[Closed]Active Thermitic Material Discovered in Dust from the 9/11 World Trade Center

Status
Not open for further replies.
What the hell is the International Center for 9/11 Studies?

Some investigative Googling for anything 9/11-related in that zip finds only this.

9-11 Hair & Nail Salon
10340 Ferguson Rd
Dallas, TX 75228
(214) 327-9609​
 
So... just curious... suppose it actually was thermite, instead of red (iron-pigmented) paint chips. A layer of thermite the thickness of a thick coat of paint--given something as massive as a steel beam, is the paint-thickness thermite likely to heat the beam up enough to make it too warm to pick up without gloves? Weaken steel? Liquify?

I have no expertise whatsoever on this, but every thermite video I have seen has used substantial amounts of thermite to attack a fairly small amount of metal. A paint-chip thickness seems... insignificant. Obviously, though, I could be wrong. Does anybody here know?


I would agree. You need alot of thermite to cut through steel.

Here is a video of a few actual thermite reactions:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WrCWLpRc1yM

Pay attention to the second part of the video, where they burn a hole in the hood of a crappy french car.

Notice how much thermite they have to use just to make a small hole. Notice how the hole is only where the flower pot held the thermite in place long enough to fully react. Notice how the thermite was set off..with a blasting cap. Notice how the entire hood of the car, made of thin sheet metal is completely covered with molten iron at one time, but it just runs off and only scorches the metal...the only hole is where the thermite was held in place. Notice how ◊◊◊◊◊ energetic the reaction is and how much molten iron is created, and how bright it burns. Notice how long the reaction takes.

If it takes a flower pot full of thermite just to burn a hole in a car...how much does it take to cut through steel beams? How do you get it to flow sideways?
 
Some investigative Googling for anything 9/11-related in that zip finds only this.

9-11 Hair & Nail Salon
10340 Ferguson Rd
Dallas, TX 75228
(214) 327-9609​

LOL..a hair salon. I know where that is too. Ferguson road isn't too far from me. That's kinda a shady part of town.
 
I would agree. You need alot of thermite to cut through steel.

Here is a video of a few actual thermite reactions:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WrCWLpRc1yM

These are my two best Thermite videos.

Mythbusters Toast 1/2 Ton of Thermite
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PPAYZMzGMwQ
(notice slag falling off hood and that the SUV isn't melted into a puddle of liquid steel.)

4 pounds of thermite doesn't even melt a PC chassis
http://video.google.ca/videoplay?docid=-4147847319296070400
(Fast forward the first 0:2:30)​
 
Wow..BigAl ..ive never seen that mythbusters one before...that was cool. 1000 lbs of thermite going off. Not even bags of the stuff was able to cleanly cut through the roof of the suv. Took a really long time too. I wonder how the insiders managed to hide all that extra smoke when the thermite when off in the tower?
 
Vanity publications?

Sorry to hear about you reading disability. The name of the journal is: The Open Chemical Physics Journal.

The highly regarded scientist R. Mackey, who recently proved that a 757 traveling at 500 mph will not bounce off a building, has stated that the Open Chemical Physics Journal is just a vanity publication.

BTW: What are R. Mackey's qualifications? Does he have a PhD in physics?

Wow, hey Chris, next time yourself a favor and read the thread before you post, m-kay? Because you just got freaking owned.

Did you see Mackey's post where freaking Bentham asked Mackey "Based on your eminent contributions in the field of space technology, we would like to consider your possible nomination to the Editorial Board Membership of the journal."

As the kids say PWNED!

I'm still waiting for an explanation of how the tons of Super Thermite works sideways. I see Metamars had a fantastic suggestion that super thermite paint could be used to heat up one side of a beam. Hey metamars, just how thick is this paint, six inches? Further, your hero knucklehead jones disagrees, please see his very scientific bic lighter experiment (snicker)
 
Dr. Jones has posted some prescient follow up notes. He must be reading jref:

I predict that debunkers will mostly ignore the detailed results from the Differential Scanning Calorimeter, the two Figures with DSC plots, which show that the energy release from two chips in kJ/gram EXCEEDS the maximum output available from THERMITE alone.

And let's see if they address our evidence for NANO-thermite (as opposed to the straw-man arguments against ordinary thermite). In the past, NIST and others seem to have been incapable of acknowledging that we have evidence for super-thermite (nano-thermite), not just thermite!
http://911blogger.com/node/19761?page=1
 
Dr. Jones has posted some prescient follow up notes. He must be reading jref:


http://911blogger.com/node/19761?page=1
I predict that debunkers will mostly ignore the detailed results from the Differential Scanning Calorimeter, the two Figures with DSC plots, which show that the energy release from two chips in kJ/gram EXCEEDS the maximum output available from THERMITE alone.

And let's see if they address our evidence for NANO-thermite (as opposed to the straw-man arguments against ordinary thermite). In the past, NIST and others seem to have been incapable of acknowledging that we have evidence for super-thermite (nano-thermite), not just thermite!

http://911blogger.com/node/19761?page=1


My investigoogling of energetic nano-compounds finds that they are all described in one way or another as having high values of brisance. That means they go "boom". I welcome any reality check by anyone that actually knows something about this.

For instance:
A lot of work has been accomplished recently
with nanopowders in energetic materials. For
example, it has been proven that because of their
large surface area, the nanopowders can increase the
burn rate in some types of propellants1,3,8-10. There
were also significant developments made in the
“super thermite” area with mixes of nanometric
aluminum and metal oxides11. Those compounds are
said to react at rates approaching (and under
particular conditions even equivalent to) those of
high explosives.
 
"it is expected that all of the board members will publish one article each year in the journal which will be published after the routine reviewing process. The first article received from the EBMs each year will be published free of charge while the subsequent ones will be entitled to a 50% discount off the publication fees for submission of their manuscripts to the journal."

OH. MY. STARS!

That is ridiculous!


Publish the free one to get a free year, then tell them to get stuffed after that.

Maybe he'll get lucky and learn for sure what kind of a sham they are and be able to provide evidence/ instances of just that.
 
Maybe he should focus on what other chemists think instead of worrying about "debunkers".
 
My investigoogling of energetic nano-compounds finds that they are all described in one way or another as having high values of brisance. That means they go "boom". I welcome any reality check by anyone that actually knows something about this.

For instance:

Are you sure about that?
 
My investigoogling of energetic nano-compounds finds that they are all described in one way or another as having high values of brisance. That means they go "boom". I welcome any reality check by anyone that actually knows something about this.

Yup. The article that Dr. Jones references to nano-thermite suggests its use in precision gas generation, i.e. as a microexplosive or one-shot microthruster, with high resistance to external temperature. There's nothing about that technology that suggests suitability for large-scale demolition or weakening of any kind.

The fact that the energy content is significantly higher than any ordinary thermite is, in fact, one of the arguments that proves the stuff is not thermite. Dr. Jones is a funny man.

Again, ordinary paper has about six times the energy content of thermite. Never knew paper was such a dangerous substance, did you? Your houses could explode and burn down at any moment! :D

It's comments like these which make this paper nearly indistinguishable from those extolling the dangers of oxidane. Poe's Law strikes again.
 
Dr. Jones has posted some prescient follow up notes. He must be reading jref:

http://911blogger.com/node/19761?page=1

Yeah, too bad you are not, because in fact that has been addressed in this thread.

Hey Dr. Jones, couple of questions: 1. how much did you pay to have this published or was this your freebie?

2. please share with us the comments from your peer reviewers.

3. what other Journals did you submit this article to and what were their responses.
 
Mackey's posts have not been published in a legitimate scientific journal.

The findings in the other journals you cite are consistent with what is found in this paper.

:confused:

Neither Chemical Physics nor Journal of Chemical Physics have any articles which speak towards Jones's paper.

Galileo, it's important not to make things up in debate. If I were feeling meaner, I could've asked you for a specific citation knowing that you couldn't provide any. But that's too snarky, and I don't feel like being snippy right now. Instead, some advice: What you post should be supportable in some reasonable fashion. In what I've posted so far, I've either indicated where I'm unsure or based what I've written on verifiable sources. You should to the same, unless it's your goal here to never be taken seriously. Now please, from here on out don't just pull things from your backside in order to make a point refutation. Address substance. And do your best to avoid committing logical fallacies, such as unsupported appeals to authority. We all fail at this at some moments in our lives, but it's important to make the effort. All right?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom