Capitalism: Early benefits, Late problems?

No, it makes productive people think "what's the point?" and become less productive, since they are still being rewarded.
Only if the reward is comparable.

Maybe, maybe it just keeps them just as productive. But it certainly gives incentives for others to become as productive as possible.
I accept that logic as far as it goes, but it seems to leave no room for any social security safety-net. If any level of transfer payment, not attached to making a contribution or adding value, is deemed a dis-incentive, then one lets some people starve. Unless you believe that everyone will be motivated into self-supporting work.
 
All right, I'll propose one. The "best" economic system maximizes the minimum quality of life for those involved in the system.

I base this metric on several factors. First, "quality of life" as a base to be maximized should be fairly self-evident. Second, basic fairness requires that we maximize the QoL of a large fraction of the population instead of a few elite.

Its a reasonable metric to choose for the sake of argument, so ok...

Third, both economic theory and psychological studies agree that increases in quality of life result in a rapidly diminishing rate of return; you get more "bang for buck" going from 1000 calories of food a day to 2000 than you do from 2000 to 3000 (or even 2000 to 4000); The difference between zero bathrooms in your house and one is more significant than between one and two.

So 10 people with 1 bathroom each = higher total QoL than 5 people with 2 bathrooms each (and 5 with none) - fair point.

Based on either of these metrics, I think the studies suggest that modified socialism as practiced in Scandinavia is better than US-style capitalism, which in turn is substantially better than command economies such as the former Soviet bloc, which in turn is better than third-world tribalism.

I think it is more accurate to describe Sweden's system as modified capitalism. The system operated in Sweden is much closer to that in the US than it is to North Korea. Despite some state ownership of certain industries, Sweden is essentially a capitalist country.

The statement that 'modified socialism ... is better than US-Style capitalism' is loaded with a suggestion that it is best to start with an essentially socialist system and tweak it. Even if we assumed (but see below) that Sweden does have the best model, you cannot say that it got there by modifying socialism. What we actually see in Sweden is a capitalist system that has been influenced by some ideas and policies that have socialist origins.

Whilst we might simplistically say that Sweden performs better against your metric than the US, it does not logically follow that the the respective economic, social and political systems can be judged on that basis. The 2 countries are where they are today as a result of hundreds of years of history - the respective systems are of course the product of this evolution, each under very specific circumstances. That the QoL is better in one than another does not logically imply that one system must be better for QoL universally.

The QoL under the current US system might well be (in pragmatic terms) more or less as high as it can be given the prevailing historical and current circumstances. It also might not, but comparison with Sweden does not really prove that. Likewise for placing tribalism at the bottom of your list - for some groups in some circumstances tribalism is likely to yield the optimum QoL.
 
Last edited:
wouldn't making everyone's quality of life equal be what maximised the minimum?

Not necessarily -- in my view, probably not at all. That's certainly an approach, but the systems that seem to be the best at the minimax game do so by creating substantial wealth and then redistributing large fractions of it, instead of forcibly equalizing all of it.
 
I honestly think that any system should not allow anyone, however unmotivated, to starve to death or die of exposure. The incentive to work and achieve should be that one can obtain (through hard work and dedication) that which the slackers do not (i.e. more bathrooms, faster cars, more beautiful partners) but for the deal to be 'work or starve' seems very, very cold, and I just can't be that callous. Yes, there will be those that abuse the system, but people abuse the system at every level, from the very top to the very bottom. I'd rather forgo my fourth bathroom so someone could eat off my money than have the fourth bathroom and have anybody starve.
 
Making everyone's QoL 'equal' would not maximise total QoL in anything but the immediate term. As has been pointed out, it simply destroys productivity and efficiency.

If I get £100 per week for making chairs irrespective of the quantity and quality of my output what incentive do I have to make more and better chairs? What incentive do I have to invent new, more efficient ways to mass produce chairs? Net result - fewer chairs to share between everyone in the system.
 
As devil's advocate, I will have to disagree. The more QoL you provide to useless, unproductive people, the more of them you will get and the more it will cost. Furthermore, without adequately rewarding the most productive members of society, the less money you will have to spread around to the freeloaders, er ah, economic free riders.

That is indeed the devil's advocate position, but I find it unsatisfactory for a variety of reasons, the first being that is simply isn't borne out by the empirical findings. In fact, I tend to feel that the "useless, unproductive people" that this argument hinges on to be a form of chimera, rather like the "welfare queens" the US conservatives railed about in the late 80s but that turned out to be rare to near-nonexistence. I've met very few people who were truly useless and unproductive; I find quite a few who are unmotivated, and who do not find the amount of money the US social system provides to entry-level jobs to be sufficient motivation. Give them something that they like doing, however, and the picture changes. Some of the worst students I knew in secondary school were the expert mechanics who spent hours tinkering on their cars....

The other problem, of course, is that an "adequate reward" is much less than modern capitalism seems to think. Again, this is borne out by surveys; William Whyte did an extensive survey of CEO pay in the 50s that was later replicated by researchers I have forgotten. He found that, while the vast majority of CEOs agreed that an adequate reward is necessary to get people to work hard, and with the generalization that without the substantial salaries CEOs are paid, they wouldn't be willing to accept the stress of the job, he also found that the vast majority of the individual CEOs found their personal job rewarding in and of itself, and that as individuals, they would be willing to do their job for substantially less. In other words, CEOs are, by their own admission, overrewarded for the work they are asked to do.

There's also the whole bugaboo about what "productive" is. A person who finds a way to shave 5% off the cost of pencil manufacturing is probably more "productive," in dollar terms, than a dentist -- but having suffered through wisdom tooth removal myself, I cannot imagine how cheap pencils would need to become to make the dentist less productive to my quality of life. One of the major changes in US capitalism recently is the development of HMOs as a form of health care provider -- which even the industry experts acknowledge are more in the business of health care withholding (I first heard that term at a keynote speech by an HMO exec). By withholding health care, they are more productive of "dollars" at the direct expense of QoL, which under my proposed metric would be a substantial setback. (Esp. since the people affected are generally below the median, so it has a much greater impact on the metric than withholding care from the well-off would have.)
 
I honestly think that any system should not allow anyone, however unmotivated, to starve to death

This is a strawman isn't it? i don't think anyone here is saying 'work or starve'. I can be a capitalist and still recognise the value of state support for the unemployed, ill and old. Even putting human compassion to one side it is fairly obvious that an economy that has absolutely no such safety nets would likely become politically fragile.
 
Last edited:
If I get £100 per week for making chairs irrespective of the quantity and quality of my output what incentive do I have to make more and better chairs? What incentive do I have to invent new, more efficient ways to mass produce chairs?

Unless you're a complete sociopath, your "incentive" is the pleasure of a job well done and the respect of your peers. One of the problems with a lot of the advocates of capitalism is that they tend to leave this particular part out of the equation when arguing how much people should be paid. Social rewards, although not necessarily easily quantifiable in pounds, shillings, and pence (if you're only getting £100 a week, you're obviously pre-decimalisation), are nevertheless real.

Net result - fewer chairs to share between everyone in the system.

That's an empirical question, innit? Will the social rewards be adequate to sustain chair production, or won't they?

But beyond that -- because by and large I agree that incentives are probably reasonable -- is the question of how much incentive is necessary or appropriate. Let's say that you figure out a way to make twice as many chairs of equal quality in the same time. Should you now get £200 a week? Should you get £500? Should you get £150, and the company can lower the price of chairs by 25% so everyone has chairs more cheaply? Or perhaps it would be sufficience for you to get £125 and the government gets another £25 to use to address the urgent table shortage that is the real social problem..... (You will of course have recognized this as the progressive taxation question in a paper-thin disguise.)
 
The other problem, of course, is that an "adequate reward" is much less than modern capitalism seems to think. Again, this is borne out by surveys; William Whyte did an extensive survey of CEO pay in the 50s that was later replicated by researchers I have forgotten. He found that, while the vast majority of CEOs agreed that an adequate reward is necessary to get people to work hard, and with the generalization that without the substantial salaries CEOs are paid, they wouldn't be willing to accept the stress of the job, he also found that the vast majority of the individual CEOs found their personal job rewarding in and of itself, and that as individuals, they would be willing to do their job for substantially less. In other words, CEOs are, by their own admission, overrewarded for the work they are asked to do.

They are paid what the market will bear - they would not do the same job for substantially less if they knew that they could get twice as much at the firm next door irrespective of how much they enjoy doing it. I think there are cases of 'overrewarded' CEOs (and in every job / role, not just CEOs) but this is nothing to do with whether individuals enjoy their jobs or not.

There's also the whole bugaboo about what "productive" is. A person who finds a way to shave 5% off the cost of pencil manufacturing is probably more "productive," in dollar terms, than a dentist -- but having suffered through wisdom tooth removal myself, I cannot imagine how cheap pencils would need to become to make the dentist less productive to my quality of life.

You can't just consider one anecdote about your own teeth to be a useful critique of productivity. The economy does not consist of you, a dentist and a clever pencil maker. The economy is the sum of all our labour, skills and efforts. The pencil manufacturer makes money, employs people, paying them wages with which they buy good dental insurance. The dentist is educated and trained in schools partly funded by taxes paid by the pencil company and its employees. The pencils are exported, producing foreign exchange that is used to buy high tech dental equipment from a foreign manufacturer, etc....
 
This is a strawman isn't it? i don't think anyone here is saying 'work or starve'. I can be a capitalist and still recognise the value of state support for the unemployed, ill and old. Even putting human compassion to one side it is fairly obvious that an economy that has absolutely no such safety nets would likely become politically fragile.

It is, to an extent. I may have been exagerating for effect. I think the basic point still stands.
 
They are paid what the market will bear - they would not do the same job for substantially less if they knew that they could get twice as much at the firm next door irrespective of how much they enjoy doing it.

But if we established a 95% CEO salary tax, they would continue to do their job.

You can't just consider one anecdote about your own teeth to be a useful critique of productivity. The economy does not consist of you, a dentist and a clever pencil maker. The economy is the sum of all our labour, skills and efforts. The pencil manufacturer makes money, employs people, paying them wages with which they buy good dental insurance. The dentist is educated and trained in schools partly funded by taxes paid by the pencil company and its employees. The pencils are exported, producing foreign exchange that is used to buy high tech dental equipment from a foreign manufacturer, etc....

And the net effect on people's Qualiity of Life is still much more substantially affected by a single dentist than by the entire pencil factory. If the pencil factory disappears, there are substitutes, such as pens, crayons, and chalk. There is no substitute for freedom-from-pain.
 
But if we established a 95% CEO salary tax, they would continue to do their job.

Yes - in another country where there is lower CEO salary tax. CEOs work in a global marketplace. You will export your best business brains and experience and deter inward investment.

And the net effect on people's Qualiity of Life is still much more substantially affected by a single dentist than by the entire pencil factory. If the pencil factory disappears, there are substitutes, such as pens, crayons, and chalk. There is no substitute for freedom-from-pain.

No - you are extrapolating a general case from your individual circumstances. The pencil machine operatives lose their jobs (lets make it a cold Christmas Eve for dramatic effect), are you really claiming the relief of your toothache has a greater impact on QoL than that?

Anyway, if you can hypothesize a crayon factory, I can hypothesize another dentist. Its an economy, not a single street we're talking about.
 
But if we established a 95% CEO salary tax, they would continue to do their job.

Yes - in another country where there is lower CEO salary tax. CEOs work in a global marketplace. You will export your best business brains and experience and deter inward investment.

And the net effect on people's Qualiity of Life is still much more substantially affected by a single dentist than by the entire pencil factory. If the pencil factory disappears, there are substitutes, such as pens, crayons, and chalk. There is no substitute for freedom-from-pain.

No - you are extrapolating a general case from your individual circumstances. The pencil machine operatives lose their jobs (lets make it a cold Christmas Eve for dramatic effect), are you really claiming the relief of your toothache has a greater impact on QoL than that?

Anyway, if you can hypothesize a crayon factory, I can hypothesize another dentist. Its an economy, not a single street we're talking about.
 
Yes - in another country where there is lower CEO salary tax. CEOs work in a global marketplace. You will export your best business brains and experience and deter inward investment.

So, how much effect would it have on the ecomomy to have the second tier of high flyers (the slightly lower flyers?) be the captains of industry while the elite ran off in search of more money? Would it really make that huge a difference? (Honest question, I really don't have the knowledge to answer it myself)

In addition, given that it is now a global marketplace, how many places could these CEO's run off to for lower taxes? (again, honest question)

Apart from these questions, I'm going to let DrK carry the argument. :)
 
Unless you're a complete sociopath, your "incentive" is the pleasure of a job well done and the respect of your peers.

Many people work in jobs that they hate or that give them little, if any pleasure. Many jobs command little respect.

Anyway that's by the by, the more important point is that in economics we are interested in the marginal person(s). For capitalism to work it does not require that nobody works for sheer pleasure, it just requires that there are marginal people who will respond to higher incentives. In reality the majority of us work in that manner, this is why capitalism is so compelling - it works.

One of the problems with a lot of the advocates of capitalism is that they tend to leave this particular part out of the equation when arguing how much people should be paid.

By and large, capitalism expects pay to be determined by the market, not by some kind of formula based on perceived utility / impact on QoL. There is no 'equation' for things to be left in or out of.
 
So, how much effect would it have on the ecomomy to have the second tier of high flyers (the slightly lower flyers?) be the captains of industry while the elite ran off in search of more money? Would it really make that huge a difference? (Honest question, I really don't have the knowledge to answer it myself)

Some of your 'second tier' would be not up to the job and this would impact the corporations concerned and thus your economy as a whole. Some of them would be up to the job, would quickly become experienced in their new roles and would them migrate since they would then be able to command the top-job rates elsewhere.

In addition, given that it is now a global marketplace, how many places could these CEO's run off to for lower taxes? (again, honest question)

I presume in this discussion we are assuming something similar to the real world where there are different countries that are able to set their own rates of taxation.
 
Here's my Better System: Mind-reading all-knowing robots. They determine what we want/need, and what we can and will do to get it. They'll design useful occupations for us, and see that we are challenged and rewarded appropriately to maximize our happiness.

Until then, a free market capitalistic system, governed by minimal but effective oversight, and complimented by minimal but effective social services, is probably as good as we're going to do.

As far as freeloaders, etc.; people at the bottom who the system does not support (whether because they won't work, or because of lack of opportunity, or whatever else) generally don't sit around and conveniently starve to death. A system that doesn't take care of them in one way is going to pay for them in another.
 
Some of your 'second tier' would be not up to the job and this would impact the corporations concerned and thus your economy as a whole. Some of them would be up to the job, would quickly become experienced in their new roles and would them migrate since they would then be able to command the top-job rates elsewhere.

<and the answer to a silly question>

Some of the 'first tier' seem to be not up to the job on occasions.

The sescond tier may be more grateful and work harder. Maybe.
 
Arbitrary and capricious rules always inspire people to find a way around them.
A 95% tax on CEO pay would result in corporations moving offshore, rewarding CEO's with other benefits (including stock options), multiple payment options, or outright cheating via cooking the books.

We already had one stupid law like this at the million/year level - did it achieve anything noteworthy except the employment of a few more tax accountants?

You seem to forget that CEO's are part of a management team that includes many more executives who also get paid well. Are you going to arbitrarily overtax them too? What about the best engineers, scientists, and researchers working on the next products, screw them too if they get paid more than the janitor? Rather silly idea if you ask me.
 
Some of the 'first tier' seem to be not up to the job on occasions.

Of course. There is dishonesty, corruption, incompetence and downright bad luck amongst CEOs as amongst any other section of society. It would be ridiculous to suppose otherwise. this does not mean that as a group they can easily be replaced wholesale.

The sescond tier may be more grateful and work harder. Maybe.

Some would, some wouldn't - so what? Anway its not like CEOs are putting in an 8 hour day running machinery, there is no simple equation that you can run - the CEO does a extra hour each day so the company makes 15% more profit. the CEOs are paid for their leadership, decision making skills, strategic vision and so on. Such is the nature of their roles that I doubt if any of them could meaningfully decide to do a better job by working harder. Most would be very hard workers indeed already.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom