carlson test and debunking randi

Professor Yaffle said:
Do you actually read what people ask you? I directly asked you to clarify if you needed the birth times for the males, and you said "I do".

Anyway, you were 100% wrong. Both the males (my brothers) are heterosexual. They have no reason to hide their sexuality since none of our family would give a toss if they were gay and both have groups of friends who have no problem with homosexuality and include some gay people.

Neither of them "love power" either. They are both very laid back and not eager to be in powerful positions.
Click to expand...

Read carefully:
I dont need birthtime for thse two males. But I need for any new males:mad:
 
idunno said:
i completely ignored their age at the time.
And why did they send birthdates of such young kids anyways. ?
Click to expand...


Why did you ignore their age? You were given their date of birth, so you must have been able to figure out how old they were. Why bother doing the reading if (as you claimed after you had failed) they were too young for the reading to work?

Had i got it right they would tell me they were too young for testing and so my reading would be irrelevant;)
Click to expand...


You are the one who is claiming that there is some sort of lower age limit beyond which the readings won't work - nobody else has suggested this.

This is just a post hoc excuse for your failure.
 
Mojo said:
Why did you ignore their age? You were given their date of birth, so you must have been able to figure out how old they were. Why bother doing the reading if (as you claimed after you had failed) they were too young for the reading to work?




You are the one who is claiming that there is some sort of lower age limit beyond which the readings won't work - nobody else has suggested this.

This is just a post hoc excuse for your failure.
Click to expand...
:eye-poppi
ok no excuses..i failed
 
idunno said:
i always said i use both chinese and western.
Click to expand...
Sorry - my perception of the original posts in the thread was wrong. I've gone back over what you read and you are right. But your first failed trial used western, and when that failed, then instead of doing the logical thing and thinking about that information, you did suggest switching to chinese ... and recently you have added the "hour sign" to keep the goal-posts moving. You appear totally un-interested in the possibility that you might be full of b@ll@cks.

idunno said:
i could argue i have no proof the trials are fair. I only bother to take up the tests because i dont really care about the results.
Click to expand...
I repeat my suggestion - go and find some people that you will trust the results for and re-conduct the tests using the protocols that you have been shown here.

idunno said:
The fact that Artwollilot was honest leaves me hopeful
Click to expand...
Aren't you just leaping on your only "hit" on the entire thread? ... does your basket ever get full when you go cherry-picking? Why should you trust arthwollipot if you don't trust anyone that your readings have very little accuracy? Here's an idea - maybe arthwollipot was cracking a joke?
arthwollipot said:
I'm actually bisexual - I just haven't met the right man yet.
Click to expand...
Read it again and think about it ...
 
kieran said:
Sorry - my perception of the original posts in the thread was wrong. I've gone back over what you read and you are right. But your first failed trial used western, and when that failed, then instead of doing the logical thing and thinking about that information, you did suggest switching to chinese ... and recently you have added the "hour sign" to keep the goal-posts moving. You appear totally un-interested in the possibility that you might be full of b@ll@cks.


I repeat my suggestion - go and find some people that you will trust the results for and re-conduct the tests using the protocols that you have been shown here.


Aren't you just leaping on your only "hit" on the entire thread? ... does your basket ever get full when you go cherry-picking? Why should you trust arthwollipot if you don't trust anyone that your readings have very little accuracy? Here's an idea - maybe arthwollipot was cracking a joke?

Read it again and think about it ...
Click to expand...

the best test is case studies like the one on Mohamed Atta. Checking peoples biography against their chart. Those never fail me and I doubt its all «confirmation bias».:boxedin:
 
I'm actually bisexual - I just haven't met the right man yet.
Read it again and think about it ...

An half Arse-bandit(grin)? Undecided? Hotel or Motel?(kidding):D
 
Professor Yaffle said:
So, to clarify, you don't need time of birth for the males?
Click to expand...

idunno said:
both, but i dont claim to get it right with females. but i dont mind trying
Click to expand...

Professor Yaffle said:
Sorry, that answer wasn't very clear to me. I am disregarding the females since you are unsure of whether you can predict for them. Do you still need time of birth for the males, or would it make no difference?
Click to expand...

idunno said:
I do bacause the combo may be in hour pillar;)
Click to expand...

Here are my questions, with your replies. How am I misreading you? You really don't express yourself very clearly.
 
idunno said:
he likes men, full stop.
its irelevant if he also likes women.
Click to expand...

I take it you've never met any gay or bisexual people? They really aren't the same thing at all.

idunno said:
they have the gay signs in the month, so, i didnt need the time. Capice?
Click to expand...

Nope. Either you can tell for at least some men without the time, in which case it makes no sense to insist on having it, or you can't, in which case it makes no sense for you to claim that you could for those two particular men. Again, what is so special about those two that is different for every other man?

Now I know why Astrologers get so annoiyed at skeptics questions.
Click to expand...

Is it because the astrologers can't come up with an answer that even sounds credible?
 
Cuddles said:
I take it you've never met any gay or bisexual people? They really aren't the same thing at all.



Nope. Either you can tell for at least some men without the time, in which case it makes no sense to insist on having it, or you can't, in which case it makes no sense for you to claim that you could for those two particular men. Again, what is so special about those two that is different for every other man?


im beginning to suspect skeptics are retarded.:mad:

READ MY LIPS: NO...MORE...TAXES...Ooops!! Sorry..
I mean...those two have a combo betwen month and day so no need for time.
Other males may not have the combo in the month but may have it in hour. So, time is required.:mad:
Click to expand...
 
Michael C said:
Bravo! Many thanks for your honesty. I don't think your failure is in any way due to lack of skills in astrology, since astrology doesn't work anyway. I would just say:

Astrology failed - again.
Click to expand...

Are you jumping with satisfaction???:)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Back
Top Bottom