I love reading your stuff, Mackey. This is pure comedy gold. It's almost as though the plot is being ghost-written as a screenplay. I just wonder what thought processes are going on in the minds of these Bentham people. They latch on to the fact that you are a scientist because you question them about their peer review P&P. So the light bulb goes on:
Hey, this guy seems sciency. Let's hit him up for some money!
Ever get the feeling you're trapped in an Evelyn Waugh novel?
It gets even worse.
Bentham's
Open Chemical Physics Journal has, in its brief lifespan,
produced exactly
two issues. With a total of 12 articles between them, so far.
Their Editorial Advisory Board, on the other hand, has an
astounding 100 members.
As you saw from the e-mail they sent me, they expect each of these people to pop out a paper every year. Apparently, these individuals are of such high caliber that less than half can even do that, assuming a rather high five authors per article and no overlaps, even if the entire publication history of the Journal comes from its own editors. I don't have to tell you that this isn't what "editor" usually means -- typically they review works submitted by
other people. Otherwise, you have a closed community, reviewing each other, each with a mutual stake in success. That's not peer review. That's advocate review.
ETA: Out of the 12 articles published so far, only five do not have at least one Editorial Board Member as a co-author. These are the first four articles (suggesting they may
have been on the Editorial Board, but since departed or been kicked out) and Dr. Jones's article. Damn.
ETAII: I missed this the first time -- they did
not latch onto me because I complained about their reviewing process before. I did that on my own time from my home e-mail. Their invitation to me went to my work e-mail. I have about 40 articles of my own out there, I'm not hard to find.
Tell me, O Truth Movement faithful, was this Journal Dr. Jones's first choice?? Why?
Apparently, you really can fool some of the people all of the time.
