Can you choose to believe?

Could you choose to believe that the Quran was the literal word of God?

  • Yes

    Votes: 26 17.8%
  • No

    Votes: 120 82.2%

  • Total voters
    146
Yes, you can choose to believe whatever you want. Just decide what you want to believe, then choose to expose yourself only to the information that seems to confirm that belief and choose to ignore all the information that contradicts it. Sooner or later you will believe in that thing.


So essentially what we believe is a function of how we process information and what we perceive ourselves to experience. In this way we cannot "choose" to believe whatever we want, but since we have at least the potential to influence some of the relevant factors we can have an effect on our own beliefs.

Any yes or no answer to this question seems bound to over-simplify how these things work in some way, certainly enough that someone could validly disagree.

I think the process by which we reach most of our conclusions is difficult to perceive, even by ourselves. That's the nice thing about critical thinking, it forces you to get specific and deal with all the little tensions that creep up when you've reached a conclusion using the mental shortcuts we're pretty much hardwired to make without concerted effort to the contrary. To speak of the process as nothing more than a choice, seems a model that is due to lead to some faulty conclusions, particularly about those who disagree with us.
 
Last edited:
My answer is "no".

I cannot somehow make myself believe something I know to be false, no matter how much I might wish otherwise. If I saw compelling evidence that someone I love committed an awful crime, I would believe it.

If I were subjected to the kind of torture Winston Smith underwent in "1984", I probably would believe anything, even that 2+2=5. But Smith did not CHOOSE to believe it. He could convince himself of anything, in order to stop the pain. No "choosing" is involved. In fact, in Winston Smith's situation it is not possible to "choose to believe" that 2+2=4.
 
If a man can choose to believe a woman when she says, "I will love you always", then he can choose to believe that a collection of aphorisms and largely apocryphal legends is God's Own Printed Word.

Some people will choose to believe anything.
 
Last edited:
Yes, you can choose to believe whatever you want. Just decide what you want to believe, then choose to expose yourself only to the information that seems to confirm that belief and choose to ignore all the information that contradicts it. Sooner or later you will believe in that thing.

I would qualify this a little bit. I wouldn't say "whatever you want." There are examples, some of them given in this thread, of things that are so absurd (or so clearly and constantly contradicted by evidence that one cannot avoid) that I don't think this would be possible. But certainly there are a lot of beliefs that one could "adopt" through the method you describe -- though it might take a very long time, and might still result in only the most fragile of beliefs that is easily shattered by exposure to the facts you've been so scrupulously avoiding.
 
Last edited:
I think the process by which we reach most of our conclusions is difficult to perceive, even by ourselves. That's the nice thing about critical thinking, it forces you to get specific and deal with all the little tensions that creep up when you've reached a conclusion using the mental shortcuts we're pretty much hardwired to make without concerted effort to the contrary. To speak of the process as nothing more than a choice, seems a model that is due to lead to some faulty conclusions, particularly about those who disagree with us.

That sounds about right.
Welcome to the forum.
 
I was raised Unitarian, and my parents encouraged me to look at what other people believed and make my own decisions.

The "choose to believe" thing was one of my earliest sticking points on accepting any religion. By the age of 12, I'd figured out that I didn't think it wasn't "real" belief it it was something you were choosing because it fit your convenience of the moment. "Real" belief, I began to think, is something that you just "know", whether it fit what you knew and liked about the world or not. It wasn't something that you consciously chose.

So in actually, by telling me I would have to "choose" what to believe, my parents very effectively caused me to not believe anything, but to accept scientific evidence instead.
 
I was raised Unitarian, and my parents encouraged me to look at what other people believed and make my own decisions.

The "choose to believe" thing was one of my earliest sticking points on accepting any religion. By the age of 12, I'd figured out that I didn't think it wasn't "real" belief it it was something you were choosing because it fit your convenience of the moment. "Real" belief, I began to think, is something that you just "know", whether it fit what you knew and liked about the world or not. It wasn't something that you consciously chose.

So in actually, by telling me I would have to "choose" what to believe, my parents very effectively caused me to not believe anything, but to accept scientific evidence instead.

It's not an accident that babies born to Christians are Christian, and babies born to Muslims are Muslim. My husband was also raised by Unitarians, and he came to the same conclusion about scientific evidence. My parents were not religious; I never knew what they believed, if anything. I find it amazing that grown humans are unable (unwilling) to look at (lack of) evidence and come away with any thoughts other than those they accepted as children. Some people accepted Santa Clause because their parents told them he's real. It is a good thing parents finally confess about Santa or who knows what people would still believe about him!
 
Pick a contentious topic; existence of gods, origins of life, abortion, party politics - whatever you like. Now, either take the contrary view to your current belief or, if undecided, flip a coin to see which side you're going to take, and see if you can choose to believe it for a day. Good luck, one and all.
 
All that is necessary for religion to triumph is for reasoning people to do nothing.

(With apologies to Edmund Burke)
 
Any yes or no answer to this question seems bound to over-simplify how these things work in some way, certainly enough that someone could validly disagree.
I agree. I find the question too broad. "I'm innocent" -- yeah, sure. "Earth has two suns" -- no way.

I think the process by which we reach most of our conclusions is difficult to perceive, even by ourselves. That's the nice thing about critical thinking, it forces you to get specific and deal with all the little tensions that creep up when you've reached a conclusion using the mental shortcuts we're pretty much hardwired to make without concerted effort to the contrary.
Nicely put. "It's not the things a man doesn't know; it's the things he knows for sure that just ain't so", and all that -- or, taken a step further: the things it never occurs to him to question. By the time we get a chance to consider whether we believe a thing, the decision has usually been made already. When I start thinking about the degree to which it may be possible to appeal such a decision, I get stuck in a recursive loop: when was the decision made that appealing the decision would be a good thing, and who made it?
 
Faith is chosen, belief is not.

Belief is a natural state of mind in assuming something to be true. Faith is the reassurance that something is and ought to be true.
 
We say " You may choose to believe that." And we mean " You may choose to say that." In that sense, we just can — because we do — choose to believe. And we have to accept the possibility of self-deception, evasion and what not.

But choosing doesn't come into it when we ask you why or for what reason you believe that. You can intelligibly respond " Because there is, or there seems to me to be, evidence" or " Because that is where the argument leads, or seems to me to lead".

What you can't intelligibly say is " Because I choose that there should be, or seem to me to be, evidence or argument..." That isn't even wrong: it's just an abuse of language.

So my vote would be Yes or No, depending on what is meant by the question.
 
I am always fascinated when people say that they can choose to believe.

I cannot understand how they can do this. If the evidence points in a particular way then I have to believe that.

You choose how to interpret the evidence. You choose what evidence to examine in the first place. You choose what beliefs to consider. Of course, this is all precipitated on the belief that you exist as an individual entity with free will and the ability to make choices. :p

So I am interested in whether the JREF community at large think they can choose to believe something.
I answered yes, but I would modify that with the restriction that the beliefs you can choose between are restricted in various ways. For example, as a skeptic, I expect that you place a great weight on empirical evidence and logically consistent arguments (not everyone does). If you feel the preponderance of evidence points a particular way, you won't consider believing in a far less probable explanation. Not even if you feel strong social pressure to do so. Thus, beliefs that are assessed as having very low probability are basically out of consideration. They aren't in the idea space you will choose your beliefs from. That doesn't mean that you didn't choose the beliefs that you do hold.

Yes, you can choose to believe whatever you want. Just decide what you want to believe, then choose to expose yourself only to the information that seems to confirm that belief and choose to ignore all the information that contradicts it. Sooner or later you will believe in that thing.

Yes, I agree that anything you want to believe badly enough, you can manage to do so. I think that folks like Robin are unlikely to want to believe in something that badly. They prefer to go with where they feel the evidence leads. Correct?
 
I think when people say they can "choose to believe" what they really mean is "if you try hard enough you can suppress your dissenting thoughts and pretend that you do believe".

Also, a lot of people don't really know how to critically evaluate evidence, so they really have no idea whether a holy book is true or not. To them, it either is or it isn't, and they're stuck somewhere in the middle. Accepting something as true when you think there's a 50% chance of it being true isn't that hard. In that case, you're not choosing - you already think there's a reasonable chance it could be true.
 
Last edited:
Belief is actively chosen, while faith is more passive (and thus more insidious) ...

You can convince me to believe any reasonable claim, provided you have the evidence to back it up. By 'evidence', I mean a practical demonstration based on scientific principles (or extrapolations thereof).

Freestanding 3D holographic cinema? Sure, just have Heidi Klum's holo-image strut through my kitchen.

Gravity control? Okay ... where's my flying car?

Anagathics? Give me the treatment, and if I'm still around in 50 years, I'll buy another dose.

Faith, on the other hand, requires only that a person's disbelief in the impossible be suspended. Since faith is the belief in improvable things, faith requires that I forego / forget the Standards of Proof,* thus giving the object of that faith a "Free Pass".

My alleged past life as a Korean Empress? Really? That explains my appetite for kimchi and rice, so it must be true!

Space aliens behind every chemtrail? Since no on knows what those chemtrails are made of and who is spraying them, then they must be mind-control substances spread by space aliens!

Honest politicians? Well ... maybe that's stretching credibility a little too far, but some people do fall for the same unfounded promises year after year, based solely on their own faith in the politician expressing those promises.


*Standards of Proof (Not a complete list, but they work for me):

1. The burden of proof is upon the favorable claim. Claiming that something exists requires proof. Claiming that something does not exist would first require proof that it did exist at one time, so that the effects of its absence can be noted and compared to the effects of its presence.

2. Claims require proof. Claiming that a horse lives in the garage next door can be proven by a quick examination of the physical evidence. Claiming that the horse is invisible, pink, and has a spiral horn growing out of its forehead requires that the horse be made visible, or made detectable by ordinary scientific instruments.

3. Proof must be material. Verbal gymnastics (i.e., "Salesmanship" or "Confidence Games") are not material proof. Neither are testimonials. If the claim is that being touched by a certain person or object will heal all ills, then let the contact be made to an amputee so that I can observe the regeneration of their lost limb.

4. Proof must be clear and convincing. The evidence must show that something is more likely than not. Again, mere words are not evidence. Horse manure, horse-shoe prints and horse hairs might be sufficient proof that there really is (or was) an ordinary horse in the garage next door.

5. Preponderance of the evidence. A saddle alone does not prove a horse. Neither does a single photograph. A single horse-hair or horse-fly might imply the proximity of a horse, but neither actually proves that it's there. A full tack, a pile of manure, horsehairs on a brush, and my allergies going into high gear would be a preponderance of evidence, Especially if it seems that a very large something is making horsey noises and trying to kick down the garage door.
 
Last edited:
1. The burden of proof is upon the favorable claim. Claiming that something exists requires proof. Claiming that something does not exist would first require proof that it did exist at one time, so that the effects of its absence can be noted and compared to the effects of its presence.

This is definitely false.

Let "Toby" be defined as: A hamster wearing a top hat, that is dancing on your head right now. Does Toby exist?
 
This is definitely false.

Let "Toby" be defined as: A hamster wearing a top hat, that is dancing on your head right now. Does Toby exist?
.
Hamsters, hats, heads, how to not believe in these?
Dancing at that location, now that is silly!
 
I think that someone can back up enough in thought to get to a point of a kind of solipsism where you have to choose what you put your trust in. At that point, there's nothing much solid to go on as to what line of philosophy you go down. I can see someone choosing to follow a path that leads to putting trust in the Quran. I think it can give what at least can appear to be a solid base to work from.

Whether I could, personally, from where I am in life and thought would be a different matter. I doubt it, but maybe with certain events, brain washings or whatever I could get back to a point where it might become a possible choice.
 
I am always fascinated when people say that they can choose to believe.

...snip...

That depends on exactly what we mean when we say "choose to". I'd say the evidence is quite strong that people will come to believe what their social group believes in, no matter how strange this is (as a generalisation of course) this is partly why social groupings like religions thrive.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom