So... just curious... suppose it actually was thermite, instead of red (iron-pigmented) paint chips. A layer of thermite the thickness of a thick coat of paint--given something as massive as a steel beam, is the paint-thickness thermite likely to heat the beam up enough to make it too warm to pick up without gloves? Weaken steel? Liquify?
No. Assuming a 100% efficient thermite reaction and 100% of all the heat generated (after heating the Fe and Al
20
3) is going to melt the steel with a final temperature of 1540°C the perfect scenario would allow 1g of thermite to melt 1.88g of steel. Funnily enough this comes from a paper by a truther - It's not a bad way to get a theoretical upper limit and I think the chemistry and mathematics is good - shame about alot of the rest.
http://www.journalof911studies.com/volume/200704/JLobdillThermiteChemistryWTC.pdf
This is obviously not a real world scenario and you'd have lots of factors to add in that would reduce this upper limit by a significant amount. Even using the upper limit, paint of this thickness couldn't possibly melt through the thickness of material inherent in a steel beam.
Obviously, Dr. Jones and company are aware that there's more than one kind of paint, or else they wouldn't have suggested the mystery substance could be "paint."
I noticed this on my first read through. I was expecting data and the source of the paint they use for comparison so waited until I had read the entire paper, but none turns up. This is very sloppy to say the least. There are hundreds of different types of paint. This doesn't need further comment it's that bad.
Keep in mind that I'm not firm on that last possibility . I note no nitrogen peak on the EDX graphs, and cyanates are one of the components of urethane polymers, so I'd need Sunstealer to tell me if the lack of such a N peak falsifies my line of inquiry.
Unsure about the N peak to be honest, it depends on the machine and the detector/window and the KeV. They do state that they use a SiLi detector. You can google the SEM model number "FEI XL30-SFEG" and have a look.
30 second google looks like it can but bear in mind that specs change and there are usually different customisation options -
http://www.matsci.ucdavis.edu/MatSciLT/Appendices/Files/FEI-XL30-SFEG.pdf
Anybody asking material scientists for criticism and comments, as I suggest, please also ask 2 questions:
1) what is the plausibility of a paint on nano-thermitic being used to create column weakness via asymmetric pressures resulting from asymmetric application? In other words, if you have a a spliced column, and you paint on nano-thermite on one side only, and then ignite it, will the differential in size between the heated side and the non-heated side cause the splice to crack? What if applied on one side of a 3.8 m length of unspliced column? Will the differential in size cause the column to noticeably bend?
Interesting idea to try a thermal shock method which is what i think you are asking, but you are not going to be able to crack steel in that fashion because you require a number of cycles to produce that effect.
http://espace.library.uq.edu.au/eserv/UQ:10040/Price_sif04.pdf
Also bear in mind the temperature of thermite, how fast it reacts and how it's unable to sustain temperatures for any length of time with the fact that the steel will oxidise heavily then the likelyhood is that all you are going to do is spall off a thin layer of rust.
2) What is the plausibility that paint on nano-therm*te was used to provide an 'impressive' fireball, in the moments of first impact?
I think the plausibility is 0%. An airliner full of fuel exploding is going to give a big enough fireball.