[Closed]Active Thermitic Material Discovered in Dust from the 9/11 World Trade Center

Status
Not open for further replies.
It would be better if you copped a plea and testified against Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld, Giuliani, and Silverstein.

Guiliani? He is part of the massive conspiracy too??

How about Henry Stern? He had personnel at OEM in WTC 7 on 9-11.


:D

The JREF forum is gonna be around for a long, long time. But you know what internet forum is really dead? Loose Change. They get about 1 post a day. That tells you something about the health of the "9-11 truth" movement.
 
Last edited:
...
I would like to see the debunkers hounded by Truth Squads and WeAreChange for the next 20-odd years!

It is already starting to happen, as Truth-Seeker Galilei and his band of merry men continue to hound those who dwell here.

Nice to tell us you are just a troll presenting second hand lies from Jones and his band of fringe failed professional 911Truth delusion manufacturers.

His paint chip from rusted steel is cute and very interesting to a kid but I have found the same junk in a fire. Good golly, Jones has a piece of junk with paint and rust on it and he says it is thermite and you spread his lie for him insulating him against being a liar; he implies and you lie.

Wake up and figure out no rational person makes up thermite four years after 911 and then tries and fails to “back in” the evidence.

What is the story not, the thermite was painted on the steel? How thick? This gets more ridicules each time Jones’ delusions and nut case ideas are resurrected from the pit of ignorance at 911blogger where dumb kids repeat insane bat crazy ideas from 911Truth junk dealers.


Big clue the paper is trash is the fact they had to pay to publish it because real science journals will not publish lies and bias tripe! Second big clue are the 911Truth sources cited in the paper. Bad news. For a big laugh drop by an engineering school and present this to the engineering department. Make my day, do it and report back oh great 911Truth expert Galileo.
 
Last edited:
I would like to see the debunkers hounded by Truth Squads and WeAreChange for the next 20-odd years!

Galileo, you or Dr. Jones have yet to present spectral evidence consistent with thermite. How can you claim thermite is present when the spectra does not show the 4.5 keV titanium marker? I thought you wanted to talk evidence?
 
Galileo, you or Dr. Jones have yet to present spectral evidence consistent with thermite. How can you claim thermite is present when the spectra does not show the 4.5 keV titanium marker? I thought you wanted to talk evidence?

At least give Jones credit for predicting that so called debunkers such as yourself would employ the strawman of referring to the paper's conclusions as deriving from thermite:

I predict that debunkers will mostly ignore the detailed results from the Differential Scanning Calorimeter, the two Figures with DSC plots, which show that the energy release from two chips in kJ/gram EXCEEDS the maximum output available from THERMITE alone.

And let's see if they address our evidence for NANO-thermite (as opposed to the straw-man arguments against ordinary thermite). In the past, NIST and others seem to have been incapable of acknowledging that we have evidence for super-thermite (nano-thermite), not just thermite!
 
At least give Jones credit for predicting that so called debunkers such as yourself would employ the strawman of referring to the paper's conclusions as deriving from thermite:

RedIbis, this is basic science. If a material exists, then so will its elemental fingerprint in a spectral analysis. So please, you or Dr. Jones please show me the control spectra for this material so I can compare it to the samples. If you can't, then you are just blowing smoke.
 
OMG!

Is another truther bringing up the old Bentham Publishing BS again. Did we not go over this TWICE???

TAM:)
 
Well, if this really is that big a deal, they should contact all the major news outlets immediately. Someone, somewhere, will put it on the news.

Maybe Press TV? Russia Today? =)
 
At least give Jones credit for predicting that so called debunkers such as yourself would employ the strawman of referring to the paper's conclusions as deriving from thermite:

:confused:

Red, "nano" thermite is thermite. The energy available in the redox reaction does not change simply because someone processed it to a finer degree. The amount of joules, kilocalories, or whatever unit you want to use per unit of mass doesn't change. The amount that's released in a classic reduction-oxidation reaction is set by the reactants, not by their processing.

If he's getting more energy than what should be available in a given amount of thermite, then either he's discovered the muon catalyzed cold fusion he's been searching for in the last two decades, or he's seeing something above and beyond a Fe2O3-Al redox reaction. It's that simple. This isn't a strawman; it's a statement of the obvious. I take his statement less to be a prediction of how someone can misinterpret his work and more a statement to give you believers cover to say "Look, the expert saw you coming!". He must answer why he's getting more energy out of the system than what's to be expected from a standard thermite redox. It's that simple.

Really, Red, I thought even you were a more critical thinker than that. Color me disappointed.
 
So... just curious... suppose it actually was thermite, instead of red (iron-pigmented) paint chips. A layer of thermite the thickness of a thick coat of paint--given something as massive as a steel beam, is the paint-thickness thermite likely to heat the beam up enough to make it too warm to pick up without gloves? Weaken steel? Liquify?
No. Assuming a 100% efficient thermite reaction and 100% of all the heat generated (after heating the Fe and Al203) is going to melt the steel with a final temperature of 1540°C the perfect scenario would allow 1g of thermite to melt 1.88g of steel. Funnily enough this comes from a paper by a truther - It's not a bad way to get a theoretical upper limit and I think the chemistry and mathematics is good - shame about alot of the rest. http://www.journalof911studies.com/volume/200704/JLobdillThermiteChemistryWTC.pdf

This is obviously not a real world scenario and you'd have lots of factors to add in that would reduce this upper limit by a significant amount. Even using the upper limit, paint of this thickness couldn't possibly melt through the thickness of material inherent in a steel beam.

Obviously, Dr. Jones and company are aware that there's more than one kind of paint, or else they wouldn't have suggested the mystery substance could be "paint."
I noticed this on my first read through. I was expecting data and the source of the paint they use for comparison so waited until I had read the entire paper, but none turns up. This is very sloppy to say the least. There are hundreds of different types of paint. This doesn't need further comment it's that bad.


Keep in mind that I'm not firm on that last possibility . I note no nitrogen peak on the EDX graphs, and cyanates are one of the components of urethane polymers, so I'd need Sunstealer to tell me if the lack of such a N peak falsifies my line of inquiry.
Unsure about the N peak to be honest, it depends on the machine and the detector/window and the KeV. They do state that they use a SiLi detector. You can google the SEM model number "FEI XL30-SFEG" and have a look.

30 second google looks like it can but bear in mind that specs change and there are usually different customisation options - http://www.matsci.ucdavis.edu/MatSciLT/Appendices/Files/FEI-XL30-SFEG.pdf

Anybody asking material scientists for criticism and comments, as I suggest, please also ask 2 questions:

1) what is the plausibility of a paint on nano-thermitic being used to create column weakness via asymmetric pressures resulting from asymmetric application? In other words, if you have a a spliced column, and you paint on nano-thermite on one side only, and then ignite it, will the differential in size between the heated side and the non-heated side cause the splice to crack? What if applied on one side of a 3.8 m length of unspliced column? Will the differential in size cause the column to noticeably bend?
Interesting idea to try a thermal shock method which is what i think you are asking, but you are not going to be able to crack steel in that fashion because you require a number of cycles to produce that effect. http://espace.library.uq.edu.au/eserv/UQ:10040/Price_sif04.pdf

Also bear in mind the temperature of thermite, how fast it reacts and how it's unable to sustain temperatures for any length of time with the fact that the steel will oxidise heavily then the likelyhood is that all you are going to do is spall off a thin layer of rust.


2) What is the plausibility that paint on nano-therm*te was used to provide an 'impressive' fireball, in the moments of first impact?
I think the plausibility is 0%. An airliner full of fuel exploding is going to give a big enough fireball.
 
I noticed this on my first read through. I was expecting data and the source of the paint they use for comparison so waited until I had read the entire paper, but none turns up. This is very sloppy to say the least. There are hundreds of different types of paint. This doesn't need further comment it's that bad.

I was trying to keep it simple for Red and Galileo, but that is exactly what my point is. There are no control spectra for comparison. The only thing I see that Dr. Jones has demonstrated in this paper is that there was NO thermite present in the samples he did spectral analysis on. So, if there is some super-thermite, nano-thermite, or whatever, give us a control spectra so that we can see its signature.
 
:blush: Umm... not to be picky, especially since you were kind enough to answer my questions patiently... but because some here like to jump on nitpicky details instead of allowing for casual language, I thought I'd better offer the following. Along with a statement of full understanding that you weren't trying to be specific, but rather were just making an offhand remark. Anyway:

I think the plausibility is 0%. An airliner full of fuel exploding is going to give a big enough fireball.

Flights 175 and 11 weren't full. A Boeing 767 is capable of holding just under 24,000 gallons of fuel. AA11 - the one that hit the North tower - was estimated to have had around 9,000 gallons of fuel at the time of impact. UA175 was estimated to have around 8,200 gallons.

Not trying to be nitpicky or overly pedantic myself. Just wanted to steel you for the inevitable, apoplectically incredulous "full of fuel??" cheap shot some others might have decided to take. Best to head that off, and save you the trouble of explaining to a truther that you were just speaking informally.
 
Last edited:
OMG!

Is another truther bringing up the old Bentham Publishing BS again. Did we not go over this TWICE???

TAM:)
The dolts at Jones institute for dumb 911 ideas did it again. A new pay for your woo to be published journal article.

http://www.bentham-open.org/pages/content.php?TOCPJ/2009/00000002/00000001/7TOCPJ.SGM

The use references from their own failed journal articles and online 911Truth work.

At least they are dumb enough to pay for this after being rejected by real journals. How stupid does it get?
 
I would like to see the debunkers hounded by Truth Squads and WeAreChange for the next 20-odd years!

It is already starting to happen, as Truth-Seeker Galilei and his band of merry men continue to hound those who dwell here.

Moderators, please take note: Galileo outright admits that his intention is to troll.
 
Moderators, please take note: Galileo outright admits that his intention is to troll.

good one, giving facts does not a troll make.

maybe the hijackers brough super thermite or supern thermate onto the planes, along with their box-cutters?
 
The dolts at Jones institute for dumb 911 ideas did it again. A new pay for your woo to be published journal article.

http://www.bentham-open.org/pages/content.php?TOCPJ/2009/00000002/00000001/7TOCPJ.SGM

The use references from their own failed journal articles and online 911Truth work.

At least they are dumb enough to pay for this after being rejected by real journals. How stupid does it get?

scientific facts are dependent on where they are published?

Good one!

the truth will not be kept down for long!
 
um...didn't they say this in 2006?

I predict they will still be saying this in 2015.

Galileo, deal with it. Your side lost. The facts defeated you.

yes, and that is the point. Gal knows the truth movement is all but dead. That is why it is clear he is trolling with his "it won't be long now" antics.

TAM:)
 
scientific facts are dependent on where they are published?

Good one!

the truth will not be kept down for long!

Facts? C'mon champ, it is a typical Jones special. Got about as many facts as his Jesus came to America "Peer Reviewed" Article (snerk!)

Super Thermite! It is Super!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom