Capitalism: Early benefits, Late problems?

The real problem with capitalism is that it is the second worst system in the world. The worst? Every other system.

So I am not the only one who has rephrased the famous Churchill comment on Democracy for this situation?
 
Propose all you want but without an example, your proposal is moot.

I suspect if a better system "came along" then the switch would be natural and not forced.

eta: In the u.s. along with most other first-world countries, capitalism is greatly diluted by socialism; not necessarily a bad thing. Without capitalism, you lack revenue, without socialism, you lack support. In the end there is an ever-shifting balance.


Agreed. A pure lassiez faire Capitalist system would self destruct in about five minutes...must like a pure Socialst system would.
 
That's true. Sony has made many mistakes and they seem too arrogant to care.

Honestly I think the only way political and business systems will improve is with improved ethics of those who hold the positions of power.

Hopefully over time, very slowly, people will make more choices based on what benefits everyone else instead of themselves. Until then, no system will work as well as it could due to corruption and greed.
 
Hopefully over time, very slowly, people will make more choices based on what benefits everyone else instead of themselves.
North Korea is thataway if you want to see how well that works.

Until then, no system will work as well as it could due to corruption and greed.
"To summarise the summary of the summary: People are a problem."
 
But what happens after this system has been in place for a long period of time and competition is no longer between small rival companies but a select few business giants? Does it not reach a point where it is better for businesses to maintain the appearance of competition to the public, but meet behind closed doors to set prices? Does it not reach a point where improving durability/quality of a product is not in the best interest of the major competing companies?
Well in a capitalist economy it is in the best (financial) interest of any company to attempt to thwart competition and raise barriers to entry and so on. But it naturally would be unless their self-interest was to change to something less logical. Capitalism is about keeping the playing field level in the full knowledge that any economic agent would inherently prefer to skew it uphill against all the others.

To me it seems not a question of what would cause this to happen, but what would stop it from happening?
Rule of law that successfully enforces against anti-competitive practice. In other words, making capitalist enterprise subordinate to and accountable to the will of society.

Capitalism accountable to no authority merely replicates the law of the jungle.
 
Last edited:
Propose all you want but without an example, your proposal is moot.

I suspect if a better system "came along" then the switch would be natural and not forced.

I would disagree. In fact, any switch from one system to a 'better' one (comunism to capitalism, perhaps) seems to have come either with great upheaval (the fall of the USSR springs to mind) or not at all due to the will of those in power (North Korea). China seems to be making the switch without too much in the way of civil disobedience, but I honestly don't know too much about that and am not sure too many do.
 
Last edited:
I would disagree. In fact, any switch from one system to a 'better' one (comunism to capitalism, perhaps) seems to have come either with great upheaval (the fall of the USSR springs to mind) or not at all due to the will of those in power (North Korea). China seems to be making the switch without too much in the way of civil disobedience, but I honestly don't know too much about that and am not sure too many do.
The existence of a better system does not guarantee that a society moves over to that system, obviously. That's because intensity of desire does not equate with ability to prevail.

To a very simplified approximation, in China, the government wants to embrace their interpretation of capitalism, so it happens. In the USSR the government became insufficiently powerful to prevent a move in this direction. In North Korea, the government is currently powerful enough to do what it wants.

Now if you bring up "western" societies, I suspect that society has the ability to prevail if it desires to change the system. Comparison with the above three is not instructive. Do you take a different view?
 
I would disagree. In fact, any switch from one system to a 'better' one (comunism to capitalism, perhaps) seems to have come either with great upheaval (the fall of the USSR springs to mind) or not at all due to the will of those in power (North Korea). China seems to be making the switch without too much in the way of civil disobedience, but I honestly don't know too much about that and am not sure too many do.

You disagree but you seem to be arguing my point. People are naturally capitalistic and it takes a good deal of force to prevent them from doing what comes naturally. Remove the force and the change happens.
 
The existence of a better system does not guarantee that a society moves over to that system, obviously. That's because intensity of desire does not equate with ability to prevail.

To a very simplified approximation, in China, the government wants to embrace their interpretation of capitalism, so it happens. In the USSR the government became insufficiently powerful to prevent a move in this direction. In North Korea, the government is currently powerful enough to do what it wants.

Now if you bring up "western" societies, I suspect that society has the ability to prevail if it desires to change the system. Comparison with the above three is not instructive. Do you take a different view?

I think the ability to prevail if changes to the system were required/desired would depend heavily on the distibution of power throughout society. If power were in the hands of a large cross section of society, then change may be affected far more easily than if the majority of power were held only by a very small 'ruling class'.

I'm not sure how you dismiss the examples given as not instructive? They are the only examples we have of such power shifts in the modern world (well, these and a few others, perhaps) and although they may not provide exact parallels, surely there is some value in them as examples?
 
Last edited:
You disagree but you seem to be arguing my point. People are naturally capitalistic and it takes a good deal of force to prevent them from doing what comes naturally. Remove the force and the change happens.

You claimed that change to a 'better' system would be natural and without force. I would say that the examples we have of societies moving from one system to a 'better' one, as capitalism is defined, has frequently come with a large amount of social upheaval and not a little forcing.
 
You claimed that change to a 'better' system would be natural and without force. I would say that the examples we have of societies moving from one system to a 'better' one, as capitalism is defined, has frequently come with a large amount of social upheaval and not a little forcing.

Forcing by whom? Seems to me it is the people snubbing the force that instantiates the change. Of course it is "social upheaval" but that too, under certain circumstances, is natural.
 
Last edited:
Forcing by whom? Seems to me it is the people snubbing the force that instantiates the change. Of course it is "social upheaval" but that too, under certain circumstances, is natural.

Guess it depends on the situation, was only really using the term 'forcing' as it is the one you chose to use.
 
I think the ability to prevail if changes to the system were required/desired would depend heavily on the distibution of power throughout society. If power were in the hands of a large cross section of society, then change may be affected far more easily than if the majority of power were held only by a very small 'ruling class'.
Agreed. In my view western societies are considerably much more towards the first camp than are N Korea, PRC and the USSR before it crumbled, which are/were firmly in the second one.

I'm not sure how you dismiss the examples given as not instructive? They are the only examples we have of such power shifts in the modern world (well, these and a few others, perhaps) and although they may not provide exact parallels, surely there is some value in them as examples?
I inferred from you that because "social upheaval" happened in the USSR dismantling, and upheaval would apparently be necessary for North Korea to change . . . then that means that even if there is a superior economic model than capitalism available to, say, the Netherlands, it would not be able to come about without similar social upheaval. Is this because you don't believe that power is significantly (enough) more decentralised in the west to allow change to be affected very easily?
 
Last edited:
Well, I think we got off on this tangent because of my use of the word "force". I used it in a narrow context of "forcing people to adopt a system they'd rather not". I don't think it's fair to equate it, in that narrow context, with any or all forms of upheaval. When an inferior system collapses, then of course their will be an upheaval.

It wasn't an intentional strawman, but a strawman nonetheless. '

Anyway, this is really not topical to the subject thread.

Let's get back on track.

Walmart!!!!!

If K-Mart only foresaw!

ETA:...

Target!!!!!

If Walmart only foresaw!
 
Last edited:
Agreed. In my view western societies are considerably much more towards the first camp than are N Korea, PRC and the USSR before it crumbled, which are/were firmly in the second one.

I think some western societies may be more 'top heavy' than others. Indeed, if power is represented by money, then large chunks of western society do, to my (perhaps limited) understanding have the power concentrated in a very small group at the top.

Of course, if power is represented by votes, then it's spread across the whole of society. I would add to this point that it takes a lot of money to get into the oval office.

I inferred from you that because "social upheaval" happened in the USSR dismantling, and upheaval would apparently be necessary for North Korea to change . . . then that means that even if there is a superior economic model than capitalism available to, say, the Netherlands, it would not be able to come about without similar social upheaval. Is this because you don't believe that power is significantly (enough) more decentralised in the west to allow change to be affected very easily?


I think my answer to this is yes. I will add to this that my knowledge is probably limited in this area, but see my comments re money = power above.

(edit for format)
 
Last edited:
Well, I think we got off on this tangent because of my use of the word "force". I used it in a narrow context of "forcing people to adopt a system they'd rather not". I don't think it's fair to equate it, in that narrow context, with any or all forms of upheaval. When an inferior system collapses, then of course their will be an upheaval.

It wasn't an intentional strawman, but a strawman nonetheless. '

Anyway, this is really not topical to the subject thread.

Let's get back on track.

Walmart!!!!!

If K-Mart only foresaw!

ETA:...

Target!!!!!

If Walmart only foresaw!

Fair enough.

To be fair, at some point during a 'revolution' of the type being discussed, there will be some 'forcing', be it at the point of a gun, or merely those in power acquiescing gracefully to the will of the people, or alternatively a strong enough ruling classes exercising power to force the people to continue accepting the inferior system, so there almost has to be force involved.


Not sure where this leaves in terms of the discussion though. :)
 
I think some western societies may be more 'top heavy' than others. Indeed, if power is represented by money, then large chunks of western society do, to my (perhaps limited) understanding have the power concentrated in a very small group at the top.
It is not the intention of capitalism that money = power. A person or a corporation is intentionally accountable to the same laws regardless of their wealth. Reality departs from this to the extent that money = resources available to circumvent law or take power by force or buy power. There you have a route to corruption and application of Lord Acton's dictum.

I maintain that the inherent "problem" (with capitalism) is that the system works if the playing field is level, yet at the same time it only works if populated by agents who would benefit from skewing it so that they have as much advantage over everyone else as possible.
 
It is not the intention of capitalism that money = power. A person or a corporation is intentionally accountable to the same laws regardless of their wealth. Reality departs from this to the extent that money = resources available to circumvent law or take power by force or buy power. There you have a route to corruption and application of Lord Acton's dictum.

I maintain that the inherent "problem" (with capitalism) is that the system works if the playing field is level, yet at the same time it only works if populated by agents who would benefit from skewing it so that they have as much advantage over everyone else as possible.

I think we're back to it being the worst system except all the others, aren't we?


Yes, in theory money does not equal power, but in reality I don't think anyone could argue against that in practice it does. How skewed the system has become is where the argument would come in.

I still maintain that if some genius came up with a system that we all here (representing a decent cross section of society and as likely all to pull in the same direction as a heard of cats) agreed was a far superior system, then, if that system involved the 'leaders of business' and the like having to give up some wealth, power and influence then their opposition to any implementation of said system would be a very difficult hurdle to overcome.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom