Capitalism: Early benefits, Late problems?

An interesting question is: which socio-economic system most closely approximates human nature? Is that system is likely to be the most durable, and would it be perceived as "best"?
 
An interesting question is: which socio-economic system most closely approximates human nature? Is that system is likely to be the most durable, and would it be perceived as "best"?

Ya see, that's the thing. Unless you define metrics (such as best) discussion is fruitless.

Let's start with a definition, an actual metric, and go from there.

And shave your pits.
 
An interesting question is: which socio-economic system most closely approximates human nature? Is that system is likely to be the most durable, and would it be perceived as "best"?

An interesting question indeed, but one that I fear will not be easily or relevantly answered.

I disagree rather vehemently with Rob that "[p]eople are naturally capitalistic and it takes a good deal of force to prevent them from doing what comes naturally." The judgement of history fails to support this; if capitalism is so natural, why did we only see it form in the 17th century, and in one society? What "force" was being applied between 5000 BCE and 1600 CE to keep people from following their natural instincts.

My understanding is exactly the opposite. The "natural state" of people is a heritable technocracy. Every useful skill has a person or people responsible for management of that skill (shoes are made by the shoemakers) who in turn are responsible for training others, often their children (you are apprenticed to a shoemaker and learn how to make shoes, then you go one to train others yourself). I would also point out that the "normal' state of people a small enough group that there's no a lot of room for an autocrat except by the consent of the people involved.

This is also how people "naturally" organize themselves when left to their own devices. If a friend needs a house remodelled, he calls upon his social circle and we all descend upon the building site. Once we get there, we will then work on whatever we feel most comfortable working on, and sort ourselves out by skills. I'm a better electrician than a carpenter, and a better carpenter than a plasterer, so I would probably offer to pull wire and hook stuff up instead of mixing plaster (and everyone knows this, so they'd probably accept -- in fact, the novice electricians would probably "naturally" ask me for instruction and direction, reflecting my higher level of skill).
 
Ya see, that's the thing. Unless you define metrics (such as best) discussion is fruitless.

Let's start with a definition, an actual metric, and go from there.

And shave your pits.

Absolutely. Better for whom and by how much.

Then again we seem to have all agreed that capitalism is the 'best' system (with all the usual caveats) then we're all jusdging it by some internal criteria.
 
Absolutely. Better for whom and by how much.

All right, I'll propose one. The "best" economic system maximizes the minimum quality of life for those involved in the system.

I base this metric on several factors. First, "quality of life" as a base to be maximized should be fairly self-evident. Second, basic fairness requires that we maximize the QoL of a large fraction of the population instead of a few elite. Third, both economic theory and psychological studies agree that increases in quality of life result in a rapidly diminishing rate of return; you get more "bang for buck" going from 1000 calories of food a day to 2000 than you do from 2000 to 3000 (or even 2000 to 4000); The difference between zero bathrooms in your house and one is more significant than between one and two.

An alternative metric would be to maximize the median (not mean) quality of life.

Based on either of these metrics, I think the studies suggest that modified socialism as practiced in Scandinavia is better than US-style capitalism, which in turn is substantially better than command economies such as the former Soviet bloc, which in turn is better than third-world tribalism.
 
Last edited:
The "best" economic system maximizes the minimum quality of life for those involved in the system.
wouldn't making everyone's quality of life equal be what maximised the minimum?

An alternative metric would be to maximize the median (not mean) quality of life.
Well you didn't say mean previously. But I think unfettered capitalism with no safety-net at all would maximise the mean, and probably mimimise the minimum (if you see what I mean . . . let the worst-off starve)
 
An interesting question indeed, but one that I fear will not be easily or relevantly answered.

I disagree rather vehemently with Rob that "[p]eople are naturally capitalistic and it takes a good deal of force to prevent them from doing what comes naturally." The judgement of history fails to support this; if capitalism is so natural, why did we only see it form in the 17th century, and in one society? What "force" was being applied between 5000 BCE and 1600 CE to keep people from following their natural instincts.

So merchants only came along in the 17th century?? Private property never existed between 5000 BCE and 1600 CE??

:crazy:

Oh, and which country would you think that was, by the way? The Netherlands? Spain? Persia? Just wondering ...
 
All right, I'll propose one. The "best" economic system maximizes the minimum quality of life for those involved in the system.
[snip]

As devil's advocate, I will have to disagree. The more QoL you provide to useless, unproductive people, the more of them you will get and the more it will cost. Furthermore, without adequately rewarding the most productive members of society, the less money you will have to spread around to the freeloaders, er ah, economic free riders.
 
An interesting question is: which socio-economic system most closely approximates human nature?

I think we must first define human nature. Anyone want to take a stab at that?
 
You disagree but you seem to be arguing my point.

Actually he's not. He's providing an example that directly contradicts your claim that "if a better system "came along" then the switch would be natural and not forced". Capitalism, a better system than statist communism, has been around for a long time and there are many countries, including the US, where its adoption hasn't been natural and not forced.
 
And I disagree with the above request, so don't shave!

oddly, one of the most erotic photos I've ever seen was that of a 20-something Asian girl looking in the mirror while shaving her pits.

but I digress...

Even given Drkitten's definition, I'd have to still go with the system we currently have in place in the U.S; capitalism tempered by a good measure of socialism.
 
I've been thinking about capitalism a bit lately. It seems to me that initially it would have benefits. There would be competition, which would lead to better quality products, lower prices, and improved service. In order to get more customers a company would try to find ways to give better products at a lower price than their competitors and their competitors would do the same.

But what happens after this system has been in place for a long period of time and competition is no longer between small rival companies but a select few business giants? Does it not reach a point where it is better for businesses to maintain the appearance of competition to the public, but meet behind closed doors to set prices? Does it not reach a point where improving durability/quality of a product is not in the best interest of the major competing companies?

It seems to me that at some point improving durability of a product would be bad for a businesses profits. If the product lasts 10+ years that means that people who buy that product will not have to buy another one for a very long time. I know that for some products there is no need to increase durability to this point because of the type of product. For example a computer. Most people will want to buy a new computer or at the very least upgrade essential parts before 10 years time, but I'm not talking about that type of product.

I know that companies have been found to be illegally meeting behind closed doors to set prices, though I don't know about other things such as durability. And when they are caught they are usually fined a small amount and nothing is really done to the company.

To sum it all up I think that in the late game trying to out compete your rivals would earn less profits than meeting behind closed doors and setting prices and durability/quality.

To me it seems not a question of what would cause this to happen, but what would stop it from happening?

I don't pretend to be an expert on the subject of economics. This is just something I was thinking about and so I'd appreciate the thoughts and opinions of those on this forum with greater economic knowledge.

Collusion is illegal - but occurs (sometimes it is called coincidental). Logic is behind planned obsolescence (planned is the key there). Logic also applies to things like hot sauces that imply they are hotter than they are - big difference between one you are still using a bottle of a year and a half later and one of same size you use in a month (I heartily recommend Yucateco Habanero red or green for good price, high heat and because of the second, long lasting).
 
Last edited:
Even given Drkitten's definition, I'd have to still go with the system we currently have in place in the U.S; capitalism tempered by a good measure of socialism.
Agreed.

And I disagree with the above request, so don't shave!
I don't plan to.

oddly, one of the most erotic photos I've ever seen was that of a 20-something Asian girl looking in the mirror while shaving her pits.
Oh well, I'm 30-something, not Asian and not shaving, so 0/3 . . . ;)
 
So merchants only came along in the 17th century?? Private property never existed between 5000 BCE and 1600 CE??
No, but capitalism as we would recognize it today, with limited liability companies, share trading and so on, does indeed date to the beginning of the 17th century, and serious capitalist economic theory to the 18th century.
 
As devil's advocate, I will have to disagree. The more QoL you provide to useless, unproductive people, the more of them you will get and the more it will cost.
Rewarding "useless" people will lower their productivity?

Furthermore, without adequately rewarding the most productive members of society, the less money you will have to spread around to the freeloaders, er ah, economic free riders.
Rewarding "the most productive" people will raise their productivity?

What do you do with the spectrum that lies between useless and most productive? And should there be any welfare safety net at all?
 
There becomes a point where it is more profitable for major competing companies to meet behind doors to fix prices and quality
That's also the point where the Feds step in and start prosecuting.
 
Rewarding "useless" people will lower their productivity?
No, it makes productive people think "what's the point?" and become less productive, since they are still being rewarded.

Rewarding "the most productive" people will raise their productivity?
Maybe, maybe it just keeps them just as productive. But it certainly gives incentives for others to become as productive as possible.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom