As devil's advocate, I will have to disagree. The more QoL you provide to useless, unproductive people, the more of them you will get and the more it will cost. Furthermore, without adequately rewarding the most productive members of society, the less money you will have to spread around to the freeloaders, er ah, economic free riders.
That is indeed the devil's advocate position, but I find it unsatisfactory for a variety of reasons, the first being that is simply isn't borne out by the empirical findings. In fact, I tend to feel that the "useless, unproductive people" that this argument hinges on to be a form of chimera, rather like the "welfare queens" the US conservatives railed about in the late 80s but that turned out to be rare to near-nonexistence. I've met very few people who were truly useless and unproductive; I find quite a few who are unmotivated, and who do not find the amount of money the US social system provides to entry-level jobs to be sufficient motivation. Give them something that they
like doing, however, and the picture changes. Some of the worst students I knew in secondary school were the expert mechanics who spent hours tinkering on their cars....
The other problem, of course, is that an "adequate reward" is much less than modern capitalism seems to think. Again, this is borne out by surveys; William Whyte did an extensive survey of CEO pay in the 50s that was later replicated by researchers I have forgotten. He found that, while the vast majority of CEOs agreed that an adequate reward is necessary to get people to work hard, and with the generalization that without the substantial salaries CEOs are paid, they wouldn't be willing to accept the stress of the job, he also found that the vast majority of the individual CEOs found their personal job rewarding in and of itself, and that as individuals, they would be willing to do their job for substantially less. In other words, CEOs are, by their own admission,
overrewarded for the work they are asked to do.
There's also the whole bugaboo about what "productive" is. A person who finds a way to shave 5% off the cost of pencil manufacturing is probably more "productive," in dollar terms, than a dentist -- but having suffered through wisdom tooth removal myself, I cannot imagine how cheap pencils would need to become to make the dentist less productive to my quality of life. One of the major changes in US capitalism recently is the development of HMOs as a form of health care provider -- which even the industry experts acknowledge are more in the business of health care
withholding (I first heard that term at a keynote speech by an HMO exec). By withholding health care, they are more productive of "dollars" at the direct expense of QoL, which under my proposed metric would be a substantial setback. (Esp. since the people affected are generally below the median, so it has a much greater impact on the metric than withholding care from the well-off would have.)