My level of education? You failed to comprehend what I wrote. To wit, nowhere in that quote did I attack your character. Try reading it carefully next time.
Nope. If I said that you were a baboon, I would not be a primary source. I have no evidence. Neither do they....Stop being a jerk....if the shoe fits... (in response to being called a jerk)You can and probably will hang on to whatever insane delusions you please...Idiocy.
Not attacking the character? I think not.
This is barely coherent. At no point did I suggest Flight 93 was low-speed. I said that, in aircraft crashes, vegetation damage from ensuing fires tends to be light (dry brush conditions excepted, of course, but not relevant here). It just so happens that this is true for any speed of impact. You interpreted this as saying since Flight 93 affected vegetation similar to low-speed impact pictures (which it does, but not just low-speed impacts!) that all the other features would also be similar to low-speed impacts.
Rmackey, I placed your quote in a a comment below. Now you continually add to the comment which you posted on another thread that you referred me to. I do not care about the vegetation as you still seemed confused about that issue. Do you keep returning to this vegetation issue because I used your own quote against you? For the third time, you stated
Killtown's assertions about the extent of burned and unburned vegetation are based on incomplete evidence cobbled together from TV news screencaptures, and fail to take into accout the litany of airplane crashes that left similar effects on vegetation
Your own debunking of Killtown calls into account the litany of airplane crashes that left similar effects on vegetation and we should then expect to see other similarities
similar smoke plume effects, debris and debris patterns, etc. I care not for the vegetation pattern as it has nothing to do with the context of this discussion. The FACT is you asserted the litany of airplane crashes have similar characteristics and I agree with you. The issue is that the smoke plume does not have a similar characteristic as the litany of airplane crashes. I'm sorry you fail to comprehend the context in which I use your quote. Does it hold that all airplane crashes will have similar characteristics? No. So why did you use that in your point about vegetation that you referred me to? In the case of the smoke plume, I have yet to see a similar plume from an airline impact with the ground that is virtually disconnected from the crash itself and gray.
The point is that you are speculating. This is sophistry. No agency and no person is infallible, therefore by your standards, I can't rely upon anything.
Idiocy. You have no point.
The point is you choose to rely on an agency that confiscated the file and has at no point to my knowledge described what happened to the file or how it was examined. The direct statements of Val about this "file" contradict the
that was returned to her. As she states debris can be seen exiting the smoke plume, however, the file when returned to her shows no visible debris.
Not only that, this same agency have a documented historical of manufacturing and faking evidence in high profile cases.
Source:
Find Articles
Source:
Scotsman
Source:
Toolbox-Vince Foster
These were just small examples from pretty significant cases. Does this prove manipulation in this case? No. Does it justify skepticism and the requirement of further evidence? Yes.
So indeed, individuals within the FBI do manufacture and fake evidence. This i why I am a skeptic first when it comes to information from the FBI.
The statement by the FBI in the article you linked to states they examined the "photo" not the digital file. A bit of a difference in terms of the evidence.
Source:
Windsor Park Stories -What is America?The Shanksville Episodes:
Val McClatchey"The Picture"
Read for comprehension, please.
http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/06218/711239-85.stm This isn't
proof that she donates the profits to charity, but it is evidence. You have no counter-evidence. Point for me.
As far as Mrs. McClatchey retaining some money for expenses,
you'll note I said that profits were donated. Expenses don't count against profit. You can whine and cry about how I also said "all money" was donated if you want, I don't care. My intent was clear, as is your willingness to quote-mine and ignore everything except what you want to read.
Lets examine what said above and check it against your actual statement:
Rmackey-Val is not profiting by this venture, but donates all money sent to Heroic Choices, a charity organization honoring Mr. Todd Beamer, a victim of Flight 93.
Counter evidence? I gave you the statement of her lawyer.
Aside from marketing the photo to news companies, Mrs. McClatchey sold personal copies. She charged $20 for each, $18 of which went to the Todd Beamer Foundation. Mr. Beamer was a passenger on Flight 93. The rest of the money from personal sales went for paper and printing costs, her lawyers said.
Source: Pittsburg-Post Gazette
Now your just refusing to admit your wrong.
You don't care? Then why are you even debating this issue. Whine and cry? The point is, you are wrong. It is ok to admit it, Rmackey. We all make mistakes or are you infallible in your reasoning skills?
Now stating you said one thing, when in fact you said something different is dishonesty. At what point has "all money" changed into "not expenses"? At what point did the marketing charge to news outlets in the amounts of $250 to $350 turn into a "profits donated to charity". The news article I linked to mentions nothing of hundreds of dollars going to charity with the context of the $18 donation to charity. You failed to mention in the article you linked to the fact that she is keeping some of the money for the legal suit. Your source is a bit dated as well considering the April 2007 article
I used and the statements of Val's lawyer.
Point for Swing, case closed.
Um... you were the one who claimed my metric said something about your hypothesis, not me. And it appears you didn't even use it, and it's certain that you didn't use it properly. Did you forget that part?
Nope I agreed with you on your point. Why would I use a scale that is untested for reliability, accuracy, and falsifiability, unless of course I used it in sarcasm? Point yours for well written fiction.
I'd be convinced it was fraudulent if:
Any of the major parties confessed
Of course not many people are going to openly admit to defrauding people unless in a court of law and even then the possibility exists of lying about fraud. If so, the person stands to loose a lot of money and face possible jail time. This may come out in the lawsuit filed by the press or it may not.
The FBI found significant digital artifacts in the photograph
So you don't care to have the digital file verified? Ok. Your prerogative. That is a condition I would call for. Everything else is meaningless. Unless the digital file is verified, paper and ink are meaningless.
Other photographs bitwise similar to the photo were found, supporting a compositing argument
Physical calculations based on the other evidence were sharply at variance with the photograph's contents
The physical calculations aren't going to determine the authenticity of a digital file, only the accuracy of ink on the piece of paper.
However, none of this has happened. Quite the opposite. The FBI is satisfied with it, there are no photos anywhere that appear to be source images, and the physics matches to a T.
See above point about the FBI.
Looking at your answers, you're in trouble. Both conditions are satisfied. As you already know, the FBI put experts on it and
concluded it was genuine:
Yep, it was a real piece of paper with ink on it. You can buy a piece of paper as well.
Well they stated the photo appeared to be authentic, but no mention of the digital file composed of 1's and 0's.
Condition unsatisfied.
As for the second, the "primary source" folks you're talking about don't say what you think they said, as I will demonstrate below. Uh-oh.
Lets examine if the following accounts of Rmackey's intreptation are accurate or if they are generalized, taken out of context, ignored, ommitted, or lied about. I hate to state lie, but as I will show below, that is exactly what has happened along with the fallacy of omission. Rmackey assumes you will take his word for it, but encourages you do listen to the files themselves. I encourage you to do the same and then compare them to the transcripts I've included in this post.

This is a lot more damaging to your case than you realize. You've admitted that the image
contents are correct and will withstand forensic scrutiny. You've accepted that the only way to falsify the image is through analysis of the
underlying code, i.e. individual pixels, file fingerprints, etc.
The pixels and fingerprints are not the code. You are confused. The code is the digital file as recorded by the camera on the memory card and then on to the hard drive. I accept your lack of understanding what digital code is, i.e. 0's and 1's.
I've admitted no such thing about the content of a digital file. Please stop making false statements.
Since you admit this, you also admit that your "primary sources," none of whom are photo experts and none of whom could have accessed the original image, can claim it is false. They are only going by a view of the image. As you admit, the view is correct.
Lets examine the logic:
1. One witness, Mr. Purbaugh, sees the sky before impact, the impact, and after impact with an unobstructed view the whole time. You have a complete account for this witness and his wife and by conversation confirms the photo is a fraud. As he does not dispute the wife's statement or correct it while on the computer listening to his wife during the phone call.
I don't recall admitting he view is correct. Another false statement.
I would admit that it was after the digital file was analyzed by experts.
Neither do I. However, as we will soon see, they didn't criticize the image at all.
Another outright lie as the transcripts below reveal.
I downloaded and listened to all three of these, roughly an hour of recorded telephone conversations -- with the infamous "
Jeff" from Sault-Ste. Marie. Yes, him.
That is Swing's "evidence."
The recorded statements of the people is the evidence. The caller's identity is of no relevance to the topic.
Let's suppose I didn't already know about "Jeff" and what a hoser he is (are you him??).
Attacking the source, and no I'm not Jeff.
What makes you think this is evidence? Like you say, people lie, people do bad things. You think they always tell the truth on the telephone to random jokers from Canuckistan? Furthermore, you're complaining that the photo might have been digitally altered, even though real experts say otherwise -- but you don't think these MP3 files might have been edited, or even fabricated from whole cloth? What kind of double standard is that?
Then sir, the burden of proof is on your shoulders, speaking of double standards. Or better yet, call them up yourself and have them confirm or correct what they said. The person, as I'm unaware if he is an expert, stated the photo was genuine, not the digital file.
In the first of the three recordings, "Jeff" speaks primarily to Mrs. Purbaugh. She is understandably agitated about those seeking to profiteer from the events of Sept. 11th, and also irritated at those sensationalizing the news with false and exaggerated reporting (sound like any Movement we know?). The question of Val McClatchey's photograph comes up four times:
[*]Approx. 2:00: "It's bull[rule 8]!" At this point, Mrs. Purbaugh is clearly referring to the larger issue of profiteering, and not commenting on the technical merit or accuracy of the photo. Even if she was, she gives no reasoning whatsoever.
5:15: "Now she's rich as can be." No discussion of the photo itself, merely commentary on her allegedly ill-gotten gains. None of this is supported, of course.
6:30: Led by "Jeff"'s question of "how would we prove it's fake," she speaks of looking through archives to see "if a paper was marked up." Clearly she is thinking the photo was embellished by a news organization. She does not realize that the image on the camera's memory card was analyzed directly by the FBI.
26:00: Discussion of Val's personality and motive, revolving around money, again focused on the larger media circus. No discussion of the photo itself.
Hmm, no evidence of a fake photo. Indeed, no evidence that Mrs. Purbaugh even thinks the photo
is fake, unless you apply an extremely literal reading of the phone call. And even if she does, she gives no reasoning, no explanation at all.
In regards to the first call, prior to the relevance of the specific photo, Purbaugh states that profeterring from the death of people, including hotel and restaurants is wrong and disgusting.
Lets examine the portion Rmackey left out either on purpose or by accident.
Jeff-"Well thats was I was thinkin' too,like that one lady Val McCatchy, she sells a photograph for $20
Purbuagh-"Sorry, its bull*** we're so disgusted
Jeff-"I've even
Purbaugh-"so digusted"
Jeff-"I've even talked to uhh what her, Kelly Levernknight, and they said this Val McClatchy's photo is fake and stuff like that.
Purbuagh-"Um hum" (notice the distinct lack of "no its not fake, it is real" or "it matches what my husband saw" but affirms the fake)
Later on after discussion of the memorial
Jeff-" Like its a pretty small town and like you guys must kind of all know each other?
Purbaugh-"Yes. Everybody knows everybody."
Jeff-"What do people think about Val McClatchy then? Do they all think what a disgusting person or..?
Purbaugh-"Yeah.
Jeff-"Yeah"
Purbaugh-"Oh yeah."Chuckle "Oh yeah." louder chuckle.
Jeff-"Then all of the sudden it was like, the way I read it, its like she was almost bankrupt and then all of the sudden that happened.
Purbaugh-"Oh yeah! And now rich!"
Jeff-"Now she's rich and has her own real estate businesses and all this stuff.
Purbaugh-"Rich as can be. Inaudible off of it. They want to put a McDonalds in up here a hotel up there.
Jeff-"But why wouldn't the FBI or the police or whoever or the authorities, be like lady this is fake, like what are you doing?
Purbaugh- "Because its money. I guess its money. Money talks around here." (notice the distinct lack of a correction about the photo authenticity.)
Jeff-"Where is she getting the money just from the $20 photo?" (I've already posted a statement from Val's lawyer about where the money is coming from.)
Purbaguh-"What I don't understand is why people, why the victims, family members, are not coming to Shanksville or to Sommerset county and bein' like this is wrong.
How can you make money off of my daughter or my son, or my husband, or my wife? And thats what they are doing."
She goes on to discuss the birth of her child on Sept. 11th, and expresses her extreme distate with a media outlet that completely changed her husband's story.
She goes on to allow Jeff to publish her information as long as it is the complete truth and nothing changed. Not looking good, RMackey. In the husband's conversation,
he is made aware of the recorded phone conversation without protest. She goes on to her displeasure about the New York Times interview as well.
Jeff-(after having Mrs. Purbaugh's thoughts on the photo) Like is there anyway that you know of to prove Val McCathy's photo is fake? Or...like..I don't know.
Like...I knew it was fake. I knew it was fake as soon as I saw it.
Purbaugh-"I don't know how to go about provin' it, except look through our archives here and see if a picture was docted up from here to another newspaper." (
Notice the distinct lack of correction to the fake)
Jeff-"That Kelly Levernknight she said that her mom or whoever I think I was talking to her daughter or somethin' I don't know and she said that her mom was the first one there and she said that she had taken pictures
and they were printed in the Shanksville paper and never anywhere else.
Purbaguh-"It isn't the Shanksville paper its the Daily American Sommerset paper that everybody in Sommerset county and county around gets the View.
In the media and in...whatever the official story is, is that Val McClatchey's picture is the only picture of 93 of anything. Thats the official version that her picture is the only thing that shows 93
Purbaugh-"Wow"
Jeff-" And thats b..s.. eh?"
Purbaugh-"Yeah."
Later on in the conversation...
Jeff-"You know, I can't believe that Val McClatchy thing. That blew my mind, llike when I was talking to Kelley and she said that it was fake, and I was like what?! Did I hear you right? I had to get her to say it three times, I couldn't believe what I was hearing.
Purbaugh-"Kelly's only reporting what she gets."
Jeff-"I know but you, I asked you and you said the same thing. I mean theres like two people now."
Purbaugh-"Right."
Kelly goes on to have Jeff call them back.
RMackey-No discussion of the photo itself, merely commentary on her allegedly ill-gotten gains. None of this is supported, of course.Indeed, no evidence that Mrs. Purbaugh even thinks the photo is fake, unless you apply an extremely literal reading of the phone call. And even if she does, she gives no reasoning, no explanation at all.
Did you not expect me to examine your claims?
RMackey, these are outright lies, as the transcript shows. I've just lost a substantial amount of respect for you. I do not understand why you would lie about the conversation to support your position. Is that the accepted standard of debate within these forums?
If you have lied about this, what else have you lied about throughout your presence on these forums?
Read the transcript and stop lying.
She affirmed the fake photo and doesn't need to give reason as her husband saw the flight's impact! Which puts you in a predicament. Is her husband lying about the plane's impact or is he lying about what he saw unobstructed on the way to the site is he lying about the photo or both or neither? Or is what was stated factual and the photo itself is a fraud?
Lets examine your next analysis.
The next phone call is strictly with Mr. Purbaugh. The photo is not even mentioned. Mr. Purbaugh, however, indicates that his position was directly upwind of the impact, and thus his view would be quite a bit different than Mrs. McClatchey's.
The photo is mentioned in the opening of the phone call. Mr. Purbaugh does not correct his wife's comments nor does he correct any statement surrounding the suggestion of a fraudulent photo in either call. Not only that, as these people are so passionate about the truth of their statements it would be contradictory to their nature surrounding the event.
No one should expect him too because it is not a photo of what he saw that day. He would be the one person to know! But instead of accept the Purbaugh's comments, you have to lie about them. I'm truly disappointed.
The third and final telephone call, to Ms. Leverknight, does make an isolated claim about the photograph, but one that is easily understood. This is also the funniest of the three, as her contempt for "Jeff" is palpable:
3:20: "It was a fake photo, it didn't have a mushroom cloud." Um... Val's photo clearly does contain a "mushroom cloud," or more correctly a smoke ring. It's not clear that Ms. Leverknight knew what photo "Jeff" was talking about, or if she did, that she had actually seen it. This cannot be viewed as credible. She also indicates elsewhere that she was a student (high school?) at the time of the event!
4:50: [Jeff] "How could they say the only photo of the crash that exists be Val McClatchey's?" [Ms. Leverknight] "Because they're idiots?" Here she is referring to pictures her mother took at the crash site substantially after impact. There are tons of such photos. The smoke in those photos is residual smoke rising from the wreckage, not the smoke of impact. Apples and oranges.
7:00: Ms. Leverknight makes her feelings about "Jeff" plain -- and he doesn't get it at all. Hilarious.
My favorite exchange takes place at about 8:00: [Jeff] "Why doesn't nobody do anything about Val McClatchey's photo?" [Ms. Leverknight] "Cause-- it's called freedom?"
Twisting the comments again? I see another reflection of dishonesty. "It" is referring to the impact. It is very clear what photo Jeff is talking about as you can tell from the transcript below. I hope people don't actually read some of your comments here and accept them as truth and fact without checking first as I have.
But lets examine the transcript relevant to the topic-
Jeff-"And they even said that.uh..that photo, that famous photo from uh some lady..uh its got like the smoke cloud or whatever they said that supposedly, thats maybe a fake photo and all this stuff like and the smoke plume doesn't line up like it should, I don't know thats weird, Val McClatchey, yeah thats it. She has a famous photo or somethin'"
Levernknight-"It was a fake photo because it didn't have a mushroom cloud."
Jeff-"It what?"
Levernknight-"There was no mushroom cloud." (she is clearly speaking of the crash site no need to try confuse the situation, Rmackey.)
Jeff-"So it was a fake photo?"
Levernknight-"Yeah."
Jeff-"Her photo's faked?"
Levernknight-"Yeah."
Jeff-"For what? For money?"
Levernknight-"Yeah."
Jeff-"You know that for sure?"
She goes on to explain that her mother was the first one on the crash site. And that people who state that Val's photo was the only one ever taken were idiots and discusses how her mother's picture was printed in the local paper.
Jeff goes on to ask why no one doesn't do anything and in truth, RMackey states [Jeff] "Why doesn't nobody do anything about Val McClatchey's photo?" [Ms. Leverknight] "Cause-- it's called freedom?"
Ms. Levernknight-cause its called freedom of speech."
Jeff-"But isn't that like fraud or forgery or something like that?"
Levernknight-"Well then that just her forte, isn't it?"
Based upon the above conversation, the exposure of how you have outright lied about the conversation with the Purbaughs, lied about your own quotes about the money received and the your statements about the litany of crash sites, your speculation, I've come to the conclusion that you, sir, haven't a leg to stand on, and if you do have a leg to stand on, it is appears to be false leg. I'm truly and honestly shocked.
To my friends from Canada, a beautiful and civilized nation, rest assured I am well aware that "Jeff" is not representative. No insult to the rest of you is intended, and if I have given offense, you have my apologies.[/size]
Attacking the source.
Why should I listen to you any further?
Perhaps I won't.
I think for your credibility on this issue alone, it would be best to not respond.
Today 02:00 AM
Pardalis Swing Dangler's ass, meet Swing Dangler, Swing Dangler, meet your ass.
You may want to revise your statement after you re-examine the facts and the analysis of RMackey's comment instead of relying upon someone else to do it for you.
, your entire argument rests on the authenticity of Val's photo. I could cut and paste a picture of burning jet fuel and it would pass your criteria for an actual event. Your analysis in now way refutes the premise that the photo is in all probability is a fraud.