Can you choose to believe?

Could you choose to believe that the Quran was the literal word of God?

  • Yes

    Votes: 26 17.8%
  • No

    Votes: 120 82.2%

  • Total voters
    146
Simple thought experiment should confirm that no, one cannot typically change their beliefs by sheer force of will. For instance, right now, attempt to make yourself believe that the current president of the United States is M. Night Shyamalan. Good luck with that.

This is why I'd say it's very important to note the distinction between believing something and knowing something. I don't believe in any god and I believe there are no gods, but I don't claim to know that there are no gods.

Yet look how many people (and you can read a lot of it in the Conspiracy Theory section) believe (and very strongly - some even go to court convinced by this belief) that Barrack is not the "legitimate" president of the USA, they seem to have been able to convince themselves of something that is entirely at odds to what most would consider the truth to be.
 
Assertion:
This is definitely false.
Evidence:
Let "Toby" be defined as: A hamster wearing a top hat, that is dancing on your head right now. Does Toby exist?
Hypothetical creatures (e.g., "Strawhamsters") in sartorial headgear and engaged in terpsichorial activities are irrelevant. Your assertion relies solely on an hypothesis, rather than physical evidence, and is therefor a null assertion.
 
Does the possibility of choosing to believe presuppose that free choice is possible - i.e. that it's possible to react in a different way to the same circumstance. I suspect a lot of people don't believe this to be the case, and therefore the idea of choosing anything is impossible.
 
1. The burden of proof is upon the favorable claim. Claiming that something exists requires proof. Claiming that something does not exist would first require proof that it did exist at one time, so that the effects of its absence can be noted and compared to the effects of its presence.

A direct implication of this assertion is that it is not possible to claim the non-existence of anything which has never existed.
 
Yet look how many people believe that Barrack is not the "legitimate" president of the USA, they seem to have been able to convince themselves of something that is entirely at odds to what most would consider the truth to be.

But that doesn't mean that they chose to believe what they believe. I think it's safe to say that the disconnect between the beliefs of such people and what most of us believe the truth to be exists because those people are all some combination of ignorant, deluded, and insane.
 
What about your beliefs about evidence? e.g. the forms of evidence to accept or reject... amount of weight to give to.. priorities etc ?

You cannot point to evidence about evidence as a basis for your beliefs about evidence, as that's circular, self-defeating, and bypasses the belief issue.

In the end then, all belief systems that describe themselves as evidence-based are ultimately based on belief (though faith might be a better descriptor).
In which case you are basing the above observation on faith.
 
What about your beliefs about evidence? e.g. the forms of evidence to accept or reject... amount of weight to give to.. priorities etc ?

You cannot point to evidence about evidence as a basis for your beliefs about evidence, as that's circular, self-defeating, and bypasses the belief issue.
Circularity is bad in an argument. But we are talking about a process here.

In a process there is no problem in having cycles - my beliefs about evidence change all the time as new evidence about evidence arrives.

What would be self-defeating would be to be stuck with the same belief about evidence for my entire life.
In the end then, all belief systems that describe themselves as evidence-based are ultimately based on belief (though faith might be a better descriptor).
That seems to be a sort of "chicken and egg" situation - what came first, the evidence or the belief?

It seems as though we are born with beliefs about evidence - a sort of starter set.

Then, as evidence arrives, our beliefs about evidence change. So it would be simplistic to say, either that belief systems are based ultimately on belief, or ultimately on evidence. It seems to be a lot more complicated than that.

And I am not saying that the belief system I have is great - I get things wrong all the time.
 
Belief is actively chosen, while faith is more passive (and thus more insidious) ...
So you answered "Yes"? You could, if you chose, believe that the Quran was Divinely inspired?
1. The burden of proof is upon the favorable claim. Claiming that something exists requires proof. Claiming that something does not exist would first require proof that it did exist at one time, so that the effects of its absence can be noted and compared to the effects of its presence.
I don't understand.

I can say "There is no female President of the United States" and establish the claim without having first demonstrated that there was once a female President.
 
So you answered "Yes"? You could, if you chose, believe that the Quran was Divinely inspired?

If the answer is 'no', Fnord could not believe that even if he wanted to, does that imply that those who do believe the Quran was Divinely inspired have no choice about their belief?
 
Robin, it seems to me that you are asserting an all-or-nothing ability, i.e., if one can choose to believe something then one can choose to believe anything. I see no reason to think this to be the case. The fact that I cannot make myself believe X does not mean I cannot make myself believe Y. For instance, I cannot make myself believe there is a teapot circling the sun, but I can make myself believe that my daughter is the most beautiful girl on Earth.

---

To take it further, I am not certain that I cannot make myself believe that there is a teapot circling the sun. Many years ago I began an experiment for myself that I have never told anyone. I adopted a story of my brother's as my own; he had told me about a run-in he had with some rough people. Regardless if his story to me was true, I began to tell myself that it had happened to me. In the many years since then, I find myself thinking it really did happen to me. Though I have never completely gotten rid of the small voice that reminds me it did not happen to me, that voice is frequently silent for long periods, and I have on more than one occasion found myself telling this story to others as if it truly did happen to me.

---

That last bit is anecdotal and may mean nothing, but my first bit is crucial, I think, to the point.
 
Assertion:

Evidence:

Hypothetical creatures (e.g., "Strawhamsters") in sartorial headgear and engaged in terpsichorial activities are irrelevant. Your assertion relies solely on an hypothesis, rather than physical evidence, and is therefor a null assertion.

You haven't answered the question. I'll break it down for you.

Does Toby exist? "Yes" is definitely not true. If you think it is, seek help. So, no, Toby does not exist, nor has he ever existed. I can judge facts as false without having any experience of their truth. I am not on the moon right now. I am justified in making that claim despite the fact that I've never been on the moon and I lack, what you might describe as, a necessary moon experience.

Funnily enough, you are discarding my claim because it lacks physical evidence. I don't know why you trumped up that requirement in the first place. After all, claims of what suffices as justification are not claims of physicality. But for the sake of argument, I will go with that. So naturally I must ask, in regards to you saying that statements on non-existence require prior existence to be demonstrated, what is your physical evidence for this claim?
 
If the answer is 'no', Fnord could not believe that even if he wanted to, does that imply that those who do believe the Quran was Divinely inspired have no choice about their belief?
A good point and I will think on't.
 
Robin, it seems to me that you are asserting an all-or-nothing ability, i.e., if one can choose to believe something then one can choose to believe anything. I see no reason to think this to be the case. The fact that I cannot make myself believe X does not mean I cannot make myself believe Y. For instance, I cannot make myself believe there is a teapot circling the sun, but I can make myself believe that my daughter is the most beautiful girl on Earth.

---

To take it further, I am not certain that I cannot make myself believe that there is a teapot circling the sun. Many years ago I began an experiment for myself that I have never told anyone. I adopted a story of my brother's as my own; he had told me about a run-in he had with some rough people. Regardless if his story to me was true, I began to tell myself that it had happened to me. In the many years since then, I find myself thinking it really did happen to me. Though I have never completely gotten rid of the small voice that reminds me it did not happen to me, that voice is frequently silent for long periods, and I have on more than one occasion found myself telling this story to others as if it truly did happen to me.

---

That last bit is anecdotal and may mean nothing, but my first bit is crucial, I think, to the point.
Also good points. I once tried to make myself believe that the Quran was the literal word of God, which is one of the reasons I chose this example.

Not much time right now but I will revisit this post soon.
 
Last edited:
Neither Koran,Nor Ten Commandments or for that matter Bhagvad Gita were God's words.
This is because If Humans have their own God/Gods, so do the ants to antelopes ,bears to baboons have their own Gods in their form.

Social writings of any nature are human creations. period.
 
I didn't choose to become a Christian, I was raised one. I didn't choose to become an atheist, one day I realized I am one.

If you set out with the goal of convincing yourself of something you know to be untrue, you may be able to do it, but the choice is to make the effort, when you've succeeded you will have your belief because you finally found it convincing, which is not synonymous with 'choosing to believe'.
 
So you answered "Yes"? You could, if you chose, believe that the Quran was Divinely inspired?
That depends.

How close is the gun being held to my head, and how good a shot is the person holding it?
 
That depends.

How close is the gun being held to my head, and how good a shot is the person holding it?

Interestingly enough, I don't feel that I would find a gun to my head very convincing. I'd simply lie about it. On the other hand, if I were deeply in love with a Muslim man and he would only marry me if I converted, that might be sufficient motivation for me to actually choose to believe. Of course, these are only hypothetical motivations. I wouldn't want to predict what I might actually do in either situation.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom