[Closed]Active Thermitic Material Discovered in Dust from the 9/11 World Trade Center

Status
Not open for further replies.
Rawstory is a good journalistic outfit. They have better coverage on this than the New York Times and ABC News combined.

Well, the New York Times and ABC News have zero coverage on this because it isn't even a story. Only complete idiots believe super duper thermite was used to destroy the WTC.
 
please seek help. Does JREF have a 12-step program? I know you feel boxed in. Everything will be OK.

:boxedin:
Wow, you present junk science from Dr Jones and you can't product the amount of heat needed or the amount of thermite needed to do it either.

Why are you 911Truth lie presenters short on math and physics but claim to have degrees and so smart that 99.999 percent of all engineers who understand 911 are wrong?

That is correct, you are supported by 0.001 percent of all engineers; your credibility posting this paper of woo is almost as good as zero. Math, you got to love the math!
 
Wow, you present junk science from Dr Jones and you can't product the amount of heat needed or the amount of thermite needed to do it either.

Why are you 911Truth lie presenters short on math and physics but claim to have degrees and so smart that 99.999 percent of all engineers who understand 911 are wrong?

That is correct, you are supported by 0.001 percent of all engineers; your credibility posting this paper of woo is almost as good as zero. Math, you got to love the math!

Using some very complicated mathematics, I derived the following formula.

[latex]CM+I=T[/latex]​

Where CM means Complete Moron. I means Internet. And T means Truther. Thus, if you give a Complete Moron (CM) the Internet (I), you will get a Truther (T).
 
Last edited:
Your original question was

2) What is the plausibility that paint on nano-therm*te was used to provide an 'impressive' fireball, in the moments of first impact?

I replied

I think the plausibility is 0%. An airliner full of fuel exploding is going to give a big enough fireball.
(Please note the casual phrasing of "full of fuel")

And you said.

Color me skeptical. There are lots of plane crashes every year. Ignoring military crashes of jets carrying napalm and/or exotic fuels and/or bombs that blow up at the instant of impact, if fireballs were the rule, any rare survivors would still be badly burned.

Plowing through a building with lots of columns to help aerosolize the kerosene jet fuel will change things, but how much?

Like I said, color me skeptical.
I'm really left quite dumbfounded, because I'm not sure how to react: I know this is not Poe's Law because of metamar's post count and posting history. Is this really the sort of logic that truther's employ? Sadly it seems so.

Yes, there are "lots" of "plane crashes" every year.

Does anyone know about military aircraft that carry, napalm/exotic fuels/bombs that explode on impact, as a matter of course? How about current US military operations? Is napalm being carried and used?

If fireballs were the rule, any rare survivors would still be badly burned.
"Fireballs" aren't the rule. Even when there are horrific "fireballs" some people emerge without severe burns. This may come as a surprise, but there is plenty of evidence, but you won't spend 60 seconds looking for it, but will ask myself and others to do so.

Unfortunately the people onboard the flights that hit the WTC towers weren't as fortunate as you in being able to theorise without any evidence whether it was going to be the fireball that killed them or the deceleration from approximately 500mph. It saddens and sickens me that you can equivocate aircraft crashes that happen due to a number of accidental factors, which are bad enough, but then compare them to the deliberate crashes on 9/11 and then debate the intensity of the fireball, all the while proposing the possibility that this gruesome event wasn't spectacular enough so additional measures were required.

And then you compound the <searching for an appropriate word) of your post with the following.

Plowing through a building with lots of columns to help aerosolize the kerosene jet fuel will change things, but how much?
Aerosolize? This just shows how sick your thinking is. I'm lost for words.
 
Your failed efforts at making up delusions about 911 is not funny, it is sad after your claim of two degrees in math and physics.

Now you can't produce the total heat needed to do what you say happened at the WTC towers. You can't produce the total thermite used, or how it was used at the WTC. But the total is fine; when can you run that super program you have from the other web site were maj tom helps you make your delusions more truthy?

Was it paint, or was it in the ceiling tiles; which delusion of 911Truth is the true fantasy for all of 911Truth. This becomes real sad after your claims of higher education.

Post the total heat to make your story come true, and the total thermite needed to complete your latest delusion. What happen to your beam weapon junk?

But even when you post your numbers, your super thermite is and always will be pure delusional claptrap.

Are you using paint and ceiling tiles? This gets better each time Dr Jones makes up a new back-in the evidence smoking gun revelation.
Got those totals yet?

If I was Paul Krugman, than you would be Timothy Geithner, with your blah, blah, blah.

Well, you lost your chance to waste yet another 15 minutes of my time. Welcome to my ignore list. You'll have to do the simple math and programming tweaks, all by your lonesome.

Happy driveling.
 
OK, someone please tell me if I am understanding this correctly. I do not have much of a scientific background, but I do have a military background, so I have at least a basic understanding of explosives. Jones continues to straddle the line where thermite is both an incendiary and an explosive, depending on what characteristic he needs at the time, but he seems to be suggesting this super magic nanothermite is an explosive, meaning it was not used to melt the steel columns, but to blow through them with force.

He, however, also suggests that this substance was painted on in a thin layer on the beams. Explosives used to cut through steel though, like a shaped charge, work by focusing their force on a very small area, painting an entire beam with a thin layer would have no effect other than blowing all the sheetrock off. There needs to be some sort of compression. It is like with gunpowder, if you pack it into a pipebomb, it makes a big explosion, if you were to spread it out over your driveway and throw a match on it, it would make a big "woomf" and and a flash and do nothing more than burn your eyebrows off.

Am I missing something?
 
Last edited:
Well, you lost your chance to waste yet another 15 minutes of my time. Welcome to my ignore list. You'll have to do the simple math and programming tweaks, all by your lonesome.

...
As expected 911Truth fails to do math and present the total thermite used, and they can't produce the total joules required to do what metamars loosely tried to say happened on 911.

Failure to come up with what metmars said he could do, but he can't because of some unknown learning impediment. Guess he does not have degrees in math and physics but just like to post claptrap from Dr Jones.

There goes another failed idea and 911Truth believers who can’t produce the numbers to prove their delusional ideas. Galileo can’t produce the numbers and he presented the paper of woo published in a vanity journal.

No numbers produce means what? 911Truth has no clue what they are talking about again.
 
Am I missing something?

I guess I am too, because at this point no one has shown me the spectral signature for titanium in the "paint". I consider this important since 70% of thermite is titanium. So Jones has proved there was no thermite and we all knew that already.

So, I guess this is supposed to be some super-thermite that uses only rust and aluminum. I have made a simple request, show me the spectra for this super-thermite made of oxided iron and aluminum only so that I can evaluate the evidence. So far, I'm obviously missing something too.
 
Your original question was



I replied

(Please note the casual phrasing of "full of fuel")

And you said.

I'm really left quite dumbfounded, because I'm not sure how to react: I know this is not Poe's Law because of metamar's post count and posting history. Is this really the sort of logic that truther's employ? Sadly it seems so.

Yes, there are "lots" of "plane crashes" every year.

Does anyone know about military aircraft that carry, napalm/exotic fuels/bombs that explode on impact, as a matter of course? How about current US military operations? Is napalm being carried and used?

"Fireballs" aren't the rule. Even when there are horrific "fireballs" some people emerge without severe burns. This may come as a surprise, but there is plenty of evidence, but you won't spend 60 seconds looking for it, but will ask myself and others to do so.

Unfortunately the people onboard the flights that hit the WTC towers weren't as fortunate as you in being able to theorise without any evidence whether it was going to be the fireball that killed them or the deceleration from approximately 500mph. It saddens and sickens me that you can equivocate aircraft crashes that happen due to a number of accidental factors, which are bad enough, but then compare them to the deliberate crashes on 9/11 and then debate the intensity of the fireball, all the while proposing the possibility that this gruesome event wasn't spectacular enough so additional measures were required.

And then you compound the <searching for an appropriate word) of your post with the following.

Aerosolize? This just shows how sick your thinking is. I'm lost for words.

If it makes you feel any better, I am also dumbfounded, but by your response. You agree that ""Fireballs" aren't the rule.", but because there are fireballs, sometimes, I'm supposed to assume that they are as spectacular as the 911 ones. Is that it?

And because I don't, it "sickens and saddens" you?

Am I in the right ballpark, here?

It's equally befuddling to me as to why, in trying to present a counter-argument to my own, in mentioning the aerosolizing effect of passing through a building with over 300 columns, you claim that this shows "how sick your thinking is"?

How does that work, exactly? The reason that I am suspicious of the fireball is because it seems to encompass all of the fuel that made it outside the building. My assumption is that, absent an igniting agent (e.g., essentially thermite matches painted onto columns), the only non-conspiratorial mechanism that might explain this is an aerosolizing effect due to collisions with columns (and other building contents), which increases the surface area to volume ratio of the droplets of fuel. Maybe that would allow fuel droplets that ignited near hot jet engines to spread a flame to fuel droplets far from hot jet engines, in the space of a second, or so.

Maybe.
 
Last edited:
...
2) What is the plausibility that paint on nano-therm*te was used to provide an 'impressive' fireball, in the moments of first impact?
Zero; what a dumb idea.



Fireball, just jet fuel. Busted; A 180 mph impact, the WTC were at 470 and 590; or is your delusions plane free?

any chance you can do the simple math and come up with totals for you super duper thermite delusion; both heat and kg of thermite used? Can 911Truth do the math?
 
Last edited:
I guess I am too, because at this point no one has shown me the spectral signature for titanium in the "paint". I consider this important since 70% of thermite is titanium.


No, not necessarily. Where did you get this idea? From wikipedia:

Thermites can be a diverse class of compositions. The fuels are often aluminium, magnesium, calcium, titanium, zinc, silicon, and boron. The oxidizers can be boron(III) oxide, silicon(IV) oxide, chromium(III) oxide, manganese(IV) oxide, iron(III) oxide, iron(II,III) oxide, copper(II) oxide, and lead(II,II,IV) oxide. [1]
The most common thermite is aluminium-iron(III) oxide.
The aluminium reduces the oxide of another metal, most commonly iron oxide, because aluminium is highly combustible:
Fe2O3 + 2Al -> 2Fe + Al2O3 + Heat

Now, I'm sending you to bed with no bananas!
 
Last edited:
I'm still trying to figure out how they make this conclusion - "The red portion of these chips is found to be an unreacted thermitic material and highly energetic."

Not that I read many scientific journals, but is there something inherently flawed with this conclusion?
 
Oh yes, we know if it is in Wikipedia it must be true. Scroll back to where I compared the spectra, you'll find a link there. I'm asking for the SPECTRA of the thermite compound you are asserting, because Dr. Jones did not provide this and that is basic science.

So provide the spectra for this super-thermite or shut up.
 
Wake Up and Smell the Aluminothermic Nanocomposite Explosives

Wake Up and Smell the Aluminothermic Nanocomposite Explosives

As Documentation of Thermitic Materials
in the WTC Twin Towers Grows,
Official Story Backers Ignore, Deny, Evade, and Dissemble


by
Jim Hoffman
Version 1.0, April 3, 2009


Introduction

The obliteration of the Twin Towers was the centerpiece of the event that launched the 'War on Terror'. Shocking on multiple levels, the events were especially traumatic for Americans, being the first bombing on the US mainland in modern history that killed thousands of people -- civilians -- in one day. Given the collective psychological trauma of the attack, it is not surprising that public discourse would remain free of observations that the destruction of the Twin Towers bore obvious features of controlled demolitions. Early candid public remarks by reporters and demolition experts where quickly retracted or forgotten. Passage of the USA PATRIOT Act and the invasion of Afghanistan would proceed apace.

By 2003 the United States had two occupations, and an international reputation as a rogue state all resting on a shaky-at-best collapse theory whose principle alternative hypothesis -- controlled demolition with pre-planted pyrotechnics -- had not even been tested by the straightforward forensic analysis of debris for residues of such materials.

By early 2009, the residue testing that NIST refused to do had been done by independent researchers, and published in a chemistry journal. Small bi-layered chips, found consistently in dust samples, have layers of red nano-engineered material that is clearly aluminothermic: it has sub-micron-diameter particles of largely of elemental aluminum, and smaller crystalline grains of primarily Fe2O3. On ignition, the chips produce temperatures above the melting point of iron, leaving tiny iron droplets matching the residues of commercial thermite pyrotechnics.

READ MORE

http://911research.wtc7.net/essays/thermite/explosives_evidence_timeline.html
 
Here's a feature of a controlled demolition alright! :wackyrolleyes:
InwardBowing.jpg
 
Wake Up and Smell the Aluminothermic Nanocomposite Explosives

...
http://911research.wtc7.net/essays/thermite/explosives_evidence_timeline.html
A 911Truth delusion pusher pushes the newest smoking gun by Jones. A software engineer backs the nut case theory of Jones; this is old junk just the dirt dumb movement making up more lies.

He does it with ceiling tiles with thermite and paint of thermite. What new dirt dumb ideas will 911Truth post next year to keep the gullible fooled?
 
A 911Truth delusion pusher pushes the newest smoking gun by Jones. A software engineer backs the nut case theory of Jones; this is old junk just the dirt dumb movement making up more lies.

He does it with ceiling tiles with thermite and paint of thermite. What new dirt dumb ideas will 911Truth post next year to keep the gullible fooled?

All you do is whine and complain.

Wa Waa Waaa.

Do you hate America?

Mods - please move this thread over to politics. It is no longer a theory anymore.

Now we need to find out who put the explosives there, and who set them off.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom