[Closed]Active Thermitic Material Discovered in Dust from the 9/11 World Trade Center

Status
Not open for further replies.
not unlike what you want done to bin Laden and KSM.

Are you comparing me to a terrorist who murdered 3,000 innocent people?

What did I do??

Honestly, Galileo. What do you want to see done to debunkers?

Put on trial for aiding and abetting the "criminal conspirators"??

Put on trial for treason?

Lynched??

You can be honest Galileo. Tells us the truth.
 
Last edited:
Ah, but when they looked closer at the red and gray chips, what did they discover?



9-11 was a Vegas job!
 
I love reading your stuff, Mackey. This is pure comedy gold. It's almost as though the plot is being ghost-written as a screenplay. I just wonder what thought processes are going on in the minds of these Bentham people. They latch on to the fact that you are a scientist because you question them about their peer review P&P. So the light bulb goes on:

Hey, this guy seems sciency. Let's hit him up for some money!

Ever get the feeling you're trapped in an Evelyn Waugh novel?

It gets even worse. :D

Bentham's Open Chemical Physics Journal has, in its brief lifespan, produced exactly two issues. With a total of 12 articles between them, so far.

Their Editorial Advisory Board, on the other hand, has an astounding 100 members.

As you saw from the e-mail they sent me, they expect each of these people to pop out a paper every year. Apparently, these individuals are of such high caliber that less than half can even do that, assuming a rather high five authors per article and no overlaps, even if the entire publication history of the Journal comes from its own editors. I don't have to tell you that this isn't what "editor" usually means -- typically they review works submitted by other people. Otherwise, you have a closed community, reviewing each other, each with a mutual stake in success. That's not peer review. That's advocate review.

ETA: Out of the 12 articles published so far, only five do not have at least one Editorial Board Member as a co-author. These are the first four articles (suggesting they may have been on the Editorial Board, but since departed or been kicked out) and Dr. Jones's article. Damn.

ETAII: I missed this the first time -- they did not latch onto me because I complained about their reviewing process before. I did that on my own time from my home e-mail. Their invitation to me went to my work e-mail. I have about 40 articles of my own out there, I'm not hard to find.

Tell me, O Truth Movement faithful, was this Journal Dr. Jones's first choice?? Why?

Apparently, you really can fool some of the people all of the time. :cool:
 
Last edited:
I was going to suggest that some forum members put together a response to the paper and get it published in the original journal. Journals do occasionally publish crap papers, and a quick response that points out the errors will often be welcome. It shows integrity.

But... the journal doesn't have a reputation to maintain, let alone an impact factor, and, thanks to its very shady business model, getting a response published would put anyone so inclined to in a thousand dollar hole. It's not worth it.

And there's a giant sized problem with Bentham's model, right there. It encourages vanity publishing by locking people in with memberships and promising discounts on their publications. If journal editors feel an obligation to publish someone's work because that person's membership entitles them to publication rights, quality will be the first thing to go. And as pay to publish is a formidable barrier, the likelihood of anyone outside the journal's walls wanting to critique an article within will surely be very low.

All Jones managed to achieve here was a publication in an inbred, pay to publish rag with a reputation for spamming scientists with requests to edit in a desperate attempt for legitimacy. Peer reviewed my naked arse.
 
Their Editorial Advisory Board, on the other hand, has an astounding 100 members.

There could be a good reason for that...

For others, the experience of being targeted by Bentham proved even more frustrating. When Professor John Furedy, Emeritus Professor of Psychology at the University of Toronto, received an invitation to be editor-in-chief of the Open Behavioral Science Journal he initially accepted. But after doing so he found himself being bombarded with further invitations. And when Bentham failed to reply to the questions he raised about the new role he had taken on he decided the best course of action was to withdraw his acceptance, reluctant to be associated with a company that behaved in this way. Even though he had resigned, however, Furedy was surprised to see that his name had been added to the list of editors on the journal's web site. And despite repeated requests to Bentham to remove it his name remains there to this day.
 
I was going to suggest that some forum members put together a response to the paper and get it published in the original journal. Journals do occasionally publish crap papers, and a quick response that points out the errors will often be welcome. It shows integrity.

But... the journal doesn't have a reputation to maintain, let alone an impact factor, and, thanks to its very shady business model, getting a response published would put anyone so inclined to in a thousand dollar hole. It's not worth it.

Exactly. That was what I attempted to do the first time this happened. (ETA: Not publish a response, though, simply point out to the editors that they'd made a grave mistake in putting out such a shoddy paper.) What I found, of course, was that the Journal is just a website being run out of Pakistan, with absolutely no clue what they're doing. If that kind of publishing is worth $600 to you, then by all means, go ahead.


I've seen a lot of complaint about Bentham, and as noted above I've also been targeted by their spam from time to time, but this is yet another wrinkle I didn't know about. I repeat: Damn.

Rather reminds me of multi-level-marketing, in fact.
 
Last edited:
This is sad. Without commenting on the vanity press aspect of Bentham, I actually think the ideal of an open access journal is not a bad one. But the way Bentham is operating is destroying the concept. From here on out, who's goinig to trust open access scholarship, even if it's from some future house that's trying to achieve a high quality of work?

It's sad.
 
This is sad. Without commenting on the vanity press aspect of Bentham, I actually think the ideal of an open access journal is not a bad one. But the way Bentham is operating is destroying the concept. From here on out, who's goinig to trust open access scholarship, even if it's from some future house that's trying to achieve a high quality of work?

I agree completely. As I noted the first time this happened, last year, I like the concept of an open journal. But, if you do this, you need to uphold the very highest quality standards. That clearly is not happening here.

I've helped others start new conferences. I know how it's done. This is not how it is done. It saddens me to see professionals from second-tier institutions, desperate for recognition, get sucked into these kinds of scams, but ultimately it's their own fault. There's plenty of information on Bentham in particular to let you make an informed decision.
 
You are unable to think for yourself, and merely rely on what others tell you. That is the mentality at JREF. Your "conspriracy" forum is going down.

LOL!!

How is that gonna happen? 9-11 truthers are gonna launch a cyber-attack and shut down the servers?

You know, Josef Stalin and Adolf Hitler and Mao ALSO told people "you are unable to think for yourself and merely rely on what people tell you".

All corrupt leaders say such nonsense.

So, Galileo, how is JREF gonna be shut down? What do you want to see done with us debunkers?

Stop evading the question like a coward and answer.
 
LOL!!

How is that gonna happen? 9-11 truthers are gonna launch a cyber-attack and shut down the servers?

You know, Josef Stalin and Adolf Hitler and Mao ALSO told people "you are unable to think for yourself and merely rely on what people tell you".

All corrupt leaders say such nonsense.

So, Galileo, how is JREF gonna be shut down? What do you want to see done with us debunkers?

Stop evading the question like a coward and answer.

you ain't gonna unleash the JREF brownshirts on me, eh?

:jaw-dropp
 
you ain't gonna unleash the JREF brownshirts on me, eh?

:jaw-dropp

You're the one who says our days are numbered.

What do you want to see done to us? Treason charges?

Prison?

Death?

You said "your days our numbered". You said "the conspiracy forum of JREF is going down".

I think we have the right to know exactly what you mean.

If you don't answer I will assume you are just too chicken to answer.

=)
 
Last edited:
I would imagine that Galileo's definition of "not thinking for yourself" is "not thinking like me" because that's obviously what he is saying.
 
I agree completely. As I noted the first time this happened, last year, I like the concept of an open journal. But, if you do this, you need to uphold the very highest quality standards. That clearly is not happening here.

I've helped others start new conferences. I know how it's done. This is not how it is done. It saddens me to see professionals from second-tier institutions, desperate for recognition, get sucked into these kinds of scams, but ultimately it's their own fault. There's plenty of information on Bentham in particular to let you make an informed decision.

Agreed.
This is the problem I have with Wikipedia. There is little or no quality control,and "accuracy" becomes a matter of who can rewrite and edit the fastest.
 
You're the one who says our days are numbered.

What do you want to see done to us? Treason charges?

Prison?

Death?

You said "your days our numbered". You said "the conspiracy forum of JREF is going down".

I think we have the right to know exactly what you mean.

If you don't answer I will assume you are just too chicken to answer.

=)

You will be labeled by the corporate media as soft on mass murder.
 
Are you comparing me to a terrorist who murdered 3,000 innocent people?

What did I do??

Honestly, Galileo. What do you want to see done to debunkers?

Put on trial for aiding and abetting the "criminal conspirators"??

Put on trial for treason?

Lynched??

You can be honest Galileo. Tells us the truth.

Perky76;

I would like to see the debunkers hounded by Truth Squads and WeAreChange for the next 20-odd years!

It is already starting to happen, as Truth-Seeker Galilei and his band of merry men continue to hound those who dwell here.

Do not alter usernames as an insult.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: prewitt81
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Perky76;

I would like to see the debunkers hounded by Truth Squads and WeAreChange for the next 20-odd years!

It is already starting to happen, as Truth-Seeker Galilei and his band of merry men continue to hound those who dwell here.

In every troother beats the heart of a Zampolit.
 
Oh thats good. Cause some truthers want to see us all put on trial for treason and killed.

It would be better if you copped a plea and testified against Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld, Giuliani, and Silverstein.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom