Chemical Engineer Mark Basile confirms Harrit nano-thermite results

What we can consider proven and confirmed is that you are not a competent chemist. xerogel Fe2O3/UFG Al nanocomposite is merely one form of nano-thermite.
What source tells you that the stuff looks anything like the crap that Harrit has tested?
 
Not only was ultra fine grained elemental aluminum not proven to be present, but it was shown to actually be absent to a significant degree. Jones's and Harrit's own spectrographs show this, and Farrer confirms it with his observation of platelet-like structures. The aluminum present was bound in kaolin, and this is clearly and unequivocably shown in the data. There's nothing else to say about this. Breathless proclaimations to the contrary do not change this fact. Neither do appeals to authority. The data itself shows that it was not thermite.
 
Okay, we know from WTC Dust's posts that crushed fire resistant foam was found in the dust. It would be impossible, as far as I can see, for there not to have been bazillions of tiny chips of paint from the steel structures and office furnishings in the dust. You simply cannot strip a coating of something off a piece of steel and tumble it in the presence of tons of whirlking twirling slabs of concrete and long blade-like pieces of steel without knocking off a considerable amount of paint. Even Jonesie's chips could only have been removed by processes that would, neccessarily, have remnoved paint as well.

How did the chuckling little dimwit separate the paint from his thermite chips in the dust samples? What ever he did, he forgot to document it, if he actually did separate them out.

My guess is, he didn't.

(Actually, he could not have, because they were all paint chips.)
 
You are blowing smoke.

When investigating thermitic materials and activity "minutiae" scientific research is required.

MM

So it has to be minutiae, but doesn't matter if competent method or incompetent method?

Gotcha.
 
Not only was ultra fine grained elemental aluminum not proven to be present, but it was shown to actually be absent to a significant degree. Jones's and Harrit's own spectrographs show this, and Farrer confirms it with his observation of platelet-like structures. The aluminum present was bound in kaolin, and this is clearly and unequivocably shown in the data. There's nothing else to say about this. Breathless proclaimations to the contrary do not change this fact. Neither do appeals to authority. The data itself shows that it was not thermite.

Yep. The absence of elemental Al is a huge drawback :rolleyes:

I was going to respond in detail to Basile's ignorance of fire technology and his confusion over eutectic corrosion vs. state-change melting but suddenly found a cool beer more attractive.
 
You are blowing smoke.

I'm blowing smoke??

LoL.

You are the one who will not acknowledge, much less address, my very simple argument: What does it say about the technical competence of the investigators if they invent their own indeterminate tests when cheap, definitive tests are readily available?

Please answer this question.

The irrelevancies that you toss around while evading my question may well be described as "blowing smoke".

___

This is simple.

US courts have made a concerted effort over the last 20 years or so to eliminate "junk science" from the court room. This is for EXACTLY the reason that we are confronting here: Questionable experts have presented questionable testing & analysis to juries who have been unequipped to judge the validity of those conclusions.

The questions that needs to be answered are:

1. Would any one of these investigators (Ferrar, Jones, Harrit, Basile, et al) be recognized as "an expert" for the purpose of providing expert witness testimony about the presence of thermite in building rubble in criminal trials in a US court?

2. Would the test methods used by FJH et al. be accepted as proven to be a valid indicator of the presence of thermite? (Even excluding the chain-of-evidence problem.)

According to my understanding of the requirements, the answers would be "no" & "no".

We need to get one of the lawyers here to weigh in on this issue, or for someone to provide a link if they have already done so.

When investigating thermitic materials and activity "minutiae" scientific research is required.

Correct.

Minutiae, such as the existence of standard tests for the presence of exactly the substance for which Jones et al were searching.

Is that the sort of minutiae you had in mind, MM?

'Cause that ain't very "minute" to me. That's a pretty "chunky" mistake.


tk
 
Last edited:
Not only was ultra fine grained elemental aluminum not proven to be present, but it was shown to actually be absent to a significant degree. Jones's and Harrit's own spectrographs show this, and Farrer confirms it with his observation of platelet-like structures. The aluminum present was bound in kaolin, and this is clearly and unequivocably shown in the data. There's nothing else to say about this. Breathless proclaimations to the contrary do not change this fact. Neither do appeals to authority. The data itself shows that it was not thermite.


It's "too funny" watching our moronic resident twoofers, ignore posts like El's. Their delusions shattered, they shift gears, babbling on about other things they know nothing about!

Priceless!
 
ElMondoHummus said:
Not only was ultra fine grained elemental aluminum not proven to be present, but it was shown to actually be absent to a significant degree. Jones's and Harrit's own spectrographs show this, and Farrer confirms it with his observation of platelet-like structures. The aluminum present was bound in kaolin, and this is clearly and unequivocably shown in the data. There's nothing else to say about this. Breathless proclaimations to the contrary do not change this fact. Neither do appeals to authority. The data itself shows that it was not thermite."

Chemical Engineer said:
"One of the things that I would like to stress about these chips is that they really shouldn't be there. They are not a natural formed agglomeration of aluminum from the aircraft or materials that were in the building and iron oxide that got knocked off. It isn't just a haphazard bringing together of iron oxide and aluminum which is the basic components of thermite. This is a material that is made up of nano-sized particles that are all very uniform, very symmetrical. It is in a silica-based matrix that holds the whole thing together, and when they are ignited, these iron droplets that are formed, basically eat through the silica matrix and form both droplets and actually creates these large relative voids within the residue of the chip that are all coated with iron films inside. If you take these chips and section them, and look at them before you ignite them, there are no iron micro-spheres, there are no iron particles, there are no iron films contained in these chips. It is only after you bring them up to their ignition point and they go through their thermitic reaction, that liquid iron is produced and the energy is released. These chips are not naturally occurring. They are not going to form because some materials fall down in a building and touch each other and get compressed together. That is just not what this material is and again I would say, that anyone who thinks that, should get some, should look at them, should analyze them, and come to their own conclusions after actually doing some work vs. simply guessing that something happened. That is why I did it. I did it because I had questions. I said the only way that I am really going to know is if I get a sample and I do it myself and that is what I did, and I would confirm that this material is thermitic, and it should not be there.

This material, is composed of, the real key ingredient, that I don't think anybody else could make in any convenient way, is the nano-aluminum. It is a controlled substance. I could go buy it, but the government limits how much I can buy. It is very very difficult to produce in these sizes and to keep from reacting. It is not something that you just get at the local five 'n dime, or you are going to make on your own. It is a very very difficult to make material. And that is the one thing in there that really tells me specifically that this wasn't some guys working in some caves in Afghanistan and/or it wasn't somebody in their basement doing this. This was a massive engineering operation that made these materials. Where they came from? I do not know. I can only speculate and guess. But it wasn't something that someone went off and made on their own. It just wasn't. It wasn't that."

Physicist said:
"The finding of aluminum in these steel samples, or what used to be steel samples, also supports the theory that thermite was used to melt the steel.

And so he came to me and said; "were getting some interesting compositional analysis from the red layer of these red/gray chips, we're actually seeing peaks of aluminum", as well as other things, but the aluminum peak was significant. He would find those aluminum peaks as well as iron peaks and oxygen peaks and various other peaks. But the aluminum, the iron, and the oxygen together were very significant because this is your composition for thermite. So that is when I started to get a little bit more interested and more interested in these red/gray chips.

So now what we have is from the composition of the red layer, we have an aluminum peak, we have a silicone peak, we have the iron and the oxygen as well as other peaks. One of the things that we did to insure that we weren't getting surface contamination, we took some of these chips, which are very very small by the way. And under a microscope we were able to cleave these chips or break them in half and then study the fresh or the broken surface so that we weren't getting surface contamination. These things were coming in in bags of dust so who knows what kinds of contamination you get on the surface. So we were looking at clean edges in order to get the composition and that is where we found the silicone, as well as the aluminum peaks and the iron and oxygen peaks in abundance and throughout all of the red layers in all of these chips.

Additional studies in the TEM (transmission electron microscope) found these were iron oxide phases. There were other particles present in the red layer. There were some plate-like particles and those again, were consistent throughout the red layer, throughout all of the samples that we found. Those appeared to have higher aluminum and silicone peaks in their compositional analysis and one of the significant things that we find in the red layer is the fact that these particles that we find in the red layer are..the fact that they are consistent. The fact that they are consistent in shape, in composition, and in size, leads me to believe that these are not naturally occurring materials."

They disagree with you and they were the ones that did the research.

MM
 
They disagree with you and they were the ones that did the research.

MM

Weren't you the one complaining about cut and paste, recently?
You really should open your mind, to info from reality based sources. These twoofers could make you look stupid!


my .02
 
Weren't you the one complaining about cut and paste, recently?
You really should open your mind, to info from reality based sources. These twoofers could make you look stupid!


my .02
Context.

I am now, not supposed quote the important findings of those who did the research,
because you feel their words should only appear only once?

You might also want to consider how your insulting quips make you appear?

MM
 
Your ignorance knows no bounds. You couldn't even be bothered to read Jones and Harritt's paper could you? If you had you would see that they use EDS/EDX and not XRD - read the links and see how different the techniques are and what is achievable with each one. Warning for truthers - links contain science and maths, you may want an adult present to help you.

 
What qualifies you to overrule the competence of those whose knowledge and expertise far exceeds your own?

MM


Appeal to false authority fallacy noted, Their incompetence has been demonstrated. That "they disagree" is not an argument. Fine grained elemental aluminum was proven to be absent in their own data, Add to that their sloppy methodology. Address the data or admit defeat.
 
Which they failed to perform. XRD would have given definitive answers - probably why it wasn't used.

so how do you think these "red chips" produced the iron microspheres that mark basile talks about if the AL that they are seeing is kaolin?

mark basile: "If you take these chips and section them, and look at them before you ignite them, there are no iron micro-spheres, there are no iron particles, there are no iron films contained in these chips."
 
What qualifies you to overrule the competence of those whose knowledge and expertise far exceeds your own?

MM


LOL

So since Dr Bazant's knowledge and expertise far exceeds all truthers put together, will you acknowledge that Bazant is right?

:rolleyes:

No?

Oh...

:rolleyes:
 
LOL

So since Dr Bazant's knowledge and expertise far exceeds all truthers put together, will you acknowledge that Bazant is right?

:rolleyes:

No?

Oh...

:rolleyes:

One could also ask if any thruther is as qualified to conduct an appraisal of WTC7's chance of collapsing than the ranking fire chief on the scene, Daniel Nigro. Or if the total knowledge and expertise (and number) of the NIST project team members exceeds, by far and away, the knowledge and expertise of all active AE911T semi-pros in the relevant fields of science.
 
so how do you think these "red chips" produced the iron microspheres that mark basile talks about if the AL that they are seeing is kaolin?

mark basile: "If you take these chips and section them, and look at them before you ignite them, there are no iron micro-spheres, there are no iron particles, there are no iron films contained in these chips."

Han't it been noted that little to nothing is said about the grey side?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom