Can you choose to believe?

Could you choose to believe that the Quran was the literal word of God?

  • Yes

    Votes: 26 17.8%
  • No

    Votes: 120 82.2%

  • Total voters
    146
Depends on what you are believing in. Credible things or not?

You are shopping for a product and you look up user 'reviews' on the internet, with a variety of experiences related. You can choose to believe that the product is good or not.

Now, believing something absurd, such as God, is not so easy, but the White Queen proved that it is possible to believe impossible things.
 
The Quran is just as believable as the Word of God as is the Christian Bible, or a book of Greek Mythology. There all equally unbelievable.
 
I put "no" with some reluctance, because the question is not as unambiguous as it might be, but was worded as a personal question. I have never found it possible to "choose to believe," and this is largely why I'm not a churchgoing Christian today. My temperament simply never could allow me to select a belief which my reason doubts or r ejects, even though I was brought up among Christians, and would have felt comfortable in the liberal New England Congregational fold that was familiar to me. Maybe others can just decide to have faith, but I can't.

However, I think others can choose to believe if they already believe something, and the leap from one faith to another seems less perilous than the leap from skepticism to faith. If you already believe that there is a God, then deciding that the God of Islamic scripture is the best fit might not be such a hard choice. Once you've made the choice, the corresponding steps that lead you to accepting the Quran as the literal word of God become easier. After all, that's what the God of the Quran says, and faith trumps circularity.
 
When you are very young you believe what you are told. As you get a little older you choose what you want to believe because you are an idealist and want independence from your parents and others in authority. Being a non conformist is cool.Then when you get middle aged and beyond you start to believe based on the evidence.
 
When you are very young you believe what you are told. As you get a little older you choose what you want to believe because you are an idealist and want independence from your parents and others in authority. Being a non conformist is cool.Then when you get middle aged and beyond you start to believe based on the evidence.

That may be how it worked out for you, but it doesn't fit with my experience. When I stopped believing in God (or rather came to realise that I believed He wasn't real) I had absolutely no sense of its being an act of rebellion. On the contrary - I just assumed that was what most people really believed.
 
Pick a contentious topic; existence of gods, origins of life, abortion, party politics - whatever you like. Now, either take the contrary view to your current belief or, if undecided, flip a coin to see which side you're going to take, and see if you can choose to believe it for a day. Good luck, one and all.

Not in the way you've phrased it, but experiments close to this have been done. (I spent some time looking and couldn't come up with any references though).

My memory is that they took some volunteers, questioned them to gauge where they stood on certain issues, and then set up a debate where they were forced to defend positions that were either complimentary or contradictory to those beliefs. Without any introduction to new evidence, the act of debating (or the competition of it) changed their stances in the direction that they were forced to defend.

Now I want to find the studies... Anyone else remember this?
 
People are influenced by many things and then choose to believe in whatever they believe in, whether it's a religion or not.

Then, as one goes through life, beliefs evolve :) and perspectives change. I find that those who are adamant about their beliefs are angry and resentful because they aren't happy adhering to what they may have believed in, in the past. I've seen it in the fundie christian community for sure.
 
I don't consider belief to be a conscious process, over which we have the luxury of choice. The things I believe, I didn't choose to believe because I thought there would be some advantage to believing them. Some things either appear to be true, or don't.

For example, I don't believe in God because the evidence is insufficient. If I thought I would be happier as a theist (I don't, but hypothetically), I couldn't consciously choose to process information differently. I could choose to live a theist lifestyle and want to believe in God, but I would still, fundamentally, believe he doesn't exist. I would often be much happier if I believed there was a cheque for £1,000 in my pocket - no matter how much I would want to believe it, I couldn't choose to, because I fundamentally know it's not the case. The information has been processed by my brain and I can't choose to ignore it, or process it differently.

I don't feel I could choose to believe something, and then convince myself of it after choosing to believe it. I will automatically believe whatever, by my logic (the rules of which I didn't choose, they're just there), seems most likely to be true. If I thought believing something less likely to be true were beneficial, or if I would prefer something else to be true and 'chose' to try to believe it, I would have a permanent voice saying, "you chose to try to believe this, you're only pseudo-believing this for reasons other than its likelihood to be true". The knowledge of my act of choosing would override any attempts believing something other than the most logical conclusion.

Of course, there is a second option - I may unconsciously skew my processing of the evidence because I so dearly want to believe something is true. I do not consider this to be 'choosing' a belief, because I consider choosing to be a conscious process. Self delusion in processing evidence is uncontrollable and unconscious. The "wanting to believe" as well as the subsequent skewing of processing are unconscious things. Choice is, to me, made after beliefs have been created by the unconscious processes - choice of a course of action, for example.

In summary: I don't think we can consciously choose what to believe, or even what we want to believe. Belief happens, and then we make choices.
 
My quibble over the precise nature of the word "choose" aside, I'm rather perplexed by these assertions:

When you are very young you believe what you are told.

Fair enough.

As you get a little older you choose what you want to believe because you are an idealist and want independence from your parents and others in authority. Being a non conformist is cool. Then when you get middle aged and beyond you start to believe based on the evidence.

Really? You think that everyone (or even a majority of people) will have beliefs based on simply disagreeing with authority figures as a primary factor? Until their forties? :jaw-dropp

Well dammit, I've got about another 15 years to go before I base my beliefs on evidence rather than derive them from rebellious idealism - which is a shame, since my dad and step-dad are both atheist skeptics. So, where did I put that Bible...
 
I choose to believe, whenever I get behind the wheel, that I'm not going to get into a car accident. I remain aware of the possibility I might be wrong, though I try to push that thought out of my head so as not to develop anxiety.

Sure, you can choose to believe. Simply ignore disconfirming evidence and overemphasize things that support your beliefs. That's the basis of religion.
 
I choose to believe, whenever I get behind the wheel, that I'm not going to get into a car accident. I remain aware of the possibility I might be wrong, though I try to push that thought out of my head so as not to develop anxiety.

Sure, you can choose to believe. Simply ignore disconfirming evidence and overemphasize things that support your beliefs. That's the basis of religion.

That reminded me - one day, about 15 years ago, I woke up convinced that if I got in the car and tried to drive to work I'd just lose control and crash. It was as if I thought I'd forgotten how to drive. The prospect of having to manoeuvre down streets and negotiate junctions was simply terrifying; there was just no way I could see myself being able to do it. I told myself I'd just walk to work and be late. Half an hour later I'd calmed down and drove as normal with no problem at all. It only happened once and I have no idea what brought it on. Maybe something I'd dreamt. Anyway, the point is on that morning I couldn't choose to believe I could drive safely.
 
I choose to believe, whenever I get behind the wheel, that I'm not going to get into a car accident. I remain aware of the possibility I might be wrong, though I try to push that thought out of my head so as not to develop anxiety.

Operating under the assumption that something probably isn't going to happen whilst being aware it could, even if you focus on the former, isn't the same as believing you aren't going to get into a car accident. You have two beliefs: you probably won't be in an accident; you could be in an accident.

Pushing the latter out of your conscious thoughts isn't changing what you believe to be truth - you're not choosing what you believe. You're choosing an action, i.e. to focus your mind on one thing over another.

I believe an Indian takeaway where I used to live does a nicer tikka masala than my local one. Whilst it would be nice to believe the tikka masala from my current local curryhouse is the nicest available when I'm eating it, I can't choose to believe that, but I can choose not to dwell on it.

Edited to include:

That reminded me - one day, about 15 years ago, I woke up convinced that if I got in the car and tried to drive to work I'd just lose control and crash. It was as if I thought I'd forgotten how to drive. The prospect of having to manoeuvre down streets and negotiate junctions was simply terrifying; there was just no way I could see myself being able to do it. I told myself I'd just walk to work and be late. Half an hour later I'd calmed down and drove as normal with no problem at all. It only happened once and I have no idea what brought it on. Maybe something I'd dreamt. Anyway, the point is on that morning I couldn't choose to believe I could drive safely.

I think this experiences reflects my point, so I hope you don't mind me hijacking it. You had a belief, you didn't choose it and couldn't choose not to have it, despite the fact it would have benefited you significantly to do so. Even though you probably objectively understood it was irrational, you couldn't choose not to have it. Only when your unconscious mind changed did your choice of action.

Incidentally, I don't consider choosing to try to believe something the same as choosing to believe something. Belief is not at the conscious will's full behest, no matter how hard the former tries. Pre-existing unconscious data processing is the ultimate control.
 
Last edited:
of course you can choose to believe.

maybe if I studied the Koran and other Islamic writings day and night, I would become a believer. that would be my choice...right?
 
I think you actually can "choose to believe" certain things if the punishment/rewards for doing so are great enough. You can untentionally turn off certain parts of your mind when the mental and sociatal rewards, such as public acceptance, are great enough to make it worthwhile.

How else can you explain politicians?
 
of course you can choose to believe.

maybe if I studied the Koran and other Islamic writings day and night, I would become a believer. that would be my choice...right?

I disagree that you would then be choosing to believe. You would be choosing to read the Koran et al day and night, which might in turn lead to you becoming convinced of something other than you currently are, but that wouldn't be choosing to believe. Your beliefs would simply change following the input of new information.

You couldn't read some of the Koran and then say, "Right, I'm going to believe that now", and start believing it. It would take an unconscious process of being convinced before you would change what you consider, ultimately, to be truth. That you can choose to put yourself in a situation which you are aware, up front, may alter your perception of things, isn't the same as simply choosing your perception.

An analogy: if I were to spend a lot of time around a particular person of the opposite sex (for me, ymmv), have lots of conversations and socialise, I may fall in love with them. I may choose to spend a lot of time with them with the hope of falling in love with them. However, falling in love is not a conscious decision, I couldn't simply choose to be in love with that person - I consider belief in a premise to be the same.

Tricky said:
You can untentionally turn off certain parts of your mind when the mental and sociatal rewards, such as public acceptance, are great enough to make it worthwhile.

My emphasis in bold. Unintentional things don't result from conscious choice.
 
I disagree that you would then be choosing to believe. You would be choosing to read the Koran et al day and night, which might in turn lead to you becoming convinced of something other than you currently are, but that wouldn't be choosing to believe. Your beliefs would simply change following the input of new information.

You couldn't read some of the Koran and then say, "Right, I'm going to believe that now", and start believing it. It would take an unconscious process of being convinced before you would change what you consider, ultimately, to be truth. That you can choose to put yourself in a situation which you are aware, up front, may alter your perception of things, isn't the same as simply choosing your perception.

An analogy: if I were to spend a lot of time around a particular person of the opposite sex (for me, ymmv), have lots of conversations and socialise, I may fall in love with them. I may choose to spend a lot of time with them with the hope of falling in love with them. However, falling in love is not a conscious decision, I couldn't simply choose to be in love with that person - I consider belief in a premise to be the same.



My emphasis in bold. Unintentional things don't result from conscious choice.
I think we have to make some distinctions, which is why I think the initial question is a bit ambiguous. You can choose what you try to believe, from pressure, cultural familiarity, existential angst, or whatever. If Thunder decided that his current faith, or lack of it, is not working for him, and admired the Muslims and their religious culture, he might seek to connect with it by studying it, and hoping that it would "take." And if, by choosing that path, he found that his efforts paid off, and he was convinced, then you might well be able to say that in a way, he chose what to believe. After all, he did not choose to read The Watchtower, or the Mahabharata. Of course, if he did this "in good faith," it would be because he's already inclined to faith, and willing to entertain the possibility of conversion, just as we might choose to take a mind altering drug in hope of enlightenment, or to hang out with an attractive woman in the hope that love will grow. All these choices are grounded in the basic idea that the desired result is at least remotely possible.

There's a difference between choosing what you will believe and what you can believe. I agree that there must have been some unconscious decision partway toward faith, before the conscious decision is made. I think the leap of faith is impossible unless you already have some faith, which is why I answered "no" to the original question as it was posed (can you choose to believe?) , but a large part of faith involves letting go of rational arguments and ordinary logical issues, and among those it seems that the rational bar to choosing what to believe is among them. After all, religious conversion is common enough, and so are second marriages.
 
Fnord,

re: “Belief is actively chosen...provided you have the evidence to back it up.”

How would you know when you had the evidence? What would be the state of your mind with regard to the belief in question when you decided that you had evidence?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom