, or the amount of thermite needed because it is a fantasy and you can’t do the numbers and total it up! Try to do some math.

You are the one who said this!
If my calculation of 2% therm*te to steel mass ratio is correct, ...
As for Joules, multiply 75,000 J by that same column weight in kg, and you'll have your answer.

What's so hard about doing that?
But you can't do it! Failure is 911Truth for 7 plus years of stupid ideas. Post the total super thermite needed, and the amount of heat needed. Else you are spewing junk science and you can't do the math.

Simple, what is hard about doing that? You can't do it; that is what is hard for you.


Your lack of totals is self-critiquing like all of 911Truth a bunch of talk and failed ideas; your lack of ability to do what you say is not hard debunks your failed repeat of junk science by 911Truth expert guys who spew nut case ideas on 911.

too hard for you? totals; waiting for totals from 911Truth.
 
Last edited:
As a practical test, 1,000 pounds of thermite doesn't do all that much damage to a SUV.

Mythbusters Toast 1/2 Ton of Thermite
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PPAYZMzGMwQ
(notice slag falling off hood and that the SUV isn't melted into a puddle of liquid steel.)​

It appears that most of the thermite burns off with no effect. Any thermite not in contact with steel is wasted and that would be a limiting factor for how much damage could be done to a beam.

Painting it on would give a much better coupling of thermite and steel (I should think). Ironically, the key limiting factor may be one that Professor Jones has missed. Professor Jones has talked about the steel frame wicking away the heat, but as Schneibster at physforum pointed out (I've also seen him post at JREF), steel isn't that good a conductor. The office fires would probably outpace any wicking effect.

In the case of thermite painted on steel, even with better coupling, a similar limiting factor may apply. Perhaps most of the heat energy will be lost via radiation and convection before it can penetrate the steel, via conduction.

Of course, the NWO has quite a budget, owning all the printing presses, as they do. Splashing another couple of millimeters of nanothermate should be no problem, financially speaking.

Some other differences with the video (which I enjoyed, btw), is we are talking nanotherm*te, and we are not trying to burn our way through metal, but rather differentially weaken metal which is already under enormous stress, to the point where a tilt would occur.

(Unless we're just trying to ignite splattering jet fuel, so it makes a big fireball. :D )

Finally, this video mentioned a strong UV output. I wonder if a similar effect in the case of nanotherm*te should leave a detectable trace in surviving WTC debris. It shouldn't penetrate steel, beyond a narrow skin depth, but if it can harm human eyes, maybe it'll leave traces in paper, and such.
 
But you can't do it!

Actually, I can do it. In fact, I've written a computer program utilizing Gregory Urich's data, which I can quickly tweak to tell me the column mass between any 2 floors. Indeed, I've posted the C# source code (with some errors, which I subsequently pointed out), so anybody with programming skills can do this.

You didn't get the hint, so I'll speak more bluntly - STOP, because you're making a fool out of yourself. If you really think, though, that somebody with a degree in math and physics, like myself, can't multiply by 75,000 on the one hand, and 0.01875 on the other, then go ahead - tell the JREF board members more about what dummies we 911 Truthers are.
 
Painting it on would give a much better coupling of thermite and steel (I should think). Ironically, the key limiting factor may be one that Professor Jones has missed. Professor Jones has talked about the steel frame wicking away the heat, but as Schneibster at physforum pointed out (I've also seen him post at JREF), steel isn't that good a conductor. The office fires would probably outpace any wicking effect. ...
Why not present the formula for the paint. lol

You can't even specify the total heat required or the amount of super thermite needed.

How truthy of you.

Got math, not in 911Truth; they use hearsay, lies and produce delusions? Paint?

Can't calculate the totals, no one in 911Truth can answer questions on their own delusions because they are... delusions.
 
Last edited:
Actually, I can do it. In fact, I've written a computer program utilizing Gregory Urich's data, which I can quickly tweak to tell me the column mass between any 2 floors. Indeed, I've posted the C# source code (with some errors, which I subsequently pointed out), so anybody with programming skills can do this.

You didn't get the hint, so I'll speak more bluntly - STOP, because you're making a fool out of yourself. If you really think, though, that somebody with a degree in math and physics, like myself, can't multiply by 75,000 on the one hand, and 0.01875 on the other, then go ahead - tell the JREF board members more about what dummies we 911 Truthers are.
Please produce the total amount of super thermite needed in your delusion.

Please present the total heat in joules required.

You say it is simple but you can't do it. Is this called failure on you part?

Why can't you post the total heat in joules and the total super thermite? errors in your program?


Actually, I can do it. ...
Called; do it! So simple we will have now instantly metamars present the total heat needed in joules and the total amount of super thermite to do his specified scenario. He is an expert at this with a degree in math and physics. Cool, simple totals coming in...

Do it.
 
Last edited:
:blush: Umm... not to be picky, especially since you were kind enough to answer my questions patiently... but because some here like to jump on nitpicky details instead of allowing for casual language, I thought I'd better offer the following. Along with a statement of full understanding that you weren't trying to be specific, but rather were just making an offhand remark. Anyway:



Flights 175 and 11 weren't full. A Boeing 767 is capable of holding just under 24,000 gallons of fuel. AA11 - the one that hit the North tower - was estimated to have had around 9,000 gallons of fuel at the time of impact. UA175 was estimated to have around 8,200 gallons.

Not trying to be nitpicky or overly pedantic myself. Just wanted to steel you for the inevitable, apoplectically incredulous "full of fuel??" cheap shot some others might have decided to take. Best to head that off, and save you the trouble of explaining to a truther that you were just speaking informally.
Thanks - it was an off hand remark, because I was trying not to make a snide comment towards a post that seemed to be a joke, seeing as he had been polite. I'm never sure - Poe's Law and all that.. but the "benefit of the doubt goes to the batsmen" (cricket).

I'm sadly aware that this sort of comment can be picked upon and misconstrued, but it's difficult to keep tabs all the time. Thanks for the detail with regard to fuel loads - I now have roughly a 1/3 capacity in my brain. ;)

Now is that US or Imperial gallons? :D
 
Called; do it! So simple we will have now instantly metamars present the total heat needed in joules and the total amount of super thermite to do his specified scenario.

I'll make you a deal. If I calculate the two quantities, as I say I can, then you will put me on ignore, forever, and I will do likewise.

Agreed?
 
I'll make you a deal. If I calculate the two quantities, as I say I can, then you will put me on ignore, forever, and I will do likewise.

Agreed?
Your failed efforts at making up delusions about 911 is not funny, it is sad after your claim of two degrees in math and physics.

Now you can't produce the total heat needed to do what you say happened at the WTC towers. You can't produce the total thermite used, or how it was used at the WTC. But the total is fine; when can you run that super program you have from the other web site were maj tom helps you make your delusions more truthy?

Was it paint, or was it in the ceiling tiles; which delusion of 911Truth is the true fantasy for all of 911Truth. This becomes real sad after your claims of higher education.

Post the total heat to make your story come true, and the total thermite needed to complete your latest delusion. What happen to your beam weapon junk?

But even when you post your numbers, your super thermite is and always will be pure delusional claptrap.

Are you using paint and ceiling tiles? This gets better each time Dr Jones makes up a new back-in the evidence smoking gun revelation.
Got those totals yet?
 
Last edited:
Your failed efforts at making up delusions about 911 is not funny, it is sad after your claim of two degrees in math and physics.

Now you can't produce the total heat needed to do what you say happened at the WTC towers. You can't produce the total thermite used, or how it was used at the WTC. But the total is fine; when can you run that super program you have from the other web site were maj tom helps you make your delusions more truthy?

Was it paint, or was it in the ceiling tiles; which delusion of 911Truth is the true fantasy for all of 911Truth. This becomes real sad after your claims of higher education.

Post the total heat to make your story come true, and the total thermite needed to complete your latest delusion. What happen to your beam weapon junk?

But even when you post your numbers, your super thermite is and always will be pure delusional claptrap.

Are you using paint and ceiling tiles? This gets better each time Dr Jones makes up a new back-in the evidence smoking gun revelation.
Got those totals yet?

please seek help. Does JREF have a 12-step program? I know you feel boxed in. Everything will be OK.

:boxedin:
 
ETAII: I missed this the first time -- they did not latch onto me because I complained about their reviewing process before. I did that on my own time from my home e-mail. Their invitation to me went to my work e-mail. I have about 40 articles of my own out there, I'm not hard to find.

That makes a little more sense. This is like a call centre or a collection agency that looks through the phone book and markets their services that way. Now, if that's the case, it's possible that Jones or his pals got exactly the same email that you got. So the light bulb that went on was in their heads:

Some sciency journal wants us to join up and write some things and maybe show them that thing we scooped up in some lady's apartment. Woo-hoo! Peer review and all that there kinda thing! Hey Griffin, where's your chequebook?

So I was wrong. You're trapped in a Faulkner novel instead.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom